Delaney Quinn returns to Blue Harbor after fifteen years of exile, hired to restore the church murals in the town that once branded her a fraud. The truth of her past—a mentor's betrayal she took the blame for to protect someone else—has never been spoken, and she's built her life around that silence. When she discovers the church renovation is overseen by Reverend Nathan Cole, the former musician who once led the youth group that shunned her, old wounds threaten to bleed anew. As Delaney's brushstrokes resurrect the faded frescoes, she and Nathan must confront their shared history of judgment and grace. Through vandalism transformed into art, hidden guitar melodies painted into corners, and the unfinished square that waits for tomorrow's colors, they discover that redemption isn't about erasing the past—it's about learning to paint over it with something beautiful.