Books like 'Theirs For Thanksgiving - Part 1: Pie Promises'
Readers who enjoyed Theirs For Thanksgiving - Part 1: Pie Promises by Imani Jay also liked the following books featuring the same tropes, story themes, relationship dynamics and character types.
contemporary reverse harem poly (3+ people) multicultural military men in uniform insta-love black-mc bwwm
-
Strings by Bea Paige
Rated: 4.59 of 5 stars · 13 ratingsWith Ivan I found acceptance. With Anton, home in the dark. With Erik, I fear my undoing… Erik Hadley is a gifted violinist with a dark past and an even more troubled soul. His only place of safety, a glass room built to protect others from his violent outbursts. But it’s nothing more than a prison, and I have every intention of setting him free. It won’t be easy...Categorized as:
military suspense contemporary reverse harem poly found-family length-medium audiobook -
![Captured by her Daddies by Laylah Roberts]()
Captured by her Daddies by Laylah Roberts
Trapped in a nightmare with no way free . . .Stuck working for a jerk with a violent streak, Chloe knows there’s no way free.She’s stuck.Resigned to her life, at least she gets to visit beautiful places like Escana.What she never expects is to find four gorgeous, sexy men.Grumpy Judd. Protective Hux. Sweet Owen. Possessive Beck.Too bad her life was already complicated enough . .Categorized as:
multicultural military consensual-non-con plain heroine menage age play contemporary bdsm -
![]()
![]()
Sponsored links -
![Kept by her Daddies by Laylah Roberts]()
Kept by her Daddies by Laylah Roberts
Maggie’s lost . . .Well, not literally. She knows where she is. Most of the time, anyway.But ever since a car accident ruined her career, she’s been jumping from job to job, unable to find her purpose.Which is how she finds herself in beautiful Escana, helping her eccentric uncle take photos of the soon-to-be Princess.What she doesn’t expect is to find three men she’s drawn to... -
![Knocked Up by my Best Friend's Brothers: A Contemporary Reverse Harem Romance by Kai Lesy]()
Knocked Up by my Best Friend's Brothers: A Contemporary Reverse Harem Romance by Kai Lesy
Rated: 4.27 of 5 stars · 10 ratingsOne cosmic wardrobe malfunction.Four people who shouldn't be together. It's my best friend's wedding and I'm casually doing my maid of honor duties.Let’s just say my dress isn’t ready for these curves.It rips at the worst possible moment, and I bolt for the nearest exit.I’m standing there in nothing but my heels when the door opens.And guess who I run into... -
-
![Faking it with the Bad Boy Bikers by Summer Haze]()
Faking it with the Bad Boy Bikers by Summer Haze
One fake date. Three alpha bikers.My rules? Don’t fall.Their rules? I’m theirs.I only agreed to one night of pretending.A fake date to keep my past in the past.But with three ex-military bikers in my corner, pretending is getting harder.They’re looking at me like I’m theirs to keep.Woodrow, with his commanding presence and deep brown eyes.Henry, whose teasing grin melts all my defenses... -
![Snowed In with Three Mountain Men by Laylah Snow]()
Snowed In with Three Mountain Men by Laylah Snow
Rated: 4.33 of 5 stars · 6 ratingsI ran away on my wedding day…And now I’m snowed in with three sizzling hot mountain men.One minute, I’m driving in the middle of a snowstorm.The next, my car slams into a tree…And everything vanishes into blackness.Luckily, three sexy ex-SEALs pull me out of the wreck,And carry me into their cabin.But when I finally wake up and take a look at my saviors,I think I’m seeing triple.. -
![Four Fantasies by Stephanie Brother]()
Four Fantasies by Stephanie Brother
Rated: 4.52 of 5 stars · 10 ratingsIf given the chance, would you bring your fantasies to life?Alone for the first time after being married for twelve years, I never expected four younger men to tempt me with a good time.When I saw them dancing — and stripping — at Club Red, they filled my imagination with all sorts of filthy thoughts. The next morning, they turned up in my backyard as the landscapers I’d hired sight unseen... -
![Bitter Pills by Coralee June]()
Bitter Pills by Coralee June
Rated: 4.56 of 5 stars · 9 ratingsI’m on the run. I’m a ghost. A nobody. A man longing for two people he can’t have. When the Ringleaders captured me, my life ended. I’ve seen the world. I’ve killed innocents. I’ve lost myself to a cause I never wanted to be apart of. If I want to keep Grace, Alessandro, and Sunshine safe, I have to become a monster. The family I’ve chosen can’t know I’m still alive.Once a Bullet, always a Bullet... -
![Sinful Ella by Nicole Casey]()
Sinful Ella by Nicole Casey
Rated: 4.56 of 5 stars · 9 ratingsThe plan was to go on one kickass tour, not fall in love with seven rock stars haunted by a tragic past.As the lead singer of my band, I’m thrilled when it’s finally time for us to go on tour. But instead of a fun road trip, I’m bombarded with complaints from my two bandmate sisters, who happen to think that nothing I do is good enough... -
![Wild Card by Jillian West]()
Wild Card by Jillian West
Lennox Summers had her life turned upside down in the blink of an eye. She's still adjusting to her new normal, but omega biology waits for no one, and according to her lab work, her first heat is coming right after the New Year.With The Omega Exchange's New England location at winter capacity, Lennox has no choice but to stay at a local bed and breakfast to wait for a spot to open up... -
![Rock & Crank by Ember Davis]()
Rock & Crank by Ember Davis
Rated: 4.38 of 5 stars · 12 ratingsAre two Dirty Sinners better than one?SUMMERWhen I left Haven to go to college, I never thought I’d be back or be a single mom, but here I am. Being Clover’s mom has been one of the best things in my life, but also the hardest because of her epilepsy... -
![Baby Makes 7 by Kai Lesy]()
Baby Makes 7 by Kai Lesy
Rated: 4.44 of 5 stars · 10 ratingsA family of seven!? How did I get this freaking lucky?”Before meeting Kellan, Fallon and Luke, I was a homeless single mother.Escaping an abusive ex, with two small children to feed.The gorgeous men of my dreams offered more than just shelter in their spectacular mansion;They gave me love, a sense of belonging, and…A beautiful baby boy.Yet just when I find peace my younger sister goes missing... -
![Forever by J.S. Lee]()
Forever by J.S. Lee
Rated: 4.44 of 5 stars · 9 ratingsThe problem with dating six guys? Six sets of in-laws…Youngbin, Xiao, Jiwon, JongB, MinMin and CX.Six idols who I'm completely in love with and ready to spend the rest of my life with.Six idols feel the same way about me.And now there's another member of Onyx about to join us.. -
![Claimed By My Boss & His Twin by Sylvie Haas]()
Claimed By My Boss & His Twin by Sylvie Haas
Rated: 4.30 of 5 stars · 13 ratingsDropping papers off at my boss's house shouldn't be a big deal. Except that I'm in love with him, and I have a little fantasy that he secretly feels the same.An unexpected change in his demeanor makes me think my fantasy is finally coming true, but the second I realize my mistake, the storm of the century unleashes a mudslide, trapping me at his house... -
-
![SEALed with a Kiss by Kai Lesy]()
SEALed with a Kiss by Kai Lesy
Rated: 4.33 of 5 stars · 9 ratingsThree Scorching Hot SEALs seeking ONE special lady to satisfy our UNIQUE lifestyle.As I gawk at the photo of three ripped GQ models in my inbox,I wonder whether I should kiss my friends or whack them over their heads for setting me up on a fake dating profile.I should delete the email and get back to my business...But my curiosity simply won't have it... -
![Christmas with my Three Best Friends by Kai Lesy]()
Christmas with my Three Best Friends by Kai Lesy
Rated: 4.33 of 5 stars · 9 ratingsWhat’s more embarrassing than accidentally emailing your crush?When you've been crushing hard on your three best friends…And now they know all your wild, kinky fantasies about the three of them.We've weathered life's storms together, Even the pain of betrayal.They're my fierce protectors, But clueless about my deepest desires.And that’s the safest way to shield my heart...Categorized as:
military reverse harem friends to lovers contemporary new adult sports poly christmas -
![Onyx: Unity by J.S. Lee]()
Onyx: Unity by J.S. Lee
Rated: 4.33 of 5 stars · 9 ratingsFirst comes love, second comes scandal, third comes a secret which could end it all...Jiwon and I screwed up and it has left Onyx in such a precarious position that Korean fans are picketing the dorms.While Atlantis is backing the group, it's not without changes. I’ve been relegated as a second photographer joins the tour and it’s one more person who we have to hide our real dating secret from... -
![Bossed by Three Billionaire Brothers by K.C. Crowne]()
Bossed by Three Billionaire Brothers by K.C. Crowne
Rated: 4.50 of 5 stars · 6 ratingsME: "I don’t want drama in my life."ALSO ME: "A four-person polygamy with my best friend’s dad and his twin bros? Why yes!!!"It started when my best friend proposed a Summer nanny gig with the Bradshaw trio.Three silver fox billionaire brothers living in the luxurious French Riviera.I've learned to equate men to heartache and pain... -
![Vengeance: Snow and the Vengeful Reapers by Theodora Taylor]()
Vengeance: Snow and the Vengeful Reapers by Theodora Taylor
Vengeance isn’t just a team of enforcers, they’re a destination where all morals and good sense get checked at the door.Every server at the roadhouse I work at knows that Vengeance is a package deal. The three enforcers for the Ruthless Reapers don’t just share a job, they share you for one night if you dare to go to one of the rooms upstairs with them... -
![Claimed By My Lawyers by Sylvie Haas]()
Claimed By My Lawyers by Sylvie Haas
Rated: 4.22 of 5 stars · 10 ratingsMy lawyers make being naughty feel good!When a high-powered lawyer and his intern not only want to take my case but insist that I’m their girlfriend, I think I’m dreaming.But I’m not. And they’re serious. They want me to be theirs in every way... -
![Steam by Whitley Green]()
Steam by Whitley Green
A vacation fling with a sexy stranger… and my brother’s best friend.CallahanMy twin brother wants me out of the house bad enough to resort to blackmail, so I have no choice but to ride along to the beach for an old friend's wedding. Talk about getting out of a girl's comfort zone.And worse, his best friend West is coming with us...Categorized as:
insta-love m-m-f menage reverse harem friends to lovers contemporary poly length-medium -
![Single Mom's Protectors by Tess Chase]()
Single Mom's Protectors by Tess Chase
Rated: 4.20 of 5 stars · 10 ratingsI ran from my abusive ex to keep my twins safe.Now three ruthless ex-military bodyguards refuse to let me go. And one of them doesn’t know he’s their father. They vow to protect me.To claim me.But the longer I stay, the harder I fall…Damon—ruthless, possessive, and watching me like he already owns me.Zane—the charmer who makes my girls laugh, then devours me with his eyes... -
![Three Grumpy Bosses by Sofia T Summers]()
Three Grumpy Bosses by Sofia T Summers
Rated: 4.25 of 5 stars · 8 ratingsDid I think that the hot guy I couldn’t stop staring at would hire me for the job I desperately needed?Let’s be honest, no one is ever that lucky. No one except for me. My good luck didn’t just end with bagging the internship at an investment firm.The other two bosses had as much of my attention. Oh, I feel like a bad girl. A naughty employee... -
![Why Choose the Bodyguards by Sylvie Haas]()
Why Choose the Bodyguards by Sylvie Haas
Rated: 4.25 of 5 stars · 8 ratingsI'm single. I'm pregnant. I'm a virgin.For every cautionary statement, there’s a poor soul serving as the example. For instance, you can get knocked up the first time you have sex. I’m sure there are a lot of examples so let’s skip ahead.You can get pregnant without penetration. Seriously! I did. And no, I’m not lying.But I am on a mission... -
-
![V-Day Double Puck by Imani Jay]()
V-Day Double Puck by Imani Jay
Rated: 4.25 of 5 stars · 8 ratingsI thought I was hiring two male escorts for a night of no-strings-attached fun.They thought they were showing up for a charity event.One wrong address later, I’ve got two massive, sinfully gorgeous hockey players staring at me like I’m their next meal. Their chiseled bodies and take-charge energy tell me they’re more than capable of making me forget my ex—and every bad date since... -
![Double Dog Dare by Ember Davis]()
Double Dog Dare by Ember Davis
Rated: 4.33 of 5 stars · 6 ratingsHADLEYI’ve been hustling for my business, Paws Up, and now that we’re growing, I need to do some more research to make sure my treats and food are the best they can be. When I get an in to visit a dog training facility, I jump at the chance. I’m looking forward to everything I’ll have the opportunity to learn and getting out of Denver for a little while...Categorized as:
insta-love military cowboys pregnancy menage alpha male grumpy sunshine reverse harem -
![Finding Serenity by Amanda Perry]()
Finding Serenity by Amanda Perry
Rated: 4.40 of 5 stars · 5 ratingsIt’s true what they say, “No good deed goes unpunished.” Taylor Lewis loves her life. She doesn’t have a fancy house or a lot of money, but she has the perfect family and friends. But everything changes the night she stumbles upon an attempted kidnapping. Taylor tries to put a stop it and finds herself captured and drugged...Categorized as:
men in uniform contemporary pregnancy strong heroine new adult reverse harem poly length-medium -
![INVICTUS by Marian Andrew]()
INVICTUS by Marian Andrew
Rated: 4.40 of 5 stars · 5 ratingsMy boyfriend of two years dumped me for a wealthy Manhattan socialite.Desperate for a distraction, I found it with the incredibly hot and spicy Archer St John, a frequent guest of the hotel I work at in London.After an unbelievably perfect night with him, I woke up next to a pool of blood that wasn’t mine. Archer was gone, and so were his clothes and every trace of him... -
![Room Twenty: Owning Their Angel by Ember Davis]()
Room Twenty: Owning Their Angel by Ember Davis
Rated: 4.40 of 5 stars · 5 ratingsHEATHERMy first mistake is forgetting my place. I let myself believe, as I give them my submission, that they will cherish it. But I am only a club angel. What I see in their eyes is lust, not a promise for the future.My second mistake is running, but when I see the positive test all I can feel is panic. I was always good at running. From my mistakes, from my past... -
![No. 2 - Second the Best by Rainy Flower]()
No. 2 - Second the Best by Rainy Flower
Rated: 4.40 of 5 stars · 5 ratings$ Lake Mother F#cking Masters is in the house $Why do I have to do everything around here? Oh yeah, because I wouldn't have it any other way. You may call me a control freak or even an a$$hole. I'm also always loyal and take care of my own. I'm finally f#cking back in So Cal where I belong. Unfortunately, I had to bring Tat Masters and all that drama with me... -
![Hotter Than Ever by Elle Kennedy]()
Hotter Than Ever by Elle Kennedy
Rated: 4.02 of 5 stars · 37 ratingsWhen you land in hot water, swim for safety—or let the fire burn. An Out of Uniform StoryClaire McKinley has just experienced every bride’s nightmare. The groom is a no-show, and now she must face five hundred guests alone... -
![Undercover Action by Cassie Cole]()
Undercover Action by Cassie Cole
Rated: 4.14 of 5 stars · 10 ratingsTwo chiseled Irish brothers. A dashing undercover cop.The three of them protecting me--and sharing me.My undercover objective is to get close to the Finnegan brothers.To learn their secrets by any means necessary.I thought I was ready for anything...Until they said they want to share me... -
![Mall Santas by J.B. Trepagnier]()
Mall Santas by J.B. Trepagnier
Four hot mall Santas save the day. Christmas used to be my favorite holiday. Until last year. Last year, I was supposed to get married in Vegas at the stroke of midnight on Christmas day. I had the perfect wedding planned. If only I’d picked the perfect fiancé. I caught him in our bed with some blonde two days before the wedding and now I’ve turned into Scrooge... -
![Nanny for the Firemen by Cassie Cole]()
Nanny for the Firemen by Cassie Cole
Rated: 4.03 of 5 stars · 23 ratingsI finally landed a date with the swooniest, most gorgeous fireman in town.But just when our date was going well, he got called back to the firehouse.Turns out, a baby was left on the fire station doorstep.And since they’re clueless about taking care of a baby, they recruit me to help.Now I’m crashing at the firehouse with them.Three hulking, chiseled heroes in suspenders... -
-
![Her Royal Treatment by Kai Lesy]()
Her Royal Treatment by Kai Lesy
Rated: 4.11 of 5 stars · 9 ratingsIt’s like being cherished. Worshipped and unbelievably fulfilled, by four of the most beautiful men I'd ever laid eyes on. All at the same time.The King ordered me to lock down.In my country, his word is final - especially for the Princess.I’m both infuriated and screwed!My anger transforms into curiosity when my eyes fall on my protectors.Four ex-military mercenaries. Brothers by war... -
![Small Town Sparks by Ava Gray]()
Small Town Sparks by Ava Gray
Rated: 4.11 of 5 stars · 9 ratings★ SMALL TOWN SPARKS is a standalone novel in the Harem Hearts series ★ I’ve suddenly inherited half of my father’s estate, right after my cheating boyfriend made his exit from my life. But I’m a small town girl, and when I meet the rest of my super rich family, I make 3 very stupid decisions… #1 I have a one night stand with Lucas Monroe...Categorized as:
military reverse harem contemporary new adult super rich hero humor poly length-medium -
![Love by J.S. Lee]()
Love by J.S. Lee
Rated: 4.11 of 5 stars · 9 ratingsOnyx's tour is winding down, but things are continuing to heat up.With just the European leg of Onyx's World Tour left, Kate and Onyx are looking forward to visiting some of the most romantic cities in the world. But with delayed flights, petty tour promoters, and accommodation issues, things aren't going smoothly in Europe either. Thankfully, Kate and Onyx have got each other to lean on...Categorized as:
multicultural reverse harem contemporary new adult rockstars office poly length-medium -
![Saved by the Marines by Cathleen Cole, Frank Jensen]()
Saved by the Marines by Cathleen Cole, Frank Jensen
Rated: 4.14 of 5 stars · 7 ratingsThey never should’ve been protecting me. Now, they’re my only hope… As the daughter of a US Senator, my life was never going to be normal. I thought I’d finally escaped out from my father’s shadow, but he dragged me back kicking and screaming... -
![A Set of Three by Melody Tyden]()
A Set of Three by Melody Tyden
Rated: 4.14 of 5 stars · 7 ratingsMy life seems to have hit a dead end. My acting career is stalled, my love life is non-existent, and earlier today, I found out that the man I've had a crush on for the last six months already has a boyfriend. It seems like things can't get much worse when a passing car drenches me with water, leaving me soaking wet in front of the very man in question... -
![Five Fathers by Kate Morgan]()
Five Fathers by Kate Morgan
Rated: 4.17 of 5 stars · 6 ratingsSin or piety. Those are the two things I’m choosing between when I walk up those stone steps and into the church. Heaven or hell. Pain or pleasure. But sometimes, pleasure brings more hurt than pain. I’ve learned my lesson the hard way and that’s why I’m doing this, giving up everything I know and love for a whole new life. A life dedicated to something, someone, other than myself... -
![If You Dare by Joanne Ganci]()
If You Dare by Joanne Ganci
They call themselves the Devils…Seven sinful, rich men that own the cornerstone of debauchery in this city. RickyBeing the face of Devils, Inc. has become the bane of my existence… Until the woman in the red dress captures my attention. Atlas needs a distraction and I need to learn everything about her. Ten secrets, and I know she was made to be a Devil... -
![Insatiable by D. Sparks]()
Insatiable by D. Sparks
I'm broken. Love chewed me up and spat me out. It left a gaping hole in my heart for sure. I gave too much of my life for too long to a man who damn near killed me, literally.I thought love and I were through. I was ready to face my recovery and my fractured life on my own. Alone. I never wanted to trust another soul with my heart again... -
![Totally Wrecked by Nicky Shivers]()
Totally Wrecked by Nicky Shivers
Rated: 4.17 of 5 stars · 6 ratingsI owe my sister big time, but seriously, isn't there any other way I can repay her? My identical twin sister is currently dominating the "Champion of the World" leaderboard, a year-long TV reality show that spans the globe. But now, she's broken her leg and needs me to become Brooke 'Action' Jackson for one installment of the program...Categorized as:
multicultural humor contemporary reverse harem forced proximity actors length-medium poly -
![Secret Baby and the Bratva by Sylvie Haas]()
Secret Baby and the Bratva by Sylvie Haas
Rated: 4.17 of 5 stars · 6 ratingsI hid my pregnancy for 9 months, but my secret's out now!We all have that friend—the one who can convince us to do anything. The one who gets away with everything. I’m not that friend. I’m the friend who lets my bestie convince me to go to a sex club, relax my better judgment for one night, hook up with three guys, and end up pregnant... -
-
![Dark Devotions by Nichole Greene]()
Dark Devotions by Nichole Greene
Rated: 4.02 of 5 stars · 17 ratingsOnce upon a time they were my best friends, my family, my soulmates. But this is no fairy tale and I have nothing left to lose.Beaten, bruised, scarred, emotionally traumatized. Olivia finally found a way to escape her sadistic husband. Now broken and penniless, with nowhere else to turn, she seeks out the four men who always protected her when they were younger...Categorized as:
multicultural suspense super rich hero reverse harem contemporary poly length-short abuse-non-mc -
![Shared by the Firemen by Cassie Cole]()
Shared by the Firemen by Cassie Cole
Rated: 4.03 of 5 stars · 15 ratingsI came back to Florida to settle my mother’s estate.But after a raging house fire, I’m rescued by three swoony firemen.There’s just one of them is sorta, kinda, my ex. Jack Franco was the boy-next-door from my childhood. Literally. Part friend, part foe—but 100% swoony hunk that I always had a crush on...Categorized as:
multicultural contemporary suspense new adult from hate to love humor length-medium reverse harem -
![Protégé by B. Lybaek]()
Protégé by B. Lybaek
Rated: 4.20 of 5 stars · 5 ratingsEvery maze needs a monster.It took losing everything before I willingly entered the cold and unforgiving maze, all to be reunited with the love of my life—my cousin. Within the world of grueling training and extravagant galas, it’s becoming harder to know who the monster is...Categorized as:
multicultural historical age difference contemporary reverse harem dub-con poly length-medium -
![Something Other than Pain by Kerry Taylor]()
Something Other than Pain by Kerry Taylor
Rated: 4.20 of 5 stars · 5 ratingsAlex Harrison has spent the first 25 years of her life trapped in a nightmare that seemed as though it would never end. Tormented by the people who should have loved and cared for her, she has only ever had herself to rely upon. Finally a chance for escape arises, but at a heavy cost...Categorized as:
military insta-love men in uniform reverse harem contemporary suspense poly length-long -
![Calling the Plays by Julia Clarke]()
Calling the Plays by Julia Clarke
Football taught me to always keep my eye on the ball. But three players have captured my focus—and now, my heart. Before them, the idea that I could care about anything more than football was inconceivable. And I never would’ve allowed one man to threaten my dreams, let alone three. Then again, I’d never met anyone like Xavier, Colt, and Tristan... -
![The Billionaires and the Librarian by Harper West]()
The Billionaires and the Librarian by Harper West
Rated: 4.00 of 5 stars · 10 ratingsThey’ll take her romance addiction from fictional—to purely physical Lily Money doesn’t buy happiness. But it sure as hell pays the bills. And for those of us without it—life can really suck. But that’s okay. I’ll take my 5 days a week of ramen, and never-ending overdraft fees, because I love my job. At the library, I’m surrounded by the thing I adore most—books...Categorized as:
insta-love menage m-f-m reverse harem contemporary super rich hero poly length-short
Fantastic book recommendations by romance book lovers for romance book lovers.
Find out more about romance.io.
Find out more about romance.io.
Get recommendations by genres & tropes
Use the romance book finder to mix and match over 100 content keywords to find the books that match your preferences
Or - use our amazing romance book finder to get recommendations based on your favorite content tropes and themes. Mix and match at will.
