Rebecca lost her parents in a tragic fire and was sent to live with her uncle, Jonas. Jonas's hope is that Rebecca will marry Daniel, his partner in the buggy shop. But Rebecca's heart is somewhere else, and she can't imagine spending her life with Daniel.Evan has returned back home after moving to his wife's Amish community when they married. But with his wife’s passing one year ago, his heart has now taken him back to his family's farm with his two children.Chance meetings between Evan and Rebecca stir up feelings, but outside circumstances and Evan's grief pull them apart. But as Christmas is the season for love and miracles, can Rebecca and Evan find hope and a lasting, eternal love?