Books like 'Born to be Witchy'
Readers who enjoyed Born to be Witchy by A.J. Macey & Jarica James also liked the following books featuring the same tropes, story themes, relationship dynamics and character types.
fantasy paranormal poly (3+ people) reverse harem gay romance new adult witches queer bisexual m-m-m
-
House of Kallan by Crea Reitan
Rated: 4.55 of 5 stars · 11 ratingsI thought I knew where I belonged. That I had found my happily ever after. Looking back, I was really just blissfully unaware of how unhealthy my family was.Now I'm wandering the world, trying to find my place. Trying to heal my broken heart from a fate that no one could have predicted. The crushing blow was served to me by those who were supposed to love and support me for the rest of my life... -
![Elemental Fae Academy: The Complete Trilogy by Lexi C. Foss, J.R. Thorn]()
Elemental Fae Academy: The Complete Trilogy by Lexi C. Foss, J.R. Thorn
Welcome to Elemental Fae Academy where fae are real, the mentors are hot, and a magical plague has wiped out entire kingdoms. Oh, and the fae think I'm to blame.╰☆☆Elemental Fae Book One☆☆╮I kiss one guy at a bar on a dare and suddenly I'm whisked away to the fae realm, thrown into an Academy to control my gifts, and dodging mean girls who want to pin me for crimes I didn't commit... -
![]()
![]()
Sponsored links -
![House of Malak by Crea Reitan]()
House of Malak by Crea Reitan
I’m the Director of Haven, a newly established sanctuary for all the misused and mistreated humans that The Harem Project recovers from the Division of Silence. I have my hands full, trying to save as many lives as I can.Then a chance meeting has me virtually running into the men that hold a piece of my heavenly soul and my world shifts... -
![Creature of the Wild by Maya Nicole]()
Creature of the Wild by Maya Nicole
With the wind at our backs and the dagger forcing our will, we’re on our way to find my next mate. New information from my brother makes me question everything. There’s no escaping what’s to come.A creature from the wild will hold me tight, but what if I’m already in pieces?*Creature of the Wild is book three in the Her Creatures series and is a paranormal shifter romance told in multiple POVs... -
-
![Celestial Academy: The Complete Series by Maya Nicole]()
Celestial Academy: The Complete Series by Maya Nicole
What consequence does Lucifer give his daughter? Celestial Academy: The Complete Series omnibus is all three books in the Celestial Academy trilogy.Book 1: AscendMy friends always complained about their parents' rules and consequences. Well, I have them beat. I'm the daughter of the devil and was just expelled from my senior year of high school for breaking a guy's nose... -
![Performer by Lexie Winston]()
Performer by Lexie Winston
Hi, my name is Lila, and I'm an alien. I have two husbands and two fiancés. I also won two more mates in a kickass battle for supremacy, and I may have been seduced and had a crazy, sexy swim with a merman when he sang to me. Oh, and did I mention I have just hatched three beautiful but slippery kraken babies?And that was just in the first month with the Galaxy Circus... -
![House of Agni by Crea Reitan]()
House of Agni by Crea Reitan
Beware the fire for it burns. It’s time to find my home. My family. In a world where strength is hunted and those unlike the rest are sentenced to death, my kind are better off in groups. Fire is not something to dabble in and when given the right fuel, it can destroy anything. Thus, we are public enemy number one in the world of supernaturals... -
![Witches Be Crazy by A.J. Macey]()
Witches Be Crazy by A.J. Macey
Rated: 4.20 of 5 stars · 16 ratingsNothing in Aris Calisto’s life has ever been basic, and after a cauldron full of unexpected events, she finds herself a fugitive. Going on the run should have been the biggest challenge of her life, but after being separated from her tethers, she’s faced with an impossible choice--submit or run.With time ticking down, Aris and her ragtag band of witches have to risk it all... -
![Broken Bonds by K.L. Moore]()
Broken Bonds by K.L. Moore
My bonds are broken. Gone. I'm left alone to pick up my shattered pieces. A bondless, pregnant omega. It feels like I can't breathe without them. We were all each other had in the world. Or so I thought. One of my alphas had a brother that he kept secret for ten years. A twin brother. Link shows up out of the blue with his pack, wanting to help me... -
![The Complete Chaos of Foxes Trilogy: A Scavenger Story by Emma Dean]()
The Complete Chaos of Foxes Trilogy: A Scavenger Story by Emma Dean
Rated: 4.43 of 5 stars · 7 ratingsWhat should you do when you're outfoxed?Kenzie is the only non-witch in her family. When her younger sister's powers end up stripped from her, Kenzie promises to find a way to get them back - after all she has a very specific set of skills after trying to make up for not having any powers of her own... -
![A King to be Loved by Brea Alepoú]()
A King to be Loved by Brea Alepoú
Rated: 4.50 of 5 stars · 6 ratingsThey say only the strong can afford tranquility.Titos has been fighting since the moment he was born he wants the happiness that everyone promises. He wants the days where he wakes up and there isn’t a new tragedy to fix. He wants it for his territory, friends, and his MATES.Is peace the stuff of dreams?As Titos is forced to take care of the remaining threat, or he and his men will never be free... -
![The Library of the Profane: The Complete Series by J.B. Trepagnier]()
The Library of the Profane: The Complete Series by J.B. Trepagnier
Rated: 4.50 of 5 stars · 6 ratingsThe Library of the Profane has everything your black heart desires. But we don’t just allow anyone to get a library card. Need to summon a demon? Raise the dead? A clan of vampires bothering you? Do you like the really nasty werewolf erotica? The Library of the Profane has all of that, but not everyone can handle the contents (Some people can’t handle their werewolf erotica)... -
![Perilous by Elle Lincoln]()
Perilous by Elle Lincoln
Rated: 4.50 of 5 stars · 6 ratingsChaos incites with a witch’s blood,Then the curse is firm and good.The world crumbles all around me, cities burn, and chaos unfolds. Driven not by heroism, but by a festering pain and seething anguish, I yearn for the inferno to consume everything. The flames dance in my eyes as the world burns, mirroring the tempest within me... -
![Not Quite Whole by Kaye Draper]()
Not Quite Whole by Kaye Draper
The phoenix sovereign of Westhold might not want Sam for anything more than their hunter skills, but that won’t stop the sabertoothed hunter from defending their unclaimed mate—and the stupid utopian city of equality that Theo insists on building.Things heat up in the last installment of the Not Quite series…and someone might just get burned... -
-
![A Witch Out of Time by C. Rochelle]()
A Witch Out of Time by C. Rochelle
**WARNING: THIS BOOK CONTAINS A CLIFFHANGER** It is also RH, with multiple POV, unusual spicy smex, and a focus on romance (including MM) and body positivity. If any of those things don't work for you, please don't read it!Four hundred years is a long time to wait for your fated mates only to have two of them cruelly ripped away... -
![Trading In Blood by Brea Alepoú]()
Trading In Blood by Brea Alepoú
Rheland is the king of vampires and in these trying times, he is reminded that ruling with fear alone isn’t good enough. People change and Rheland is the embodiment of that. He knows his past isn’t the cleanest but he wants to spend the rest of his eternity trying to clear off a spot.Lynk needs housing for his pack and Rheland wants the man closer. A win-win... -
![The Dragon Mistress: Book 2 by R.A. Steffan]()
The Dragon Mistress: Book 2 by R.A. Steffan
Rated: 4.22 of 5 stars · 9 ratingsThe survival of the last living dragons rests with me and my misfit friends.So... yeah. No pressure.Mind you, this whole thing would be easier if two of our number weren't hell-bent on killing each other. Rayth and Nyx have both been hiding secrets for a very long time, but now they face a choice. Let go of their ugly pasts, or watch the future burn to the ground... -
![A Cursed Legacy by Kaye Draper]()
A Cursed Legacy by Kaye Draper
Rated: 4.29 of 5 stars · 7 ratingsMy family is dead and gone. But they left their grimoire behind. Now it's my job to free the powerful magical beings trapped in the pages. I might just find a whole new family…if they don't kill me first... -
![The Lost and the Hunted - Book One by Grace McGinty]()
The Lost and the Hunted - Book One by Grace McGinty
Rated: 4.40 of 5 stars · 5 ratingsWhat’s the worst part of being a snow leopard shifter? It wasn’t the epic-sized hairballs or the constant nudity. No, it was the fear. The fear of being captured and becoming another statistic, another underground prize. When an unintentional rescue results in some accidental consequences, Celeste knows that the sunny-natured Reese will have her back... -
![Resting Witch Face by A.J. Macey, Jarica James]()
Resting Witch Face by A.J. Macey, Jarica James
Rated: 4.06 of 5 stars · 20 ratingsAris Calisto is no longer the newest student at Aether Academy but after her creepy headmaster finds out about her relationship with a professor, she’s finding her seemingly new home is quickly becoming hellsticks. To make matters worse, when someone leaks Aris’s new powers, her and her guys are faced with a Council inquiry... -
![Southeast by Vera Valentine]()
Southeast by Vera Valentine
With another summer on the Jersey shore coming to a close, Jess was more than ready to hang up her water park vest until next year. Still recovering from the shock of being kidnapped and nearly killed, she's barely had time to process the fact that monsters are real.The impulsive offer to let her repentant abductor-turned-protector crash on her couch is going better than anticipated... -
![Silenced by Jayce Carter]()
Silenced by Jayce Carter
Rated: 4.10 of 5 stars · 13 ratingsFrom spoiled rich girl to imprisoned siren—sometimes life sucks.My life was perfect—a cute, loving boyfriend, a rich and well-connected family and an immaculately planned-out future.As it turns out, perfection is a lie... -
![Claiming by A.K. Koonce]()
Claiming by A.K. Koonce
I’m coming after Kreedence. I want him to know what it feels like to live in fear. Just as I did for so many years.Three dragon shifters and a hellhound should be more than enough help. And yet, I’m seeking out allies in all the wrong a prince with resources, a deadly king with power, and a mysterious queen who died decades ago.New secrets will come to light... -
![Elemental Fae Academy: Book Two by Lexi C. Foss, J.R. Thorn]()
Elemental Fae Academy: Book Two by Lexi C. Foss, J.R. Thorn
Someone wants me dead. Worse yet, my link to Spirit is dying. Why? Because Exos has been taken by a new enemy. Now I have to rely on my other elements to find my missing link before it’s too late. Oh, and I need a guard to protect me while I learn how to defend myself. No big deal. Master the elements, find my lost Spirit, and identify the bad guy. Yeah. Easy... -
-
![Trial of the Vampire by Jarica James]()
Trial of the Vampire by Jarica James
Last semester at Obsidian Cove Supernatural Academy ended with Lennox’s heart shattering. Now Evander is stuck in the Regency Prison while she’s forced to stay at school pretending nothing is wrong. She focuses every waking hour on trying to learn how to use her constantly changing powers and free him at the same time... -
![Hell's Redemption: The Complete Series Boxset by Grace McGinty]()
Hell's Redemption: The Complete Series Boxset by Grace McGinty
THE COMPLETE HELL'S REDEMPTION SERIES including bonus Novella! a #Whychoose romance with the devil, swearing, M/M, inappropriate gifts and orgies in Hell. THE REDEEMABLE : BOOK ONE Arcadia’s dying. But that’s okay... -
![Stowaway and Silent Song by Vera Valentine]()
Stowaway and Silent Song by Vera Valentine
A selkie, a siren, and a sea captain walk into a tavern...After building a reputation for herself as one of the best cargo-runners in the Winding Way, Captain Miranda Cardonna finally feels at home on the deck of her own ship, the Tempest Tossed... -
![Daruss by April Kelley]()
Daruss by April Kelley
Rated: 4.20 of 5 stars · 5 ratingsOne is his enemy. The other is his fated mate. Daruss has never had so much to fight for.Dragon shifter Daruss Oyen has everything to lose. After a rival club starts a war over territory, Daruss is there to fight for the family he’s found. But everything changes after he falls in love with a snarky human named Jude, who happens to be the rival club’s spy... -
![Shaped by Destiny by Sara Hinds]()
Shaped by Destiny by Sara Hinds
Rated: 4.00 of 5 stars · 11 ratings“You’re nothing.Just a nobody that wasn’t wanted.”Those words have played in my head since I was five years old.Every night when I close my eyes, I relive that moment. The heat, the smoke, and the cruel smile on her face. For the longest time, I believed them. All I wanted was to find a place to belong, to be needed... -
![Elemental Fae Academy: Book Three by Lexi C. Foss, J.R. Thorn]()
Elemental Fae Academy: Book Three by Lexi C. Foss, J.R. Thorn
How is a girl supposed to concentrate with five hot fae mentors? It’s not like I have a lot to do or anything. Royal Coronations. Finals. A Solstice Ball. And a mother hellbent on ruining the fae world. Just another ordinary day for me, Claire Summers, the halfling fae with access to all five elements. Everyone is counting on me, even my esteemed mentor, Elana... -
![Home to the Hollow by Cassandra Featherstone]()
Home to the Hollow by Cassandra Featherstone
Rated: 4.00 of 5 stars · 6 ratingsYou can take the girl out of the South, but you can't take the South out of the girl.Jolene Athena Whitley left home a decade ago and has never looked back—until her dream job rejects her. Heartbroken, she vows to get her life back on track. If she can figure out the dirty secrets that flagged her file, the job as an FBI profiler is in the bag... -
![Talon's Claim by Melody Novak]()
Talon's Claim by Melody Novak
Rated: 4.00 of 5 stars · 5 ratingsI’m not who anyone thinks I am.But they all want to make me their queen.Kidnapped from Earth six years ago, I'm used to hiding my true nature. I pretended to be bad at my studies while secretly helping the resistance against the City's cruel overlords. But now that my sister has taken the dragons’ throne, I’m in the spotlight. Not great for a Fae thief... -
![Home to the Hollow by Cassandra Featherstone]()
Home to the Hollow by Cassandra Featherstone
Rated: 4.00 of 5 stars · 5 ratings"You can take the girl out of the South, but you can't take the South out of the girl."Jolene Athena Whitley left home a decade ago and has never looked back—until her dream job rejects her. Heartbroken, she vows to get her life back on track. If she can figure out the dirty secrets that flagged her file, the job as an FBI profiler is in the bag... -
![Where There's Smoke by Amy Sumida]()
Where There's Smoke by Amy Sumida
A Gay Why Choose Fantasy RomanceI have three lovers and I'm about to add a fourth. Not because I'm greedy but because we need to form a stronger fighting team to kill the Corrupter. My love literally empowers men. We fall in love, bond, then go kick ass. Romantic, right? No, not very. But I'm good with it. How could I not be? I'm the one who they share. I don't do the sharing... -
-
![Secrets Among the Tides by Aleera Anaya Ceres]()
Secrets Among the Tides by Aleera Anaya Ceres
Rated: 3.95 of 5 stars · 10 ratingsThe only life Maisie Fauna knows is one of poverty and tragedy. Years of war killed off her friends and neighbors one by one. So when the crown’s soldiers arrive to take their pick of able-bodied mer, it’s no surprise that the Captain of the Royal Guard takes an interest in her.Only, it’s not so she can fight.The Princess of Thalassar is missing and to save the kingdom, they’ll need a lookalike... -
![The Call of Monsters by J.B. Trepagnier]()
The Call of Monsters by J.B. Trepagnier
People might used to have worshipped the Olympians, but I never did. I’ll kill every last one of them to get Hephaestus back. I used to love my Greek mythology classes until I got kidnapped and actually met some Gods. I took Hephaestus as a lover and Hades and Persephone are not all that bad, but the rest of them?They hurt my monsters... -
![Elemental Fae Queen by Lexi C. Foss, J.R. Thorn]()
Elemental Fae Queen by Lexi C. Foss, J.R. Thorn
A Why Choose Paranormal Romance I never should have listened to Cyrus.I knew better. But he has this sexy little smile that just melts my heart. Add that to all my handsome mates encouraging me to take the next step in our lives, and I agreed to what I thought was a fantastic plan.Big. F*cking. Mistake.Because now I'm pregnant, and let me tell you, this is no freaking picnic! I can't see my feet... -
![Restless Spirit by Briana Michaels]()
Restless Spirit by Briana Michaels
Rated: 3.91 of 5 stars · 18 ratingsHunted by dark spirits, she’s running out of options... At first glance, she probably seemed like any woman in her prime - Full of life, fearless, and dances like everyone’s watching. Except no one is because she’s dead. Worse than dead, she’s invisible... -
![Tainted Souls by Alisha Williams]()
Tainted Souls by Alisha Williams
Zed is dead. I watched him die in my arms.But I refuse to let this be the end. My father has the power to bring him back. And if he refuses to, I’ll go into the pit of souls and get him out myself.I’m warned that if I do this, that he won’t be the same. That there's no guarantee that what I pull out of the pit will be my Zed.I’m too stricken with grief to care... -
![Fake It Till You Mate It by Flora Quincy]()
Fake It Till You Mate It by Flora Quincy
No one finds happiness with the same pack twice. Right?In three months, I’m marrying the perfect-for-me pack. The SweetNothings are internationally famous rockstars who share my love of adventure. It doesn’t hurt that they have a private jet and spoil me rotten.But before I can tie the knot, my ex-pack needs to sign the divorce papers... -
![Safe Haven by Jarica James]()
Safe Haven by Jarica James
Who knew that two words could shatter every hope and dream Briar had for her future.You’re pregnant. Most omegas dream of this, but the only thing Briar can think about is that awful night. While she suffers alone, her attacker gets to flaunt his perfect life in her face.Until his assistant finds out her secret... -
![The Dragon Mistress by R.A. Steffan]()
The Dragon Mistress by R.A. Steffan
They’re the last five dragons in existence. To survive, they must form soul-bonds with five humans who are pure of heart and resolute of spirit. Too bad they’re stuck with us instead. The angry drunk. The shameless man-whore. The coward who ran away and got his comrades killed. The ice-cold assassin for hire. And me, the girl with abandonment issues as deep and wide as the Southern Sea... -
![Mercy & Her Devils by Rosemary A. Johns]()
Mercy & Her Devils by Rosemary A. Johns
Rated: 3.82 of 5 stars · 16 ratingsMy name is Mercy, and I’m an Omega with a broken bond.Devastated, I’m sent to the Omega Institute. I'm held until the auction with a gorgeous single dad, whose scent is like paradise. Both Omegas, we make a pact to form a found family without Alphas. With our heats fast approaching, we’re broken out of the Institute by a mysterious pack of a giant, blazing hot Alpha and his flirty mafia Beta... -
![Hunter's Moon by Gwyneira Blythe]()
Hunter's Moon by Gwyneira Blythe
Rated: 3.83 of 5 stars · 6 ratingsThey call it the Golden Age. An age of sorcery and gaslight. The magical and the mundane. The gifted and the cursed.My name is Victoria Grey.Witches in this day and age move through the ton with ease and grace, but not me. No mother. No magic. No connections... -
-
![Jolly Cupid by Sarah Blue]()
Jolly Cupid by Sarah Blue
What’s a cupid to do when she’s not in the Christmas spirit?Make the men who broke her heart fall to their knees begging for forgiveness, of course.Candy has spent the last six months pouting around Cupidale, wondering why the two men she finally had a connection with haven’t reached out... -
![Winter Fae Queen by Lexi C. Foss, J.R. Thorn]()
Winter Fae Queen by Lexi C. Foss, J.R. Thorn
Rated: 3.83 of 5 stars · 15 ratingsThe Royal Water Fae I’m in love with just hired me to be his intern. Oh. My. Fae. I only applied for the job because of a dare, and now I’m packing my bags for the North Pole. No big deal. I can totally be professional. I haven’t seen him since the Academy anyway. Maybe he’s gotten fat from all the Winter Fae sweets? Except, no. Kalt hasn’t gotten fat at all... -
![Tainted Hearts by Alisha Williams]()
Tainted Hearts by Alisha Williams
So everything the pure bloods have been taught all these years was a lie?Does God really know what his right hand men are doing in his name?And how the hell do I tell three of my mates that their fathers are lying, deceiving sorry excuses of Archangels?My life got turned upside down the moment I stepped onto this island and it never seems to stop.I went from two mates to five... -
![Call of the Siren by Jarica James]()
Call of the Siren by Jarica James
Obsidian Cove Prep was supposed to be Lennox Malia’s chance at freedom. Instead, it ended up as her own personal hell on Earth. Daily bullying and a severe lack of friends left her feeling hopeless and desperate for graduation. That all changed one day when five guys showed up, very obviously interested in her... -
![Rebel & Her Knights by Rosemary A. Johns]()
Rebel & Her Knights by Rosemary A. Johns
My name is Rebel, and I’m the only Omega resistance leader.I should be hiding from my dad who marked me as a Reject. But instead, I fall into the path of the impossibly beautiful, wealthy, and influential Knight pack, during my first heat... -
![Unlikely Omega by Mona Black]()
Unlikely Omega by Mona Black
Rated: 3.75 of 5 stars · 8 ratingsThe prophesy speaks of Fae-blooded omegas, destined to bring back the lost Fae race. I just never thought the prophecy was about me. I am just an acolyte in the Temple, sworn to purity of mind and body. An average young woman with doubts and hopes and dreams. I'm certainly not a prophesied Fae omega who will help bring back the lost Fae race. Not me...
Fantastic book recommendations by romance book lovers for romance book lovers.
Find out more about romance.io.
Find out more about romance.io.
Get recommendations by genres & tropes
Use the romance book finder to mix and match over 100 content keywords to find the books that match your preferences
Or - use our amazing romance book finder to get recommendations based on your favorite content tropes and themes. Mix and match at will.
