Books like 'And Then There Were Five'
Readers who enjoyed And Then There Were Five by Lillith Carrie also liked the following books featuring the same tropes, story themes, relationship dynamics and character types.
fantasy paranormal reverse harem poly (3+ people) shapeshifters werewolves forbidden love from hate to love stepsibling
-
Rebuilding the Wolf by Erin R. Flynn
Rated: 4.47 of 5 stars · 17 ratingsDivision Chief Seraphine Thomas got knocked on her ass when a witch bespelled the people she cared for most to attack her. But a month later and she’s glad she listened to her best friend that it was well past time to focus on herself and build a better foundation for her life. And that’s why she’s testifying before Congress to make the vampire SWAT idea a reality...Categorized as:
shapeshifters werewolves heroine sleuth mystery vampires paranormal suspense reverse harem -
![Tea Time with the Dead by M. Sinclair]()
Tea Time with the Dead by M. Sinclair
I hadn’t been wrong about the trouble I’d felt brewing. Now, the problem was here to stay unless we could figure out a plan. A plan to stop Nero from trying to take New Orleans from me. A plan to stop Asmodeus from kidnapping me to the demonic realm. Hell. A plan to figure out what I was going to do about these six men in my life... -
![]()
![]()
Sponsored links -
![Beauty in Ashes by Harper Wylde, Quinn Arthurs]()
Beauty in Ashes by Harper Wylde, Quinn Arthurs
There’s nothing pretty about war—blood, death, pain… that’s all it brings.And this one has already taken it’s sacrifice.But there’s no choice anymore, we need this new world and fighting is the only way.Damien, Theo, Killian, Ryder, Hiro, Joshua, and I face more challenges than ever before, death a shadow over us that even I’m not safe from... -
![Dead Wolf Rising by Rory Miles]()
Dead Wolf Rising by Rory Miles
Rated: 4.55 of 5 stars · 11 ratingsWhat do you do when your friend turns out to be a ghost and you accidentally send them to the Underworld?You try to bring them back to life. Or at least, that’s what I do.We may have defeated our enemy, but not before she struck a final blow. We refuse to let her win though. My men, my pack, and I will find peace. We will get our happily ever after and we will get our friend back... -
-
![Midnight Guardian by Tamara White]()
Midnight Guardian by Tamara White
Rated: 4.56 of 5 stars · 9 ratingsOne night destroyed my life. One bite turned me. One truth, long buried, will change everything. My life used to be so simple. After all, humans don’t have to worry about the creatures that go bump in the night. But after one fateful night, my world is turned upside down. I lose my home, my family and my humanity, all in one fell swoop... -
![Pack Captive by Cate Corvin]()
Pack Captive by Cate Corvin
Rated: 4.38 of 5 stars · 12 ratingsMy pack is dying.After being hunted down by ghostly shadow wolves, we’re on the brink of extinction. As one of the rare Moon Callers, wolves who imbue warriors with lunar power, I was meant to protect our pack...but I failed.When a shadow wolf nearly kills me, a powerful new pack sees its chance to strike.They call it rescue. I call it servitude... -
![Rats of Murk by Eva Chase]()
Rats of Murk by Eva Chase
She thought she'd found her place among the fae... but was it all a lie?Just when I thought I'd overcome the biggest obstacles my fae mates and I could face, I find myself in the hands of their greatest enemies. Enemies who have far more power than we ever imagined.Enemies who hold so much more sway over my life than I want to believe... -
![Pack Possessed by J. Kearston]()
Pack Possessed by J. Kearston
Rated: 4.57 of 5 stars · 7 ratingsYou can’t outrun your demons, but you sure as hell can give them a run for their money. The monster that’s tormented us from the shadows has finally stepped into the light, and he has his sights set on me. But discovering that my entire life has been orchestrated as a twisted form of training to help him literally unleash hell on earth? Not exactly my idea of a romantic gesture... -
![Moon Child by Serena Akeroyd]()
Moon Child by Serena Akeroyd
Rated: 4.50 of 5 stars · 8 ratingsEli A goddess told me my child would change the pack. Until it happened, I didn't believe it. Not until I saw it with my own eyes. My woman is a nurturer. She's a bringer of change. A broker of the future. She deals with emotions, sees auras, and glories in the urges of her three alpha mates. To me, she's the saint. But that doesn't make me or my brothers sinners... -
![Power of Draken: A Fated Mate Fae Romantasy by Alex Lidell]()
Power of Draken: A Fated Mate Fae Romantasy by Alex Lidell
Rated: 4.44 of 5 stars · 9 ratingsThe next generation of the bestselling Power of Five must find their fated mate—and Kai’s just happens to be human... and his sworn enemy.ROWANI’m an alchemist, not a soldier. But when your mother is an ambitious war hero and your rare magic is the key to defending the kingdom from draken-riding fae, you don’t get a choice...Categorized as:
from hate to love shapeshifters reverse harem fantasy fae paranormal new adult magic -
![Warring Magic by Sadie Jacks]()
Warring Magic by Sadie Jacks
Rated: 4.23 of 5 stars · 15 ratingsShe warned them to leave her alone.They didn’t listen.All Kiema wanted was to fix and master the power coursing through her body. To spend the rest of her days with her chosen family in peace. All she needed was one more mate and two guardians to complete the rune branded in her skin. But just like all of her plans, this one was destined to fail... -
![Cursed Mates by Skyler Andra]()
Cursed Mates by Skyler Andra
Rated: 4.27 of 5 stars · 11 ratingsRuthless. Killers. Bikers. I swore off bikers and my family’s motorcycle club, and enrolled in nursing to save lives instead of taking them. When a rival club murders my father, my brother orders me to infiltrate and avenge him. I’m the only one who can get close without being recognized. Destroying my enemies from within won’t be the hard part... -
![The Witch Chase by Ginna Moran]()
The Witch Chase by Ginna Moran
Rated: 4.38 of 5 stars · 8 ratingsThe witches want me to bow.They tried hard to break me.I can't be broken.After fleeing from the sanctuary and the dark magic of a coven of witches, I must learn the secrets of my existence and find my dad. He has the answers and knowledge we need to fight back. But the witches who have invaded our sanctuary aren't my pack's only problem. Other enemies lie in wait, trying to collar and leash us... -
![Mating My Mob by Amanda Cashure]()
Mating My Mob by Amanda Cashure
Rated: 4.50 of 5 stars · 6 ratingsMeanwhile, in Australia… a feisty chick in her red ballgown is jumping off the Pyrmont Bridge in Darling Harbour to escape dingo shifters. She’s saved by five guys with mixed feelings over whether to kill her or use her to form the mate bond that will move their lives from 'fight and run' into 'safety and belonging'... if only one of them wasn’t keeping a secret that completely changes the game... -
-
![Trierna by Serena Akeroyd]()
Trierna by Serena Akeroyd
Rated: 4.25 of 5 stars · 11 ratingsThalia has a purpose. After months of having to roll with the punches, she now knows what her part is in the grand scheme of things. Newly crowned as Queen of the Fae, and mother to a newborn hybrid, Thalia is about to take on her most daunting role yet: she's been ordained, by the Gods themselves, to bring down the Devil. And no, there isn't a euphemism hidden in that sentence... -
![Elizabeth and Her Dragons Box Set I by Ava Mason]()
Elizabeth and Her Dragons Box Set I by Ava Mason
Rated: 4.25 of 5 stars · 11 ratingsCan four sexy dragons save a wolf from her own pack? Elizabeth is the fated Alpha of her pack, but how can she lead them if she’s never shifted? She doubts herself, but her fate is tied to the moon and Elizabeth is honor-bound to fulfill her destiny. However, evil forces lurk in the shadows... -
![Bear Triplets by J.L. Wilder]()
Bear Triplets by J.L. Wilder
Could this single mom Wolf be the answer these Bears were waiting for?Triplet Bears:If that damn wolf woman thinks her son can get away with killing our cattle,we will make her pay.We have the most productive ranch in the county,But it’s been barren without one thing—a woman we can share.So for now, we’ll let them stay.We’ll give them protection from other shifters...Categorized as:
shapeshifters werewolves paranormal fantasy bear shifter small town reverse harem alpha male -
![Broken Bond by Callie Rose]()
Broken Bond by Callie Rose
Nothing is what I thought it was. Not even me.Everything changed the night I ran from Uncle Clint.And everything changed again the night he tracked me down.The four alphas who’ve each claimed me as their mate kept their promise to protect me. They came for me. They saved me. For one beautiful, blissful moment, the five of us were united, joined more closely than I’ve ever been with anyone... -
![House Of Vampires 4: The Puzzle by Samantha Snow]()
House Of Vampires 4: The Puzzle by Samantha Snow
Rated: 4.16 of 5 stars · 14 ratingsThe highly anticipated 4th book from the betselling "House Of Vampires" series is here! "Wow, this series just gets better and better." ★★★★★ "Samantha Snow you are the best, I am so addicted!" ★★★★★ Lorena awakens in the Fae Court, with only one clear memory; that she is engaged to the Prince of Shadows...Categorized as:
werewolves shapeshifters vampires reverse harem paranormal witches fantasy multicultural -
![Moon Kissed by Ruby Vincent]()
Moon Kissed by Ruby Vincent
Rated: 3.89 of 5 stars · 9 ratingsI was the chosen one.Born with the rarest power. The fated mate of the most powerful, strongest, and handsome men in our pack.I was going to change the world, and bring the Wolf Nation to great heights.Until I murdered my mate during the bonding ceremony and took off.I know what you’re thinking.He must have treated me terribly.Nope. You couldn’t have met a sweeter guy... -
![Savage Wolves by Ginna Moran]()
Savage Wolves by Ginna Moran
Rated: 4.40 of 5 stars · 5 ratingsI thought after surviving the wild world of Shadow Moon that my life would be easier. Being moon-blessed saved my life, but it ruined my future. I’m still trapped on this messed up island, forced beneath the men who think I deserve to bow at their feet. But down here, I have an advantage. I can use their savage natures against them... -
![Exordium by Frankie James]()
Exordium by Frankie James
Emberhold Academy is where Aurathians go to form their Faction or die trying.The only acceptable outcome for me is the first option.My name is Reverie Hawthorne, and I'm the only child of the most powerful Faction in existence...Or what's left of them.Great things are expected of me.I will deliver.Armed with the secret knowledge of my Nexus status, I'll show them what real power looks like... -
![Winning the Legend by B. Kristin McMichael]()
Winning the Legend by B. Kristin McMichael
Rated: 4.12 of 5 stars · 14 ratingsArianna has gathered the outside clans to decide her fate in marriage. A tournament will be held, and she is the prize, whether she wants to be or not. The only thing for her to do is watch the clan leaders fight over her, or is it? Thanks to her team's well-made plans, Arianna has other strategies in place. Hopefully one of those plans will earn her freedom...Categorized as:
werewolves shapeshifters contemporary magic paranormal vampires fantasy reverse harem -
![Wolf Mate by Jen L. Grey]()
Wolf Mate by Jen L. Grey
In the shadows, I found a destiny that was never meant to be mine. All my life, I've been an outcast and the target of cruel jokes. But fate flings me onto a different path when I receive a full-ride scholarship to a prestigious university I never applied to. As the new girl at Evergreen Elite, I’m surrounded by whispered secrets and danger that lurks in every corner...Categorized as:
shapeshifters forbidden love werewolves vampires paranormal fantasy fated-mates witches -
-
![Dragon Hunted by Alexis Pierce]()
Dragon Hunted by Alexis Pierce
Rated: 4.10 of 5 stars · 10 ratingsTHIS BOOK IS PART OF A SERIES. DESCRIPTION CONTAINS SPOILERS FOR BOOK 1.Serenity has been kidnapped.After the rebels broke into the castle, her world fell apart.Her dragons are determined to get her back, but there are dangers untold and secrets that could destroy everything.Serenity must find the strength to fight this new darkness, or this new family she's found could be gone forever... -
![The Lost Girl by Scarlett Haven]()
The Lost Girl by Scarlett Haven
Rated: 4.10 of 5 stars · 10 ratingsI’m officially a member of Mateo’s pack now, which means the panthers can’t touch me. I thought joining his pack would mean that I would finally belong somewhere, but not everybody is welcoming. I’m still the odd one out—the runt who stole their future alpha. But those things don’t matter. I have my mates, and I’m content. For the first time in my life, I am happy...Categorized as:
shapeshifters werewolves reverse harem paranormal fae abuse sweet heroine alpha male -
![Court of Dragons and Ruin by G. Bailey]()
Court of Dragons and Ruin by G. Bailey
My dragon kings are lost in another world.This world is ruled by wolf shifters…and gods.After beating Aphrodite’s tests in each of the courts, she sent Arden, Grayson, and Lysander to another world. I have to figure out which world to travel to before the magic of the staff disappears...Categorized as:
shapeshifters from hate to love reverse harem paranormal fantasy magic fated-mates poly -
![Wings of Sapphire and Storm by L.J. Swallow]()
Wings of Sapphire and Storm by L.J. Swallow
Rated: 4.11 of 5 stars · 9 ratingsTo reclaim my life from Talindra, I must embrace what I am.Become a dragon queen. Become her.The First-Born are Talindra's consorts. The dragon princes must become mine.I've been pulled from my everyday life into a world of dragon courts and royalty where four princes secretly protect me. I'm not allowed to leave the dragon realm, and the Ruby Queen demands that I marry one of the princes... -
![Surrender by Elle Lincoln]()
Surrender by Elle Lincoln
Doughnut in distress.I repeat, there is a doughnut in distress. Wait...Scratch that. Reverse it.Damsel. There is a damsel in distress. Me.I had one goal, just one teensy-weensy simple goal—to figure out what happened to my dad. All I had to do was head out to his cabin in the woods, look for clues, and figure out how and why he died then go home to the city where I belong... -
![Becoming a Legend by B. Kristin McMichael]()
Becoming a Legend by B. Kristin McMichael
Rated: 4.04 of 5 stars · 14 ratingsArianna Grace is about to turn seventeen and her life has been very complicated lately. She is the leader of four clans of night humans: dearg-dul, baku, tengu, and lycan. While the four clans seem to get along better with each other, there is internal conflict on both sides of her family, not to mention the three boys vying for her attention...Categorized as:
werewolves shapeshifters contemporary magic vampires paranormal fantasy reverse harem -
![Desperate for Her Wolves by Tara West]()
Desperate for Her Wolves by Tara West
Rated: 4.17 of 5 stars · 6 ratingsBook three in the bestselling Hungry for Her Wolves Series by USA Today Bestselling Author, Tara West The threads of Amara’s happy life are quickly unraveling as external forces threaten to tear her family apart. Branded as a killer, a lone wolf’s fateful decision severs the truce between the Amaroki and the government... -
![Mercy's Rise by Lacey Carter Andersen]()
Mercy's Rise by Lacey Carter Andersen
Rated: 4.17 of 5 stars · 6 ratingsDying was just the beginning…I know the truth of what I am. A rare and dangerous supernatural that was believed to be hunted to extinction.But now what?On one hand, I have the three men who love me and a chance at a future with them. My shy shifter. My royal vampire. And my dangerous half-breed.On the other hand, I have my father and the mysterious group he belongs to... -
![The Bone Wolf by Lucy Scott Bryan]()
The Bone Wolf by Lucy Scott Bryan
The Bone Wolf - Book One in Cedar Mountain Pack“We’re born as wolves, we die as wolves, but the night of your ascension you will find your place.”The Blackall Pack had been showing me my place since the day Dad, my brother Max and I arrived. I’m a weak wolf. The weakest in the pack. And everyone, aside from my family and King, have no problem reminding me of my place. Constantly... -
![Pack Forsaken by Jarica James]()
Pack Forsaken by Jarica James
I’m a lone wolf with a stalker on my tail… My name is Vanya Mason, and after an incident that left me broken, I chose exile from my pack rather than facing the harsh truth.The alpha made it very clear that my pack never cared about me, they cared about my submission. And that’s not the life I want to live.Especially alone...Categorized as:
shapeshifters werewolves paranormal suspense fantasy reverse harem contemporary new adult -
-
![Doubtful Dreaming by Elle Lincoln]()
Doubtful Dreaming by Elle Lincoln
Rated: 4.20 of 5 stars · 5 ratingsThe world falls apart around us. Screams fade into the night. No one is safe. And there is nothing we can do about it. Balor, Casseus, Mac, and Patrick. They have burrowed their way beneath my skin, consumed my heart, and now with Logan demand my soul... -
![Bound By Song by Crystal North]()
Bound By Song by Crystal North
Rated: 4.25 of 5 stars · 6 ratingsThree rockstar alphas. One omega in hiding. And a storm that’s about to blow everything apart… I’ve spent my whole life pretending I’m not an omega, drowning my true nature in industrial-strength neutralisers and strict isolation. No scents, no alphas, no complications – just me and my secrets, safe inside my fortress of lies.Until they show up at my door, bringing chaos in their wake...Categorized as:
werewolves shapeshifters omegaverse reverse harem fantasy fated-mates poly paranormal -
![Night Captive by Marissa Farrar, Skye Jones]()
Night Captive by Marissa Farrar, Skye Jones
Rated: 4.07 of 5 stars · 10 ratingsOne girl, five monsters, one hell of a ride.Taken from the Pit where she was raised, Aisha believes all vampires are horrifying… Then she finds herself in Dashiell’s possession.Powerful, handsome, and charismatic, Dashiell is not what she thought her master would be.His dark desires draw her into his world, and things heat up between them... -
![Destiny Found by Leah Steele]()
Destiny Found by Leah Steele
With more questions than I have answers to, I have to complete the bonds with my mates and find a way to protect my people. Time is running out before the truth of who I am will spread throughout my kingdom. Once he finds out, I know Silas will be coming after me. Deep down I know it‘ll come down to a final battle...Categorized as:
werewolves shapeshifters from hate to love reverse harem fantasy fated-mates paranormal magic -
![Embraced by D.M. Page]()
Embraced by D.M. Page
This is book three in the series and must be read after books one and two...Categorized as:
from hate to love shapeshifters reverse harem vampires fantasy fated-mates magic suspense -
![Carrie and the Dastardly Dragons by Ava Mason]()
Carrie and the Dastardly Dragons by Ava Mason
Rated: 4.00 of 5 stars · 8 ratingsFilthy, vicious, bitter, snob: words whispered in dark corners to describe The Elite. And they’ve Earned. Each. One. Carrie, once innocent and sweet. Now, gone through hell and back, just to survive. She’s on her way to a magical country she never new existed, packing her bags with positivity and optimism. She’s ready to take on the world of dragons to save the future for her pack... -
![Academy Of Beasts I: Shifter Romance by Becca Fanning]()
Academy Of Beasts I: Shifter Romance by Becca Fanning
Rated: 4.00 of 5 stars · 8 ratingsI lost everything in the fire, then I was whisked away to this Academy for Shifters. I don't know anyone, I don't like anyone, and I definitely can't trust anyone. And they don't even know that I have a secret... I'm not supposed to be here. I'm not a Shifter. I'm something else. All the while these five young men stare at me with primal hunger.. -
![Foreverland by Story Brooks]()
Foreverland by Story Brooks
Rated: 4.00 of 5 stars · 8 ratingsIt was a dream.Like a book filled with pirates and lost boys in a land beyond a star. A sneaky shadow that can never be caught.It was a dream, until it turned into a nightmare.I, Willow Haynes, am now the object stuck between two men and their war. They claim I’ve been here before. They claim I know them and have ran in these woods and fought on their ships... -
![Omega Vanished by Ava Gray]()
Omega Vanished by Ava Gray
Rated: 4.00 of 5 stars · 8 ratingsThere’s no way I would return to that hell…Not after it took every ounce of courage in me to escape my pack.And yet, when I saw those three sexy wolf shifters at my door, my knees buckled.I knew I was in trouble.They wanted me back, and they needed me to defeat the demons.And what did I want?I wanted Everett, the trained warrior and the future Alpha of the pack... -
![Wolf Child by Serena Akeroyd]()
Wolf Child by Serena Akeroyd
Rated: 3.93 of 5 stars · 31 ratingsSABINAI'm human.They're... not. I'm afraid. They're not. We're mated. We're whole.And together? We're going to change the Pack. Forever.Violence thrust me into this world. My past defined me.I was on the run. Constantly evading an adolescence loaded with heartbreak and fear, and then the end came.But with it? I found a new beginning.Three mates. Three Alphas. All mine.To have. To hold... -
-
![Prey to the Heart by Kristen Banet]()
Prey to the Heart by Kristen Banet
Rated: 3.92 of 5 stars · 14 ratingsShe sees them and wants to bolt. They see her and want to chase. Abigail Harris has spent her life searching for a place to belong. One phone call and a new job working for the Kingson Pride means she may have found it. Everything about Wild Junction calls to her and her inner animal. There's only one problem...Categorized as:
shapeshifters werewolves paranormal fantasy reverse harem poly contemporary length-medium -
![Chosen Omega by Kaytie Marie]()
Chosen Omega by Kaytie Marie
Rated: 3.88 of 5 stars · 8 ratingsThey say that everything in life happens for a reason, and after tonight, I may believe them. Afterall, I’ve always been a quiet, reserved girl who did exactly what she was supposed to do. I’ve been good and I never fight back.The universe decided I needed a new life though. That’s the only reason I can think that I was in the wrong place at the right time...Categorized as:
shapeshifters werewolves omegaverse reverse harem paranormal menage hurt-comfort friends to lovers -
![Heir of Blood and Moonlight by Lindsey Sparks]()
Heir of Blood and Moonlight by Lindsey Sparks
Rated: 3.83 of 5 stars · 6 ratingsSeven immortals. One queen. A love to die for. I'm the last of my kind–the last living female vampire. The only one left to save my race from extinction. No pressure, right?For three decades, I’ve been on the run, living as a human librarian and hiding from the shifters who slaughtered my family when I was a kid... -
![Real Alphas Mate by C.R. Jane, Mila Young]()
Real Alphas Mate by C.R. Jane, Mila Young
Syn is the girl no one wanted…And now, they’ll light the world on fire to claim herSyn never believed in fairy tales until she met the three men who stole her from her fated mate. They may be a dark fairy tale, but every touch, every kiss, every whisper seals their bond. She now calls them her alphas…her future... -
![Hunted by Wolves by Rhea Watson]()
Hunted by Wolves by Rhea Watson
Rated: 3.80 of 5 stars · 10 ratingsThree alphas forced to play nice for the sake of their mate—fated to a she-wolf kissed by the divine and cursed with gold. All my life, I wanted a family.Nothing fancy… Just someone to call my own, to love and respect me.A true partner.Somehow, fate decided I deserved three such mates. Sure, we’re a mess right now. We struggle. We argue. We fail to connect. But nothing and no one is born perfect... -
![The Wolf Queen by Sam Hall]()
The Wolf Queen by Sam Hall
The Reaver king tried to take everything from me. And almost managed to achieve his goals. But I'm fighting back. That takes me into the hostile lands of my birth, where everyone hates what I have become. Or do they? Either way there's only one way out of this. I have to become the queen everyone says I am, to lead both of our people out of this mess...
Fantastic book recommendations by romance book lovers for romance book lovers.
Find out more about romance.io.
Find out more about romance.io.
Get recommendations by genres & tropes
Use the romance book finder to mix and match over 100 content keywords to find the books that match your preferences
Or - use our amazing romance book finder to get recommendations based on your favorite content tropes and themes. Mix and match at will.
