Books like 'If The Broom Fits: A Quirky Paranormal Menage Story'
Readers who enjoyed If The Broom Fits: A Quirky Paranormal Menage Story by Sinclair Kelly also liked the following books featuring the same tropes, story themes, relationship dynamics and character types.
fantasy reverse harem paranormal poly (3+ people) witches fated-mates m-m-f menage monsters high fantasy
-
Dodging Calamities by Erin R. Flynn
My name is Tamsin Vale and I’m the last known fairy… And I think I’m out of time. The walls are closing in from all sides and we’re quickly running out of options.But I don’t think help is coming.Making up with Darby and Lucca—having them at my side—has helped my soul, but I’m still missing pieces of it. I want to let Hudson back in, though I don’t know how... -
![Thwarting Cheaters by Erin R. Flynn]()
Thwarting Cheaters by Erin R. Flynn
My name is Tamsin Vale and I’m the last known fairy. Someone found out and that was why I was abducted, which I survived.And my boyfriend freaking out after drinking my blood.And all the drama with Mel’s family.And getting the havens running, which we received so much flack over.And… A lot. There’s been a lot and it’s sort of a miracle I’ve not been outed or taken out... -
![]()
![]()
Sponsored links -
![Multiplying Storms by Erin R. Flynn]()
Multiplying Storms by Erin R. Flynn
Rated: 4.38 of 5 stars · 20 ratingsMy name is Tamsin Vale and I’m the only living heir to all of Faerie. It’s still hard to accept that, but given how often people call me “Princess” or “Your Highness” like it’s my actual name, I can’t deny it.I simply hate that I am.Yeah, it’s going that well.The councils’ win might have seemed small, but the ripples from that decision are drowning me at every turn... -
![Unregulated Upheaval by Erin R. Flynn]()
Unregulated Upheaval by Erin R. Flynn
My name is Tamsin Vale and I’m the only living heir to all of Faerie. I want to do what’s right and use that position to help my people, but too many treat me as if I belong to them and that world.And I cannot live my life that way.Nor can I keep pretending all my relationships are okay. Three are great, but it’s time to let one go and stop forcing myself to accept so much... -
-
![Compounding Traumas by Erin R. Flynn]()
Compounding Traumas by Erin R. Flynn
My name is Tamsin Vale and I’m the last known fairy, fighting to find out what happened to all fairies and our world.But I’m running out of hope, and it has a lot to do with the four pieces of my soul I no longer have with me. Going through one breakup is terrible, but four in rapid succession is… More than one person can handle... -
![Chaos Unleashed by Nikita Parmenter]()
Chaos Unleashed by Nikita Parmenter
Rated: 4.43 of 5 stars · 16 ratingsThat psychopath has taken her, and the only reason we aren’t watching the world burn in our grief is because of Grey, or should I say Hades! He has assured us he would’ve felt her soul depart if she was dead... -
![A Blackened Bond by Isla Davon]()
A Blackened Bond by Isla Davon
Death once claimed me, stole the air from my lungs as I burned alive…only I didn’t stay dead. Instead I was returned to my past, and back to a living hell. The Academy. Where those who I believed were friends were actually foes. My enemies thought they could break me, but I proved them wrong. Two months ago I was given a second chance…A second life. With it I now wanted answers…and revenge... -
![Ghostly Touches by Salem Cross]()
Ghostly Touches by Salem Cross
They came to me in the dead of night.I should be used to ghosts, I’m a necromancer after all. But the three men who show up at my house aren’t the spiritual beings I’m used to. These Ghosts are part of a brotherhood so secret that they were thought to be a myth.When they ask for my help, I leap at the opportunity to aid these warriors.But none of us expected my help to come with a price tag... -
![All the Devils Are Here by Devyn Sinclair]()
All the Devils Are Here by Devyn Sinclair
I always wanted to love a monster… I just didn’t think I’d need to be stranded on an island to do it.My name is Meghan Irela, and I’ve just been fired.Not my proudest moment, but I’ll be all right. A trip to Paris is just what I need. Visit my friends, ignore my problems, and pretend I’m not completely alone... -
![Blood and Midnight by Sarah Piper]()
Blood and Midnight by Sarah Piper
Three sexy-but-psycho monsters. One fiery, determined witch. And a high-stakes heist about to go very wrong…I've made some pretty questionable choices in the name of my witchcraft—dabbling in necromancy, double-crossing vampires—but summoning the dark goddess? That was just plain stupid.Now I’m in her debt, and goddesses don’t exactly do payment plans... -
![Born to be Witchy by A.J. Macey, Jarica James]()
Born to be Witchy by A.J. Macey, Jarica James
Rated: 4.31 of 5 stars · 14 ratingsAris Calisto was not your basic witch in the world of Akasha; with pink hair, sass, and an unusual upbringing that gave her a unique perspective on things, she wouldn’t accept being held back forever. After many twists, turns, and uphill battles, Aris and her men finally have their happy ever after... -
![The Wronged: Completed Series by M. Sinclair]()
The Wronged: Completed Series by M. Sinclair
Rated: 4.67 of 5 stars · 6 ratingsWelcome to Wicked Blaze Correctional, home to the world’s most dangerous criminals…and me. My only crime was knowing too much, yet somehow I took a fall for the real bad guy. Drake thought I’d be an easy scapegoat, that I’d cower and accept the punishment I hadn’t earned.Absolutely not. Pushed to the brink, my magic boiled over, and now it’s ready to burn anyone who gets too close... -
![Delivered to My Orcs by Mazzy J. March]()
Delivered to My Orcs by Mazzy J. March
Rated: 4.57 of 5 stars · 7 ratingsI have worked in the family business I was a teenager and planned to continue to do so for the rest of my life. But when my mom and dad died in a freak accident, the will listed my brother as the sole owner and CEO to avoid “dividing the assets.” His first act was to sell everything, including our warehouse and the storefront with the apartment upstairs where I live... -
![The Leviathan's Debt by Merri Bright]()
The Leviathan's Debt by Merri Bright
Rated: 4.50 of 5 stars · 8 ratingsThere’s a price for everything.Forty years ago, Wren was attacked by King Talon the day after their wedding. She fled and was lost at sea…and then found by an ancient being, who saved her with his blood.The price for her life? Someday, the monster will return to claim it.Now, she’s become the mysterious Ankelsang, the Angel of Blood who protects the vulnerable...Categorized as:
monsters fated-mates witches omegaverse reverse harem friends to lovers fantasy paranormal -
-
![House of Malak by Crea Reitan]()
House of Malak by Crea Reitan
Rated: 4.50 of 5 stars · 8 ratingsI’m the Director of Haven, a newly established sanctuary for all the misused and mistreated humans that The Harem Project recovers from the Division of Silence. I have my hands full, trying to save as many lives as I can.Then a chance meeting has me virtually running into the men that hold a piece of my heavenly soul and my world shifts... -
![Great Falls Protector by Alex Lidell]()
Great Falls Protector by Alex Lidell
Rated: 4.27 of 5 stars · 15 ratingsLera burned him. Now it’s Tye’s turn. Tye has sacrificed everything for his chance at the Prowess Trials, and Lera’s betrayal in reporting his injuries nearly ended it all. Now there is nothing left but to kick Lera out of his world—and ensure the eviction stays... -
![Her Elemental Dragons: The Complete Series by Elizabeth Briggs]()
Her Elemental Dragons: The Complete Series by Elizabeth Briggs
Rated: 4.26 of 5 stars · 13 ratingsFour sexy dragon shifters. A huntress with a dark past. A bond that could save the world. I've spent my entire life running from my past and staying out of trouble. That's how I've kept alive ever since my parents were killed by the Black Dragon, who's ruled the world under her oppressive talons for as long as anyone can remember...Categorized as:
monsters fated-mates reverse harem fantasy paranormal poly length-epic dragon shifter -
![Fawn by L.V. Lane]()
Fawn by L.V. Lane
Rated: 4.26 of 5 stars · 13 ratingsFawn is not good at keeping secrets. And she has been poorly hiding two very big ones for some time.But it’s been getting harder and harder for her to hide her infatuation with the big, growly wolf pack enforcer.She’s not surprised when he rejects her. He thinks she’s a human beta, after all.But then a mysterious stag shifter arrives at the pack, and her other secret is out.The stag wants her... -
![Beautiful Beast by Devyn Sinclair]()
Beautiful Beast by Devyn Sinclair
Rated: 4.17 of 5 stars · 19 ratingsStanding in front of a dragon means dying by fire, but the heart knows there’s more than one way to burn.Humans and dragons are at war, and I am a pawn in the battle.Princess of a dying land, my life is not my own, and a marriage to a vicious, dragon-hunting prince will save my people from deadly famine or death by fire...Categorized as:
fated-mates monsters menage fantasy paranormal from hate to love reverse harem dual-pov -
![The Hunt by Reece Barden]()
The Hunt by Reece Barden
Rated: 4.30 of 5 stars · 11 ratingsWhen the pack is under threat, Max is tasked with finding the man determined to take down his alpha and destroy his home. He'll never let that happen, even if that means working with Sharon, the council witch he's never quite trusted. Sharon's trying to make up for putting the Steel pack's luna in danger, but Max, their stubborn beta, is making it extremely difficult...Categorized as:
witches m-m-f fated-mates shapeshifters fantasy reverse harem vampires from hate to love -
![Witches Be Crazy by A.J. Macey]()
Witches Be Crazy by A.J. Macey
Rated: 4.20 of 5 stars · 16 ratingsNothing in Aris Calisto’s life has ever been basic, and after a cauldron full of unexpected events, she finds herself a fugitive. Going on the run should have been the biggest challenge of her life, but after being separated from her tethers, she’s faced with an impossible choice--submit or run.With time ticking down, Aris and her ragtag band of witches have to risk it all... -
![Fated In Blood: Nocturne Vampire Clan: 1 by L.A. McGinnis]()
Fated In Blood: Nocturne Vampire Clan: 1 by L.A. McGinnis
Rated: 4.30 of 5 stars · 10 ratingsI’ve always known vampires were the enemy.For years, I’ve hidden in the shadows, hoping they forget I exist. Then the bloodsuckers did the unthinkable—they stole my sister. When my rescue mission goes terribly wrong, I'm forced to make an impossible choice.Perish, or become one of the immortal creatures I despise...Categorized as:
fated-mates witches monsters menage vampires paranormal from hate to love reverse harem -
![Gemini Kings by Laura Navarre]()
Gemini Kings by Laura Navarre
I summon the dragon. I claim my throne. The warlocks of Icarus Academy claim me.I start my night with a heist in a Catwoman costume at a Vegas casino…and end up shifting into my dragon form for the first time ever in mid-plummet from the roof.Except I can’t actually fly. Oops... -
![The Complete Horse Mistress Collection by R.A. Steffan]()
The Complete Horse Mistress Collection by R.A. Steffan
Rated: 4.33 of 5 stars · 9 ratingsMy secret could save my people.It will also destroy my life.My name is Carivel. I was born female, but I've been secretly living as a boy in my adoptive village of Draebard, doing a job the elders insist could never be done by a woman... -
-
![Dragon Games by November Sweets]()
Dragon Games by November Sweets
Rated: 4.33 of 5 stars · 9 ratingsIt’s that time of year once again ladies!The dragon mating season is upon us!It’s time for those highborn human women to lie, cheat, claw, and stab their way into a chance at being mated to a dragon.But something strange has happened this year, it’s not only the high borns that have a chance to win the gauntlet, even the low born like me has a chance to win the prize and the bragging rights...Categorized as:
high fantasy fated-mates reverse harem fantasy shapeshifters paranormal magic dragon shifter -
![Jasmine by Crystal North]()
Jasmine by Crystal North
Rated: 4.33 of 5 stars · 9 ratingsJasmine: an insanely talented half-witch who can’t see her own worth, even though the humans and the Supes of Silver Springs all adore her; shop owner; holistic healer; visionary; fortune teller.The only problem she ever has with fortune telling, however, is her own. All she ever gets is visions of trees when she tries... -
![Clever Witch by Nikki Dean]()
Clever Witch by Nikki Dean
Rated: 4.33 of 5 stars · 9 ratingsHide your magic. Don't tell anyone you're dating your TA, and now maybe your handler, too. Don't tell anyone about the jaguar in your room, or secret lab under the dorm. Keep your friends close, and your enemies closer... -
![House of Agni by Crea Reitan]()
House of Agni by Crea Reitan
Rated: 4.38 of 5 stars · 8 ratingsBeware the fire for it burns. It’s time to find my home. My family. In a world where strength is hunted and those unlike the rest are sentenced to death, my kind are better off in groups. Fire is not something to dabble in and when given the right fuel, it can destroy anything. Thus, we are public enemy number one in the world of supernaturals... -
![Coveted by the Alpha Pack by Serenity Rayne]()
Coveted by the Alpha Pack by Serenity Rayne
Rated: 4.38 of 5 stars · 8 ratingsRunning for my life from a deranged ex-fiancé was just the beginning.It’s hard to believe that only eighteen months ago, I was running for my life, fleeing an abusive marriage. Fast forward to now, and I’m not just the Luna of one pack, but six.Yeah, you heard that right—six packs, three kids, and six incredibly sexy partners.Absorbing five packs wasn’t on my bingo card, but it was a necessity... -
![Jay's Silence: The Worst Guide to Collecting Dragons by Kate Messick, Eileen Troemel]()
Jay's Silence: The Worst Guide to Collecting Dragons by Kate Messick, Eileen Troemel
Rated: 4.43 of 5 stars · 7 ratingsFour dragon shifters. Three parts of a casket. Two unexpected portals. And a sorceressstuck in a pear tree.I may have my voice back, but that doesn’t mean I’ve got anything else worked out. Like how toregain my powers. Or how to get my four hot dragon shifters to understand I’m not for keeps.Even if they filled gaps in my soul, I never knew were missing, saying goodbye is inevitable...Categorized as:
witches fated-mates reverse harem paranormal dragon shifter shapeshifters poly fantasy -
![Their Trials by Avah Larke]()
Their Trials by Avah Larke
Apparently, life isn’t going to get any easier for Rhowyn.With the trials starting, Rhowyn must find a way to use what she’s got, which isn’t much except determination, survival instincts, and her MMA training to somehow make it through to the end without dying. She must learn to rely on her consorts, a concept that’s new to the independent girl that has only ever relied on herself... -
![My Beautiful Monsters: The Complete Series by J.B. Trepagnier]()
My Beautiful Monsters: The Complete Series by J.B. Trepagnier
Rated: 4.50 of 5 stars · 6 ratingsI’ve always been able to talk to animals. Apparently, I can hear monsters too. Hades kidnapped me. Yeah, that Hades. Greek mythology is real and I’m learning the gods are real dicks. I’m tasked with caring for the monsters in the Underworld. Oh, yeah, Demeter is pissed about the whole Persephone thing. She’s kidnapped her daughter and making the monsters fight for sport... -
![If The Wand Sparkles by Sinclair Kelly]()
If The Wand Sparkles by Sinclair Kelly
Rated: 4.50 of 5 stars · 6 ratingsOnce upon a time usually ends in happily ever after, right? For us, it's a little too early to tell. The ogre is suddenly a ray of sunshine, the troll too busy pouting to chip in and help, and the kitty dragon has secrets. Duck my life. Yeah, that's not a typo. With my villainous uncle on the hunt for us, I don't have time to play the role of princess, dagnabbit... -
![Delivered to My Gargoyles by Mazzy J. March]()
Delivered to My Gargoyles by Mazzy J. March
Rated: 4.60 of 5 stars · 5 ratingsSo I take a dare. As a “human” I have no real right to be looking for a “mate” on an app for shifters and other paranormal beings. But I never have been able to hold my liquor, which is why I rarely drink to excess. I am not entirely sure shifters or vampires or whoever exist beyond cosplay anyway...Categorized as:
monsters menage fantasy reverse harem contemporary shapeshifters paranormal new adult -
-
![Great Falls Cadet by Alex Lidell]()
Great Falls Cadet by Alex Lidell
Rated: 4.10 of 5 stars · 26 ratingsOne elite fae warrior. Four superior officers. A bond they can’t resist.Lera was once human. Now, with dark magic leaking into the mortal world, the petite fae warrior must return to protect it—even if it means going undercover with four powerful fae males to a harsh military academy. But when a terrible accident melds the males with their human disguises, everything changes... -
![A Witch Out of Time by C. Rochelle]()
A Witch Out of Time by C. Rochelle
**WARNING: THIS BOOK CONTAINS A CLIFFHANGER** It is also RH, with multiple POV, unusual spicy smex, and a focus on romance (including MM) and body positivity. If any of those things don't work for you, please don't read it!Four hundred years is a long time to wait for your fated mates only to have two of them cruelly ripped away... -
![Defiance by Sadie Moss]()
Defiance by Sadie Moss
Rated: 4.27 of 5 stars · 10 ratingsWhen the gods war, no one wins. My three messengers took a greater risk than I realized when they agreed to help me save my village. Now they must face the consequences, and so must I. If Kaius and Zelus go to war, it will devastate humanity... and that's not the only danger that lurks on the horizon... -
![Hidden in Deception by M. Bonnet]()
Hidden in Deception by M. Bonnet
Everyone is counting on me to change the world, but I can barely handle the changes within myself. Just as I think things are getting better, they nosedive and fall through the sky like a sack of bricks. And I can’t help but think they’re going to get way worse… I just have this feeling I can’t shake. Millions of lives are in my hands. My life is, too... -
![Risky Business: A Reverse Harem Prison Romance by J.B. Trepagnier]()
Risky Business: A Reverse Harem Prison Romance by J.B. Trepagnier
And then Daddy Dearest enters stage left. So, I met my father. I beat the crap out of him, but I haven’t killed him yet. Yet being the operative word. I still haven’t made up my mind about that. I had my to-do list before I broke out of Scorchwood and killing him was a major part of my big kill list. I mean, the man framed me, sent me to prison in Hell, then had a mad warlock experiment on me... -
![Bloodline Trilogy: The Complete Edition by Rhea Watson]()
Bloodline Trilogy: The Complete Edition by Rhea Watson
Rated: 4.22 of 5 stars · 9 ratingsThree alphas forced to unite to defend their territory—fated to a she-wolf with starlight in her eyes and destiny in her blood.All my life, I thought I was the only one.Not a wolf. Not a woman. Just some freak in between. A mistake. A monster.Abomination.Abandoned and dismissed. Shunned and forgotten.Until they find me.Ewan. Lucian. Soren.Men and wolves... -
![Wolf Forsaken by Maya Nicole]()
Wolf Forsaken by Maya Nicole
His job was to protect the pack.Instead, he tried to kill me, and now three of my mates are in danger. Will a new ally help me take back what I've lost or will I have to take matters into my own hands?There's a storm coming and it has red hair and an appetite for more than just deer.Wolf Forsaken is book 2 in the Arbor Falls series and is a reverse harem wolf shifter romance told in multiple POVs...Categorized as:
fated-mates m-m-f paranormal fantasy shapeshifters super rich hero reverse harem poly -
![Severed by Magic by Lexie Scott]()
Severed by Magic by Lexie Scott
Rated: 4.14 of 5 stars · 13 ratingsWhen you're saved from the absolute worst-case scenario, you're supposed to be happy, right? At the very least, I should be grateful but we've been thrown to the wolves--literally--but I'm not the only one struggling to adjust.When we were at Drexel Academy, we knew our enemies. Now the only people my mates and I know we can trust is each other.Fans of Meg Xuemei X and & G... -
![Night of the Berserkers: A Reverse Harem Romance by Lee Savino]()
Night of the Berserkers: A Reverse Harem Romance by Lee Savino
Rated: 4.29 of 5 stars · 7 ratingsI have one night to meet the mage... One night to destroy him... One night to break the Berserker's curse... One night to save them... As the Corpse King threatens to destroy our land, my sisters and I gather to find a spell to defeat him. But when magic delivers me to the mage’s stronghold, I become a captive of his Berserker guard. I didn’t count on his Berserker guards... -
![Princess Taken by Tyler Parker]()
Princess Taken by Tyler Parker
Rated: 4.29 of 5 stars · 7 ratingsZane, Daniel, and Blaze - My Protectors.The men I must fall in love with to save the word... wait, what?Imagine my excitement when I find out there's more to my dreary life and that I'm powerful beyond my wildest belief.In fact, I'm apparently the key to to kicking Venom's ass.But then I learn that I'll only be able to reach my full potential once I fall in love with all my protectors... -
-
![A Wolf Scorned by Taylor Spratt]()
A Wolf Scorned by Taylor Spratt
Rated: 4.29 of 5 stars · 7 ratingsEvery girl dreams of being the Alpha’s mate, but for me it’s a nightmare.Being born a ‘blue moon shifter’ means living my life underground and not being allowed to visit the surface world, not ever. Being an outcast in my pack, ridiculed and taunted daily didn’t make life any better.I’ve dreamed of escape for years but when Alpha Logan rejects me, I make a break for it... -
![Broken Bond by Callie Rose]()
Broken Bond by Callie Rose
Nothing is what I thought it was. Not even me.Everything changed the night I ran from Uncle Clint.And everything changed again the night he tracked me down.The four alphas who’ve each claimed me as their mate kept their promise to protect me. They came for me. They saved me. For one beautiful, blissful moment, the five of us were united, joined more closely than I’ve ever been with anyone... -
![CADET by Alex Lidell]()
CADET by Alex Lidell
Rated: 4.08 of 5 stars · 17 ratingsOne elite fae warrior. Four superior officers. A bond they can’t resist. Lera was once human. Now, with dark magic leaking into the mortal world, the petite fae warrior must return to protect it—even if it means going undercover with four powerful fae males to a harsh military academy. But when a terrible accident melds the males with their human disguises, everything changes...Categorized as:
menage high fantasy fated-mates fantasy legends & fairy tales historical medieval reverse harem -
![BlackWing by Connie Suttle]()
BlackWing by Connie Suttle
Rated: 4.08 of 5 stars · 16 ratingsQuin: Finder, healer, student, teacher, lover, pirate— BlackWing "My life in Gungl began a moon-turn later, when I was finally able to pull myself out of bed without crushing grief slamming into me and causing me to collapse. The following day, my plan for revenge against Vardil Cayetes, the man responsible for Siriaa's destruction, began... -
![More than a Bargain by Jet Mykles]()
More than a Bargain by Jet Mykles
Ding dong, the wicked witch is dead. Unfortunately, Meg killed him. With magic. A definite no-no where the Witches' Council is concerned. If the Council can prove it, she'll be put to death. To make matters worse, she also absorbed a hell of a lot of the wicked witch's power and memories and she's barely able to contain them. What's a good witch to do? Rely on her shifters, of course... -
![Secret Witch by Letty Frame]()
Secret Witch by Letty Frame
Rated: 4.13 of 5 stars · 8 ratingsDeath always has a way of bringing secrets to light. But when the only person who knows the truth is gone, how do you figure out what was real? It’s a shame the dead can’t talk.Elzora Miller is a human. Wait, that’s not true. It turns out she’s actually a witch. When her grandma dies, a binding spell placed on her as a babe breaks, and the truth comes to light...Categorized as:
witches fated-mates magic paranormal fantasy reverse harem college friends to lovers
Fantastic book recommendations by romance book lovers for romance book lovers.
Find out more about romance.io.
Find out more about romance.io.
Get recommendations by genres & tropes
Use the romance book finder to mix and match over 100 content keywords to find the books that match your preferences
Or - use our amazing romance book finder to get recommendations based on your favorite content tropes and themes. Mix and match at will.
