Books like 'Third Time's A Charm'
Readers who enjoyed Third Time's A Charm by Persephone Steele also liked the following books featuring the same tropes, story themes, relationship dynamics and character types.
contemporary reverse harem funny poly (3+ people) bdsm m-f-m alpha male menage
-
Just Drive by Devyn Sinclair
Being the first female Formula 1 driver in the sport’s history is like being struck by lightning. Powerful, electrifying, and dangerous. Don’t get me wrong, it’s incredible. Plenty of racing fans are celebrating. Plenty more are enraged, hoping I either quit or crash. They can hope all they want. I’ll never quit. But there’s more than Formula 1 fans to worry about... -
![Unwrapped by Them by Eva Ashwood]()
Unwrapped by Them by Eva Ashwood
Snowed in with three gorgeous billionaires? I must be on Santa’s naughty list. As the manager of Whispering Pines resort, it’s my job to give the new owner, Cade McAllister, a tour of his latest acquisition. But I wasn’t prepared to show up at the lodge and realize I already know him. Biblically, I mean...Categorized as:
bdsm contemporary humor christmas reverse harem forced proximity grumpy sunshine super rich hero -
![]()
![]()
Sponsored links / Remove ads -
![Deadly Betrayal by Nikita Parmenter]()
Deadly Betrayal by Nikita Parmenter
It’s been two years since Mr Rising offered Ever and her men the chance to work for them. They’ve settled into the job now, but by no means have their lives become any less dangerous. The older teams don’t like how many high-profile jobs they get, and now there’s a mole in their midst, one that threatens everyone who works for Mr Rising; agents and families are in danger... -
![Faking it with the Bad Boy Bikers by Summer Haze]()
Faking it with the Bad Boy Bikers by Summer Haze
One fake date. Three alpha bikers. My rules? Don’t fall. Their rules? I’m theirs. I only agreed to one night of pretending. A fake date to keep my past in the past. But with three ex-military bikers in my corner, pretending is getting harder. They’re looking at me like I’m theirs to keep. Woodrow, with his commanding presence and deep brown eyes. Henry, whose teasing grin melts all my defenses... -
-
![My Best Friend's Triplet Brothers by Rebel Bloom]()
My Best Friend's Triplet Brothers by Rebel Bloom
Walking into the wrong room and catching one of my best friend’s triplet brothers in the shower was going to cost me EVERYTHING. Especially since it was her wedding. .. and I was the maid of honor. I should have turned around. Friends never sleep with their friends’ brothers. It’s code. Instead, Warren gave me pleasure like I’ve never experienced. Then his brothers joined in on the fun...Categorized as:
menage alpha male contemporary new adult humor from hate to love insta-love pregnancy -
![Secrets Worth Keeping by Nikita Parmenter]()
Secrets Worth Keeping by Nikita Parmenter
Of course a supposed vacation couldn't stay that way for Ever and the guys. With the arrival of Atlas and the mysteries that seem to grow the longer they're around him, including how he not only knows the new bartender in town but gives him orders of a questionable nature that are followed without hesitation but with a knowing smile...Categorized as:
menage humor reverse harem contemporary new adult poly explicit-open-door length-medium -
![Silver Fox Firefighters Next Door by Summer Haze]()
Silver Fox Firefighters Next Door by Summer Haze
Stuck with a glued dildo, I never expected my firefighters neighbors to be the rescue team—and my new obsession. Moving back to Harmony Valley was supposed to be about helping Grandpa and editing romance novels. Instead, it's about Nash, Tate, and Aiden—three alpha firefighters who are too tempting to ignore... -
![Ruled by her Daddies by Laylah Roberts]()
Ruled by her Daddies by Laylah Roberts
One was a friend. One was a former lover. And the other was her nemesis. Hurt, alone and out of options, they’re her last hope. And her every desire. Three gorgeous, sexy men to crave. Three alpha personalities to navigate. Three daddies to cherish and indulge her…. And discipline her. Welcome to Escana, where the men are gorgeous, dominant and they like to share their women. -
![Sold to the Single Daddies: A Military Reverse Harem Romance by Summer Haze]()
Sold to the Single Daddies: A Military Reverse Harem Romance by Summer Haze
One night. Three cowboys. No names, no promises… and now? A baby with their steel-blue eyes—and they have no idea. It was supposed to be a mistake. A wild, reckless, never-talk-about-it-again night at Club Devil. I was the auction prize nobody expected… until three possessive cowboy brothers outbid the entire club to claim me... -
![My Brother's Best Friends by Rebel Bloom]()
My Brother's Best Friends by Rebel Bloom
My Brother’s Best Friends claim I’m the one thing they can’t have, and the only thing they’ve ever wanted. They’re also the ones that took my v-card and ran me out of town. Coming back to Lunar, New Mexico was a nightmare. I had no choice after my life had gone up in flames. Between finding out that my boyfriend had a wife and getting fired from my job, I had little desire to think about hot men...Categorized as:
menage alpha male m-f-m contemporary humor military friends to lovers from hate to love -
![Single Dads Club by Rebel Bloom]()
Single Dads Club by Rebel Bloom
I thought I was done with men after my ex-husband walked out on my daughter and me. .. But now I'm caught between three gorgeous single dads—and an impossible choice. I'm the single mom of a seven-year-old wild child, a struggling art teacher, and my house is about to go into foreclosure. I’m basically the dictionary definition of a "hot mess"... -
![Knot All That Glitters by Devyn Sinclair]()
Knot All That Glitters by Devyn Sinclair
All she ever wanted was a quiet life doing what she loved. Her family had other plans. Being the Omega daughter of Slate City’s favorite politician is exhausting. Everyone in our family is perfect. Good jobs, good images, no scandals, and smiling at all times. That’s not me, and it never will be. No matter how hard I try... -
![Four Pucking Christmases by Emma Foxx]()
Four Pucking Christmases by Emma Foxx
Chicago Racketeers Book Two. I always imagined bringing my hot, charming, amazing new boyfriend home for Christmas. And I thought about how great it would be to meet his parents too. But I never really thought about what that might look like if I was dating three men. Together. As in, what it would be like if we were all dating each other. And now it's here. Our first Christmas... -
![Unraveling Connections by Nikita Parmenter]()
Unraveling Connections by Nikita Parmenter
Luc’s hurt and we have no idea what’s going on or how long it’s going to take for him to recover. Not even Mr R knows what’s poisoned him, and he’s refusing to let me pay Luc’s father a visit, knowing it would get bloody. It’s probably the right choice, but I’m not happy about it...Categorized as:
menage humor contemporary reverse harem poly mystery length-medium explicit-plentiful -
-
![The Pitch Slap by Kris Butler]()
The Pitch Slap by Kris Butler
Is it better to swing and miss or never get up to bat? Growing up a baseball princess had taught me a few things:. One, the only truly scary thing about ball players was their superstitions. Second, baseball always came first. It was their one true love. And third, never take your eye off the ball, or you just might get pitch-slapped... -
![Talk About... Drama by Jarica James]()
Talk About... Drama by Jarica James
Maybe hiring a fake pack to make your ex jealous is petty… but I don’t really care. Cameron Whitaker was the one alpha that was able to build me up then tear me down faster than I could blink. We were scent matches. Meant to be together. Every omega’s perfect fairytale, right? Wrong...Categorized as:
m-f-m alpha male humor contemporary reverse harem second chances fated-mates insta-love -
![Claimed By My Boss & His Twin by Sylvie Haas]()
Claimed By My Boss & His Twin by Sylvie Haas
Rated: 4.30 of 5 stars · 13 ratingsDropping papers off at my boss's house shouldn't be a big deal. Except that I'm in love with him, and I have a little fantasy that he secretly feels the same. An unexpected change in his demeanor makes me think my fantasy is finally coming true, but the second I realize my mistake, the storm of the century unleashes a mudslide, trapping me at his house... -
![Walker by LeAnn Ashers]()
Walker by LeAnn Ashers
Rated: 4.36 of 5 stars · 10 ratingsSUMMER. All it took was one night for my past and my present to collide headfirst. Consumed by work, I was letting life pass me by. I had reached a point where I found myself merely existing, so I decided to go out and have some fun with my friend, Lynn. That night brought me face to face with the two men that would become my everything—Walker and Darren... -
![Christmas With The Camdens by A.M. McCoy]()
Christmas With The Camdens by A.M. McCoy
Deck the halls with balls of Camden Twins… Oops, I mean boughs of holly. Fa-la-la-la- but also the twins. Three years have passed since we left Bailey, Finn, and Walker Camden in Mayfield Montana with their three-year-old daughter Eloise Jade. Now, the trio have been married for six years, and have two more kids running around causing trouble, twin boys Parker and Paxton... -
![Rainbows and Unicorns by S.N. Moor]()
Rainbows and Unicorns by S.N. Moor
Everlee and her men are back! Everything is going great for them, but when a woman from the men's past enters the scene with a proposition that is hard to refuse, how will things change for our favorite quintet? If you like your books super spicy, then you will love this book. Don't let the cover fool you. Please check content warnings... -
![Necessary Roughness by Cassie Cole]()
Necessary Roughness by Cassie Cole
I almost hooked up with the two most popular football players on campus. And just when I think I’ll never see them again, they show up in my classes the next day. But instead of making fun of me, they offer me the deal of a lifetime. The three of us. No strings attached. All semester long. Our extracurricular activities help keep them focused on the football season,... -
![Fireworks with Three Mountain Men by K.C. Crowne]()
Fireworks with Three Mountain Men by K.C. Crowne
Rated: 4.24 of 5 stars · 14 ratingsMy sister's ex wants to make me his. And his two equally hot friends are ready to join the party. With all this sexual tension between the four of us. .. I'm feeling sparks like the Fourth of July! ! Dylan is my sister's ex boyfriend and as dreamy as they come. He's protective, strong and as big as the mountains he calls home. Red is quiet and thoughtful... -
![Nanny for the Bossholes by Rebel Bloom]()
Nanny for the Bossholes by Rebel Bloom
I got dumped and fired for not making babies with my boss. And now my only way to get revenge is to become a nanny for his enemies. .. My plan for revenge was simple: Get a job with the Graves Brothers, my ex's biggest competitors... -
![Motorcycle Daddies by Liz Archer]()
Motorcycle Daddies by Liz Archer
Rated: 4.19 of 5 stars · 14 ratingsI have a debt to pay. The price? My innocence. The buyers? Three bossy silver fox bikers…. My momma died when I was young, and as for my dad… well, I’d be better off without him. But now that he owes the Bratva, they kidnap me and say I have to pay Daddy’s debts with my freaking V-card. I don’t have much hope left… not until I meet three of the highest bidders at my auction... -
-
![Silver Fox Daddies: An MC Reverse Harem Romance by Liz Archer]()
Silver Fox Daddies: An MC Reverse Harem Romance by Liz Archer
Three silver fox bikers. Two pink lines. One drunk voicemail. And zero clue who the daddy is. I’m a librarian. But one drunk voicemail later,. I lost my v-card to three bikers twice my age. Now I’m pregnant…. And the. property of Bishop, Cash and Diesel. Bishop is the badass who takes what he wants—and what he wants is me. Cash's filthy tongue urges me to do unspeakable things... -
![Shared by the Highest Bidder by Tori Chase, Deborah Garland]()
Shared by the Highest Bidder by Tori Chase, Deborah Garland
𝐖𝐡𝐞𝐧 𝐲𝐨𝐮’𝐫𝐞 𝐜𝐮𝐫𝐯𝐲 𝐚𝐧𝐝 𝐮𝐩 𝐟𝐨𝐫 𝐚𝐮𝐜𝐭𝐢𝐨𝐧, 𝐚𝐧𝐝 𝐭𝐡𝐫𝐞𝐞 𝐛𝐫𝐞𝐚𝐭𝐡𝐭𝐚𝐤𝐢𝐧𝐠, 𝐫𝐢𝐜𝐡-𝐚𝐬-𝐬𝐢𝐧 𝐛𝐢𝐝𝐝𝐞𝐫𝐬 𝐟𝐢𝐠𝐡𝐭 𝐨𝐯𝐞𝐫 𝐲𝐨𝐮…. (Bernadette's story! ). It started when my ex-boyfriend got arrested and ended with me being shared by three men. .Categorized as:
menage m-f-m alpha male reverse harem m-m boss & employee super rich hero found-family -
![Mountain Men Triplets by Rebel Bloom]()
Mountain Men Triplets by Rebel Bloom
Relationship Status: It’s complicated. Dating three triplet brothers might sound like fun, but I’m hiding a dark secret that could tear them apart. I’ll never regret my one-night stand with Julian. He gave me a son–one that he knows nothing about. Gruff, damaged, and moody enough to cause whiplash, Julian Steele is everything I should stay away from...Categorized as:
m-f-m alpha male humor contemporary secret child spanking reverse harem single-mother -
![Claimed By My Lawyers by Sylvie Haas]()
Claimed By My Lawyers by Sylvie Haas
Rated: 4.22 of 5 stars · 10 ratingsMy lawyers make being naughty feel good! When a high-powered lawyer and his intern not only want to take my case but insist that I’m their girlfriend, I think I’m dreaming. But I’m not. And they’re serious. They want me to be theirs in every way... -
![A Wicked Education by Mika Lane]()
A Wicked Education by Mika Lane
Rated: 4.25 of 5 stars · 8 ratingsA Student/Professor Reverse Harem Romance. They say I’m the hottest girl on campus, and my sexy professors are about to show me why I should choose them over the boys my age. I can have any guy on campus. One look and a smile are all it takes. Jocks, nerds, hippies…they all love me. But my professors have other ideas. They want to give me a wicked education…in lust...Categorized as:
menage reverse harem contemporary college age difference insta-love forbidden love new adult -
![Four Daddies for Christmas by K.C. Crowne]()
Four Daddies for Christmas by K.C. Crowne
Rated: 4.05 of 5 stars · 26 ratingsFour untamed ex-military daddies. One very unassuming girl. Who said Christmas miracles don’t exist? My family’s failing farm combined with my father’s debt has me tossing and turning. Luckily a chance rescue brings me face to face with an opportunity I can't resist. I've been hired to take care of an adorable set of twins. But I'm nervous for three VERY good reasons:. 1... -
![Forbidden Intentions by Quinn Arthurs]()
Forbidden Intentions by Quinn Arthurs
Four masks. Three strangers. Two words. One night. Zero chance of a future. Yes, sir. That was the game. One night of fun, of seeing what it was like to be sexually adventurous and finally have the orgasms I’d never gotten. Masks and wigs kept my anonymity—and theirs. Or so I thought. Two days later, champagne in hand, I realize the eyes looking back at me are familiar, too familiar... -
![Bittersweet Sim-Phony by Jay Leigh Brown]()
Bittersweet Sim-Phony by Jay Leigh Brown
Rated: 4.40 of 5 stars · 5 ratingsWhat happens when a cam girl, a chef, and a venture capitalist walk into a bar? Everybody’s got problems. Except Albany. Aside from the constant battle of fending off her deadly enemy the sun, a chronic case of single-itis, and a knack for starting new hobbies as frequently as most folks change socks, her life is predictable. Consistent. Safe... -
![Biker Daddies by Liz Archer]()
Biker Daddies by Liz Archer
It started with one drunk sext to three silver fox bikers…. And ended with two babies in my belly. My daddy taught me better. I should’ve known not to drink too much tequila…. And sext all three of his hot-as-sin best friends. But Alto, the very bossy VP, makes my heart race faster than his bike. And Colt is a walking, talking wet dream... -
![Ten Hammers by Liz Archer]()
Ten Hammers by Liz Archer
I’m on a TV show with my ten best friends. This is our last season, and we’re going out with a bang. But which one of the ripped, hunky Hammer brothers will I end up with? Spoiler maybe all ten of them…. Since I was a little girl, I’ve been best friends with my ten neighbors - the Hammer brothers... -
-
![Unwrapping Holly by Krista Wolf]()
Unwrapping Holly by Krista Wolf
It’s my one unwritten rule: I don’t date clients. But when three incredibly gorgeous men ask me out on three separate dates, right before Christmas? Staying off Santa’s naughty list just became a lot harder. Dumped just weeks before Christmas, personal shopper Holly doesn't feel so merry... -
![Double Your Standards by Sarah Blue]()
Double Your Standards by Sarah Blue
The last thing I wanted was a boyfriend, let alone two. I wanted to explore my sensual side in a safe space, a club designed where other like-minded people can experiment and discover themselves. It was a chance to take back the confidence my ex had stolen. No strings attached. No relationships. So, of course, a heated one-night stand changed everything... -
![A Sinful Classroom by Mika Lane]()
A Sinful Classroom by Mika Lane
Rated: 4.11 of 5 stars · 9 ratingsA Student/Professor Reverse Harem Romance. I’ll do anything to stay in college…even my professors. Working as a hotel maid is a last resort. But it’s the only way I can afford to stay in school. But when my professor makes me an offer I can’t refuse…. I can’t turn him—or his sexy friends—down. They want to teach me…naughty things. Expose me to…everything they have to offer... -
![Pack Plus One by Ella Beck]()
Pack Plus One by Ella Beck
Leah Carter would rather eat glass than attend her ex’s wedding—especially since he dumped her for not being ‘pack material. ’ But when a pack of rowdy, overprotective alphas adopts her as their last-minute date, she’s suddenly the center of more attention than she bargained for. Including Mason, the too-perceptive beta who sees right through her…...Categorized as:
alpha male m-f-m menage omegaverse reverse harem humor contemporary fake relationship -
![Nanny for the Mercenaries by Cassie Cole]()
Nanny for the Mercenaries by Cassie Cole
Rated: 4.03 of 5 stars · 16 ratingsThree rugged mercenaries. One lucky nanny. And a globe-hopping adventure that will test the limits of their love. I was only venting about my career problems at the gym. I never expected the two hot military guys in the squat rack to overhear. And I definitely didn’t expect them to offer me a solution. A chance to nanny their daughter Kaylee for two months... -
![Deck My Halls: Happy Con-idays by Reese Rivers]()
Deck My Halls: Happy Con-idays by Reese Rivers
Blue is back. And so are the men she tricked on Halloween. Blue thought she had pulled off the perfect con by drugging three masked criminals, stealing their loot, and vanishing into the night. She thought she was home free. She was wrong. Now, she’s in Santa Monica for a high-stakes Christmas Eve heist, poised to ruin a corrupt billionaire and empty his safe... -
![Mountain Daddies by Liz Archer]()
Mountain Daddies by Liz Archer
I’m snowed in with the mountain men of my dreams…. And there’s only one way to keep warm. I didn’t mean to trespass on their cabin…. Or for them to catch me in their shower dripping wet. But now I’m snowed in with three irresistible triplets…. And there’s nothing to do but… them. Ed is the bossiest triplet. I hate how my body obeys when he barks orders at me...Categorized as:
menage m-f-m alpha male reverse harem grumpy sunshine age difference forced proximity insta-love -
![Knotty, Nice, & Holiday Lights by Raven Vespo]()
Knotty, Nice, & Holiday Lights by Raven Vespo
I was an Omega living the life! An educated, independent woman working at my dream job. But then, my whole world crumbles when I'm laid off. Happy Effing Holidays to Izzy Ross. Instead of subjecting myself to the torture of a family gathering after that, I take my friend's advice and travel north for the holidays to a cozy, small town called Crescent Lake. But when I arrive, things get tricky...Categorized as:
alpha male m-f-m omegaverse christmas reverse harem length-medium virgin hero second chances -
![Shared by the Pilots by Cassie Cole]()
Shared by the Pilots by Cassie Cole
Rated: 3.98 of 5 stars · 10 ratingsI’m the pickiest dater in the world. So I made a deal with my say ‘yes’ to the first three guys who asked me out. But I never thought I’d be saying yes to these three hunks. Luke Hendricks is a calm, confident, and dry-witted former Air Force Captain who now pilots commercial aircraft...Categorized as:
menage contemporary reverse harem historical suspense humor super rich hero military -
![Baby Makes 5 by Roxanne Riley]()
Baby Makes 5 by Roxanne Riley
Rated: 4.00 of 5 stars · 7 ratingsI've always known I wanted to be a mom. But when yet another one of my relationships crumbles, I feel miles away from the possibility. At least until I start looking into other routes. My in vitro fertilization research is interrupted by my two best friends, Corey and Andrei, inviting me over for a game night... -
-
![Room Mated by Stephanie Brother]()
Room Mated by Stephanie Brother
It's my first day of graduate school and I'm mistakenly assigned to the men's dorm! I don't want to live with three strange guys. That is until I take a tour of the suite. Once I see the huge living room, the study nook, the fireplace, and the balcony, there’s no way I’m moving out. But the suite has nothing on the hot-as-hell men themselves...Categorized as:
menage contemporary new adult humor reverse harem poly length-medium explicit-plentiful -
![Nanny for the Firemen by Cassie Cole]()
Nanny for the Firemen by Cassie Cole
Rated: 3.94 of 5 stars · 24 ratingsI finally landed a date with the swooniest, most gorgeous fireman in town. But just when our date was going well, he got called back to the firehouse. Turns out, a baby was left on the fire station doorstep. And since they’re clueless about taking care of a baby, they recruit me to help. Now I’m crashing at the firehouse with them. Three hulking, chiseled heroes in suspenders... -
![Men on a Mission by K.C. Crowne]()
Men on a Mission by K.C. Crowne
Four hunky marines and one very lucky girl. We lived through war together. Literally. All five of us. The biggest hurdle was keeping my intense attraction a secret all these years. But suddenly one goes missing. Radio silence means danger. Danger means. .. . reunion. Now we're back together. This time we're on a rescue mission... -
![Wicked Waves by Roxanne Riley]()
Wicked Waves by Roxanne Riley
Rated: 4.00 of 5 stars · 5 ratingsThere are lots of fish in the sea. And she's got two on her line! Raised by a rock star, fame was never the life that Marina McNamara wanted. While several of her six siblings were eager to follow in her father's footsteps, Marina got a nursing degree, and loves every minute of it. Helping people is what she's born to do. Well, most of it... -
![What the Heart Wants by Nikki Ash]()
What the Heart Wants by Nikki Ash
From USA Today Bestselling Author Nikki Ash comes an emotional romance about finding love after loss. .. Aubree. After losing my husband, life was all about taking care of my kids and trying to remain afloat. Brody and Hayden crashed into my life with the force of an entire ocean. Five years is a long time to be alone. Now, I have not one but two sexy and successful men to drown in...Categorized as:
m-f-m menage alpha male friends to lovers super rich hero reverse harem contemporary insta-love -
![Her Dirty Jocks by Mika Lane]()
Her Dirty Jocks by Mika Lane
Rated: 3.91 of 5 stars · 11 ratingsI have to tutor three hot student athletes to earn extra cash. But they’re the ones who end up teaching me… how to be dirty. I needed money for school. Three hot jocks needed to pass math. You could say I made the team. One has very hard… muscles. Another knows how to… score. And the third throws a real curve… ball...
Fantastic book recommendations by romance book lovers for romance book lovers.
Find out more about romance.io.
Find out more about romance.io.
Get recommendations by genres & tropes
Use the romance book finder to mix and match over 100 content keywords to find the books that match your preferences
Or - use our amazing romance book finder to get recommendations based on your favorite content tropes and themes. Mix and match at will.
