Books like 'Tenderly Bewitched'
Readers who enjoyed Tenderly Bewitched by Lyra Winters also liked the following books featuring the same tropes, story themes, relationship dynamics and character types.
fantasy reverse harem poly (3+ people) paranormal witches magic forced proximity insta-love competent heroine independent heroine
-
The Rowan's Destiny by Stella Brie
The Rowan's destiny is to power the stone and save the magic of witches everywhere. Or is it? When the words of the past reveal new secrets, Arden must decide which path to follow—the one dictated by others, or the one designed by her. From the ballroom to the battlefield, Arden and the Imperium Cadre discover an intricate web of deceit and a massive abuse of power... -
![Multiplying Storms by Erin R. Flynn]()
Multiplying Storms by Erin R. Flynn
Rated: 4.44 of 5 stars · 22 ratingsMy name is Tamsin Vale and I’m the only living heir to all of Faerie. It’s still hard to accept that, but given how often people call me “Princess” or “Your Highness” like it’s my actual name, I can’t deny it. I simply hate that I am. Yeah, it’s going that well. The councils’ win might have seemed small, but the ripples from that decision are drowning me at every turn... -
![]()
![]()
Sponsored links / Remove ads -
![Lumi by Crystal North]()
Lumi by Crystal North
Rated: 4.67 of 5 stars · 9 ratingsLife for Lumi is tough but she’s not complaining. She’s a single mom in a new town (country! ) and she’s trying to make friends, launch her own business, and deal with whatever powers her daughter is sure to emerge with any day now. The last thing on her mind is love. In fact, she actively avoids it. Romance brings her out in hives. Nasty ones...Categorized as:
insta-love magic reverse harem shapeshifters fated-mates paranormal single-mother poly -
![The Devil's Salvation by Kira Roman]()
The Devil's Salvation by Kira Roman
Rated: 4.39 of 5 stars · 13 ratings“You were created in the fiery depths of Hell, and to the darkness of Hell you will return! ” The third and final book. -
-
![Spark of Sorcery by Hannah Haze]()
Spark of Sorcery by Hannah Haze
The Princes believe they can protect me. But what they don't understand is that no one is safe in the academy. Not even them. We've survived one semester of deadly trials, but darker forces are gathering within these ancient walls. We're all guarding secrets. All hiding bitter truths. And while hunting for the truth may put my life at risk, it won't stop me from trying...Categorized as:
magic forced proximity independent heroine from hate to love fantasy reverse harem poly paranormal -
![The Price of Exorcism by Dakota Brown]()
The Price of Exorcism by Dakota Brown
Rated: 4.23 of 5 stars · 23 ratingsI was an exorcist, one of the best. When things got hot, I got out. I wasn’t fast enough, and I ended up with nothing but my parents’ old pizza parlor. Then my ex-best friend Darius wandered back into my life needing my skills. Innocent lives were in danger and I couldn’t say no. That dragged me deeper into the occult than I ever thought possible, and I can’t see a way back out... -
![Wish for Me: Book 3 by Yumoyori Wilson]()
Wish for Me: Book 3 by Yumoyori Wilson
Rated: 4.57 of 5 stars · 7 ratingsA life of despair, a heart-crippling desire, and a desperate wish to belong. When I experience a horrible nightmare, I assume that's all it is. After Luke, Owen, and Jeremiah encourage me to confront Mother Fantasia, I finally find out that there's more to my existence than I previously believed... -
![Forgotten Fairytale 2 by Yumoyori Wilson]()
Forgotten Fairytale 2 by Yumoyori Wilson
Rated: 4.57 of 5 stars · 7 ratingsWhat if your life was like a forgotten fairytale? Would you cry in despair at losing the memories of a story you held so dearly? Or move on to start a new chapter, deciding to accept your fate? That's how I previously felt until I face the men from my past... -
![Whiskey, Thieves, and Bastards by J.B. Trepagnier]()
Whiskey, Thieves, and Bastards by J.B. Trepagnier
Rated: 4.57 of 5 stars · 7 ratingsI can barely handle the truth about what Athena really did to me. I don't even have time to process it really. Hannibal is on the warpath after we destroyed his Asylum. Father Nathan leaked the documents Pax and Cas stole. Everyone knows Hannibal is the leader of a culty hate group. He's doing damage control now and that makes him dangerous... -
![Bound by Light by Demi Warrik]()
Bound by Light by Demi Warrik
Rated: 4.50 of 5 stars · 8 ratingsFate always has a plan for us. But sometimes I wonder if fate really knows what the hell she’s doing. With my best friend missing, my life is a chaotic mess. This supernatural world I’ve found myself in is placing new pawns on the table faster than I can keep track. The line between friend and foe is murky, and I don’t plan on pulling a knife out of my back anytime soon... -
![Retaliation by S.D. Paine]()
Retaliation by S.D. Paine
For nearly a decade, Seraphina Valdis has plotted and planned, stalked and killed. After her mother and elder sister were murdered, her father and younger sister left Seraphina behind. Alone and confused, revenge became her entire world... -
![Her Fated Wolves by Lacey Carter Andersen]()
Her Fated Wolves by Lacey Carter Andersen
Rated: 4.50 of 5 stars · 8 ratingsWorking at the House of Wieners isn’t as glamorous as it sounds…. I spend my days being yelled at by customers and working for a boss who couldn’t give a crap, but all that’s about to change. My best friend has an opportunity to move to a small town and start over, and I’m going with her. Everything had been arranged. I’m ready to leave this town behind. But then they show up...Categorized as:
insta-love witches magic reverse harem shapeshifters paranormal fated-mates age difference -
![Called by Fate by Demi Warrik]()
Called by Fate by Demi Warrik
Rated: 4.44 of 5 stars · 9 ratingsFate always has a plan for us and I’m finally ready to own mine. My destiny is spread out before me and like all things in life, I’m going to tackle it head on with fists and magic blazing. I couldn’t dodge this magical shitstorm even if I wanted to, and now, it just engulfed me, sucking me into this mystical world that’s starting to feel like my own... -
![Unbidden : (A HellNight Academy Story) by Dreia Wells]()
Unbidden : (A HellNight Academy Story) by Dreia Wells
Rated: 4.44 of 5 stars · 9 ratingsA year has passed. HellNight Academy is no longer what it was. There’s no fear of the coming night, no fear of death lurking around every corner. Light Guardians grace the halls right along with the rest of us. The lines between good and evil are balanced, at least for now. Everything is right with the world, or so I thought. Something stirs inside me, haunting my dreams and unravelling my powers...Categorized as:
magic witches insta-love paranormal reverse harem found-family from hate to love demons -
-
![Blazing Academy: Semester Two by Avery Song]()
Blazing Academy: Semester Two by Avery Song
Rated: 4.34 of 5 stars · 11 ratingsThose cursive words, written in dark red ink, haunt me day by day in my new life here at Blazing Academy. I, Alice Blaze, always dreamed of staying in one school long enough to learn, grow, and make a few friends. At last, my wish has been granted at the academy for all things blazing, but it comes with heavy consequences... -
![Phoenixfall by K.T. Strange]()
Phoenixfall by K.T. Strange
Rated: 4.22 of 5 stars · 17 ratingsBook 2 in the Rogue Witch Series follows Darcy Llewellyn, fourth year university student, music intern, secret witch, and the werewolves that make up the band Phoenixcry: Finn Gunner, Elias Gunner, Charlie Gage, Wesley “Ace” Rivers, and Cash Legend... -
![Their Mate: A Dark Wolf Shifter Romance by Sara Fields]()
Their Mate: A Dark Wolf Shifter Romance by Sara Fields
Rated: 4.17 of 5 stars · 6 ratingsFirst she'll take her punishment. Then she'll take our knots. If this feisty little human hadn't tried to blow one of our heads off before we even caught her scent, we might have been a little bit gentle when we mounted and rutted her for the first time. But now our naughty mate is going to have to earn our seed before she's bred... -
![Evading Wicked Blaze by M. Sinclair]()
Evading Wicked Blaze by M. Sinclair
Wicked Blaze Correctional has fallen, and along with it, my chance to take revenge against Drake for Clara’s death. For now. Mark my words, though, he would suffer at my hands. It was only a matter of when. Instead of burying my hand in his chest cavity and removing his heart, I was making my way through an unknown realm with my men... -
![Fortuna Academy Box Set Books 1-4 by J.B. Trepagnier]()
Fortuna Academy Box Set Books 1-4 by J.B. Trepagnier
Rated: 4.30 of 5 stars · 10 ratingsThe Complete Fortuna Academy Series, Available in one boxed set. Hayley Killoran was not ready to find out she was the daughter of Lucifer and a powerful witch. Lucifer was not ready for one of his brothers to stage a hostile takeover of Hell. Hell was not ready for Hayley. Fortuna Academy is an adult reverse harem Academy series with one snarky female and five fated mates. -
![Fates Mark by Demi Warrik]()
Fates Mark by Demi Warrik
Rated: 4.30 of 5 stars · 10 ratingsFate always has a plan for us, which is likely why it sends me stumbling face first into my mate’s crotch. Literally. Imagine my surprise when I first hold his hand and, bam, a bond clicks into place throwing me into a supernatural world I know nothing about... -
![Dark Arts by Fiona Starr]()
Dark Arts by Fiona Starr
Rated: 4.33 of 5 stars · 9 ratingsThree wolf shifters tormented by a deadly secret. Two worlds torn by a twisted legacy. One girl determined to choose her own fate. They say being called to the world's oldest magic organization is the pinnacle of achievement for a witch. The lottery is done in secret. The names appear by magic. Membership in this exclusive club is like receiving a golden ticket... -
![Clever Witch by Nikki Dean]()
Clever Witch by Nikki Dean
Rated: 4.33 of 5 stars · 9 ratingsHide your magic. Don't tell anyone you're dating your TA, and now maybe your handler, too. Don't tell anyone about the jaguar in your room, or secret lab under the dorm. Keep your friends close, and your enemies closer... -
![Unforgotten Family by Mary Martel]()
Unforgotten Family by Mary Martel
Rated: 4.38 of 5 stars · 8 ratingsAriel Kimber has settled into life with her family and coven. Everything seems to be as it should, and she finally feels like she's exactly where she needs to be in her life. Her dad is awesome and she loves getting to know him. Her guys are the best and she falls deeper in love with them by the day... -
![Jay's Silence by Kate Messick, Eileen Troemel]()
Jay's Silence by Kate Messick, Eileen Troemel
Rated: 4.38 of 5 stars · 8 ratingsFour dragon shifters. Three parts of a casket. Two unexpected portals. And a sorceress. stuck in a pear tree. I may have my voice back, but that doesn’t mean I’ve got anything else worked out. Like how to. regain my powers. Or how to get my four hot dragon shifters to understand I’m not for keeps. Even if they filled gaps in my soul, I never knew were missing, saying goodbye is inevitable. At...Categorized as:
witches magic reverse harem paranormal shapeshifters fantasy fated-mates dragon shifter -
-
![Magic's Flight by L.L. Frost]()
Magic's Flight by L.L. Frost
Rated: 4.38 of 5 stars · 8 ratingsThe story of the Wendall witch is written in blood. Hartford Cove was supposed to be a safe haven. Instead, Rowe discovered a family legacy steeped in magic and wolf shifters. The hallucinations she grew up with weren’t tricks of her broken mind. Her toaster is fully functional–thank you very much–and the real world is more wonderful and horrifying than she ever imagined... -
![Monsoons and Monsters by Amy Sumida]()
Monsoons and Monsters by Amy Sumida
Rated: 4.50 of 5 stars · 6 ratingsAs strange rainstorms and power outages spread across America, Vervain's personal life hits some stormy weather as well. Magic and love are hopelessly intertwined for the Godhunter, and it begins to take a toll on her heart as well as her relationships. Can Vervain weather the storm or will she fall prey to the monsters lurking within the mist? -
![Catatonic by Alba Lockwood]()
Catatonic by Alba Lockwood
Rated: 4.50 of 5 stars · 6 ratingsIf cats have nine lives, then I’m down to eight. Barely surviving the loss of my witch, I awake to find Charlie, Zaide and I are captured, caged and filthy. We don’t know what the witches want with us but at least we are together as we plan our escape... -
![Beaver by Eva Delaney]()
Beaver by Eva Delaney
Rated: 4.50 of 5 stars · 6 ratingsSupernatural prison wouldn’t be so bad if I wasn’t locked in with my scheming ex—who I’d put in prison in the first place. When an innocent beaver is locked up, I plan to break her out. But I need the help of my ex and three new inmates who landed in prison for something weirder than even I've seen before. And I spent a week fighting cursed adult toys... -
![Magic's Dawn by L.L. Frost]()
Magic's Dawn by L.L. Frost
Rated: 4.50 of 5 stars · 6 ratingsA town on edge. A secret heritage revealed. No pie in sight. Rowe thought putting the feud between the wolf shifters and the huntsmen to rest was the hard part, but learning to control her magic turns out to be a whole new monster. In true Rowe fashion, nothing is going right, and the expectations of the witch community only make it worse... -
![Reign by Cilla Raven]()
Reign by Cilla Raven
Rated: 4.60 of 5 stars · 5 ratingsBecks’ outlook on life has never been better since her meds are long gone, and she can finally see the supernatural world again. There are new realms, brand-new creatures, and an entire world to save from the apocalypse. She has an elf-goyle familiar and three distractingly steamy teammates who will stop at nothing to protect her and help her along the way... -
![Sol & Lune: Book Two by Kathryn Moon]()
Sol & Lune: Book Two by Kathryn Moon
A woman in the shadow of the new moon…. Lumen Fenn was torn down by the men who took possession of her home and has sequestered herself in the Lunar Convent, searching for peace. But being left an empty vessel of a woman makes room to be filled by new forces. Called on by her Goddess, Lumen must return to the land and the men she fled. Three men burning under the sun’s glare…... -
![Guardians of the Phoenix Box Set by J.L. Madore]()
Guardians of the Phoenix Box Set by J.L. Madore
Monsters, Magic, and Mates I never knew existed. Kia versus power pole isn't the end I expect—it's the beginning of. .. gawd, where do I begin? Four wildly sexy males. Powers I don't understand. And the eyes of the fae world on me as the person to unite the severed realms. No pressure...Categorized as:
competent heroine independent heroine cold hero shy-hero insta-love magic paranormal fantasy -
![Forbidden Bond by Fiona Starr]()
Forbidden Bond by Fiona Starr
Rated: 4.15 of 5 stars · 15 ratingsThey’re the ones in power, so why are they are so afraid of me? Newly minted magic user? Check. Hot-as-hell boyfriends who want only me? Check. A fresh start after surviving a murderous attack? Yeah, about that…. They said choosing a life at Stormwood Academy wouldn’t be easy. But nobody mentioned it would make me a target... -
![Held In Contempt by Jade Thorn]()
Held In Contempt by Jade Thorn
Melody needs to keep Dean and The Apex free from her aunt’s machinations, she simply must escape Coven Bestia. Her aunt is angered by Dean’s continuing absence and wants Melody to return to the compound as soon as possible. While she might be safer at Adolphus Academy, not everyone is happy to have her there - especially when she’s bonded to a much-desired member of The Apex... -
-
![Pack Scratch Fever by Liliana Carlisle]()
Pack Scratch Fever by Liliana Carlisle
Rated: 4.01 of 5 stars · 10 ratingsWho needs a pack when you can have cats? Piper has everything she wants, even if others call her a crazy cat lady. She doesn't need a pack--she has a cat rescue and enough cuddly felines to keep her company. She definitely isn't attracted to the handsome Alpha lawyer that smells like catnip and claims he doesn't like cats...Categorized as:
forced proximity insta-love omegaverse reverse harem fantasy fated-mates monsters contemporary -
![Family Ties by J.E. Cluney]()
Family Ties by J.E. Cluney
Rated: 4.18 of 5 stars · 11 ratingsWith the big bad handled and the bond with my men sealed, life is looking up for me. Or so I thought. With powers I need to learn to wield, and my mates all stronger than ever, we find ourselves dealing with a potential new threat. All whilst trying to continue life with my newfound family and friendships... -
![Rebels and Psychos by Leigh Kelsey]()
Rebels and Psychos by Leigh Kelsey
If a secret wolf society thinks they can take me down, they’ve got another thing coming. There’s a reason they call me Graves. The steamy, crazy Rebels and Psychos series is now in one collection. It’s not my fault I’m a psychopath... -
![Delightfully Charmed by Lyra Winters]()
Delightfully Charmed by Lyra Winters
One mage’s curse was another mage’s gift. The worst burden of my immortality was that being alone hurt less than the pain of losing the ones I loved. That changed after five charming mages crashed into my life, and I craved what I never let myself want; a life with them... -
![Good Witch, Bad Witch by Mary Martel]()
Good Witch, Bad Witch by Mary Martel
Rated: 4.20 of 5 stars · 10 ratingsAriel Kimber is a 17 year old girl who has not lived a very happy-go-lucky life so far. So much so, she's never been able to celebrate to joys of Halloween before. This year, things are different. This year, Ariel's got herself a whole new family, and they just so happen to be witches. Like her. And this year, they are making the best out of Halloween... -
![Witch, My Crazy Works by Em Pitts]()
Witch, My Crazy Works by Em Pitts
Rated: 4.22 of 5 stars · 9 ratingsHave you ever thought about that person inside of you? The one that whispers of an alternate reality and begs to be let out to help make that happen? My inner person wants to play too. I'm fighting against the witch's system and losing tremendously. Now, I've got one month left to either conform or accept the consequences. I'm choosing option C, the "Cameron Richardson Way"... -
![Darkmoor Manor by Jenn D. Young, Aspen Black]()
Darkmoor Manor by Jenn D. Young, Aspen Black
Rated: 4.22 of 5 stars · 9 ratingsI thought I was inheriting a life of glitz and glamour, but all I got was a castle that even a reality television show wouldn't touch. After inheriting Darkmoor Manor, I was ready to start my new life living in a castle. Instead, what I found inside my new home was a world full of chaos and things that make even grown men cry... -
![Crazy Witch by Nikki Dean]()
Crazy Witch by Nikki Dean
Rated: 4.22 of 5 stars · 9 ratingsHide your magic. Hide your boyfriends. Hide your real power. Mallory Serra is in over her head. Finals are coming up, Christmas is around the corner with two and a half boyfriends to buy gifts for, and the Defense Department is still trying to kill them all. Oh, and she might be a murderer on top of all of that. Fun stuff... -
![The Sons of Sacred Hill by Kira Roman]()
The Sons of Sacred Hill by Kira Roman
Rated: 4.22 of 5 stars · 9 ratingsThe Sons of Sacred Hill were once my friends, but now they’re determined to get rid of me, no matter the cost. .. Sacred Hill Academy is my only chance at a better future for my sister and me. Spending the next four years serving spoiled rich kids isn’t ideal, but there’s nothing I wouldn't do to give AJ the life she deserves... -
![Defeating Wicked Blaze by M. Sinclair]()
Defeating Wicked Blaze by M. Sinclair
I couldn’t remember what life was like before Wicked Blaze Correctional. The place had left a permanent imprint on my brain. A bloody, savage tattoo that seemed to shade everything in dark, cynical colors. Jaded. That was the lens I viewed the world through. Any rose-colored glasses I once owned had been dropped and stepped on, ground into the cold, hard floor of my cell...Categorized as:
witches magic paranormal shapeshifters reverse harem fantasy poly aristocratic heroine -
-
![Welcome to Nevermore Bookshop: cozy paranormal books 1-3 by Steffanie Holmes]()
Welcome to Nevermore Bookshop: cozy paranormal books 1-3 by Steffanie Holmes
Rated: 4.25 of 5 stars · 8 ratingsWelcome to the bookshop where fictional villains walk, talk… and fall in love. After her life implodes in spectacular fashion, Mina Wilde retreats to her fog-drenched hometown for what’s meant to be a quiet reset. A temporary job at the charmingly peculiar Nevermore Bookshop should be shelve books, drink tea, avoid drama. Unfortunately, Nevermore is cursed... -
![Severed by Magic by Lexie Scott]()
Severed by Magic by Lexie Scott
Rated: 4.14 of 5 stars · 13 ratingsWhen you're saved from the absolute worst-case scenario, you're supposed to be happy, right? At the very least, I should be grateful but we've been thrown to the wolves--literally--but I'm not the only one struggling to adjust. When we were at Drexel Academy, we knew our enemies. Now the only people my mates and I know we can trust is each other. Fans of Meg Xuemei X and & G... -
![Night of the Berserkers: A Reverse Harem Romance by Lee Savino]()
Night of the Berserkers: A Reverse Harem Romance by Lee Savino
Rated: 4.29 of 5 stars · 7 ratingsI have one night to meet the mage. .. One night to destroy him. .. One night to break the Berserker's curse. .. One night to save them. .. As the Corpse King threatens to destroy our land, my sisters and I gather to find a spell to defeat him. But when magic delivers me to the mage’s stronghold, I become a captive of his Berserker guard. I didn’t count on his Berserker guards... -
![Princess Taken by Tyler Parker]()
Princess Taken by Tyler Parker
Rated: 4.29 of 5 stars · 7 ratingsZane, Daniel, and Blaze - My Protectors. The men I must fall in love with to save the word. .. wait, what? Imagine my excitement when I find out there's more to my dreary life and that I'm powerful beyond my wildest belief. In fact, I'm apparently the key to to kicking Venom's ass. But then I learn that I'll only be able to reach my full potential once I fall in love with all my protectors... -
![How NOT to Resurrect the Dead by Kira Roman]()
How NOT to Resurrect the Dead by Kira Roman
Rated: 4.29 of 5 stars · 7 ratingsBind blood, bind magic, bind souls…. I know what you’re thinking… How does a Witch born into the Westerly Bloodline, one of the Original Eight families no less, mess up a resurrection spell? Well, it was fairly simple, if I’m honest. Instead of bringing Tillie back, I summoned a Demon. Specifically the Prince of Death... -
![Teddy's Boys by E.J. Frost]()
Teddy's Boys by E.J. Frost
Rated: 4.40 of 5 stars · 5 ratingsThree boys. Two murders. One terrible choice. From the moment Mum climbed into a limo with a fae stranger and left me behind without a backwards glance, all I've wanted was a home. A place I knew was my own, where I was safe and loved. Twelve years later, just as I'm starting to carve out that safe place, Da exiles me to backwater Massachusetts...
Fantastic book recommendations by romance book lovers for romance book lovers.
Find out more about romance.io.
Find out more about romance.io.
Get recommendations by genres & tropes
Use the romance book finder to mix and match over 100 content keywords to find the books that match your preferences
Or - use our amazing romance book finder to get recommendations based on your favorite content tropes and themes. Mix and match at will.
