Sarah Moore is getting older by Amish standards and needs a way to find a man to marry or a career. But it hasn’t been easy because she doesn’t have confidence in herself, nor does she feel like she has a place in the community. The only thing she knows how to do is make Englisch dolls, but she can't make a career out of it because it’s actually not allowed the Amish community.
When her dolls eventually get found by her family, Sarah’s world is turned upside down. Can she find a way to reconcile her passion and the demands of the community? And what about the love she’s secretly been longing for?