Books like 'And Then There Were Four'
Readers who enjoyed And Then There Were Four by Lillith Carrie also liked the following books featuring the same tropes, story themes, relationship dynamics and character types.
reverse harem paranormal poly (3+ people) fantasy funny werewolves shapeshifters forbidden love fae suspense
-
For the Love of Cupidity by Raven Kennedy
First comes love, then comes mating, then comes the baby and some cupid training. Cupidville is overrun with new cupid recruits, and it’s up to me to train them in time for Valentine’s Day. Too bad I have four mates who keep insisting that it’s time for me to take a break...Categorized as:
fae fated-mates shapeshifters grumpy sunshine sassy heroine alpha male cold hero possessive hero -
![Cupidity: The Complete Heart Hassle Series by Raven Kennedy]()
Cupidity: The Complete Heart Hassle Series by Raven Kennedy
Love. Lust. It's my job to spread it around like a virus during cold season. But guess what? Life as a cupid isn't all chocolate hearts and pink arrows. Because even though love makes the realms go round, it seems cruel that cupids don't get to have any of their own. Which might be why I sometimes go on Love strikes and get in trouble with my supervisors. I get a little cranky... -
![]()
![]()
Sponsored links / Remove ads -
![Unexpected Heat by Sedona Ashe]()
Unexpected Heat by Sedona Ashe
Things are falling apart. I’ve been betrayed and captured, but that’s not even the worst part…. I’m in heat. Three hundred years early. When I get my hands on those who betrayed me, I’m going to punt their butts over the dang moon! First, though, I need to work on escaping this dungeon while also surviving the torture by the traitors trying to steal my power. Idiots...Categorized as:
shapeshifters fae fated-mates werewolves possessive hero alpha male nerdy-hero forced proximity -
![Sin by Meg Anne, K. Loraine]()
Sin by Meg Anne, K. Loraine
I always thought I’d start the apocalypse. Instead I’ve been asked to help end it. How does one stop the end of the world, you might ask? You gotta knock up Lucifer’s vessel before he does. I know, I know. I was surprised too. But let me tell you, if ever there was an incubus made for the job, it’s me. With a name like Sin, you’d think this should have been the easiest task I’d ever been assigned...Categorized as:
forced proximity grumpy sunshine fae alpha male suspense fated-mates sassy heroine nerdy-hero -
-
![Of Magic and Reindeer by Maya Nicole]()
Of Magic and Reindeer by Maya Nicole
Neve North has zero Christmas spirit. She hates the cold, won't touch cookies, and rolls her eyes at anything remotely festive. As far as she's concerned, the holidays can choke on a candy cane. But when she catches reindeer eating someone's rooftop garden and watches them shift into men, everything changes. Suddenly nine strangers are at her door to call a herd meeting... -
![Dinosaurs, Doubts & Albert Einswine by Sedona Ashe]()
Dinosaurs, Doubts & Albert Einswine by Sedona Ashe
I’m ready for the chaos of Texas to be a speck in my rearview mirror. So when the museum director throws me a bone by arranging for us to visit a fossil dig in Utah, I jump at the opportunity. I need a breather from all the craziness that has become my life since waking multiple dino shifters. A dig in Utah sounds like exactly what I need, the perfect getaway...Categorized as:
fated-mates shapeshifters alpha male possessive hero magic reverse harem paranormal contemporary -
![Court of Fury by Lacey Carter Andersen]()
Court of Fury by Lacey Carter Andersen
What happens when three sexy princes are dying to bring me to my knees? I turn the tables and leave them begging on their knees for. me. …. The three handsome royals are driving me out of my mind. Not only are they making my life miserable at the dragon riders’ academy, but some unexplainable force is pulling me to them. All I want is to ride my dragon and become the warrior I need to be...Categorized as:
fated-mates suspense forced proximity sassy heroine alpha male cold hero possessive hero paranormal -
![Dying for the Dead by M. Sinclair]()
Dying for the Dead by M. Sinclair
My mission? To save New Orleans from Nero’s demonic clutches. Should be simple, right? I mean, hell, I am literally the Queen of the Dead. I fear that we are running out of time though. Time to save the missing supes taken by Nero and Asmodeus. Time to get out of the Demonic realm, before we can’t leave. Time to save our city and my kingdom. The biggest snap in my plan? I’ve died...Categorized as:
shapeshifters werewolves fated-mates sassy heroine alpha male possessive hero paranormal vampires -
![Calluna: A Christmas Present for Klaus by Jewels Arthur]()
Calluna: A Christmas Present for Klaus by Jewels Arthur
Rated: 4.80 of 5 stars · 5 ratingsEveryone deserves love right? Even ferrets! Calluna is back for a Christmas bonus featuring all her men, Lars and Reg, and of course Klaus the rashy ferret! Join the gang as they celebrate their first Christmas together as a family... -
![Her Fated Wolves by Lacey Carter Andersen]()
Her Fated Wolves by Lacey Carter Andersen
Rated: 4.50 of 5 stars · 8 ratingsWorking at the House of Wieners isn’t as glamorous as it sounds…. I spend my days being yelled at by customers and working for a boss who couldn’t give a crap, but all that’s about to change. My best friend has an opportunity to move to a small town and start over, and I’m going with her. Everything had been arranged. I’m ready to leave this town behind. But then they show up...Categorized as:
shapeshifters fated-mates reverse harem paranormal insta-love age difference vampires witches -
![Court of the Fae Princes: The Complete Collection by Lacey Carter Andersen]()
Court of the Fae Princes: The Complete Collection by Lacey Carter Andersen
I agreed to a fake marriage with a handsome fae prince, and then everything went wrong…. As a human, I’m little better than scum to the fae. I’m good enough to scrub their butts and clean their floors, but that’s about it. But when I’m fired from the only job I’m qualified for, I’m in serious danger of starving to death. Which is when the Summer Prince makes me an offer I can’t resist... -
![Lupine by Hanleigh Bradley]()
Lupine by Hanleigh Bradley
They say I'm they're princess! Who are they kidding? I'm just Silver Springs Resident Orphan. Even in Silver Springs, a town full of paranormal abnormalities, Lupine, the town's resident orphan has never felt like she belonged. Overworked, stressed, hair flying everywhere, Lupine is constantly on the move working with the unique children in the Silver Spring's Orphanage... -
![Spin the Shadows by Cate Corvin]()
Spin the Shadows by Cate Corvin
I ate six seeds. Now I owe six months of debt to a dangerously sexy Fae hitman. I’d had everything a dryad could want- a job, an apartment, and a scandalous human boyfriend-. Until I stole the wrong fruit from the wrong Fae. Dragged into the Seelie underworld of deception and lies, I do anything he commands: steal, spy, even fight as we hunt down a notorious Fae fugitive... -
![Wicked by Adaline Winters]()
Wicked by Adaline Winters
A cursed maiden. Four unruly knights. A chance meeting that will entwine their destinies. Daphne Stone lives with her sister on the outskirts of the precious Hallows, where all the shiny and blessed fairy-tale folk live. Every annus, Prince Charming searches the realm for his fated Cinderella. Without fail, he finds her, beds her, and moves on to his next conquest... -
-
![Dragon Games by November Sweets]()
Dragon Games by November Sweets
It’s that time of year once again ladies! The dragon mating season is upon us! It’s time for those highborn human women to lie, cheat, claw, and stab their way into a chance at being mated to a dragon. But something strange has happened this year, it’s not only the high borns that have a chance to win the gauntlet, even the low born like me has a chance to win the prize and the bragging rights...Categorized as:
shapeshifters fated-mates reverse harem fantasy high fantasy paranormal magic dragon shifter -
![Magic's Flight by L.L. Frost]()
Magic's Flight by L.L. Frost
Rated: 4.38 of 5 stars · 8 ratingsThe story of the Wendall witch is written in blood. Hartford Cove was supposed to be a safe haven. Instead, Rowe discovered a family legacy steeped in magic and wolf shifters. The hallucinations she grew up with weren’t tricks of her broken mind. Her toaster is fully functional–thank you very much–and the real world is more wonderful and horrifying than she ever imagined... -
![Fate Hollow Academy by Lyra Winters]()
Fate Hollow Academy by Lyra Winters
Welcome to Fate Hollow Academy, where supernaturals blessed by the Fates cultivate their manifested powers and master ancient magic. Fate Hollow is the academy of the elite, where supernatural beings with special magic train for war against humans. A big-hearted, naïve arctic fox shifter like me couldn’t have prepared for the treachery lurking within the walls of the academy...Categorized as:
fated-mates suspense fae shapeshifters werewolves forbidden love forced proximity college -
![Only Protector Alphas by Rosemary A. Johns]()
Only Protector Alphas by Rosemary A. Johns
I was gifted three wickedly handsome wolf princes…. …but now I’m the wolves’ prisoner. I’m Crimson Tide. For centuries, witches have been at war with werewolves. As a kid, mom drilled into me that I was a Charmer with the badass magical power to control the scorching hot shifters...Categorized as:
shapeshifters grumpy sunshine fated-mates forbidden love magic witches fantasy humor -
![Nothing is Free by Dreia Wells]()
Nothing is Free by Dreia Wells
I was finally free. Or so I thought. New city and a new job with my best friend Mercy. We'd both overcome the odds and came out stronger. I have a pack of adoring Alphas and an obsessive male Omega, my true mate. Everything I never thought I would have. I was no longer just a Beta who hid in the shadows away from a family who disowned me. I had finally found my place in this world... -
![Their Cursed Wolves by Lacey Carter Andersen]()
Their Cursed Wolves by Lacey Carter Andersen
I need to cure the wolves, or my life is forfeit. Unfortunately, I have no idea how to help them. I’m not the witch my husbands think I am. I’m about as good at magic as I am at flirting, which is pretty darn bad. Still, I’m going to try to save them. Not just because it’s the only way to save myself, but because I want to...Categorized as:
shapeshifters suspense fae werewolves grumpy sunshine fated-mates forced proximity alpha male -
![Only Pretty Betas by Rosemary A. Johns]()
Only Pretty Betas by Rosemary A. Johns
When the witches throw me to the wolves…. …they don’t mean the cute-as-a-button kind. The shifters are hot, deadly, and our enemies for centuries. Luckily, I’m Crimson, the last Wolf Charmer with the badass magical power to control the gorgeous werewolves. Except, my powers have been bound, and I’m at their mercy. It’s make or break time in the savage kingdoms behind the wall...Categorized as:
shapeshifters suspense fated-mates forbidden love forced proximity alpha male magic fantasy -
![The Guards' Haven by Merri Bright]()
The Guards' Haven by Merri Bright
They're guarding her body. She's guarding her heart. After thirty years of cruel captivity in Verdan, Haven convinces the new, magic-wielding queen of neighboring Rimholt to allow her to open a school for poor children. It’s everything she’d hoped. Except the school is an abandoned brothel. The students are tiny criminal masterminds... -
![Second Glances by Kelsey Soliz]()
Second Glances by Kelsey Soliz
I thought having six mate marks was more than I could handle. And then Cyrus and Dar came along and told me that I was theirs, too. Male conduits, looking for their mate for over a hundred years. No pressure, right? I thought that being someone else's fated meant everything would be easy, that our connection would be instant...Categorized as:
fated-mates shapeshifters college possessive hero fantasy reverse harem vampires paranormal -
![Remnanix by Luna May]()
Remnanix by Luna May
Rated: 4.50 of 5 stars · 5 ratingsHave you ever had a dream where it felt so real, that it leaves you questioning reality when you wake up? Yeah, well…welcome to my world. After almost dying like a noob in my last boss fight and having serious heart to hearts with NPC’s, the wires between reality and fantasy are starting to blur... -
-
![Rebels and Psychos by Leigh Kelsey]()
Rebels and Psychos by Leigh Kelsey
If a secret wolf society thinks they can take me down, they’ve got another thing coming. There’s a reason they call me Graves. The steamy, crazy Rebels and Psychos series is now in one collection. It’s not my fault I’m a psychopath... -
![Ghost by Lyla Oweds]()
Ghost by Lyla Oweds
Rated: 4.22 of 5 stars · 9 ratingsMy abilities are growing every day. But thanks to my new friends, I know that I'm not insane. Even so, there's a darkness inside me. It's been getting stronger. A reality that I've been trying to avoid. Being near the boys draw it out. Being close to them also make me unafraid for the first time in my life... -
![The Blaze of the Dragon's Heart by Willa Hart]()
The Blaze of the Dragon's Heart by Willa Hart
Rated: 4.29 of 5 stars · 7 ratingsCan’t a girl catch a break? The evil mage the dragon world thought was long dead? Turns out…not so much. Vazha’s back with a vengeance, ready to destroy dragonkind and enslave the human population. My boys and I may have rescued my best friend, but the devastating news Uncle Max has been captured means we can’t go home until Vazha is destroyed... -
![The Flame of the Dragon's Heart by Willa Hart]()
The Flame of the Dragon's Heart by Willa Hart
Rated: 4.40 of 5 stars · 5 ratingsJust when things can’t get any worse, they do. My bestie’s been kidnapped and I’m desperate to find her…but my inability to sprout wings like my dragon shifter guys means we have to adopt a more mundane form of flight. We just have one more important task to complete before we can hop on a plane and follow the kidnapper’s trail to Romania... -
![Forbidden Honor by May Dawson]()
Forbidden Honor by May Dawson
In my world, dragon shifters rule. Dragon shifters are always royals. They’re always male. They’re always assholes. An orphaned servant like me? Everyone assumes on first shift, I’ll turn into a squirrel. Instead, I grow wings. Breathe fire. Throw the world into chaos. No one wants a girl in the Royal Dragon Guard. So I’m disguised as a man and sent off to military training...Categorized as:
shapeshifters fae forced proximity college werewolves sassy heroine alpha male possessive hero -
![Shadow Bonds by Rumer Hale]()
Shadow Bonds by Rumer Hale
Death was supposed to be my end. Instead, it was just the beginning. I woke up in someone else’s body, inside the Shadow Academy, a school for elite warriors. Now they think I’m someone I'm not, and until I escape, I’ll have to play along. But things get complicated when strange powers awaken inside me, along with forgotten memories... -
![Their Witch Bride by Lacey Carter Andersen]()
Their Witch Bride by Lacey Carter Andersen
My mother sold me to the shifters, all in the name of peace. For more than a century, the witches and shifters have been at war. So when my mother came home with the news that peace had been struck between us, I should’ve known better. Warning bells should have been ringing in my head, but they weren’t. It wasn’t until the shifters came for me that I knew better...Categorized as:
fated-mates shapeshifters suspense werewolves grumpy sunshine alpha male cold hero possessive hero -
![Tall, Dark and Haunted by Mia Harlan, Hanleigh Bradley]()
Tall, Dark and Haunted by Mia Harlan, Hanleigh Bradley
I always thought I was unlucky. Now, I’m dead. Not dead-dead. Ghost-dead. And NAKED. Very, very naked. Quick word of advice: Don't shift and die. Unless you want the whole world to see your hoo-ha. My afterlife takes me to a haunted castle and my three fated mates. They’re handsome ghosts. .. beneath their top hats, sideburns, and nineteenth century mustaches, that is... -
![Nope, Nada, Never by Sedona Ashe]()
Nope, Nada, Never by Sedona Ashe
My life is a chaotic mess…times three. I rely on me, myself and I. It’s the only way I can be sure nothing will go wrong. Everyone believes we are triplets, and I am happy to let them believe it. Thanks to the temperamental ancient magic that runs through my veins, I can split myself into three women. Three sides of me, and we don’t always get along...Categorized as:
shapeshifters possessive hero forced proximity alpha male suspense fated-mates paranormal humor -
![Allie by Lia Davis]()
Allie by Lia Davis
As a free spirit white witch,. I always embrace what life throws at me. So, when my BFF and roommate gets married and moves out of our pricey rental, I decide to do what anyone would. I pack up all my things and move in with my big sister. You weren't expecting that, were you? Me either. Silver Springs is a small - town haven for paranormal beings, and I'm positive it will be a good fit for me...Categorized as:
shapeshifters werewolves fated-mates paranormal reverse harem witches vampires magic -
-
![Inter by Frankie James]()
Inter by Frankie James
My journey at Emberhold Academy has barely began, and things are already going sideways. My name is Reverie Hawthorne and my first year has been full of surprises. Strange abilities that no one can explain. Mean girls taking things to the next level. Dark Faction starting to make their move...Categorized as:
college fated-mates sassy heroine alpha male possessive hero reverse harem fantasy poly -
![Resisted by Delilah Mohan]()
Resisted by Delilah Mohan
Never pick dare if you aren’t willing to suffer. The fates only gift shifters one mate in this lifetime. That’s the rule. That’s how it has always been. One mate, one subpack. Which was why it was so devastating to watch our mate die mere moments after learning she existed. It was our job to protect her, and we failed. But we wouldn’t fail her twice... -
![A Killer Crescent Valentine by Leigh Kelsey]()
A Killer Crescent Valentine by Leigh Kelsey
A killer just made Blake Hall, home of Rebel "Graves" Falcon, their hunting grounds. And they're picking off residents one by one. The killer is either ballsy or just plain dumb, because with Rebel - the notorious hitlady - determined to find them, they're a hundred percent dead. No one messes with Rebel's family of criminal weirdos and lives to tell the tale... -
![Origins by Lyla Oweds]()
Origins by Lyla Oweds
The things I see aren’t for the faint of heart. And I am no longer willing to ignore them. Not even when my family, and my best friend, tell me to keep quiet about what’s happening. They say people will think I’m crazy. Maybe I am. But the spirit haunting my professor’s house is definitely trying to tell me something, and I’m the only one who can see it...Categorized as:
suspense college shapeshifters alpha male possessive hero humor new adult paranormal -
![Pack Education Part One by Hannah Haze]()
Pack Education Part One by Hannah Haze
Returning home to Rockview after three years abroad, I find my stepbrother, Daxton, and his two best friends have formed a pack. Which is just fine, because I no longer think about that summer fling. Or the fact no alphas I’ve met since have been able to compare. Nope, not something I think about. Not at all. I. Am. Over. Them... -
![Winter Fae Queen by Lexi C. Foss, J.R. Thorn]()
Winter Fae Queen by Lexi C. Foss, J.R. Thorn
Rated: 3.90 of 5 stars · 16 ratingsThe Royal Water Fae I’m in love with just hired me to be his intern. Oh. My. Fae. I only applied for the job because of a dare, and now I’m packing my bags for the North Pole. No big deal. I can totally be professional. I haven’t seen him since the Academy anyway. Maybe he’s gotten fat from all the Winter Fae sweets? Except, no. Kalt hasn’t gotten fat at all... -
![A Curse So Cruel by Mia Hartson]()
A Curse So Cruel by Mia Hartson
Enter Shadowbone Academy where the shadows come alive, the professors are dark gods, and humans fight for immortality. When I get locked in my local library overnight, I look on the bright side: I'm surrounded by smutty books, my backpack is full of snacks, and a cushion fort is calling my name...Categorized as:
fated-mates sassy heroine alpha male cold hero possessive hero fantasy paranormal magic -
![Knot for You by Aura Riley]()
Knot for You by Aura Riley
Vera has always been an omega, but being just an omega? Never an option. Being just an omega meant that she was too timid, too sensitive, and never enough for anyone, let alone her alpha mother. Now, she is forced to deal with even more complicated matters as the only omega on campus... -
![Fury of the Kings by Lacey Carter Andersen]()
Fury of the Kings by Lacey Carter Andersen
Rated: 3.83 of 5 stars · 22 ratingsI made a thoughtless decision, then I lost my princes…. Apparently, the best time to ask someone a life or death question is when they’re fresh from being kidnapped and tired as hell. Who knew? Now, my princes are gone to a terrible place, and it’s up to me to bring them back... -
![Exordium by Frankie James]()
Exordium by Frankie James
Emberhold Academy is where Aurathians go to form their Faction or die trying. The only acceptable outcome for me is the first option. My name is Reverie Hawthorne, and I'm the only child of the most powerful Faction in existence. .. Or what's left of them. Great things are expected of me. I will deliver. Armed with the secret knowledge of my Nexus status, I'll show them what real power looks like...Categorized as:
fated-mates college sassy heroine alpha male possessive hero paranormal from hate to love poly -
-
![Rage Quit by Kira Roman]()
Rage Quit by Kira Roman
Well shiz. Things are not going the way I planned. My danger-noodle stalker is apparently one of my Heart Bonded. Add to that list a lost Orc-Elf Prince…and his brother… That was an awkward conversation, because they didn't even know they were brothers. Surprise! Now you have to share the same girl for all time! Yay you... -
![Taken by L.V. Lane]()
Taken by L.V. Lane
Taken is the third and final book in the Omega Prey series and concludes Priya’s story! More adventures will be coming for new characters in the Omega Prey universe! First I was a broken Beta. Now I am a broken Omega. My mates are worried; I am worried. Trapped, and a prisoner of my home lest my scent send Alphas mad with lust. I just need a moment. But I won’t get one...Categorized as:
shapeshifters werewolves fated-mates alpha male possessive hero paranormal fantasy humor -
![Her Donut Shifters by Mia Harlan]()
Her Donut Shifters by Mia Harlan
My name is Jetta, and I'm not a psychopath. I just hate donuts. When the Squishy Shifters Donut Emporium opens down the street from my house, I want it gone...Categorized as:
shapeshifters fated-mates paranormal humor witches fantasy reverse harem contemporary -
![Strong as a Horse by Jarica James]()
Strong as a Horse by Jarica James
Welcome to the Society of Shifters, where every person you meet has an animalistic secret. Enter a world of unusual shifters, steamy romance, and laugh-out-loud characters who embody the personalities of their shifted forms... -
![First Addition by Kelsey Soliz]()
First Addition by Kelsey Soliz
I was so close to getting everything I wanted, an internship with my Uncle, an officer with the special-ops team. If it weren't for a stupid boy that had to go and make me angry, causing me to turn a certain part of his anatomy purple and sparkly, I wouldn't have accidentally revealed to my family what I really was. What I had been hiding...Categorized as:
fated-mates college shapeshifters possessive hero reverse harem vampires poly contemporary -
![Kiss of Fate by Heather Long, Blake Blessing]()
Kiss of Fate by Heather Long, Blake Blessing
Idioms are what we idiots tell ourselves to make us feel better. They're all lies. Truth sets you free. Ha. Justice is blind. Hardly. Life ends when you die. Wrong! All’s fair in love and war. Fine. I’ll give you that one. But you’d be wise to remember Fate isn’t fair, kind, or gentle. How do I know? I almost died. I say almost because a moment before my last breath, Judgment found me...Categorized as:
sassy heroine possessive hero angels humor paranormal fantasy reverse harem contemporary
Fantastic book recommendations by romance book lovers for romance book lovers.
Find out more about romance.io.
Find out more about romance.io.
Get recommendations by genres & tropes
Use the romance book finder to mix and match over 100 content keywords to find the books that match your preferences
Or - use our amazing romance book finder to get recommendations based on your favorite content tropes and themes. Mix and match at will.
