Books like 'Shadow of a Doubt'
Readers who enjoyed Shadow of a Doubt by Lexie Scott also liked the following books featuring the same tropes, story themes, relationship dynamics and character types.
contemporary reverse harem paranormal young adult urban fantasy poly (3+ people) fantasy high-school menage friends to lovers
-
When To Fear The Living by B.L. Brunnemer
Hi, I’m Alexis Delaney. I’m your average 17-year-old girl. Except I can see the dead. And talk to the dead and help them move on. So..okay, I’m not your average 17-year-old girl. Right now, the Veil is shut off, and the Way is closed. Which means the dead can’t move on, so, they are camping out on my lawn...Categorized as:
friends to lovers high-school young adult new adult paranormal urban fantasy mystery magic -
When the Dead Come Home by B.L. Brunnemer
I’m Lexie Delaney, and I’m a necromancer. Which means, I can see the dead, talk to them, affect them. Not as fun as it sounds. Especially since the Veil closed and the dead have been stuck here. Things in town are getting tense. School is starting, and I’m already tired of our plan to keep our relationships quiet. Bodies keep showing up and no one has a clue as to why... -
Awakened and Betrayed by Ivy Asher
My name is Vinna and I am a Sentinel. I’m the last in a line of a hunted, magical race, coveted and killed for our power and abilities. I was hidden and protected, but now that I’ve been found, it’s a race to see who can command and control me. Joke’s on them, I bow to no one. I need to master my magic, and protect the five guys I’ve marked as my own at all costs... -
Dark Arts and a Daiquiri by Annette Marie
When I found myself facing down the scariest black-magic felon in the city, practically daring him to abduct me, I had to wonder exactly how I ended up here.It all started when I accidentally landed a job as a bartender--but not at a bar. At a guild, populated by mages, sorcerers, alchemists, witches, and psychics... -
-
When the Dead Come A Knockin' by B.L. Brunnemer
My name is Alexis Delaney, and I’m your average 17-year-old girl. Except I’m a Necromancer. Which means I can see the dead, talk to them and help them move on. Well, I used to be able to. Someone as sealed the Veil. Now the dead are stuck here. And with the extra energy floating around town, the ghosts are getting stronger...Categorized as:
high-school friends to lovers young adult new adult paranormal fantasy magic contemporary -
Dragon Mystics by Jaymin Eve
Rated: 4.21 of 5 stars · 46 ratingsWhen the formidable power of Jessa Lebron's mark was unleashed, during her impulsive foray into Vanguard, the American supernatural prison, she learned the truth. She's a dual shifter: wolf, and as an added bonus, dragon - of the fluffy persuasion. Yep, she's one special cupcake. Now, pursued by the Four, powerful hunters of the dragon marked, she has no choice but to run...Categorized as:
friends to lovers urban fantasy fantasy magic paranormal vampires new adult alpha male -
Magical Academy for Delinquents by Ann Denton
Rated: 4.30 of 5 stars · 24 ratingsNo one wants to be sent to Academie Metamorphose, the magical academy for delinquents. No one but me. I’ve purposely gotten kicked out of three prestigious academies. It’s taken two and a half years. Finally, I’m about to get put into their reform program. And I’m thrilled. Not about the shit classes at this boarding school. Definitely not about the intense physical regimen... -
Shadows and Curses by Willow Hadley
The Abbot House has been cursed and abandoned for twenty-three years. Until now.When Harriet’s mother receives a mysterious letter in the mail with the news that the curse is about to end, she wastes no time in uprooting Harriet’s life and moving them to the spooky New England town of Weeping Hollow... -
Witchling Academy: Semester Eight by Avery Song
Rated: 4.48 of 5 stars · 10 ratingsMurder? Threats? Court trials? Shocking revelations?Turning twenty is more about chaos than celebration as my final semester at Witchling Academy kicks off with a bang.Semester Eight will be the most intense one yet; with the cheer squad competition, the football league championships, kendo master matches, and the spring festival art competition, we're going to be busy around the clock...Categorized as:
friends to lovers reverse harem fantasy paranormal witches magic time travel new adult -
Fallen Academy: Year Two by Leia Stone
Family is everything to Brielle, so when she learns about an opportunity to free her mother from Demon City, she takes it. No matter how dangerous, Brielle will do anything to unite her family in Angel City. All is going according to plan, until her brother's awakening ceremony. What he is… it shocks everyone, and he's sent away until he can get his powers under control... -
Kiss of the Rose Princess, Vol. 1 by Aya Shouoto
Rated: 4.13 of 5 stars · 30 ratingsAnise Yamamoto has been told that if she ever removes the rose choker given to her by her father, a terrible punishment will befall her. Unfortunately she loses that choker when a bat-like being falls from the sky and hits her. Anise is granted four cards representing four knights whom she can summon with a kiss... -
Flicker by M. Sinclair
The most powerful and dominant shifters at DIA are my mates. I finally shifted. I should feel relief and excitement, but instead I’m faced with fear of the unknown. The hidden threat that defeated my parents is still out there, and the looming presence of it, posing a threat to my mates, is a constant thought in the back of my mind...Categorized as:
friends to lovers menage reverse harem paranormal shapeshifters fantasy new adult poly -
Blood Moon by Belle Harper
You can have your cake and eat it too... can't you?Galen is a Vampire, Rafferty is a Red Wolf, and the twins, Ranger and Maverick shift into Grey Wolves.What the shifters don't know is there is a war brewing and Lexi is caught right in the middle.But Lexi isn't human...Is she the cure they all have been waiting for?Or is she the destruction that ends them all...Categorized as:
high-school paranormal vampires shapeshifters young adult fantasy reverse harem new adult -
Reflections of You by Yumoyori Wilson, Avery Phoenix
What do you do when your Mother signs you up for the prestigious Brighten Academy of Magic? You pack up your things, grab your familiar, and pray this doesn’t go horribly wrong. Having a sweet Mother like mine, whose mind is slowly deteriorating thanks to her Alzheimer’s, it’s my role to make her happy. After my older brother’s death, I vowed to make her smile and do whatever she asked...Categorized as:
friends to lovers reverse harem paranormal fantasy magic new adult urban fantasy young adult -
-
Lost Spirit by H.A. Wills
As a Spirit Witch, seventeen-year-old Callie has magical powers that rival gods, but having control over the four elements and life itself won’t help her with her current problem: falling in love with her five supernatural best friends...Categorized as:
menage high-school friends to lovers reverse harem paranormal fantasy witches vampires -
Shifted Soul by Elena Lawson
Rated: 4.09 of 5 stars · 26 ratingsI’m not just Allie Grace anymore. A beast slumbers beneath the surface of my skin.I have new urges and impulses. Not to mention a hot temper that flares up at the slightest provocation. But that’s not all—apparently, I’m also mated.It’s like a part of my soul has been sucked out, cleaved in two, and deposited into Jared and Clay...Categorized as:
menage high-school reverse harem paranormal shapeshifters fantasy werewolves young adult -
Twice Bitten by Belle Harper
For seventeen years Alexis “Lexi” Turner has been running. From foster homes, creeps on the street and the law. Lexi is a survivor, she has spent her whole life moving from one abusive foster home to the next, until she decided to take charge of her own life. Living in abandoned buildings, couch surfing and working at a strip clubs are huge improvement on what she had before...Categorized as:
menage high-school fantasy urban fantasy young adult shapeshifters vampires paranormal -
Dead Girls Club by May Dawson
Rated: 4.25 of 5 stars · 8 ratingsWhen I’m resuscitated after a car accident, my second chance at life comes with a gift. I can hear the dead. I’m struggling to figure out my new life as a psychic. I’m trying to figure out my new feelings for my best friend since second grade, Jax. And I’d like to pass my freshman year of college, too. And then the Hunters show up. Rough Luke and gorgeous Mave... -
Coven's Revenge by May Dawson
My oldest enemy is back from the dead. My father. Backed by an army of witches and mercenaries, he’s determined to steal my magic and make me his slave again—and to subject my sister to the same fate. To save us, I’ll need both my packs. The Northern wolves I loved first, the ones who saved me. The dangerous but alluring men of the Atlantic pack who have won my heart since...Categorized as:
high-school reverse harem paranormal fantasy shapeshifters suspense urban fantasy young adult -
Their Shifter Princess by May Dawson
Love could cost me everything. It’s love that keeps me coming home, to the beautiful house full of ugly secrets. I’m going to save my little sister. As soon as I’m eighteen, as soon as I can take custody of my little sister myself, I’m going to run. Survivors don’t fall in love. But my cynical view of the world is turned upside down by the four men who insert themselves into my life...Categorized as:
high-school fantasy urban fantasy young adult shapeshifters paranormal magic reverse harem -
Pack War by May Dawson
A few months after escaping the coven that drained my magic, life is golden. My little sister Maddie is safe and happy. I have my pack. I’m in love. But nothing gold can stay… Maddie’s violent, dangerous birth pack wants her back. My four men and I face dozens of wolves, intent on taking my little sister by force. If we keep fighting, my pack will be destroyed all over again...Categorized as:
high-school fantasy urban fantasy young adult witches shapeshifters paranormal non-human-heroine -
Blitz by M. Sinclair
Three dominant dragon alphas who seemingly have it all... except the one thing they want: me.My life hasn’t been typical. All I remember is waking up in an alley when I was ten, scrounging for scraps to survive until I was taken to the Bronzeheart estate.That’s where my life began, where I’ve lived for the past eight years with the ruling family, the Blitz Clan...Categorized as:
friends to lovers paranormal new adult shapeshifters fantasy poly royalty reverse harem -
Nightworld Academy: Term Two by L.J. Swallow
Welcome to the Nightworld Academy, attended by vampires, shifters, and witches. A place filled with harmony and mutual respect between the supernatural races. Sometimes.I'm the only witch at the academy who can wield a rare magic...Categorized as:
friends to lovers reverse harem fantasy paranormal vampires witches shapeshifters magic -
Infinity Chronicles Book Two by Albany Walker
I’m learning to accept that my entire life has been a lie, and that with my mother’s disappearance there are mysteries I may never uncover. Not to mention, my abilities are manifesting and I’m just beginning to understand what being part of an Infinity really means. As my relationship with each guy grows, so does the Infinity bond between us...Categorized as:
high-school menage paranormal new adult shapeshifters urban fantasy fantasy reverse harem -
-
Nothing Left to Hide by Lexie Scott
Rated: 3.90 of 5 stars · 10 ratingsMy heart is split in five.The future I want feels impossible.I can’t hold back. Not anymore.Every step forward is followed by a hard shove ten feet back. I want things to work with the guys, all of them, but keeping the sun from setting seems easier and more likely to happen...Categorized as:
friends to lovers reverse harem paranormal contemporary poly urban fantasy fantasy young adult -
Fear is the Key by Lexie Scott
Rated: 3.89 of 5 stars · 9 ratingsProgress comes with a price.For every step forward I take,someone slips further away.There’s more to this world than I imagined. More secrets, more people, more confusion. Meeting members our age only raises more questions. I’m not sure I want the answers.I thought the guys and I were past the hard part. We’ve come so far in the past few months and things have been going in the direction I hoped...Categorized as:
friends to lovers reverse harem paranormal contemporary poly urban fantasy fantasy young adult -
Leap with No Regrets by Lexie Scott
Rated: 3.89 of 5 stars · 9 ratingsI had love and lost it.I don’t want that pain again.I have to make a choice.All I wanted was a week off from the drama. I should have known better than to think we could pretend to be normal when we’re anything but. The Society is more than an organization. It’s a lifestyle and it’s time I accept that.The life I want is within reach, but there are consequences I’ll have to face...Categorized as:
friends to lovers reverse harem paranormal contemporary poly urban fantasy fantasy young adult -
Loyal to a Fault by Lexie Scott
Rated: 3.88 of 5 stars · 11 ratingsThe more answers I get, the more questions I have.I only know one thing for certain.I need my guys. All of them.I let myself get comfortable. I found a rhythm and thought life might actually calm down for a while. That I might find a new normal, but the Society needs something from me.My guys tell me I can trust them, their parents, and the organization they belong to...Categorized as:
friends to lovers menage reverse harem paranormal contemporary poly urban fantasy fantasy -
Betrayed by Your Love by Lexie Scott
Rated: 3.86 of 5 stars · 7 ratingsOne little lie.Now I second guess everything.This is no way to live.It’s time to uncover the truth, once and for all. Tennyson said it’s better to have loved and lost it than to have never loved at all. Well, that man clearly overestimated the amount of pain and suffering I could tolerate.The more I discover, the more uncertain I am of everything my life has become in Arlington Park...Categorized as:
friends to lovers reverse harem paranormal contemporary poly mental illness urban fantasy fantasy -
Infinity Chronicles: Book Four by Albany Walker
Turns out, I’m still in for a few surprises. I may have found my mom, or rather she found me, but I still have questions only she can answer. Now, getting her to cooperate has presented new challenges. She’s still ruled by fear. Hellbent on keeping my Infinity safe, we take a few chances... -
Secrets In Her Eyes by Lexie Scott
Rated: 3.84 of 5 stars · 16 ratingsI should have died. Sometimes I wish I did. At least then I wouldn’t be alone. After my parents’ divorce, my mom moved on with her yoga-teaching boyfriend and my dad threw himself into work leaving me to figure out how to navigate my new reality on my own...Categorized as:
high-school friends to lovers reverse harem paranormal young adult contemporary poly magic -
When The Grave Calls by B.L. Brunnemer
With the Veil finally closed, I hoped that would be the end of the fight. But I was wrong. Jadis is still in town, people are still going missing, and things are getting worse. Choices will be made, lives will be lost, and friendships tested. Not all family is blood, not every family is the norm. What would you do to hold onto yours?Join us for the thrilling conclusion to The Veil Diaries...Categorized as:
high-school friends to lovers paranormal new adult reverse harem fantasy contemporary shapeshifters -
Destiny of Ashes by Tessa Hale
A paranormal reverse harem...Categorized as:
menage high-school friends to lovers reverse harem paranormal abuse fantasy shapeshifters -
Unearthly by Cynthia Hand
Rated: 3.83 of 5 stars · 121 ratingsIn the beginning, there's a boy standing in the trees... Clara Gardner has recently learned that she's part angel. Having angel blood run through her veins not only makes her smarter, stronger, and faster than humans (a word, she realizes, that no longer applies to her), but it means she has a purpose, something she was put on this earth to do. Figuring out what that is, though, isn't easy...Categorized as:
high-school contemporary fantasy young adult forbidden love suspense strong heroine dystopian -
-
Infinite Bond by L. Rose
With three hearts to worry about, as well as my own, time will tell if I’m up for the task. I’ve always been normal. Okay, maybe more of an average guy, who’s quiet and awkward. Just someone who’s trying to survive living in my trailer while dodging my mom’s debt collectors. Everything changes when a power within me surfaces, and my eyes are thrown wide open... -
Protecting Hope by Briana Alisandra
Rated: 3.66 of 5 stars · 20 ratingsSeven years ago my mother was killed and I went into the system. She was the only family I had. Scratch that. She was the only family I thought I had. It turns out my mother had a sister. Now I'm moving to a small town called Salem Point to live with her.There are a lot of interesting people here in Salem Point. My neighbor, Knight, is the sweetest guy I've ever met...Categorized as:
high-school reverse harem paranormal vampires shapeshifters fantasy young adult werewolves -
Legacy by L.J. Swallow
An alternative cover edition for this ASIN can be found here.What's worse than being pursued by the Four Horsemen?Discovering you're the Fifth.Verity Jameson's day switches from mundane to disastrous when she runs down a stranger with her car. Fortunately for Vee, she can't kill Death.Death, who just happens to be one of the Four Horsemen, and he's looking for her... -
Cursed by the Gods by Raye Wagner
Rated: 3.61 of 5 stars · 31 ratingsHope has a deadly secret… Even though mortals think the gods have disappeared . . . Olympus still rules. Demigods have elite hunters who viciously kill monsters. And shadow-demons from the Underworld, the very harbingers of death, are tracking her. When tragedy destroys the only safety she’s ever known, all signs point to Hades’s demons...
Find out more about romance.io.
Get recommendations by genres & tropes
Use the romance book finder to mix and match over 100 content keywords to find the books that match your preferences

Or - use our amazing romance book finder to get recommendations based on your favorite content tropes and themes. Mix and match at will.