Books like 'Untamed'
Readers who enjoyed Untamed by Lily Black also liked the following books featuring the same tropes, story themes, relationship dynamics and character types.
contemporary reverse harem poly (3+ people) forbidden love single-father anal sex
-
Converge by Kitty Cox
Lives that are meant to be together always converge.I was proud to be a simple country man. All I had to do was take care of my little girl, feed the cows, and live a good life - until Violet showed up. With one bat of her false eyelashes, that woman rocked my world. The things she offered sounded too good to be true...Categorized as:
single-father anal sex contemporary new adult poly strong heroine small town bisexual -
![Bound to the Bikers by Stephanie Brother]()
Bound to the Bikers by Stephanie Brother
For three hot bikers, off-limits just became no limitsMy father will kill them if they touch me, but when our family's dark past crashes into my quiet life, my cute little bookstore goes up in smoke and I'm thrown into the arms of three wickedly irresistible bikers.All dads are protective, but mine is the president of the Screaming Eagles MC, so he really means it...Categorized as:
forbidden love anal sex contemporary praise-kink humor suspense fake relationship forced proximity -
![]()
![]()
Sponsored links -
![Grumpy Makes Three by Rebel Bloom]()
Grumpy Makes Three by Rebel Bloom
๐๐ก๐๐ฒ ๐ฌ๐๐ฒ ๐ฒ๐จ๐ฎ ๐๐๐ง ๐๐๐ญ๐๐ก ๐ฆ๐จ๐ซ๐ ๐๐๐๐ฌ ๐ฐ๐ข๐ญ๐ก ๐ก๐จ๐ง๐๐ฒ, ๐๐ฎ๐ญ ๐๐ฅ๐ฅ ๐ฆ๐ฒ ๐ฌ๐ฎ๐ง๐ฌ๐ก๐ข๐ง๐ ๐๐ฑ๐ญ๐๐ซ๐ข๐จ๐ซ ๐ก๐๐ฌ ๐ ๐จ๐ญ๐ญ๐๐ง ๐ฆ๐ ๐ข๐ฌ ๐ ๐๐ก๐๐๐ญ๐ข๐ง๐ ๐๐ฑ ๐๐ง๐ ๐๐ง ๐๐ฏ๐ข๐๐ญ๐ข๐จ๐ง ๐ง๐จ๐ญ๐ข๐๐..Categorized as:
anal sex single-father contemporary new adult humor length-medium age difference boss & employee -
![Shades of Trouble: Books 1-4: Complete Series by Kitty Cox]()
Shades of Trouble: Books 1-4: Complete Series by Kitty Cox
Rated: 4.75 of 5 stars · 8 ratingsComplete Series - Collide, Converge, Combust, and ConquerBook 1: Destiny is what happens when dreams collide with reality.I've made a name for myself as a world famous lingerie model. I'm rich and powerful now. Not too bad for a girl from small town Texas. All I really wanted was to become so beautiful that Luke, my teenage crush, would fall at my feet.But thirteen years is a long time... -
-
![Broken Prince by Alisha Williams]()
Broken Prince by Alisha Williams
When I met three sexy strangers and had one of the best summers of my life, never in my wildest dreams would I expect to find out they were the sons of my moms new husband. My step brothers. Now we have to try and put those nights behind us and move on. I can't risk ruining my mom's happiness. Rose Briar Hill University is my new start, new friends, new life...Categorized as:
single-father reverse harem sports poly new adult spanking praise-kink grumpy sunshine -
![Collide by Kitty Cox]()
Collide by Kitty Cox
Destiny is what happens when dreams collide with reality.I've made a name for myself as a world famous lingerie model. I'm rich and powerful now. Not too bad for a girl from small town Texas. All I really wanted was to become so beautiful that Luke, my teenage crush, would fall at my feet. But thirteen years is a long time...Categorized as:
single-father anal sex contemporary new adult strong heroine poly reverse harem small town -
![My Ex-Best Friends by Rebel Bloom]()
My Ex-Best Friends by Rebel Bloom
Running from the altar in a wedding dress? Not exactly how I pictured my big day.But crashing back into the lives of my ex-best friends? Thatโs where the real trouble begins.Colt, Noah, and Logan werenโt just my best friendsโthey were my whole damn world. Oh, and the ones who got my V-card in one unforgettable night. Then I ran, leaving them behind with nothing but questions and broken trust...Categorized as:
single-father anal sex contemporary new adult humor reverse harem poly second chances -
![Vicious Lies by Rachel Leigh]()
Vicious Lies by Rachel Leigh
At Boulder Cove Academy, three things are certain:The Lawless Rule.The games are dangerous.Nothing is as it seems. I came here expecting to face my bullies with an iron fist. I played their games and won. Now that Iโve earned my place, at the academy and in their home, I should have nothing to fear. But with every past there is a shadow and mine is drawing closer with each step I take... -
![Finding the Road to Us by Carrie Ann Ryan]()
Finding the Road to Us by Carrie Ann Ryan
I was ready to say, โI doโ, then my fiancรฉ left me at the altar.Broken and embarrassed, Trace and Elliot helped me run awayโditching my wedding dress in the process.When I come back to the Wilder Retreat to show the world Iโm no longer hurting, I know I must ignore my traitorous needs when it comes to these two men.Because my body wants them both.And my soul craves them just as much... -
![Big 3 by Stephanie Brother]()
Big 3 by Stephanie Brother
I didnโt know I had three ripped, gorgeous stepbrothers until Iโd already crossed the mind-blowing line. A sexy photoshoot is not supposed to end with the model showing me all of his best positions. Especially not so soon after my break up. After what my ex did, Iโve concluded that men arenโt worth my time or trust. Except Mason is fun and sexy as hell...Categorized as:
anal sex contemporary reverse harem m-f-m poly stepsibling length-medium double-penetration -
![Single Dads Club by Rebel Bloom]()
Single Dads Club by Rebel Bloom
I thought I was done with men after my ex-husband walked out on my daughter and me...But now I'm caught between three gorgeous single dadsโand an impossible choice.I'm the single mom of a seven-year-old wild child, a struggling art teacher, and my house is about to go into foreclosure.Iโm basically the dictionary definition of a "hot mess"...Categorized as:
single-father anal sex pregnancy reverse harem secret child humor contemporary insta-love -
![Scandalous by Melissa Adams]()
Scandalous by Melissa Adams
The Release Date is going to be brought forward...Categorized as:
forbidden love single-father contemporary poly new adult stepsibling sports length-long -
![Shadowed Obsession by Penelope Black]()
Shadowed Obsession by Penelope Black
Rated: 4.30 of 5 stars · 13 ratingsbook two coming this...Categorized as:
single-father reverse harem suspense contemporary grumpy sunshine forced proximity new adult poly -
![Unwrapping Their Christmas Present by Ajme Williams]()
Unwrapping Their Christmas Present by Ajme Williams
Rated: 4.27 of 5 stars · 14 ratingsI needed to tear my eyes away from Jake Jacobs... immediately. One glance at the hot older lawyer and I knew I was in trouble. Jake unwrapped me like his little Christmas present. Even though I was his new employee that he absolutely shouldnโt have claimed... But he wasnโt the only one that broke the rules at his law firm... -
-
![My Brother's Best Friends by Rebel Bloom]()
My Brother's Best Friends by Rebel Bloom
My Brotherโs Best Friends claim Iโm the one thing they canโt have, and the only thing theyโve ever wanted.Theyโre also the ones that took my v-card and ran me out of town. Coming back to Lunar, New Mexico was a nightmare.I had no choice after my life had gone up in flames.Between finding out that my boyfriend had a wife and getting fired from my job, I had little desire to think about hot men... -
![Rainbows and Unicorns by S.N. Moor]()
Rainbows and Unicorns by S.N. Moor
Everlee and her men are back!Everything is going great for them, but when a woman from the men's past enters the scene with a proposition that is hard to refuse, how will things change for our favorite quintet?If you like your books super spicy, then you will love this book. Don't let the cover fool you. Please check content warnings... -
![Bossed by Three Billionaire Brothers by K.C. Crowne]()
Bossed by Three Billionaire Brothers by K.C. Crowne
Rated: 4.50 of 5 stars · 6 ratingsME:ย "I donโt want drama in my life."ALSO ME:ย ย "A four-person polygamy with my best friendโs dad and his twin bros? Why yes!!!"It started when my best friend proposed a Summer nanny gig with the Bradshaw trio.Three silver fox billionaire brothers livingย in the luxuriousย French Riviera.I've learned to equateย men to heartache and pain... -
![Nanny for the Bossholes by Rebel Bloom]()
Nanny for the Bossholes by Rebel Bloom
I got dumped and fired for not making babies with my boss.And now my only way to get revenge is to become a nanny for his enemies...My plan for revenge was simple: Get a job with the Graves Brothers, my ex's biggest competitors...Categorized as:
single-father anal sex contemporary new adult humor vengeance menage from hate to love -
![Nanny for the Mercenaries by Cassie Cole]()
Nanny for the Mercenaries by Cassie Cole
Rated: 4.16 of 5 stars · 15 ratingsThree rugged mercenaries. One lucky nanny. And a globe-hopping adventure that will test the limits of their love. I was only venting about my career problems at the gym.I never expected the two hot military guys in the squat rack to overhear.And I definitely didnโt expect them to offer me a solution.A chance to nanny their daughter Kaylee for two months... -
![Filthy Rich Single Daddies by Alix Vaughn]()
Filthy Rich Single Daddies by Alix Vaughn
โThatโs it, baby. Let go for us.โMaybe skinny dipping in the neighborโs pool wasnโt the best idea. Especially when the ridiculously hot new homeowner catches me and scolds me like Iโve been a very naughty girl.Turns out, my new neighbor, Austin, doesnโt live alone. He has two smoking-hot housemates and two adorable kids... -
![The Wild Boys: The Complete Series by K.A. Knight, Erin O'Kane]()
The Wild Boys: The Complete Series by K.A. Knight, Erin O'Kane
Rated: 4.25 of 5 stars · 8 ratingsEnjoy all three books of The Wild Boys Series all in one place. Including - The Wild Interview, The Wild Tour and The Wild Finale plus extra never been published bonus scenes!I have been working hard my whole life for people to take me seriously. After all, women โdonโt belongโ in the music industry... -
![A Wicked Education by Mika Lane]()
A Wicked Education by Mika Lane
Rated: 4.25 of 5 stars · 8 ratingsA Student/Professor Reverse Harem Romance They say Iโm the hottest girl on campus, and my sexy professors are about to show me why I should choose them over the boys my age.I can have any guy on campus.One look and a smile are all it takes.Jocks, nerds, hippiesโฆthey all love me.But my professors have other ideas.They want to give me a wicked educationโฆin lust...Categorized as:
forbidden love reverse harem menage contemporary college age difference insta-love new adult -
![Four Daddies & I by D. E. Bartley]()
Four Daddies & I by D. E. Bartley
Book Two of OโReillyโs FC Jasmine finally has a place she can call home with her four Daddies who want to love and care for her, giving her everything she could want and more. Sheโs always believed she was unlovable but the OโReilly brothers are more than happy to show her how far from the truth that is...Categorized as:
anal sex mafia contemporary reverse harem length-medium explicit-plentiful stepsibling spanking -
![Dare by Caitlyn Dare]()
Dare by Caitlyn Dare
Rated: 4.33 of 5 stars · 6 ratingsKat Walker has wanted Styx for as long as she can remember.Her friend.Protector.The guy who would do anything for her.Thereโs just one problem.Heโs her big brotherโs ex-best friend.But sheโs done playing by the rules.For one night, sheโs going to risk it all.Sheโs going to dare Styx to take a chance on her. On them.And sheโs found the perfect stranger to help her accomplish her goal...Categorized as:
forbidden love reverse harem age difference m-f-m friends to lovers menage bikers new adult -
-
![Bunnies & Bowties by S.N. Moor]()
Bunnies & Bowties by S.N. Moor
It's Easter time and Everlee McKinley is several months post the worst decision she's ever made. When her best friend guilts her into getting back out there and going to the Bunnies and Bowties party at Club Vixen, she thinks she's prepared to run into her men, but when she does... she realizes things are still as hot between them as ever. Perhaps hotter..Categorized as:
anal sex humor explicit-plentiful contemporary spanking exhibitionism reverse harem poly -
![Four Daddies for Christmas by K.C. Crowne]()
Four Daddies for Christmas by K.C. Crowne
Rated: 4.05 of 5 stars · 26 ratingsFour untamed ex-military daddies.One very unassuming girl.Who said Christmas miracles donโt exist?My familyโs failing farm combined with my fatherโs debt has me tossing and turning.Luckily a chance rescue brings me face to face with an opportunity I can't resist.I've been hired to take care of an adorable set of twins.But I'm nervous for three VERY good reasons:1... -
![Nanny for the Athletes by Cassie Cole]()
Nanny for the Athletes by Cassie Cole
Three chiseled professional athletes. One single woman. And a little girl who will bring them all together.When these guys showed up to board their dogs, I thought they were just a trio of extremely handsome men. I definitely didnโt know they were the three most famous athletes in St. Louis.Christian, the stoic, broad-shouldered quarterback who oozes leadership and confident charm from every pore... -
![Mall Santas by J.B. Trepagnier]()
Mall Santas by J.B. Trepagnier
Four hot mall Santas save the day. Christmas used to be my favorite holiday. Until last year. Last year, I was supposed to get married in Vegas at the stroke of midnight on Christmas day. I had the perfect wedding planned. If only Iโd picked the perfect fiancรฉ. I caught him in our bed with some blonde two days before the wedding and now Iโve turned into Scrooge...Categorized as:
anal sex contemporary length-novella explicit-open-door new adult m-f height-difference insta-love -
![Shameless by Melissa Adams]()
Shameless by Melissa Adams
๐๐จ๐ฏ๐ ๐ข๐ฌ ๐ฆ๐จ๐ซ๐ ๐๐ฎ๐ง ๐ฐ๐ก๐๐ง ๐ข๐ญโ๐ฌ ๐๐ก๐๐ฆ๐๐ฅ๐๐ฌ๐ฌDarkness follows me everywhere I go.All Iโve ever wanted was to be loved.When I finally get my wish, will I be able to keep myself and the boys Iโve always loved safe?Chaos and danger threaten to pull us apart at every turn and everyone is watching us.Our families, our friends, the entire town has their eyes on us...Categorized as:
forbidden love single-father stepsibling reverse harem contemporary new adult sports poly -
![Lowlife by Kelsey Soliz]()
Lowlife by Kelsey Soliz
Cheat on me once? Shame on you.In fact, let's take it one step further.I'll take your car, your job, your friends...But let's focus on the job part.I play drumkit better than I can speak most of the time, unless I'm singing.I've made a name for myself as a singer, going viral everywhere. The thing is, no one knows my identity... -
![A Not So Silent Night by J.L. Quick]()
A Not So Silent Night by J.L. Quick
Rated: 4.13 of 5 stars · 8 ratingsTwelve Days of Day 12โTake the scenic drive through Canada,โ they said. โItโll be fun,โ they said.Ok, so no one said it. Iโm the one with the bright idea to sightsee on my way home from college.When one of the biggest storms of the year hits, I end up stuck, waiting it out in a lakeside cabin with the two gorgeous men who rescued me from a snowbank... -
![Protรฉgรฉ by B. Lybaek]()
Protรฉgรฉ by B. Lybaek
Rated: 4.20 of 5 stars · 5 ratingsEvery maze needs a monster.It took losing everything before I willingly entered the cold and unforgiving maze, all to be reunited with the love of my lifeโmy cousin. Within the world of grueling training and extravagant galas, itโs becoming harder to know who the monster is...Categorized as:
forbidden love historical multicultural age difference contemporary reverse harem dub-con poly -
![The Proximity Effect by Maya Nicole]()
The Proximity Effect by Maya Nicole
Getting stuck in a snowdrift and watching my red thong take flight into a pine tree was not how I imagined starting my honeymoon. Then again, I also hadn't imagined starting it alone...Categorized as:
anal sex contemporary office humor reverse harem m-f grumpy sunshine forced proximity -
![Icing It by Emma Foxx]()
Icing It by Emma Foxx
Sex is a fantastic stress reliever.Or so Iโm told by the two hot guys who offer to help me get over some of my work-induced anxiety by getting under both of them.I say yes. For one night.And proceed to have my world rocked. For three days.I can not afford that kind of distraction...Categorized as:
single-father anal sex forbidden love hockey contemporary grumpy sunshine age difference sports -
-
![Three Hearts Hideaway by Luna Day]()
Three Hearts Hideaway by Luna Day
When Ava stumbles into sleepy Little Greenfield with nothing but a suitcase and humiliating voice message on her phone, the last thing she expects to find is Romanโa tattooed B&B owner who offers her a place to stay. After dumping her narcissistic boyfriend and running away from the embarrassment he caused her, she needs to focus on herself... -
![Hat Trick: Nanny for the Hockey Players by Christina Sterling]()
Hat Trick: Nanny for the Hockey Players by Christina Sterling
Rated: 3.99 of 5 stars · 10 ratingsWhen the Captain of The Titans bursts into my work and shouts at me "I need you" I think all of my dreams have come true.What I don't expect is the baby he's holding.Now, the Captain, our star goalie and the best defenseman in the league are my new roomies and I'm their live-in nanny.Carter is the Captain, easy-going, boy-next-door and all American good-guy...Categorized as:
single-father hockey reverse harem sports forced proximity contemporary poly length-medium -
![Hat Trick: Nanny for the Hockey Players by Christina Sterling]()
Hat Trick: Nanny for the Hockey Players by Christina Sterling
Rated: 3.95 of 5 stars · 15 ratingsWhen the Captain of The Titans bursts into my work and shouts at me "I need you" I think all of my dreams have come true.What I don't expect is the baby he's holding.Now, the Captain, our star goalie and the best defenseman in the league are my new roomies and I'm their live-in nanny.Carter is the Captain, easy-going, boy-next-door and all American good-guy...Categorized as:
single-father hockey sports reverse harem new adult dual-pov forced proximity contemporary -
![Nanny for the Army Rangers by Krista Wolf]()
Nanny for the Army Rangers by Krista Wolf
When I saved the little boy from falling off the bleachers at the aquarium, I never imagined it would change my life. But his three Army Ranger dads had other plans for me, and sometimes the best things in life come when you least expect...Categorized as:
single-father suspense new adult military contemporary reverse harem poly explicit-open-door -
![Their Boss's Daughter by Chloe Kent]()
Their Boss's Daughter by Chloe Kent
Her deepest desire might be too much for her to handleโฆ When twenty-one-year-old Saylor Fielding spends a tiny fortune from her new trust fund on something sheโs always wanted, sheโs not prepared for the consequences that follow...Categorized as:
anal sex forbidden love new adult bdsm contemporary age difference forced proximity spanking -
![Sugarplums and Submission by Sylvie Haas]()
Sugarplums and Submission by Sylvie Haas
My life plan didn't involve stepbrothers.It also didn't involve them being famous heartthrob hockey players.And it most certainly wasn't suppose to allow them to bid on me at the Christmas Cherry Auction... -
![Virgin and the Bratva by Sylvie Haas]()
Virgin and the Bratva by Sylvie Haas
Iโm supposed to be losing my virginity as part of a fundraiser. Instead, Iโm handcuffed to one of my stepbrothers who plans on taking me away from the event...Categorized as:
forbidden love contemporary virgin heroine poly age difference bad boys first-person-pov mafia -
![Room Fourteen: Making Her Beg by Amanda Keen]()
Room Fourteen: Making Her Beg by Amanda Keen
Rated: 3.75 of 5 stars · 8 ratingsIt was just supposed to be a fantasy.Dancing at the club makes my world crazy enough. But now my reality is three dangerously hot men wanting to be with meโฆAnd a stalker whoโs making my life a living hell.But just when I think this life of mine canโt get crazier, it does.Because Iโm falling for all three men. Each tempts me, teases me, and then denies me what Iโm craving most...Categorized as:
forbidden love reverse harem bdsm stepsibling age difference m-f-m suspense insta-love -
![Pucking Disaster by Charlotte Byrd]()
Pucking Disaster by Charlotte Byrd
Three hot hockey players will do anything for herโฆCan the four of them make it work?I canโt believe that I actually fell for three men at once. I never thought that this would ever happen.Ash is the Southern Californian laid back surfer dude. Soren is the exotic aloof Scandinavian.Ryder is the tortured, brooding ex-foster kid from South Boston...Categorized as:
forbidden love reverse harem contemporary sports new adult super rich hero poly hockey -
![Rush by Lane Hart]()
Rush by Lane Hart
Rated: 3.81 of 5 stars · 17 ratingsA shy bookworm is about to get an education in falling in love from three incredibly hot football players.When college football star Graham Lawson is given one last Hail Mary chance to pull up his GPA or lose his spot on the team, he turns to the sweet but shy bookworm from his hometown - the girl who saved his ass back in high school... -
-
![A Naughty Lesson by Mika Lane]()
A Naughty Lesson by Mika Lane
A Student/Professor Reverse Harem Romance The sexy professors who make my life hell are about to teach me a naughty lesson.Write an English essay about being a virgin, I thought.Seemed like a great idea at the time.Now, not so much.My professor, who always looked at me with hungry eyes, is now looking at me with something else in his gaze.Heโs intent on teaching meโฆa lesson... -
![Tormented Royal by Lily Wildhart]()
Tormented Royal by Lily Wildhart
Rated: 3.79 of 5 stars · 22 ratingsEchoes Cove was my home once. But after leaving to tour the world with my dad and his band, I never thought it would be home again. He never looked back, and neither did I.Now, after his death, Iโm forced to come home, and it seems the people I left behind want me here about as much as I want to return.My guardians donโt want me, they want my fatherโs money...Categorized as:
forbidden love contemporary new adult suspense reverse harem poly dub-con length-medium -
![The Alpha's Arrangement by Tea Ravine]()
The Alpha's Arrangement by Tea Ravine
I found you when it was too late to love you My omega came to me when I'd given up on ever finding happiness. And then his alphas appeared in my life too, and I realised just how much of a joke I really am. As a rare female alpha, I know well enough what my appeal is to the males of my designation. But I'm who I am and I won't change that. My omega isn't mine and he won't be ever...Categorized as:
anal sex forbidden love omegaverse contemporary alpha male tortured heroine suspense reverse harem -
![Pretty Little Omega by Leslie Ayla]()
Pretty Little Omega by Leslie Ayla
Rated: 3.64 of 5 stars · 11 ratingsOne upon a time there was an Omega. She was pretty, kind, and sweet. And she was hiding two very big secrets. She thought she was alone. Forced to hide what she was, she lost herself in books. Until that wasn't an option anymore... -
![The Wrong Idea by Annika Martin]()
The Wrong Idea by Annika Martin
(formerly The Wrong Turn)When Isis hooked up with three yummalicious bank robbers, she entered a world of forbidden thrills and wicked spicytimesโฆas well as hot tubs, sky-high room service bills, and major chances to accessorize with wigs during crime sprees.What was she not expecting? A deep relationship with desperately wounded badasses... -
![Bullets & Mistletoe: A Why Choose Holiday Novella by C.J. Lucci]()
Bullets & Mistletoe: A Why Choose Holiday Novella by C.J. Lucci
Last Christmas, she gave her ex her heart, but the very next day, he gave it away.This year, to save herself from tears, she'll give it to the three mafia capos she's snowed in with.Emilia Pietri loves her quiet but lonely life in the mountains of Sant Evisa, working as a hotel clerk in her hometown. When a fierce snowstorm threatens to trap her Christmas guests, they're swiftly evacuated...
Fantastic book recommendations by romance book lovers for romance book lovers.
Find out more about romance.io.
Find out more about romance.io.
Get recommendations by genres & tropes
Use the romance book finder to mix and match over 100 content keywords to find the books that match your preferences
Or - use our amazing romance book finder to get recommendations based on your favorite content tropes and themes. Mix and match at will.
