Books like 'Time to Choose: Time to Ride Series, Book 4'
Readers who enjoyed Time to Choose: Time to Ride Series, Book 4 by Lynn Donovan & Erin Dameron-Hill also liked the following books featuring the same tropes, story themes, relationship dynamics and character types.
western time travel fantasy paranormal
-
The Amber Brooch by Katherine Lowry Logan
Rated: 4.65 of 5 stars · 11 ratingsSparks fly and tension soars when a gutsy 21st century lawyer meets a 19th century Pinkerton agent in a Colorado mining town! Fast-paced Western adventure with a railroad war, gunslingers, dinosaur bones, and romance.. -
The Outlaw Bride by Maggie Shayne
Rated: 4.31 of 5 stars · 20 ratingsA Woman From The Past....When he first finds himself at an old west hanging in the middle of Quinn Texas, Elliot realizes that he probably hit his head a little harder than he thought when he ran his brother’s truck into a tree.It’s only a concussion-induced delusion, but he rescues the beautiful outlaw from the gallows all the same... -
My Heart Will Find You by Jude Deveraux
Rated: 4.14 of 5 stars · 22 ratingsTheir love refused to stay quiet, echoing across time…When the world is brought to a standstill in the early days of a global pandemic, Etta Wilmont finds herself suddenly stranded in Kansas City. Desperate to secure a roof over her head, Etta crosses paths with Henry Logan, a lonely older man in need of a caretaker... -
Indiana Wild by S.E. Smith
Indiana Wild is as wild as the Montana ranch she was raised on. The youngest of four children, she was a delightful surprise for her older parents. She spends her time training horses and cow dogs and loving the freedom of the wide open spaces. When her grandfather dies, she finds her much older brothers have different plans for the ranch she calls home and for Indiana...Categorized as:
contemporary time travel alpha male paranormal cowboys western fantasy possessive hero -
-
Walking On Air by Catherine Anderson
Rated: 4.14 of 5 stars · 20 ratingsFrom "incomparable" (Fresh Fiction) author Catherine Anderson comes a novel of lost souls, second chances, and love everlasting.... Random, Colorado, is just another stop on the road for solitary gunslinger Gabriel Valance. Known for his drinking, gambling, and womanizing, he prefers to remain a stranger to anyone who crosses his path... -
The Blacksmith's Bride: A Golden Valley Story by Laura D. Bastian
Rated: 4.38 of 5 stars · 8 ratingsMarriage was never her plan until her inheritance depended on it. He just wants a family to call his own. Can they find a happy ever after even with such different backgrounds? Susan Hanson’s life is anything but normal...Categorized as:
20th century historical western christian time travel paranormal fantasy historical western -
Sierra's Homecoming by Linda Lael Miller
Rated: 4.10 of 5 stars · 27 ratingsSometimes, coming home is only the beginning… Don’t miss this reader favorite McKettrick tale from #1 New York Times bestselling author Linda Lael Miller.Sierra McKettrick felt like a fraud. She might be moving to her family’s ancestral ranch with her son, but being a McKettrick by blood wasn’t enough to make her fit in... -
Feather in the Wind by Madeline Baker
Rated: 4.26 of 5 stars · 10 ratingsBLACK WIND He gazed out over a land as vast and empty as the sky, praying for the strength to guide his people, and he saw her face. She came to him in a vision, a woman as mysterious as the new moon over the prairie, as tender as springtime in the Paha Sapa. And he knew his life was changed forever...Categorized as:
time travel contemporary paranormal western fantasy indigenous-mc north-america california -
Come Home To Me by Peggy L. Henderson
Rated: 4.10 of 5 stars · 18 ratingsJake Owens is tired of life on his parents’ Montana ranch, catering to city folk who want a taste of old-fashioned country living. He enjoys life in the fast lane, with fast cars and even faster women. When he falls in with the wrong crowd and is accused of murder, a stranger’s bizarre offer at a second chance might be his only hope to clear his name...Categorized as:
contemporary cowboys western time travel paranormal fantasy virgin heroine historical -
Sierra's Homecoming: Montana Royalty by Linda Lael Miller, B.J. Daniels
Rated: 4.07 of 5 stars · 23 ratingsSierra McKettrick felt like a fraud. She might be moving to her family's ancestral ranch with her son, but being a McKettrick by blood wasn't enough to make her fit in. To make matters worse, from the moment she'd met the Triple M's ranch hand, he'd gotten under Sierra's skin. With his rugged body and tender compassion, Travis Reid was a temptation she didn't need or want... -
Highland Storm by Tanya Anne Crosby
Rated: 4.25 of 5 stars · 8 ratingsEach Man to His destiny. As the last male heir of the dún Scoti clan, Keane’s future is known from the hour of his birth: Someday, he must take his brother's place as Guardian of the true Stone of Destiny. A Storm is Brewing. Alas, the fickle Highland winds must turn...Categorized as:
highlander historical medieval western time travel historical western fantasy paranormal -
Ain't No Angel by Peggy L. Henderson
Rated: 4.33 of 5 stars · 6 ratingsBook 2 in the Second Chances Time Travel Romance SeriesDelaney Goodman has been running from her painful past all her life. Dreams of working with horses have long been replaced with the reality of doing anything to make ends meet. About to hit rock bottom, she accepts a stranger's proposition, even if it sounds too good to be true. She figures she has nothing, not even her dignity, to lose...Categorized as:
western time travel historical western fantasy paranormal historical m-f length-medium -
Yellowstone Legends by Peggy L. Henderson
Rated: 4.40 of 5 stars · 5 ratingsThe future of Yellowstone is in their hands . . . Detective Weda is a woman of today: smart, independent, and able to do anything she sets her mind to. Growing up on the Rez, she’s been taught about the traditions of her ancestors, but all she wants is to live in the modern world and escape the dreams that have haunted her since childhood...Categorized as:
time travel historical multicultural indigenous-mc western paranormal fantasy historical western -
Diamond in the Dust by Peggy L. Henderson
Rated: 4.50 of 5 stars · 4 ratingsBook 3 in the Second Chances Time Travel Romance Series Reverend Johnson is in the business of granting second chances to those deserving a new start, even if it means bending the rules of time travel on occasion. In Gabe McFarlain’s case, he may have gone too far . . . Abandoned by his father, and raised in a whorehouse, Gabe has grown bitter to the world... -
-
Vestige of Legacy by Sara Blackard
Rated: 4.50 of 5 stars · 4 ratingsA woman bent on survival……a man intent on saving……thrown together by a tumble through time.After running away from her foster home and surviving several years living on the streets, Samara has finally found her path in life—performing music with the hope of putting down roots...Categorized as:
time travel historical fantasy western christian historical western paranormal north-america -
Silver Hearts by C. R. Charles
Rated: 4.67 of 5 stars · 3 ratingsAvery is exploring a silver mine-shaft under a Western museum when she finds a secret shaft. Hearing noises, Avery follows the shaft and finds a dirt covered wooden door. The old door shuts behind her, locking her inside a strange maze-like passageway. She follows the passage to a secret compartment inside the walls of an old building... -
Timeless Healing by Peggy L. Henderson
Rated: 4.67 of 5 stars · 3 ratingsBook 4 in the Timeless Hearts Western Time Travel Series Day to day life for Francine Eaton means constant hard work, being isolated from her community, and trying to stay one step ahead of her abusive, alcoholic husband. She's resolved that she has no options to change her miserable existence, but she is determined to protect her unborn child at any cost... -
The Minx Miner: A Miners to Millionaires Story by Janelle Daniels
Rated: 4.67 of 5 stars · 3 ratingsTime travel and fairy godmothers? When Gemma is offered the chance of a lifetime—to travel back in time and meet the love of her life—she jumps at the opportunity no matter how far-fetched it sounds. But when she’s held at gunpoint after accidentally prospecting on one of Promise Creek’s largest claims, she realizes her fairy tale might not end in a happily-ever-after. He’s jaded...Categorized as:
christian super rich hero western time travel historical western fantasy paranormal historical -
The Blushing Bride: A Brides of Golden Valley Story by Jaclyn Hardy
Rated: 4.67 of 5 stars · 3 ratingsCharlotte loves nothing more than a good mail order bride novel, so when Dr. Lachele says that she can send them to take part in any love story that they want, Charlotte knows exactly where and what time period she wants to go. She thinks the life she wants can be found in 1880 in Idaho Territory... -
The 25th Hour by Jaye Garland
Rated: 5.00 of 5 stars · 2 ratingsChased through time by her father's murderer, Houston architect Sheridan Wells unwittingly 'erases' herself and hurtles back to 1877 Wyoming Territory, to the moment that changed her family's history forever-to the source of her father's wealth-wealth the villain swears is his... -
Yellowstone Love Notes: Yellowstone Romance Series Valentine's Short Story by Peggy L. Henderson
Rated: 5.00 of 5 stars · 2 ratings***This is a 10,700 word short story in the Yellowstone Romance Series Valentine’s Day … 1847 It’s a day like any other in Yellowstone’s Madison Valley, except it is also Aimee Osborne’s birthday. While her family plans to celebrate with her, the most important person isn’t present... -
Jenna's Journey: Book Club: Heartsgate by Kay P. Dawson
Rated: 5.00 of 5 stars · 2 ratingsJenna Hart grew up knowing she couldn't count on anyone. And now, when her life is being threatened by someone who claimed to love her, she knows it's up to her if she ever wants the happiness she's searching for. When a purple-haired matchmaker who can grant wishes joins their weekly book club, Jenna knows what she has to do...Categorized as:
time travel western christian paranormal historical fantasy historical western length-novella -
Wilderness Wanderings: Bookclub: Heartsgate by Peggy L Henderson
Rated: 5.00 of 5 stars · 2 ratingsBlake Simmons gave up on himself – and life – two years ago when he lost his wife to a random act of violence. These days, not much brings him joy except his doting sister, and immersing himself in his historical research about the Westward Expansion of the 1850’s. Bizarre circumstances with a crazy, purple-haired lady thrust Blake into a world where even his imagination pales in comparison... -
A Miracle for Boone And An Angel for Luke by Peggy L Henderson
Rated: 5.00 of 5 stars · 2 ratingsWhen several friends embark on a winter adventure in the snowy wonderland of Yellowstone National Park and meet a strange old ranger who fills their heads with the possibilities of finding true love by Christmas, they quickly find themselves faced with new challenges and thought-provoking ideas... -
-
Fireworks for George by Peggy L Henderson
Rated: 5.00 of 5 stars · 2 ratingsGeorge Murdoch leads a quiet life on his Montana ranch. After the deaths of his parents when he was only eighteen, he’s vowed to keep his father’s dreams alive. He has no time or interest in courting anyone, especially not when his friends’ wives plan to play matchmakers during the Fourth of July celebrations... -
The Echo of Valor: Codename Rose - Based On A True Story by Hannah Byron
Rated: 5.00 of 5 stars · 2 ratingsUncovering the echoes of female heroism, one secret at a time. In The Echo of Valor, book 2 in the Timeless Spies series, the secrets of the past meet the mysteries of the present.In the seaside town of Torquay on England’s south coast, Mia Thompson’s chance encounter with her reclusive neighbor, Eileen Nearne, sparks an unexpected discovery...Categorized as:
20th century historical time travel western paranormal fantasy historical western length-long -
Eleanor by Calliope Stewart
London, 1872Eleanor Thompson is a beta governess who spends most of her time chasing after the Earl of Cornwall’s rambunctious children, with no plans to ever marry despite her cousin’s pushing.But everything changes one night when she perfumes as an omega... -
Under a Prairie Moon by Madeline Baker
Rated: 4.20 of 5 stars · 5 ratingsDalton Crowkiller is the kind of man a woman would sin for and die for, if she could only keep him in her arms. But the dangerous half-breed belongs to the untamed West, and he'd been claimed by another woman long ago. Time itself would keep him and Kathy apart--until he is given one last chance to change the course of his life...Categorized as:
western time travel historical historical western paranormal fantasy indigenous-mc length-long -
Yellowstone Origins by Peggy L. Henderson
Rated: 4.20 of 5 stars · 5 ratingsGet ready for a new era in the Yellowstone Romance Series.... All her life, Riley Bernard has felt like an outsider. Bullied and misused, she finds solace in her books and research. She comes to Yellowstone, hoping to learn about its ancient inhabitants, and unexpectedly overhears a strange tale about time travel from a couple of park rangers...Categorized as:
western time travel historical ancient times historical western fantasy paranormal length-medium -
Winds of Time by Zoe Matthews, Jade Jenson
Rated: 4.25 of 5 stars · 4 ratingsBridget wants a family, more than she ever has before.. Now that her two older brothers are married- to women from the year 2006, no less- and her younger brother spends the majority of the year in Denver at school, Bridget decides it is time for her to find love herself. But she also wants something she has never had a chance to have before- an adventure... -
Secrets of Time (Time Travel Romance Series, Book 4) (Time Travel/Mail-Order Bride Romance Series) by Zoe Matthews, Jade Jenson
Rated: 4.25 of 5 stars · 4 ratings1904 Keegan has finally accomplished his lifelong goal- he is a doctor. He was able to work in an office, and he loves his job. However, when he is offered an even better position, he isn’t sure why he doesn’t want to accept it. He can’t explain why.. until he meets Megan Conway. The only problem is Megan is from 2015. 2015 Megan has had dreams of the same man her entire life...Categorized as:
christian time travel western historical western fantasy historical paranormal length-short -
Cowboy Above the Law by Delores Fossen
Rated: 4.25 of 5 stars · 4 ratingsGuilty until proven innocent?This deputy isn’t taking chancesWhen his father is shot, Deputy Court McCall initially suspects Rayna Travers. Her mysterious past raises questions, even if his attraction to her is impossible to contain. Before long, though, he discovers Rayna is an innocent pawn in a very dangerous game. Now, to catch a killer, this cowboy will go wherever the case takes him... -
Here and Then by Linda Lael Miller
Rated: 4.03 of 5 stars · 13 ratingsIn the wrong place at the wrong time. When her cousin dissappeared without a trace, Rue Claridge volunteered to find her. But by retracing Elisabeth's steps, Rue never dreamed she'd wind up in 1892. And she certainly wasn't prepared for Marshal Farley Haynes. He arrested her and threw her in jail, But discovering how dangerous the Old West was, Rue needed his help... -
Cowboy of Mine by Red L. Jameson
Rated: 4.33 of 5 stars · 3 ratings**Book Three in the Glimpse Time Travel Series** The matchmaking, time-traveling muses have a huge problem. An angry Norse god has just captured one of their mortals, refusing to tell them where he took Jacob Cameron, let alone when. As a seventeenth-century Highlander, being shuttled through time by a man calling himself Odin, might have been enough to crack Jake Cameron’s sanity... -
-
Return To Yellowstone by Peggy L Henderson
Rated: 4.33 of 5 stars · 3 ratings***This is a 25,000 word novella Letting go might be harder than they thought... Everything she'd hoped for has come true. Aimee Donovan's mountain man of her dreams came to 2010 to find her and take her home, and now they can live together forever. But a life two hundred years in the past is filled with challenges... -
Timeless Hearts Prequel by Kay P. Dawson
Rated: 4.33 of 5 stars · 3 ratingsSelf-proclaimed matchmaker Moira has always had the gift of knowing when two people are meant to be together. One night, while driving home in Heartsbridge, Texas, she comes across an old diner that calls to her. What she finds inside will change her life forever. Together with a woman from the past, Moira discovers how truly powerful her gift is...Categorized as:
christian western time travel historical western fantasy paranormal historical length-novella -
Timeless Whisper by Sandra E Sinclair, Timeless Heart
Rated: 4.33 of 5 stars · 3 ratingsTainted by scandal, Raven Eyez leaves New York to return to her mother’s hometown of Heartsbridge, Texas, penniless with her reputation and career in tatters. If that wasn’t bad enough, she reads in a celebrity magazine her childhood sweetheart, who broke her heart five years ago, is getting married...Categorized as:
christian western time travel historical western fantasy paranormal historical length-novella -
The Hopeful Heart: A Cottonwood Ranch Story by Jaclyn Hardy
Rated: 4.33 of 5 stars · 3 ratingsBrianna loves her job as a teacher in New York City, but she has a secret wish. She wants to move to a small town to teach school. When Dr. Lachele offers a chance to be sent to a small town, Brianna is not sure she believes it could happen—but then she wakes up in the middle of a field in rural Idaho... -
Ride the Whirlwind by Jackie North
Rated: 4.33 of 5 stars · 3 ratingsSoulmates across time. Two hearts, stronger together. In present day, Maxton is good at finding trouble and bad at everything else. In 1892, Trent Harrington, sheriff of Trinidad, Colorado, lives a respectable but lonely life, devoid of any closeness. Trying to escape a past that keeps chasing him, Maxton drives south to avoid getting arrested... -
Days to Hide by Stephanie Flynn
Thrust back in time to 1854, she’s on a mission to save a good man turned bandit. Falling for him wasn’t part of the plan and neither was joining the notorious outlaws. Veterinary assistant Becca Wagner drowns in romance novels on her lunch break, someday hoping to find what she had lost: a family...Categorized as:
suspense time travel historical western paranormal fantasy historical western miscarriage -
Find the Lightning by Madeline Baker
Rated: 4.33 of 5 stars · 3 ratingsBE CAREFUL WHAT YOU WISH FORRusty Ryan has always felt she was born in the wrong century. Since childhood, she had dreamed of living in the Old West...
Fantastic book recommendations by romance book lovers for romance book lovers.
Find out more about romance.io.
Find out more about romance.io.
Get recommendations by genres & tropes
Use the romance book finder to mix and match over 100 content keywords to find the books that match your preferences

Or - use our amazing romance book finder to get recommendations based on your favorite content tropes and themes. Mix and match at will.