Books like 'Dancing with the Headless Horseman'
Readers who enjoyed Dancing with the Headless Horseman by Elena H. Covens also liked the following books featuring the same tropes, story themes, relationship dynamics and character types.
paranormal fantasy vampires monsters virgin hero virgin heroine
-
Warrior's Hope by Rebecca Zanetti
This thrilling novel in the New York Times bestselling author’s popular Dark Protectors series takes readers on a wild ride as the only female vampire ever born brings a love triangle to its explosive conclusion—deciding the fate of battling factions as the forces of good and evil gather for the ultimate showdown... -
![Cheating Death by Sarah Reynolds]()
Cheating Death by Sarah Reynolds
The last thing Sunday Prescott wanted to do was rescue her brother from another problematic adventure, but that is exactly where she ended up.When Colton found himself in the holding cells of the Ruby Star Casino, Sunday knew that the only way to get him out what to appeal to the casino's owner... -
![]()
![]()
Sponsored links -
![Shades of Witches by Kim Richardson]()
Shades of Witches by Kim Richardson
Rated: 4.63 of 5 stars · 8 ratingsDon't miss the next book in the Witches of New York series!Shades of Witches is perfect for fans of urban fantasy, mystery, slow-burn romance, and humor... -
![Valkyrie's Choice by Fiona Davenport]()
Valkyrie's Choice by Fiona Davenport
Rated: 4.32 of 5 stars · 14 ratingsBeing turned into a Valkyrie put a crimp in a girl's dating plans, even when the rest of the town was full of monsters. Isla Hart figured the odds of finding her happily ever after were slim when she sprouted wings…until she saved Cooper Madison’s life and couldn’t get him out of her head. Too bad he was human, and it wasn’t as though she’d ever see him again anyway... -
-
![FANGS, Vol. 3 by Billy Balibally]()
FANGS, Vol. 3 by Billy Balibally
Rated: 4.30 of 5 stars · 14 ratings"What kind of guy is unlucky enough to get bitten... and survive?"As the sole survivor of a vampire attack, En wakes up to find that his hair has gone white as snow... and, worse, that he's developed a craving of his own for blood.Fortunately, the vampire health and welfare organization FANGS is there to help with the transition, and the handsome Ichii steps up as his guardian and mentor... -
![Dragon’s Obsession For Darkness by Brittany White]()
Dragon’s Obsession For Darkness by Brittany White
Rated: 4.67 of 5 stars · 6 ratingsLove is put to the test when secrets become unraveled.After losing my mother to vampire hunters when I was eighteen, I moved with my siblings and father across the country – until the hunters found us again. That was how my family and I ended up in Snow Haven, Alaska. I saw a dragon shifter, Josiah Bazin, the second day after we moved to the area and I fell in love... -
![Bearly Tart by Loni Ree]()
Bearly Tart by Loni Ree
Rated: 4.28 of 5 stars · 12 ratingsWilder BearlyIt's true. I'm a dumb*ss.Doing my brother a quick favor leads to the biggest shock of my life—his mate's youngest sister is my soulmate. The second Cora Sweet opens the door, I lose my heart and my mind. My mouth takes off without consulting my brain or my inner bear and I end up p*ss*ng her off...Categorized as:
virgin heroine virgin hero paranormal shapeshifters fantasy fated-mates alpha male dual-pov -
![Frederick by Taylor Rylan]()
Frederick by Taylor Rylan
Rated: 4.31 of 5 stars · 10 ratingsWhat happens when your fated One happens to be someone you’re investigating? Frederick Ainsworth’s life is, for lack of a better word, mundane. Needing something to occupy his time, he joins the Council as an enforcer, with the small hope that he’d have a better chance of finding that perfect someone to spend the rest of eternity with too. So far, nothing... -
![Tooth and Nail by Patricia Logan, Meg Amor]()
Tooth and Nail by Patricia Logan, Meg Amor
The very last thing U.S. Marshal Eoghan Sapphire wants is a new partnership. Worse yet, the transfer from Lexington, Kentucky is a civilian. That means it’ll be Eoghan’s responsibility to break him into the I.S.R. and the unique way their particular U.S. Marshals Service unit operates... -
![Stealing Snow by Skye Alder]()
Stealing Snow by Skye Alder
Rated: 4.38 of 5 stars · 8 ratingsHe could show her that they're meant to be. Sayer is used to getting what he wants. He's got more money, more power, then most and he's used it to get to where he is today. Now that he's settled, he's looking for the missing piece of his life. His mate. When he catches her scent, he figures that mating her will be as easy as everything else in his life. He was wrong...Categorized as:
virgin heroine virgin hero paranormal shapeshifters fantasy alpha male contemporary insta-love -
![Johnson Jones' Diary by Robyn Peterman]()
Johnson Jones' Diary by Robyn Peterman
Rated: 4.38 of 5 stars · 8 ratingsA fabulous mash-up of three of my favorite characters from three of my favorite series?Umm… Yes, please!Johnson from My Big Fat hairy Wedding, Dwayne from Shift Happens and Zorro from Magic and Mayhem are hanging out together and having the time of their lives... -
![I Dated a Mob Wolf by Viola Grace]()
I Dated a Mob Wolf by Viola Grace
Rated: 4.60 of 5 stars · 5 ratingsHe had been her favourite date, so she arranged for him to be the father of her child... should she have told him?Vallu spent over five years as an escort with the Blind Date Corporation. On her last date, she used her activation to provide her with something she needed... a child. She just didn’t tell him... -
![Turnabout is Fairy Play by Andie Fenichel]()
Turnabout is Fairy Play by Andie Fenichel
Rated: 4.25 of 5 stars · 11 ratingsLorenzoI rarely eat the food at my upscale Italian restaurant. Vampires need blood, not pasta. I crave the hunt, but I’m not a killer. A lady-killer, yes. There’s something about the vampire in me that lures women. The only woman immune to my allure is my dearest and oldest friend, Lily. She helped me survive my transition to vampirism, despite also becoming a monster of sorts... -
![The Orc's Innocent Plaything by Veronika Kane]()
The Orc's Innocent Plaything by Veronika Kane
A midwife should have some understanding of pleasure, aye? And I know just the male to teach me… I came through the stones to the orc’s world to help with my sister’s birth. So many human women have Mated with orc males, and I’ve long grown accustomed to the way their brutish features hide honorable and caring hearts...Categorized as:
monsters virgin heroine orcs paranormal fantasy fated-mates historical length-medium -
-
![Three to Find by Kelsey Soliz]()
Three to Find by Kelsey Soliz
The goddess has jokes. It seems I'm at the end of her latest one. I've been notified that I have three mates I must find, and if I can't complete my circuit, it's not too big of a deal. It's just that, well, the Night might eat my soul. So, the fact that one of my mates doesn't want me, and that I don't know who the last one is, isn't too worrisome... -
![Dragon Next Door by Terry Bolryder]()
Dragon Next Door by Terry Bolryder
Rated: 4.06 of 5 stars · 27 ratingsA dragon hiding among humans just found the one woman he can't resist...As a dragon on the run from others of his kind, Tristan has only one rule: don't get involved. But when he spots Kelsie Lawton, in way over her head with a couple of street thugs, there's no way he can walk away. Especially when the dragon in him, buried and smothered for a lifetime, insists he's found his mate...Categorized as:
virgin heroine virgin hero witches shapeshifters fantasy multicultural paranormal insta-love -
![The Dragon's Appraiser: Part Two by Viola Rivard]()
The Dragon's Appraiser: Part Two by Viola Rivard
Rated: 4.22 of 5 stars · 9 ratingsWhen Madja manages to convince Sevrrn to take her into town, hilarity ensues. But so does the realization that Sevrrn will never fully understand her or her needs. Can an ancient dragon god ever possibly love her? And if he can’t, can she live with that? Does she even have a choice? *** http://www.amazon...Categorized as:
virgin heroine virgin hero magic fantasy historical paranormal non-human-hero length-novella -
![Bound by the Golden King by Ellie Pond]()
Bound by the Golden King by Ellie Pond
Rated: 4.22 of 5 stars · 9 ratingsThere’s no leaving the Veiled City, not now. I’m in it, my heart is tied to Nico, Holter and Eros. But there’s one more who I yearn Castor Drakos. I can’t have him. Having a human mate will make it hard for him to ever rule as king. He’s bent on changing this place. And if there’s one thing it needs, it's change. The assailant who destroyed the Glyden lobby up their attacks to a new level... -
![Shadow Born by D.N. Hoxa]()
Shadow Born by D.N. Hoxa
Rated: 4.25 of 5 stars · 8 ratingsThey call me Kallista Nix, but that is not my real name. My past was taken from me, and though I search for it every day for the past five years, all I find are dead ends.Though I search for the Dark Shade, everyone keeps telling me that it doesn’t exist. The darkness, the monsters, the fear—they’re all in my head.I’m tempted to believe them... -
![Bloody Fairy: A Novella by B. Love]()
Bloody Fairy: A Novella by B. Love
Rated: 4.33 of 5 stars · 6 ratingsAt the end of her life cycle, aquatic fairy, Syena, is willing to do just about whatever she can to live a little longer. An unlikely hero saves her life, and she’s surprised when he offers to extend it too. One bite from a vampire changes Syena instantly. What they don’t prepare for is their bond to be fated, causing Syena to be both fairy and vampire... -
![Hot as Suck by Andie M. Long]()
Hot as Suck by Andie M. Long
Rated: 4.40 of 5 stars · 5 ratingsJASONOne minute I’m finally dating my ideal woman, the next I’m told I’m the new king of the dragons.They can’t mean me; I’m the village idiot. An identity I have no problem with because it means I don’t have to take life too seriously. Well, until now.The dragons say I have to endure a series of trials before I can rule, but I haven’t become one with my inner dragon yet... -
![Havoc's Mate by Lila Rose]()
Havoc's Mate by Lila Rose
Rated: 4.11 of 5 stars · 14 ratings*0.99 pre-order sale. Price increases to 1.99 after release.*Cora Smith only wants peace. She wants to find a place she can live without looking over her shoulder for trouble, for it to be somewhere she’ll be happy, and somewhere her mom can go about cooking pot cookies and talking to the ghosts. She doesn’t expect to find it in a town called Badlands Territory...Categorized as:
virgin heroine virgin hero paranormal shapeshifters fantasy insta-love fated-mates non-human-hero -
![Claiming Beauty by Skye Alder]()
Claiming Beauty by Skye Alder
Rated: 4.13 of 5 stars · 10 ratingsWho chooses to fall in love with a beast?That's the question that Thatcher has been asking himself for years.It's why he doesn't date, has never tried to find his fated mate, and rarely leaves his home.He knows what he is and he can't bear to see the looks he gets whenever he goes out.He's content with his life of solitude.Until she shows up.Clara Young...Categorized as:
virgin heroine virgin hero paranormal shapeshifters fantasy dual-pov fated-mates werewolves -
![My Eye Adored You by Kylie Marcus]()
My Eye Adored You by Kylie Marcus
Rated: 4.09 of 5 stars · 12 ratingsHe may only have one eye, but it adores her … he just doesn’t know it yet. Reece Spencer became a monster after a Halloween party gone wrong, but instead of letting it ruin his life, he dedicated his life to monsters. After selling his portion of a successful investment firm, he funded the creation of a college for monsters just outside the monstrous little town of Screaming Woods... -
-
![Outbride: Beauty and the Beasts Vol. 3 by Tohko Tsukinaga]()
Outbride: Beauty and the Beasts Vol. 3 by Tohko Tsukinaga
Rated: 4.09 of 5 stars · 11 ratingsONE HUMAN CAN SAVE THEM ALL.Humanity as she knew it is gone, but Mashiro is slowly coming to terms with her new reality. She has even warmed slightly to her companions, the four impressive male celestials all set on being the first to procreate with her... -
![Cruel Moon by Marissa Farrar, Skye Jones]()
Cruel Moon by Marissa Farrar, Skye Jones
Rated: 4.13 of 5 stars · 8 ratingsOne girl, five monsters, one hell of a ride.Aisha was reduced to nothing but a blood serf in the Citadel, until wolf shifters offered her a chance to escape.Though she tries to resist her new captors, the muscular, tattooed shifters soon break her down.But everything comes at a price.With a vampire and a gargoyle on her trail, and wolves holding her hostage, Aisha learns who—or what—she really is...Categorized as:
vampires monsters paranormal fantasy shapeshifters reverse harem poly length-novella -
![Pure Surrender by Aja James]()
Pure Surrender by Aja James
Rated: 4.14 of 5 stars · 7 ratingsAella Alexander: An Amazon warrior in her human life, Aella has always taken and fought for what she wanted, and what Aella wanted, she got. Until him. Cloud Drako: The mysterious new recruit to the Pure Ones’ team of Elite soldiers is not what he seems. He has a critical role to fulfill to maintain Balance in the universe… He cannot afford to be distracted by her...Categorized as:
virgin hero vampires shapeshifters fantasy paranormal suspense from hate to love alpha male -
![Wed to the Lionman by Cara Wylde]()
Wed to the Lionman by Cara Wylde
Betrayed. The female I'd thought was my mate ran off with someone else in the middle of the night. Now I'm the mock of the pride, the lionman who couldn't rein in his lioness. I don't care what they say. I don't want to control my female, I want her to be with me because I'm her world, like she is mine. For that to happen, we have to be fated mates. So next time, I won't make the choice...Categorized as:
monsters virgin heroine fated-mates marriage of convenience futuristic paranormal dystopian aliens -
![Demigod's Mate by Celeste King]()
Demigod's Mate by Celeste King
Rated: 4.20 of 5 stars · 5 ratingsA human woman has three stages of her life on Protheka…Birth. Service. Death.On the run, I sought shelter from a dark elf named Tarron.I expected to die, but instead he took me into his home where he healed and protected me.But most of all, he made me happy.I should have never stopped running.All it took was one slip up and I was back to being sold at the market... -
![Unholy with Eyes like Wolves by Morgan Dante]()
Unholy with Eyes like Wolves by Morgan Dante
“Indulgent, depraved, and sanguine, UNHOLY WITH EYES LIKE WOLVES is a gory fugue that will have readers cheering for its queer women no matter the wrongs they commit in pursuit of survival and salvation... -
![The Heartbreak Hex by Jordyn Alexander]()
The Heartbreak Hex by Jordyn Alexander
Rated: 4.20 of 5 stars · 5 ratingsGertrude Nightshade never thought that she’d be heartbroken right before Halloween.A busy potion witch in the middle of Holiday Village with a thriving shop, Gertrude thought that she’d be with her werewolf boyfriend forever. That is, until he unceremoniously dumps her at the busiest time in her career... -
![Suit & Fangs by Marian Tee]()
Suit & Fangs by Marian Tee
Rated: 4.04 of 5 stars · 12 ratingsCaros are what vampires used to be.We are slaves to pleasure, power turns us on, and each and every one of us has a weakness to hide. All things sparkly and beautiful are 18-year-old Caylie Sonora’s greatest source of pleasure, and no one is more irresistibly gorgeous and seductive in her eyes than the quiet and old-fashioned Luka...Categorized as:
vampires virgin heroine contemporary paranormal shapeshifters werewolves fantasy possessive hero -
![Damon by Teagan Wilde]()
Damon by Teagan Wilde
Rated: 4.02 of 5 stars · 12 ratingsDamon came into my life when I needed him the most. I’d never imagined my mate would be the Alpha of the most notorious pack around. He became my everything, but little did I know my future with him was in danger. Things were not what they seemed... Damon When I allowed a new member to join my pack, I never imagined that she would become mine... -
![Toadstools and Vampire Kisses by SJ Sanders]()
Toadstools and Vampire Kisses by SJ Sanders
Every Halloween, the Durmont coven gathers for the Witch’s Ball...Categorized as:
vampires monsters paranormal witches forced proximity magic fantasy explicit-open-door -
-
![Hungry for Red by Loni Ree]()
Hungry for Red by Loni Ree
Rated: 4.03 of 5 stars · 11 ratingsAn experiment gone wrong has left W. Aaron Wolfe a little different, furrier and such. He’s been living in the middle of the woods for years to hide his secrets. When he stumbles across an injured camper being attacked in the forest, his inner wolf demands that he step in to save the beauty and claim her as theirs. One minute, Isla Redmond is running from a beast in the woods...Categorized as:
virgin hero virgin heroine paranormal shapeshifters fantasy insta-love dual-pov alpha male -
![The Blackest Night by Fiona Davenport]()
The Blackest Night by Fiona Davenport
Rated: 3.99 of 5 stars · 18 ratingsStephan Bancroft was happy for his brothers, but seeing them blissfully settled made him feel the lack of his own consort even more. Taking on extra missions for the vampire council didn’t help. Nothing would except finding the woman who was destined to be his.Bronwyn O’Brien had no idea vampires existed until she was attacked while walking home from a party...Categorized as:
vampires virgin hero virgin heroine paranormal alpha male insta-love fantasy dual-pov -
![Sensual Danger by Tina Folsom]()
Sensual Danger by Tina Folsom
Rated: 4.00 of 5 stars · 11 ratingsVenice, Italy - early 1800s When vampire Nico purchases a house to further his fellow vampires' goal of creating a secure compound within Venice, he doesn't expect to get a headstrong wife in the bargain. He plans to send her to the mainland after their wedding night so he can continue his debauched bachelor life...Categorized as:
vampires virgin heroine fantasy historical paranormal sassy heroine length-novella audiobook -
![Arts and Witchcraft by Dakota Rebel]()
Arts and Witchcraft by Dakota Rebel
Rated: 4.00 of 5 stars · 9 ratingsFun fact, they’re still running witches out Salem, even in the twenty-first century. So, after being chased from their home by people with actual pitchforks, the LaFey triplets have settled down in a small town in northern Michigan.Unfortunately, the saying is true. There’s no rest for the wicked…witches.Mindi – All I wanted was a normal life. And I thought we’d finally found that here... -
![The Vampire's Mail Order Bride Prologue by Kristen Painter]()
The Vampire's Mail Order Bride Prologue by Kristen Painter
Rated: 4.00 of 5 stars · 9 ratingsavailable from author's websiteOriginal prologue to The Vampire's Mail Order BrideAuthor's note: Here's the original opening to The Vampire's Mail Order Bride. It was left out of the book because some of my savvy beta readers thought it might give readers the wrong impression about the hero, Hugh Ellingham. Now you can decide for yourself... -
![Enchanting the Ogre's Heart by Lyonne Riley]()
Enchanting the Ogre's Heart by Lyonne Riley
Rated: 4.00 of 5 stars · 8 ratingsNorgren the ogre wants nothing more than a mate of his own, and he’s found the perfect one: a beautiful, curvy woman named Tally, who works as an apothecary in the nearby human town. He expects her to be thrilled about the charming, cozy home he’s built for her, but Tally flees in fear instead—shattering Norgren’s heart... -
![The Demon Alpha by Belle Kayce]()
The Demon Alpha by Belle Kayce
Rated: 4.00 of 5 stars · 7 ratingsAva is on her way to college and to freedom . . . until she stumbles upon a gruesome information that could cause the next great alpha wars.Without no one to turn to, she runs for her life and leaves her future hanging in the balance.As danger pursues her, she becomes trapped in another. She meets her mate—Lance, the Demon Alpha. His reputation precedes him, but Ava is nonetheless enchanted... -
![The Bleeding Hearts Club by Morgan Blackwell]()
The Bleeding Hearts Club by Morgan Blackwell
Rated: 4.00 of 5 stars · 6 ratingsAfter being bombarded by her best friend with news of a matchmaking single’s retreat, Mina tries to look at the bright side. A week of sun, sand, relaxation, fruity cocktails, shirtless guys, and all the free time to read her favorite romances. Her plans, however, are derailed at the airport after a mix up leads her to meet Theo, the adorably goofy, “guy next door” type...Categorized as:
vampires monsters forced proximity paranormal insta-love from hate to love dual-pov curvy heroine -
![Jack Addison vs. Doing The Right Thing by K.A. Merikan]()
Jack Addison vs. Doing The Right Thing by K.A. Merikan
Rated: 4.00 of 5 stars · 5 ratings“Mr. Addison… I’m so sorry to impose, but I was hoping you would sign my venator card?” Jack thought he had it all: a powerful family ready to offer a helping hand in times of need, success and fame, and the most amazing lover in the person of Roux Chat-Bonnes... -
![Today Tomorrow and Always by Tessa Bailey]()
Today Tomorrow and Always by Tessa Bailey
Tucker isn’t interested in quests, thank you very much. Though the cigar-smoking, Uber-driving vampire has long been an official member of the undead club, his very human heart still lurks inside of him—and no one has ever spoken to it more clearly than Mary…the fairy he’ll be driving to her wedding. Where she’ll be marrying someone else...Categorized as:
vampires virgin heroine virgin hero paranormal suspense fantasy contemporary height-difference -
-
![Possessed by The Alpha by Skye Alder]()
Possessed by The Alpha by Skye Alder
Rated: 3.93 of 5 stars · 12 ratingsEmpath: A person with the paranormal ability to apprehend the mental or emotional state of another individual.That’s what I am. I can feel emotions and so when I turn eighteen and start to feel this strong pull, I grab my best friend, hop in the car and follow it. It leads me deep into the forest to him.Gunner Harding.The alpha of the Red Ridge Pack and my mate...Categorized as:
virgin hero virgin heroine contemporary paranormal shapeshifters fantasy fated-mates length-novella -
![Melting the Frost Troll by Ella Maven]()
Melting the Frost Troll by Ella Maven
Rated: 3.91 of 5 stars · 11 ratings“She wants to cross my bridge… but not if I claim her first.” I used to have much more important things to protect, but now after sipping a strange drink at a party, I’m merely an ice troll guarding a frozen bridge. It’s not much, but it’s my duty. When I catch three thieves attempting to cross my bridge without paying the tax, they sacrifice one of their own to get away... -
![Bearly Sweet by Loni Ree]()
Bearly Sweet by Loni Ree
Rated: 3.90 of 5 stars · 17 ratingsThorne BearlyMy headache is growing by the minute. I can’t believe my secretary, who also happens to be my mother, took on another job for my already overbooked construction company. At this rate, I’m going to be working twenty-four hours a day for the next fifty years to catch up...Categorized as:
virgin heroine virgin hero paranormal shapeshifters fantasy fated-mates alpha male dual-pov -
![The Beast's Mate by Mila Crawford]()
The Beast's Mate by Mila Crawford
Rated: 3.89 of 5 stars · 11 ratingsArkin Savage, has been alone for a decade, and he prefers it that way. A ferocious wolf shifter and known as The Beast of Badlands, he’s stayed hidden in the mountains, content with his solitude.And then he sees her. His one and only mate.Calliope Grace is the most beautiful person he’s ever seen. The bunny shifter is small where he’s large, gentle where he’s rough... -
![Jameson by Elisa Leigh]()
Jameson by Elisa Leigh
Rated: 3.89 of 5 stars · 12 ratingsJameson Walker has lived many years never meeting his mate. He's about given up on the idea, convinced mates were a romantic notion his parents told him about as a child. Maybe there wasn't one soul perfectly matched in every way for each shifter. Maybe it was time to start looking for a good woman to settle down with...Categorized as:
virgin heroine virgin hero paranormal new adult shapeshifters insta-love fantasy age difference -
![Samuel by Kathi S. Barton]()
Samuel by Kathi S. Barton
Rated: 3.88 of 5 stars · 8 ratingsSamuel Payne left his pride five years ago because of his father, a cruel man with a heavy fist and little conscience. Samuel despises the man and only goes back to save his mother and start a new life―as far away from his father and the pride as he can get. Taking a mate is at the bottom of his list of priorities...Categorized as:
vampires virgin heroine contemporary paranormal fantasy shapeshifters length-short audiobook
Fantastic book recommendations by romance book lovers for romance book lovers.
Find out more about romance.io.
Find out more about romance.io.
Get recommendations by genres & tropes
Use the romance book finder to mix and match over 100 content keywords to find the books that match your preferences
Or - use our amazing romance book finder to get recommendations based on your favorite content tropes and themes. Mix and match at will.
