Books like 'Buttercup'
Readers who enjoyed Buttercup by Helen Scott also liked the following books featuring the same tropes, story themes, relationship dynamics and character types.
paranormal reverse harem fantasy funny poly (3+ people) magic vampires witches demons shapeshifters
-
Dinosaurs, Doubts & Albert Einswine by Sedona Ashe
I’m ready for the chaos of Texas to be a speck in my rearview mirror. So when the museum director throws me a bone by arranging for us to visit a fossil dig in Utah, I jump at the opportunity.I need a breather from all the craziness that has become my life since waking multiple dino shifters. A dig in Utah sounds like exactly what I need, the perfect getaway... -
Coven Relics by J.B. Trepagnier
How is this my life right now? Key is not really Doctor Key. I’m over that part, but it wouldn’t shock me if he really was a doctor. He definitely wasn’t lying about getting arrested. There are now three people at my museum who can translate the missing page from the grimoire as easily as breathing. This isn’t good. This isn’t good at all.But I trust my new houseguests... -
Rogue's Crisis by Jillian West
Rogue is a rule follower through and through.Working as a bounty hunter for the paranormal council is the perfect job for this Seelie fae, especially considering she can sense mistruths. Things get muddy when what the council believes doesnʼt line up with what she sees with her own two eyes.Everything points to her suspects being innocent, while one of her coworkers begins to look guilty... -
Spirited by C.M. Stunich
Brynn of Haversey is a spirit whisperer—a person blessed with the ability to see and speak to the dead. In the country of Amerin, she's one of a select few with magical gifts known as whisperers. Every year, the Royal College accepts a small number of new students, all magically inclined, all whisperers... -
-
Calluna: A Paranormal RomCom by Jewels Arthur
Calluna is sassy, snarky, and doesn't give a crap about, well, anything. A complete cynic, Calluna doesn't believe in all this love garbage that she keeps seeing all over the town. Nope, she is just fine keeping to herself and her pet store, Beastie Besties. She has a mystery to solve anyway, someone is cursing all the animals in town with dark magic... -
Sage by J.E. Cluney
Do you know what I love? Being my own boss. Do you know what I hate? A lack of social life.Silver Springs is supe friendly, so I thought it was the perfect place to call home with my pet pig, Wilma.Too bad I can’t seem to get myself out to meet people, despite Wilma’s consistent nagging...Categorized as:
shapeshifters vampires paranormal vikings legends & fairy tales fantasy reverse harem poly -
Magic Awakened: The Complete Series by Sadie Moss
Rated: 4.40 of 5 stars · 11 ratingsThis complete reverse harem series is ready to be devoured! Book One: Bound by MagicOne badass mercenary. Four sexy-as-sin rebels. Bound together by powerful magic and dangerous desire...In a world ruled by magic, surviving without it means I have to be quicker, smarter, and fiercer than the magical beings that run this city.I get by just fine working as a bounty hunter.. -
Power and Pentad: Part Two by Amanda Cashure
Rated: 4.41 of 5 stars · 10 ratings♥ Power & Pentad Part-Two promises the reuniting of our beloved harem, the introduction of long-awaited key players in the battle to win this war, Shade finding her Alpha voice and Pax learning to trust mortals (well, a select few mortals) as well as a bubble bath scene, shower scene, and the beginning of answers to so many of the questions we've all been waiting for (though not all of them)... -
Amethyst (Jewels Cafe) by C.Y. Jones
Amethyst is a curse worker on the run after hexing her ex. (He he that rhymes) On the bus to Silver Springs, she meets a set of hot twins but with a vengeful ex after her and a group of pissed off vampires, she’s a little distracted... -
Bound by Light by Demi Warrik
Rated: 4.50 of 5 stars · 8 ratingsFate always has a plan for us. But sometimes I wonder if fate really knows what the hell she’s doing.With my best friend missing, my life is a chaotic mess. This supernatural world I’ve found myself in is placing new pawns on the table faster than I can keep track. The line between friend and foe is murky, and I don’t plan on pulling a knife out of my back anytime soon... -
Called by Fate by Demi Warrik
Rated: 4.44 of 5 stars · 9 ratingsFate always has a plan for us and I’m finally ready to own mine.My destiny is spread out before me and like all things in life, I’m going to tackle it head on with fists and magic blazing. I couldn’t dodge this magical shitstorm even if I wanted to, and now, it just engulfed me, sucking me into this mystical world that’s starting to feel like my own... -
A Tail of Woah by Jacquelyn Faye
Rated: 4.21 of 5 stars · 18 ratingsAs the daughter of an Inari Fox, celestial messenger to the gods, I should have been reverent, wise, and collected like my father. As the daughter of a kitsune queen, I should have been poised and delicate, with just a hint of playfulness to pay homage to the fox spirit within, just like my mother... -
Warrior Witch by T.L. Hamilton, Katherine Isaac
“Violence may not solve everything, but it sure as f*ck makes me feel better.”Between attempts to tame her out-of-control lightning magic and her job in security, every day has been a battle for untrained witch, Harlow. Which suits her “electrocute first, ask questions never” attitude... -
Christmas With The Camdens by A.M. McCoy
Rated: 4.22 of 5 stars · 15 ratingsDeck the halls with balls of Camden Twins… Oops, I mean boughs of holly. Fa-la-la-la- but also the twins.Three years have passed since we left Bailey, Finn, and Walker Camden in Mayfield Montana with their three-year-old daughter Eloise Jade. Now, the trio have been married for six years, and have two more kids running around causing trouble, twin boys Parker and Paxton... -
-
Myth-Behaving by M.J. Marstens
Rated: 4.30 of 5 stars · 10 ratingsIt's a bird.It's a plane.It's. . . Belle Harper trying to flap away from all her problems.I thought being a sex addict was bad—but a war with men who can turn into bloodthirsty predators and want to breed me totally tops that. Add on I'm turning into some unknown monster, and I miss the good ol' days where I knew what I was—a dirty little pervert... -
Lupine by Hanleigh Bradley
They say I'm they're princess! Who are they kidding? I'm just Silver Springs Resident Orphan.Even in Silver Springs, a town full of paranormal abnormalities, Lupine, the town's resident orphan has never felt like she belonged.Overworked, stressed, hair flying everywhere, Lupine is constantly on the move working with the unique children in the Silver Spring's Orphanage... -
The Breach by L.L. Frost
Rated: 4.33 of 5 stars · 9 ratingsCousin Cassandra has made her presence known by crashing Adie’s housewarming party and it’s up to Adie to help Julian while also protecting her roommates... -
Dragon Games by November Sweets
Rated: 4.33 of 5 stars · 9 ratingsIt’s that time of year once again ladies!The dragon mating season is upon us!It’s time for those highborn human women to lie, cheat, claw, and stab their way into a chance at being mated to a dragon.But something strange has happened this year, it’s not only the high borns that have a chance to win the gauntlet, even the low born like me has a chance to win the prize and the bragging rights...Categorized as:
shapeshifters magic reverse harem fantasy high fantasy paranormal fated-mates dragon shifter -
Clever Witch by Nikki Dean
Rated: 4.33 of 5 stars · 9 ratingsHide your magic. Don't tell anyone you're dating your TA, and now maybe your handler, too. Don't tell anyone about the jaguar in your room, or secret lab under the dorm. Keep your friends close, and your enemies closer... -
Her Fated Wolves: A Reverse Harem Prequel by Lacey Carter Andersen
Rated: 4.43 of 5 stars · 7 ratingsWorking at the House of Wieners isn’t as glamorous as it sounds…I spend my days being yelled at by customers and working for a boss who couldn’t give a crap, but all that’s about to change. My best friend has an opportunity to move to a small town and start over, and I’m going with her.Everything had been arranged. I’m ready to leave this town behind.But then they show up...Categorized as:
shapeshifters vampires witches magic reverse harem paranormal fated-mates insta-love -
Lupine: Wanted by Wolves by Hanleigh Bradley
My birth started a war that my daughter's birth will end... Does that even make sense to you?There is no such thing as a 'normal day' at the Silver Springs Orphanage. In fact, most days are utter chaos between the Creepy Twins giving away all of Lupine's secrets and Edmond constantly running away... -
The Blaze of the Dragon's Heart: A Reverse Harem Paranormal Fantasy Romance by Willa Hart
Rated: 4.50 of 5 stars · 6 ratingsCan’t a girl catch a break?The evil mage the dragon world thought was long dead? Turns out…not so much. Vazha’s back with a vengeance, ready to destroy dragonkind and enslave the human population.My boys and I may have rescued my best friend, but the devastating news Uncle Max has been captured means we can’t go home until Vazha is destroyed... -
Moonlit Nephrite by Eva Delaney, Mia Harlan
Rated: 4.50 of 5 stars · 6 ratingsMy ex said I was a failure. I proved him wrong by opening a magical cafe. When it might get shut down, can my four fated mates help save it?I woke up in bed with my best friend. He never wanted me, and neither did my ex. Will my other three fated mates reject me, too?When every object in my cafe comes to life, my mates are the only ones who can help... -
Venus by Hanleigh Bradley, Mia Harlan
Rated: 4.50 of 5 stars · 6 ratingsMy memory loss is so bad I can’t remember half the stuff I’ve done. So how am I supposed to make one relationship work—let alone three?I'm Venus and I've got amnesia. Or at least I think I do.My memory's filled with black holes... -
-
The Wyvern's Redemption by Merri Bright
Rated: 4.50 of 5 stars · 6 ratingsShe found love in the ocean. He’ll find his redemption in fire.Long ago, a wyvern king cast his bride out, leaving her broken and dying. Now, after forty years, Wren has found love in the arms of some of the most unlikely men she’s ever met. Though a few of those arms may be tentacles...Categorized as:
magic shapeshifters omegaverse reverse harem fantasy monsters paranormal friends to lovers -
Delphine by Cali Mann
Rated: 4.50 of 5 stars · 6 ratingsNormal sisters get you a bottle of enchanted wine for your birthday and call it a day. Mine bought me a dolphin and a whole lot of too-sexy trouble that I hadn’t bargained for. I show up at the Silver Springs Aquarium to meet my new pet, only to discover that its owner is a handsome dark magician from an old Viking tribe... -
Ghost by Lyla Oweds
Rated: 4.22 of 5 stars · 9 ratingsMy abilities are growing every day. But thanks to my new friends, I know that I'm not insane. Even so, there's a darkness inside me. It's been getting stronger. A reality that I've been trying to avoid. Being near the boys draw it out. Being close to them also make me unafraid for the first time in my life... -
Witch, My Crazy Works by Em Pitts
Rated: 4.22 of 5 stars · 9 ratingsHave you ever thought about that person inside of you? The one that whispers of an alternate reality and begs to be let out to help make that happen?My inner person wants to play too.I'm fighting against the witch's system and losing tremendously. Now, I've got one month left to either conform or accept the consequences. I'm choosing option C, the "Cameron Richardson Way"... -
Crazy Witch by Nikki Dean
Rated: 4.22 of 5 stars · 9 ratingsHide your magic.Hide your boyfriends.Hide your real power.Mallory Serra is in over her head. Finals are coming up, Christmas is around the corner with two and a half boyfriends to buy gifts for, and the Defense Department is still trying to kill them all.Oh, and she might be a murderer on top of all of that. Fun stuff... -
Fates Mark by Demi Warrik
Rated: 4.22 of 5 stars · 9 ratingsFate always has a plan for us, which is likely why it sends me stumbling face first into my mate’s crotch. Literally.Imagine my surprise when I first hold his hand and, bam, a bond clicks into place throwing me into a supernatural world I know nothing about... -
Mercy's Fall by Lacey Carter Andersen
Rated: 4.25 of 5 stars · 8 ratingsI got into the guild… but that was just the beginning.Imprisoned for attempting to kill a dangerous vampire, I finally gained my freedom after years of suffering. Now, I’ve been sent to the Guild of Assassins where I must succeed or lose my freedom once more.But nothing is that easy.The three men I’ve vowed to kill have been keeping secrets. Secrets about me... -
Sacrifice by L.L. Frost
Rated: 4.29 of 5 stars · 7 ratingsAdie escaped the Hunters, but not without cost. Nightmares plague her sleep, questioning the choices she made. Or is it something more?Part 9 of Succubus Dreams.Join Adie on her (mis)adventures toward achieving a quasi-normal life among humans.A charming, slow-burn reverse harem serial about one reluctant succubus and the sexy demons determined to have her... -
You're Cursed: Disaster Zone Jones Book Two by Kat Quinn
Rated: 4.40 of 5 stars · 5 ratingsOkay, well, that’s fine: everything’s fine. Just turns out my ex-sorta-boyfriend is a crazy shadow creature stalker and has some sort of murder boner for me and my five new...boyfriends? Soul mates isn’t something you just slip into casual conversation, but murder boner totally is.Other people have these problems too, right?The good news is we’re all still alive... -
Resting Witch Face by A.J. Macey, Jarica James
Rated: 4.06 of 5 stars · 20 ratingsAris Calisto is no longer the newest student at Aether Academy but after her creepy headmaster finds out about her relationship with a professor, she’s finding her seemingly new home is quickly becoming hellsticks. To make matters worse, when someone leaks Aris’s new powers, her and her guys are faced with a Council inquiry... -
-
The Deal by L.L. Frost
Rated: 4.12 of 5 stars · 11 ratingsLocked out of her apartment with nowhere to go, Adie’s day goes from bad to worse when she finds out she’s been accused of breaking demonic law. While hunting down a red hot demon, seeking refuge with her mentor, and doing a little research, Adie finds herself stalked by more than misfortune... -
The Terms by L.L. Frost
Rated: 4.12 of 5 stars · 11 ratingsArmed with new knowledge about the sexy demons who pursue her, Adeline Pond decides to stop running and confront them with an offer of her own. But will her carefully laid plans get her into more trouble than she bargained for, or will Adie finally get back on her feet and back to planning her bakery? Join Adie on her (mis)adventures towards achieving a quasi-normal life among humans... -
Trial of the Vampire by Jarica James
Last semester at Obsidian Cove Supernatural Academy ended with Lennox’s heart shattering. Now Evander is stuck in the Regency Prison while she’s forced to stay at school pretending nothing is wrong. She focuses every waking hour on trying to learn how to use her constantly changing powers and free him at the same time... -
The Rules by L.L. Frost
Rated: 4.10 of 5 stars · 10 ratingsSeduction and anger make for awkward bedfellows as Adie struggles to settle into life with her new roommates. They run hot and cold, and every step she takes to explore the boundaries of her new home becomes a negotiation. If she can’t figure out their rules, she’ll have to make her own. But there’s a silver-lining in the thunderclouds rolling into the city... -
The Blaze by L.L. Frost
Rated: 4.10 of 5 stars · 10 ratingsOpening Boo’s Boutique Bakery is almost within Adie’s reach. It’s so close, she can taste the frosting. With her plate already full of three sexy demons, a cadre of wayward imps, and her search to find out about her errant demonic nature, it’s not the best time for an unknown hunter to walk into her bakery with her prospective new employee. Adie can’t seem to catch a break... -
The Gain by L.L. Frost
Rated: 4.11 of 5 stars · 9 ratingsAdie’s life is a slippery slope she just can’t gain traction on. Every time she finds a foothold, she’s yanked back down to the bottom. Only this time, she knows who to blame for her most recent disaster. And revenge is at the top of her list, just as soon as she convinces K&B Financial to finally sign the loan she needs for her bakery... -
Candela by J.R. Thorn
Rated: 4.11 of 5 stars · 9 ratingsWhat do a firefighter, a Fire Fae, and a husky shifter have in common? They all want a bite of Candela’s cupcake…Hi! I’m Candela and I own the best cupcake shop in Silver Springs—before my reputation got ruined, anyway. Lately all of my cupcakes have been coming out burnt, my smoke detectors are on the fritz, and my husky companion named Jasper won’t stop barking at customers... -
Marked Immortals by Lacey Carter Andersen
Rated: 4.13 of 5 stars · 8 ratingsThis has to be a joke…Right? I refuse to believe that everything we went through, everything we sacrificed, led us to this. Nope, I just can’t believe that fate would be that cruel.But then we’re in danger again, whether I want to accept it or not. So, I need to pull my “big girl panties” on and try to keep going.Because the alternative is a very bloody death... -
Hexed, Vexed, and Undersexed: Trials of a Salem Witch by M.J. Marstens, A.J. Macey
Rated: 4.13 of 5 stars · 8 ratingsThey say you learn something new every day. . .I learned that reality tv isn’t real.To undo the curse that was placed on my family centuries ago, I must compete in the human game show called Modern Day Witch Hunt.The prize: Mother Shipton’s grimoire.The irony: only a spell from its pages can reverse the hex.The stakes: my family will lose all their magical ability without that spell... -
Myths for Half-Wits by Lacey Carter Andersen, May Dawson
Rated: 4.14 of 5 stars · 7 ratingsEveryone here wants us dead... and I don't blame them.The gods inside of us are dangerous. They seek power above all else. As we learn to use our supernatural abilities, we also have to learn how to control them.Because the stronger we grow, the stronger the gods grow. And that's terrifying.The four boys who I loved in childhood have become gods alongside me...Categorized as:
vampires shapeshifters witches paranormal humor legends & fairy tales fantasy reverse harem -
-
Eve and Her Evil Stepbrothers: Why Choose Paranormal Romance by Zoe Marsh
Rated: 4.17 of 5 stars · 6 ratingsEve's new stepbrothers are the worst. Arrogant, gorgeous and rich, they invade her home town, her house, and her whole life. The five of them bring more trouble than any one girl could handle.That's because they're warlocks. Good thing Eve has a secret weapon to use against their magic.The Westing brothers have no use for Eve, but they mess with her relentlessly... -
Feline the Pressure by Lacey Carter Andersen, L.A. Boruff
Rated: 4.17 of 5 stars · 6 ratingsCallie’s Checklist:1. Stop being distracted by my hot firefighters.2. Learn my powers before it’s too late.3. Avoid the witches that want me dead.4. Overthrow my uncle and rule.5. Keep the people I love safe.Oh, and remember that the whole world is counting on me... -
Surf's Up by Bee Murray
Rated: 4.20 of 5 stars · 5 ratingsThe ridiculous summer beach read you’ve been waiting all year for.Ronnie Meryn’s life is heading in a very predictable direction. Marriage. Kids. The usual. But when she catches her boyfriend in a compromising situation with her boss, she sees red. With her old but faithful minivan, Betsy, she sets out on an impromptu #VanLife road trip up the California coast to start a new life...Categorized as:
shapeshifters paranormal humor fantasy reverse harem poly childfree-couple length-short -
Tall, Dark and Haunted by Mia Harlan, Hanleigh Bradley
Rated: 4.20 of 5 stars · 5 ratingsI always thought I was unlucky. Now, I’m dead. Not dead-dead. Ghost-dead. And NAKED. Very, very naked. Quick word of advice: Don't shift and die. Unless you want the whole world to see your hoo-ha.My afterlife takes me to a haunted castle and my three fated mates. They’re handsome ghosts... beneath their top hats, sideburns, and nineteenth century mustaches, that is... -
Forged from the Ashes by J. Kearston
Rated: 4.01 of 5 stars · 15 ratingsIt takes more than blood to be a dragon.You have to fight for everything you want in this world, then fight to keep it because there will always be someone that tries to take it away from you. In a world of nothing but predators, the only way to the top is to claw your way there. You have to be the monster other monsters fear... -
Juniper by Eva Delaney
When my dark magic meets a spelled book, my favorite adult toys turn into…three hotties?!I made an enemy of my allies when I stole a few items that weren't necessarily mine. Now that I'm being hunted, romance isn't in the cards...
Fantastic book recommendations by romance book lovers for romance book lovers.
Find out more about romance.io.
Find out more about romance.io.
Get recommendations by genres & tropes
Use the romance book finder to mix and match over 100 content keywords to find the books that match your preferences

Or - use our amazing romance book finder to get recommendations based on your favorite content tropes and themes. Mix and match at will.