Books like 'Brothers Next Door: A Menage Romance'
Readers who enjoyed Brothers Next Door: A Menage Romance by Samantha Twinn also liked the following books featuring the same tropes, story themes, relationship dynamics and character types.
contemporary poly (3+ people) second chances independent heroine
-
Hoards and Harbors by S.M. Olivier
Navigating our new reality has its ups and downs. My relationships with my men and most of my family continue to grow. Together, we've made it our duty to help those who can't help themselves. We're determined to ensure good prevails despite the evil forces against us. We make new friends, giving us hope we're not alone in our mission...Categorized as:
second chances independent heroine military post-apocalyptic dystopian poly reverse harem menage -
![Three Second Chances for Christmas by Rebel Bloom]()
Three Second Chances for Christmas by Rebel Bloom
I thought I had left my failures behind me, until I needed a fake boyfriend for Christmas.Now my past is catching up to me, in the form of three sexy ex-boyfriends who ALL want me back…As a struggling entrepreneur with nothing to show for it but a failing candle business and a trio of ex-boyfriends, I've always been the black sheep of the family... -
![]()
![]()
Sponsored links -
![Uncomplicated by K.M. Neuhold]()
Uncomplicated by K.M. Neuhold
Two men with a rocky history, and one with an all-consuming love for both of them. Sometimes I’m so lonely I swear I can’t breathe. I bring men and women into my bed to chase away the ache, but it never seems to help. I want something real, something lasting, but I’ve never been more afraid of anything in my life...Categorized as:
second chances m-m bisexual friends to lovers menage contemporary men in uniform poly -
![Catalyst by Aurora Crane]()
Catalyst by Aurora Crane
Detective Quinn Hughes doesn’t have many regrets in life, but Sebastian Devlin is the biggest. As a cop and a defence lawyer, the deck was stacked against them to start with, but Quinn was the one who left a burning inferno behind him... -
-
![Knot Sharing the Ice: A WhyChoose Omegaverse Romance by Harper Lennox]()
Knot Sharing the Ice: A WhyChoose Omegaverse Romance by Harper Lennox
Four pro hockey alphas, one driven figure skating omega, and an unexpected blizzard that turns up the heat…After dumping the ex who saw my skating career as competition, all I want is some time to perfect my routine before my family sucks me into their quaint but corny Christmas traditions.Instead, the rink I rented to have all to myself is invaded by the Reapers... -
![Vicious Lies by Rachel Leigh]()
Vicious Lies by Rachel Leigh
At Boulder Cove Academy, three things are certain:The Lawless Rule.The games are dangerous.Nothing is as it seems. I came here expecting to face my bullies with an iron fist. I played their games and won. Now that I’ve earned my place, at the academy and in their home, I should have nothing to fear. But with every past there is a shadow and mine is drawing closer with each step I take... -
![Finding the Road to Us by Carrie Ann Ryan]()
Finding the Road to Us by Carrie Ann Ryan
I was ready to say, ‘I do’, then my fiancé left me at the altar.Broken and embarrassed, Trace and Elliot helped me run away—ditching my wedding dress in the process.When I come back to the Wilder Retreat to show the world I’m no longer hurting, I know I must ignore my traitorous needs when it comes to these two men.Because my body wants them both.And my soul craves them just as much... -
![Second Chance SEALs Next Door by Summer Haze, June Deborahae]()
Second Chance SEALs Next Door by Summer Haze, June Deborahae
Bumping into my three ex-SEAL one-night stands from years ago, now living next door? Yep, our fresh start just turned into a wild complication for me and my son. Life as a single mom in Lilyfield seemed simple until my past walked back in – Justin, Ben, and Mason, the men from a long-ago wild night, reappear... -
![Reminders of Her by Claudia Y. Burgoa]()
Reminders of Her by Claudia Y. Burgoa
From USA Today bestselling author Claudia Burgoa comes an achingly poignant tale—an exquisite Why Choose? An MMF polyamorous romance told partially in epistolary-style that promises a rollercoaster of emotions, bringing together love, loss, and the unabating pull of the past. This wasn’t the typical boy meets girl story.In our case, it was extraordinary: a boy met a girl and another boy... -
![The Pitch Slap by Kris Butler]()
The Pitch Slap by Kris Butler
Is it better to swing and miss or never get up to bat?Growing up a baseball princess had taught me a few things:One, the only truly scary thing about ball players was their superstitions.Second, baseball always came first. It was their one true love.And third, never take your eye off the ball, or you just might get pitch-slapped...Categorized as:
second chances independent heroine reverse harem sports poly contemporary bisexual m-m-f -
![Money Shot by Heather Long]()
Money Shot by Heather Long
Kaitlin Crosse wields an extraordinary power over me. She pushes, dares, and drives me to the brink of madness. Ever since our paths intertwined, my obsession with her has been absolute and unyielding. Every aspect of her calls out to me, yet the very thing I yearn for the most might be forever beyond my grasp. She resists my attempts to possess and protect her... -
![My Brother's Best Friends by Rebel Bloom]()
My Brother's Best Friends by Rebel Bloom
My Brother’s Best Friends claim I’m the one thing they can’t have, and the only thing they’ve ever wanted.They’re also the ones that took my v-card and ran me out of town. Coming back to Lunar, New Mexico was a nightmare.I had no choice after my life had gone up in flames.Between finding out that my boyfriend had a wife and getting fired from my job, I had little desire to think about hot men... -
![Forgiven by Leigh Lennon]()
Forgiven by Leigh Lennon
ClaraMy ex-husband kept a secret from me, when we were married. It was the worst betrayal. Now, after three years, of picking up my life, I've found a new man, one who had claimed my heart. He held the same secret, but in his honesty, I can move on with him, the only problem, I've never stopped loving my ex-husband.BodhiI lied to my wife for years, never being true to myself...Categorized as:
second chances single-mother m-m-f poly contemporary bisexual first-person-pov dual-pov -
![Steamy Ever After by Willow Winters, DD Lorenzo]()
Steamy Ever After by Willow Winters, DD Lorenzo
Rated: 4.50 of 5 stars · 6 ratingsWe’re putting our hottest book forward.From dark romances to small towns, protectors and second chances, binge this collection of our best selling romances or never before released stories all with happily ever afters... -
-
![Perilous Lady by Eva Chance, Harlow King]()
Perilous Lady by Eva Chance, Harlow King
Keep your enemies closer...I've proven I can stand with the fiercest gang in Paradise Bend. Now it's time to crush my traitor ex-fiancé and his stooges into smithereens.They've already butchered my family. I can't let them destroy the streets I called home. Wylder Noble and his inner circle are ready to rain down their own brand of justice... -
![Enchanted Lyrics by Addison Carter]()
Enchanted Lyrics by Addison Carter
You know how it goes, boy meets girl, girl falls for boy, boy takes someone else home.Or there’s this one, the one that got away comes back, and they don’t live happily ever after, because he never called.OK, I could have called too, but really after the turns that night took, I wasn’t sure he’d even want to hear from me.Then the rumours started, the reputation he built for himself confirmed it... -
![Wicked in the Shadows by Trina M. Lee]()
Wicked in the Shadows by Trina M. Lee
Rated: 4.33 of 5 stars · 6 ratingsI knew that coming home to them would be painful. I had no idea that it was only the beginning.After coming together to deal with the syndicate that followed me home, the guys went their separate ways once again. As I struggle to forgive and forget the past, they do as well. It all gets so much worse when an attack on the nightclub Wolfe and Ace own sets off a chain of horrific events...Categorized as:
second chances contemporary suspense length-medium reverse harem poly mafia vengeance -
![Pack Plus One by Ella Beck]()
Pack Plus One by Ella Beck
Leah Carter would rather eat glass than attend her ex’s wedding—especially since he dumped her for not being ‘pack material.’ But when a pack of rowdy, overprotective alphas adopts her as their last-minute date, she’s suddenly the center of more attention than she bargained for... -
![Twisted Kings: A why choose reverse harem mafia romance by Ava Summers]()
Twisted Kings: A why choose reverse harem mafia romance by Ava Summers
Dario promised to protect me from the evil monsters that lurked in the dark.Only it was all a pretty lie.After he vanished, I never expected to see Dario again. But fate had other ideas.The sweet, kind-hearted boy I once loved has grown into a dangerously sinful man with muscles, tattoos, and vengeance in his heart.I have no clue what Dario’s problem is... -
![Reign of Psychos by Ava Summers]()
Reign of Psychos by Ava Summers
Leaving might break us apart, but staying will be the death of us all.My heart is shattered.Just as I let my walls down and allowed my five broken princes in, I’m forced to push them away again.Milo, my sweet nerd.Landon, my future husband. Or so he thinks.Kyril, my fierce protector.Cassian, the man who gave up everything for me.And Dario, my first love... -
![The Sun & Her Burn by Giana Darling]()
The Sun & Her Burn by Giana Darling
From Wall Street Journal best-selling author Giana Darling comes a MMF romance about a movie star caught in a decade old scandal, a marriage of convenience, and forbidden love under Hollywood’s unforgiving spotlight. Ten years after my scandalous affair with the world’s most famous actor, Adam Meyers, and his gorgeous ex-wife, Savannah, I’ve achieved almost everythingI’ve ever dreamed of... -
![Who Laughs Last by Eva Ashwood]()
Who Laughs Last by Eva Ashwood
They say revenge is a dish best served cold... But I'd rather serve it hot, with a side of humiliation. The Icons got what they wanted. My life is a smoldering wreck because of them. But that doesn't mean I'm done fighting. What I did to Trent is just the beginning. He deserves so much worse for what he's done to me. West and Reese are no better...Categorized as:
second chances new adult contemporary cruel hero poly length-medium college from hate to love -
![Lethal Empress by Eva Chance, Harlow King]()
Lethal Empress by Eva Chance, Harlow King
Bury the hatchet... in your enemy's heart.I've reclaimed my throne, and Wylder Noble has demanded his. But war still rages all through Paradise Bend.It turns out this war involves powers from far beyond our little county. Powers determined to bring the fighting to an end, even if that means painting the streets with blood on both sides... -
![Ruthless Queen by Eva Chance, Harlow King]()
Ruthless Queen by Eva Chance, Harlow King
Heavy lies the crown…I thought getting my revenge would give me some kind of peace. Instead it seems to have brought an even worse villain to my doorstep.Or rather, to the Nobles’ doorstep, which the big boss of Paradise Bend’s most powerful gang is not at all happy about. I may have won over Wylder Noble and his men, but his father is another story entirely.A brutally murderous story...Categorized as:
second chances contemporary suspense reverse harem poly cold hero length-short from hate to love -
-
![Bikers & Bars by Suki Williams, Jarica James]()
Bikers & Bars by Suki Williams, Jarica James
Always the mom-friend and never the mom… That was the most painful feeling in my life until now.My new found pack was finally settling in until my past came calling. Viper. A powerful alpha and my ex-fiancé I’d left with a bullshit apology.Not only do my besties want answers, but so does my pack, and the alpha who isn’t too keen on the ex part of the fiancé description... -
![The Lieutenant by Melissa Adams]()
The Lieutenant by Melissa Adams
Rated: 3.71 of 5 stars · 7 ratingsClose quarters, hot sand, and forbidden love in this sexy new military stepbrother romance.To me Star Cove means love and heartbreak indissolubly tied together. When my father was assigned as base commander in Star Cove, I couldn’t say no to his offer to move in with him. I couldn’t wait for the beach and the sand and my first real job out of college...Categorized as:
second chances contemporary military reverse harem poly stepsibling first-person-pov dual-pov -
![Marked By Cain by A.R. Rose]()
Marked By Cain by A.R. Rose
Remember the saying that ends with ‘words can never hurt me’? They were wrong. Words can cut deep. Especially when hurtful words float past the lips of a man who felt like home. Cain Michaels My ex-boyfriend’s brother. The only man who could make me feel deeper than I ever thought possible. My worst nightmare and most vivid dream... -
![Three Shots by Brigham Vaughn]()
Three Shots by Brigham Vaughn
A musician, a computer designer, and a tavern owner walk into a bar: it’ll take three shots to get this right …When Reeve Jenkins picks up his guitar to sing at a local dive bar, the last thing he expects is to bring a guy home that night. Grant McGuire is a man drowning his sorrows in beer after a painful breakup...Categorized as:
independent heroine m-m-f menage contemporary bisexual poly small town length-medium -
![Power Play: A Why Choose Hockey Romance by Christina Sterling]()
Power Play: A Why Choose Hockey Romance by Christina Sterling
Lacey Bennett is ready for a fresh start. Leaving her troubled past behind, she lands her dream job as a physical therapist for the North Carolina Titans, an NHL team that’s as dynamic off the ice as they are on it.But her new beginning hits a snag when she discovers her high school sweetheart, Ben Kowalski, is one of the players.Ben has never gotten over Lacey—the girl who got away... -
![Ice Rivals by Kristen Granata]()
Ice Rivals by Kristen Granata
I once fell in love with two people.I was lucky enough they fell in love with me too.Chance Kellerman was the broken boy whose father convinced him he was worthless, and needed to hide his shameful desires.We became friends first, then brothers when we played hockey for the same team.But it was Presley King who brought us even closer. With her we became more...Categorized as:
second chances independent heroine from hate to love hockey m-m-f single-mother menage sports -
![Sweet Strings by Aly Beck]()
Sweet Strings by Aly Beck
Long before the world bowed down to the band Whispered Words. They shattered me to pieces when they walked away. Now, after five years apart, they're back to fix what they broke. If I let them... Before our fall—Callum, Rad, Kieran, and Asher—were mine. My everything. My rock stars. My future. Until they weren't. All it took was one night. One massive lie. One false accusation...Categorized as:
second chances independent heroine reverse harem contemporary new adult poly angst boss & employee -
![The Crash by Skye Warren, Amelia Wilde]()
The Crash by Skye Warren, Amelia Wilde
Carter Morelli works alone, but his orders are clear. Pilot the small aircraft carrying the renowned photographer to a remote island.June Porter wants to stay on solid land. She doesn't want to fly, but it's the only way to get to the research facility. Then her worst fears come true.A plane malfunction. A swift fall from the sky. And a heart-stopping crash...Categorized as:
second chances forced proximity contemporary grumpy sunshine suspense mystery angst humor -
![Who Falls Hardest by Eva Ashwood]()
Who Falls Hardest by Eva Ashwood
"What happened between the four of us—it changes everything."Everything in my life has been turned on its head. My allies have become enemies, and my enemies have become...I don't even know what.There's no denying the pull between me and each of the Icons anymore. I've denied it long enough, and I'm done letting secrets fester between us.I know they want me too...Categorized as:
second chances sports new adult contemporary cruel hero reverse harem poly length-short -
![Testing the Goalie by Laura John]()
Testing the Goalie by Laura John
Rated: 4.00 of 5 stars · 10 ratingsIt’s my last year as a GSU Koala, and I’ve worked hard to become the hotshot goalie our fans know and love. I could go pro, but that’s never been my end goal. I want to be a doctor, and I’m determined to get there.I give hockey and school my all, which hasn’t left much time for relationships. Not that I want one, since people always leave - a lesson I learned the hard way... -
-
![Gilded Princess by Penelope Black]()
Gilded Princess by Penelope Black
When I was little, I was obsessed with fairytales. My dad told me the stories of the stars and white knights who rescue princesses. I’d wear a silver plastic crown and stare at the sky, waiting for the day my knight in shining armor would come.Then my dad died, my crown broke, and my mom shipped my sister and me off to boarding school.And then I met them.My knights...Categorized as:
second chances contemporary suspense new adult reverse harem mafia poly explicit-open-door -
![Power Play Pieces by Ella Market, Ella Merkado]()
Power Play Pieces by Ella Market, Ella Merkado
After years of putting everyone else first, you decide to bet on yourself and gamble a relationship---or three. But love isn’t a game, and you can only hope your heart doesn’t end up in pieces. Five years ago, Audrey Hamilton's life was turned upside down after giving birth to a beautiful baby boy. Raising Asher by herself and opening her own business took everything she had and more... -
![Dual Wielding by Allyson Lindt]()
Dual Wielding by Allyson Lindt
ReeseI’ve loved Danny for as long as I can remember. As a friend. As a band mate. As more. We had a good run as a couple, but I walked away for fame. Talk about a big-time screw-up. No wonder I'm almost forty, still single, and singing in dive bars for beer tickets.DannyWhen Reese and I split, I was adrift without an anchor. I climbed into the bottom of a bottle and made myself at home... -
![Finding Her Sweet Spots by Joya Lively]()
Finding Her Sweet Spots by Joya Lively
The gorgeous Sweet brothers are New York City’s most eligible bachelors. They're anyone’s dream come true. But they can’t be mine.I made a vow to myself to take control of my life and make all my dreams come true. And that was going pretty well… Until them.A decade younger than me, I tell myself they’re nice to me because we work well together in our graduate program. Nothing else... -
![All That They Desire by Zoe York]()
All That They Desire by Zoe York
The final book in New York Times bestselling author Zoe York's first series! Jessica Doran needs a date who will make her husband—her ex-husband, she needs to remind herself—incredibly jealous. Evan West will do nicely, even if the charismatic winery owner runs the risk of being too much of a good thing. Too hot, too kind, too ruthlessly honest about wanting to take her to bed... -
![Three Hearts on the Line by Michelle Dare]()
Three Hearts on the Line by Michelle Dare
Rated: 3.95 of 5 stars · 12 ratingsThe NamesakeDexen Dremest leads a good life. He owns an exclusive club, has friends he cares about, and has a supportive family. Too bad there’s a hole inside his chest where his heart used to be. One man ripped it out, leaving only tattered ends behind.The Tech GuruGreer Lynx is happy most of the time... -
![My Ex-Best Men by Rebel Bloom]()
My Ex-Best Men by Rebel Bloom
Getting stuck at a destination wedding with one ex is awkward.Getting stuck with all three? A spicy disaster I didn’t RSVP for.I’m Claire, a chronic people pleaser determined to be the perfect Maid of Honor for my best friend. That plan flies out the window the moment I step into the hotel lobby… and find all three of my ex-boyfriends standing there... as best men...Categorized as:
second chances independent heroine contemporary humor poly reverse harem rockstars tycoon -
![Saving Liam by Sasha L. Miller]()
Saving Liam by Sasha L. Miller
Rated: 3.86 of 5 stars · 7 ratingsLeyton lived a quiet, simple life as a prosperous, thriving merchant alongside his twin brother Liam. But that life is shattered when Liam goes missing, and Leyton is told that the only way to save his brother's life is to seduce a king... -
![Scorned Princess by Eva Chance, Harlow King]()
Scorned Princess by Eva Chance, Harlow King
Hell hath no fury...I thought I was trading one evil for a lesser one. Marry a man I might eventually love, forge an alliance between his gang and my father's, and get out from under Dad's sadistic thumb.Turns out my fiancé has other plans. Like slaughtering me and my entire family the night before the wedding.I make it out alive, left with nothing but a thirst for vengeance...Categorized as:
second chances contemporary suspense new adult reverse harem cold hero poly length-medium -
![Rough and Ready by Mari Carr]()
Rough and Ready by Mari Carr
A steamy friends to lovers romance that breaks the bro-code…big time!Gio is blessed with a big family and lots of friends. Unfortunately, there’s an unspoken code amongst his buddies…one where sisters are off-limits. That wouldn’t be a problem if he and his best friend, Rafe, could stop thinking about Kayden’s vivacious, fun-loving little sister, Keeley...Categorized as:
independent heroine menage m-f-m friends to lovers forced proximity contemporary multicultural poly -
-
![Dumb Girl by C.R. Jane, Rebecca Royce]()
Dumb Girl by C.R. Jane, Rebecca Royce
They were never supposed to find me.Graham, Charles, Jamie, and Steven are back.And this time they want revenge.The four of them are dead if Holland doesn’t pull off the impossible.But all of the guys are more interested in why Holland did what she did to them than the danger that’s knocking on their door...Categorized as:
second chances sports new adult contemporary length-short open-door forced proximity poly -
![Her Four Cowboys by Natasha L. Black]()
Her Four Cowboys by Natasha L. Black
Rated: 3.78 of 5 stars · 14 ratingsThis cowgirl knows how to ride.All night long.My tomboy best friend is all grown up.One mistletoe kiss is all it takes.Electric and steamy.I want to break all the rules.So do my three brothers.The Kent brothers learned a long time ago:Don’t fight with your brother. Just share.We wouldn’t mind sharing,To get Lucy all to ourselves.She can still be a good girl,Even if she’s a little bit bad with us... -
![Room Three: They Like to Bite by Ember Davis]()
Room Three: They Like to Bite by Ember Davis
Rated: 3.60 of 5 stars · 5 ratingsELLAI’ve explored a lot within the walls of Club Sin, but it hasn’t been quite right. I’ve found pleasure, but I’m still searching for what or who makes my body come alive like it never has before. It’s a place where no one knows more than I want them to, and I feel free. I wasn’t expecting to walk in one night to find three men who I haven’t seen in ten years...Categorized as:
second chances independent heroine anthologies contemporary military poly reverse harem fetish -
![Vengeful Princess by Ava Summers]()
Vengeful Princess by Ava Summers
In my world, mafia princesses are weak, but I’m no victim.Out of the blue, my father sends me to Abernethy, an exclusive college for the offspring of the rich and criminally inclined. He says I must get close to the campus’ golden boy.Cassian is the infamous son of Lucian Forsyth, a powerful, connected man - and my father's enemy...Categorized as:
second chances independent heroine new adult mafia length-long contemporary poly reverse harem -
![Jagged Lies by Evelyn Flood]()
Jagged Lies by Evelyn Flood
Six months ago, I had my life all figured out.I was going to be free of this horrible town, away from the small-minded, perfect people who judged me at first glance without bothering to look again.Nothing has changed.And yet everything has changed.The alphas that once acted as my shield now look at me with hatred in their eyes.They say it’s my fault.All of it is my fault...Categorized as:
independent heroine second chances omegaverse new adult contemporary angst m-f reverse harem -
![Her Secret by Ivy Fox]()
Her Secret by Ivy Fox
“Our love is so much more than a mere catastrophic occurrence.” My name is Freya Wilson. I am not your typical girl next door. I’m far from it. As my mother likes to point out since I graduated high school, I should be planning my life instead of wallowing around the house, in my pajamas all day...
Fantastic book recommendations by romance book lovers for romance book lovers.
Find out more about romance.io.
Find out more about romance.io.
Get recommendations by genres & tropes
Use the romance book finder to mix and match over 100 content keywords to find the books that match your preferences
Or - use our amazing romance book finder to get recommendations based on your favorite content tropes and themes. Mix and match at will.
