Books like 'Puck Your Neighbor'
Readers who enjoyed Puck Your Neighbor by Sara Vincent also liked the following books featuring the same tropes, story themes, relationship dynamics and character types.
contemporary poly (3+ people) reverse harem young adult omegaverse sports hockey athletes hurt-comfort fated-mates
-
First Days by C.L. Stone
Sang Sorenson used to be the invisible girl in class. As a new student to Ashley Waters High School, Sang hopes that her new friends will be the change she’s been craving and will make fitting in a breeze. But Academy students aren’t there to take it easy. The high school is overcrowded and rife with violence... -
![Forgiveness and Permission by C.L. Stone]()
Forgiveness and Permission by C.L. Stone
Sang Sorenson’s abusive mother is secure in a hospital, and her father has vanished to a new family of his own, leaving Sang and her sister to fend for themselves. Sang is hanging by a thread, and her only hope is a group of boys she feels she barely knows. She’s never really alone. The Academy team has stepped in, promising to protect and care for Sang... -
![]()
![]()
Sponsored links / Remove ads -
![Love's Cruel Redemption by C.L. Stone]()
Love's Cruel Redemption by C.L. Stone
From USA TODAY Bestselling Author, C. L. Stone, read Love's Cruel Redemption, the much-anticipated twelfth book in The Academy Ghost Bird Series. Sang’s life was on pause after the dramatic break with her real family. Now she’s back in the game, returning to Ashley Waters to appear like a normal student. However, returning to school hasn’t made her life any easier... -
![Trials and Tiaras by Heather Long]()
Trials and Tiaras by Heather Long
It’s not true. It can’t be. Four DNA tests. Only one positive. The man claiming to be my father is quite literally the worst option imaginable. This isn’t happening to me. For the first time in my life, I know who I am and where I want to be and, in the blink of an eye, everything is spinning so utterly out of control. I thought the fight with Maddy was the worst thing I faced. It’s not... -
-
![Broken Trust by R.A. Smyth]()
Broken Trust by R.A. Smyth
My name is Hadley Parker, and today is the first day of the rest of my life. Today I start school at Pacific Prep. This is my new lease on life, and I won’t be wasting it. I need this, now, more than ever. I need the education, the promise of a future that I wouldn’t get anywhere else. These rich kids don’t like me though. When Hawk Davenport decides he doesn’t want me here, his friends back him... -
![Claim & Don't Tell by Rory Miles]()
Claim & Don't Tell by Rory Miles
In my world, nothing is more important than finding a pack that’s the perfect scent match. But what happens when your match also happens to be your step-brothers? Welcome to my personal hell. My name is Quinn and I can never have the pack that’s meant for me. An unexpected turn of events has me out of a job and my apartment in the same week...Categorized as:
omegaverse tortured heroine creative-anatomy fated-mates anal sex hurt-comfort m-f-m contemporary -
![Sugar Baby by Harley Madison]()
Sugar Baby by Harley Madison
Four Daddy Doms. Three hours. Ten Thousand Dollars. Who wouldn’t say yes to that? I’m not going to bore you with my tragic backstory, because fuck that. I worked my ass off for the scholarships I have and the first day of the rest of my life is only four days away. My goal? Graduate college, get my CPA, and become an accountant...Categorized as:
caretaking m-f-m m-f independent heroine tortured heroine age difference contemporary bdsm -
![Saving Memphis by Bre Rose]()
Saving Memphis by Bre Rose
Ashlynn. I thought by running he wouldn’t find me, and I could protect the ones I loved. How wrong was I. He found me and the threats continued. I thought this time was different, I had the guys, who swore to protect me. What we never suspected was that there was also a threat closer than we knew. Aiding him in his desire to take me... -
![Pyxis by Autumn Reed, Julia Clarke]()
Pyxis by Autumn Reed, Julia Clarke
Rated: 4.19 of 5 stars · 23 ratingsHaley Jones already thought her life was complicated, but after the events of the gala, she is in desperate need of direction—if only there was a compass for locating her missing dad or navigating relationships. Despite her efforts to gain independence and forge her own identity, she still feels adrift in her new life... -
![Rules, Roses, and Rivals: The What If Edition by Heather Long]()
Rules, Roses, and Rivals: The What If Edition by Heather Long
What if the girl with the plan met the boy who was never part of it—just a little too soon? When it comes to yearbook fame, my class rank might earn me a line or two—but not much else. I don’t wear makeup, style my hair, or bother with the popularity game. I’ve made it through high school with decent grades, minimal drama, and a reputation I didn’t even know I untouchable...Categorized as:
hurt-comfort m-f-m independent heroine sunny hero athletes reverse harem new adult poly -
![Silent Desires by Shona Knight]()
Silent Desires by Shona Knight
For the past 11 years, Mina has remained silent for fear of her mother’s constant abuse. But when she’s suddenly let out of the locked basement to attend high school, a whole new set of fears threatens to suffocate her. Stepping into the outside world is terrifying. The fear of speaking, of having a panic attack, of standing out in any way, looms over her... -
![Keys and Kisses by Heather Long]()
Keys and Kisses by Heather Long
When the year started, I had one goal—make my AP classes count and keep my grades up. Both my focus and my grades started wobbling. Dating my best friends came with perks like hugs, kisses, and invitations to dances, but it also came with cons in the form of vindictive posts, hate mail, and vandalism of my car. I asked if it could get any worse, and I guess I got my answer. My college essays suck... -
![A Game of Choice by Alisha Williams]()
A Game of Choice by Alisha Williams
Tobias Monroe has never been just a step-brother to me. From the moment we met as little kids, he’s been my everything. My best friend, my protector, the person I could always rely on for anything. As the years went on, our relationship developed into something more, something deeper than what was expected of us... -
![Foul Line by E.M. Moore]()
Foul Line by E.M. Moore
The Ballers may have the upper hand at RHS. I underestimated them, their cruelty, their ability to look the other way when something hits them over the head, but camp is a whole other story. Their asses are mine. Foul Line is a reverse harem high school bully romance novel. It's the second book in The Ballers of Rockport High series. -
-
![Dare You To Love Me by Serena Akeroyd]()
Dare You To Love Me by Serena Akeroyd
Jessa loves Sam, as does Drew. And Sam? Well. .. That's where things get complicated. There's a new boy in town. Troubled teen, Max, has been brought into the elite academy of HawkRidge High School by his father, a General in the Armed Forces. On his first day, he meets Jessa and she brings him into the fold of the captain of the football team, Sam, and the quarterback, Drew...Categorized as:
sports possessive hero athletes young adult new adult contemporary reverse harem poly -
![Sacrifice by Caitlyn Dare]()
Sacrifice by Caitlyn Dare
The next installment in the dark romance series from the bestselling author of the Rebels at Sterling Prep series…. Rhett Savage, Dane Stray, and Wesley Noble. I shouldn’t want them. But I do—all of them. They each give me something I need. Challenge. Love. Comfort... -
![Draco by Autumn Reed, Julia Clarke]()
Draco by Autumn Reed, Julia Clarke
Rated: 4.01 of 5 stars · 28 ratingsIt’s been two weeks since Haley Jones turned eighteen and her life was turned upside down. While searching for her dad, Haley is adjusting to life in Santa Cruz with a new job and friends. Surrounded by six dangerously appealing guys, she’s still trying to figure out just who Liam, Knox, Ethan, Chase, Theo, and Jackson are and what they do... -
![Defiant Princess by Callie Rose]()
Defiant Princess by Callie Rose
They called me trash. They called me whore. They called me so much worse. They told me I didn’t belong in their world, and you know what? Maybe they were right. But I can’t just let this go. I’m still a Hildebrand, after all, and I’ve only just begun to scratch the surface of what that legacy means. There are secrets buried in Roseland, and I’m determined to dig them up...Categorized as:
sports tortured heroine possessive hero m-f new adult contemporary young adult from hate to love -
![Crowned Crew: Heights POVs & Stories (The Heights Crew) by E.M. Moore]()
Crowned Crew: Heights POVs & Stories (The Heights Crew) by E.M. Moore
Rated: 4.29 of 5 stars · 12 ratingsThe Crew is back! Delve inside the world of the Heights Crew with stories of how Kyla’s sexy, dangerous guys—Johnny, Brawler, Oscar, and Magnum—ended up in the Crew. Then, read a variety of scenes from all four books from the guys’ perspective... -
![Dare You To Keep Me by Serena Akeroyd]()
Dare You To Keep Me by Serena Akeroyd
Rated: 4.50 of 5 stars · 6 ratingsShe dared to love them, but can she keep them? Choices. .. Drew had many of them, but one bad decision has put his health and his future in jeopardy. With those choices coming back to bite him in the ass, Drew's up a certain creek without a paddle...Categorized as:
sports possessive hero young adult new adult contemporary length-short queer bisexual -
![Smile Like You Mean It by Willow Hadley]()
Smile Like You Mean It by Willow Hadley
After Charlotte’s father died, her mother changed. She became cold and distant, and Charlotte slowly withdrew into herself. She spent years feeling lonely and insignificant, and rarely spoke more than a few words to anyone. One night, after a traumatic incident instigated by her mother, Charlotte is arrested and taken to juvie... -
![Sever by Caitlyn Dare]()
Sever by Caitlyn Dare
Rated: 4.03 of 5 stars · 23 ratingsSadie, Rhett, Dane, and Wes are back one more time. Will they find their HEA or are there too many obstacles against them? SEVER is a full length dark enemies-to-lovers/bully romance. This is a why choose novel, meaning the main character has more than one love interest. It is book two in the series and must be read after the first three books in the Savage Falls MC series.Categorized as:
sports m-f-m new adult contemporary young adult reverse harem from hate to love abuse -
![Reign of Psychos by Ava Summers]()
Reign of Psychos by Ava Summers
Leaving might break us apart, but staying will be the death of us all. My heart is shattered. Just as I let my walls down and allowed my five broken princes in, I’m forced to push them away again. Milo, my sweet nerd. Landon, my future husband. Or so he thinks. Kyril, my fierce protector. Cassian, the man who gave up everything for me. And Dario, my first love...Categorized as:
independent heroine tortured heroine possessive hero sunny hero anal sex m-f-m m-f insta-love -
![Sparrowood Academy: Book 2 by Angel Lawson]()
Sparrowood Academy: Book 2 by Angel Lawson
Rated: 4.14 of 5 stars · 17 ratings -
-
![Breathe Me by C.R. Jane, Ivy Fox]()
Breathe Me by C.R. Jane, Ivy Fox
They say that true love only comes once in a lifetime. In my case, they were wrong. I gave my heart away three times. To the blue eyed sensitive soul, who read poetry when he thought no one was looking. To the green eyed jock, who made you laugh as hard as he made you cry. And to the dark eyed boy, whose dark heart only ever beat for me. They were my everything, until suddenly they weren’t... -
![Leap of Faith by Lucy Smoke]()
Leap of Faith by Lucy Smoke
Rated: 4.14 of 5 stars · 16 ratingsThe Iris Boys crash landed into my life and changed everything in it. Now, I’m surrounded by four incredible men - five, if the last one will ever fully open up to me. Never in a million years did I think I’d fall in love. Much less with more than one man. But that’s what I did. I’m in love with the Iris Boys. They are my confidantes. My friends. My closest allies...Categorized as:
m-f reverse harem contemporary new adult menage virgin heroine high-school young adult -
![Remember Me This Way by C.R. Jane]()
Remember Me This Way by C.R. Jane
The Sound of Us are supernovas in the sky and I’ve been following their light from the moment we met. It was easy to get wrapped in them, for me to feel like I wasn’t a real person unless I was in their presence, helping them, loving them. Since Gentry’s attack we haven’t been the same, and I’m afraid that the magic we had been working so hard to build may be gone forever...Categorized as:
m-f caretaking hurt-comfort shy heroine tortured heroine sunny hero possessive hero new adult -
![Remember You This Way by C.R. Jane]()
Remember You This Way by C.R. Jane
Can you ever really start over? It’s the question that follows Ariana now that she’s reunited with the boys from the Sound of Us. Haunted by the past and her hopefully soon to be ex-husband, Ari is dragged along as the band continues its world tour. Touring the world together. .. it’s what they all used to dream about. Sold out stadiums and screaming fans, it’s everything anyone would want...Categorized as:
possessive hero m-f shy heroine tortured heroine young adult new adult contemporary reverse harem -
![In Pieces by K.G. Reuss]()
In Pieces by K.G. Reuss
Nothing says I love you like murder. Seeing their lifeless bodies nearly killed us. Knowing some monster harmed those we loved created a whole new set of worries. In the wake of all the madness, we need to stay focused. With revenge warranted, we must bide our time. Good things come to those who wait, after all... -
![Lads & Lattes by A.J. Macey]()
Lads & Lattes by A.J. Macey
Rated: 4.40 of 5 stars · 5 ratingsEmma’s to-do list:. 1- dump Tyler. 2- survive new school. 3- rock senior year. My life was as perfect as a teenage girl could hope it would be; friends, boyfriend, straight-A student, loving parents, and all that jazz. Until my entire world comes crashing down...Categorized as:
m-f young adult new adult contemporary reverse harem poly length-short first-in-series -
![Sacred by Caitlyn Dare]()
Sacred by Caitlyn Dare
Rated: 4.04 of 5 stars · 25 ratingsWelcome to Savage Falls. .. A brand new dark reverse harem bully romance trilogy from bestselling author Caitlyn Dare, coming this summer! Two dirty-talking tattooed bikers, a pretty boy football player with secrets, and the MC princess who will bring them to their knees. .. Are you ready for a SAVAGE summer? -
![Starlee's Home by Angel Lawson]()
Starlee's Home by Angel Lawson
Starlee ran back to Lee Vines for a taste of freedom. She found that, family and love. But an innocent night away brings unwanted attention to Sierra's foster home and Starlee plays an unwilling part in sending George and Charlie back to their once abusive father. Not only that Sierra forces her to stay away from Dexter and Jake... -
![Twisted Kings by Ava Summers]()
Twisted Kings by Ava Summers
Dario promised to protect me from the evil monsters that lurked in the dark. Only it was all a pretty lie. After he vanished, I never expected to see Dario again. But fate had other ideas. The sweet, kind-hearted boy I once loved has grown into a dangerously sinful man with muscles, tattoos, and vengeance in his heart. I have no clue what Dario’s problem is... -
![Remember Us This Way by C.R. Jane]()
Remember Us This Way by C.R. Jane
They are idols to millions worldwide. I hear their names whispered in the hallways and blasted through the radio. Their faces are never far from the television screen, tormenting me with images of what I gave up. To everyone else, they're unattainable rockstars, the music gods who make up The Sound of Us. But to me? They'll always be the boys I lost...Categorized as:
m-f shy heroine tortured heroine possessive hero sunny hero young adult new adult contemporary -
-
![Holding On To Heaven by Angel Lawson]()
Holding On To Heaven by Angel Lawson
Rated: 4.14 of 5 stars · 14 ratingsKeep Calm and Survive High School. That was my motto. It was easier with the Allendale Four by my side and with college on the horizon, I had no doubt we'd have the best time of our lives. No parents. No rules. Lots of freedom. Except even with the bullies that harassed me out of the picture the past is hard to shake. New obstacles emerge, along with old hang-ups and bad habits... -
![Triple Option Play by K.L. Coburn]()
Triple Option Play by K.L. Coburn
Football? No, thanks. Life isn’t great, but I’m managing. I just have to finish this last year of high school while avoiding my bully and without embarrassing myself in front of my crush. Easily done! But when my mother’s mental health takes a turn for the worse, I find myself living with my dad and having to change schools...Categorized as:
sports m-f reverse harem high-school contemporary new adult friends to lovers age difference -
![Trust by Scarlett Haven]()
Trust by Scarlett Haven
Rated: 4.13 of 5 stars · 8 ratingsKidnapped in the middle of the night. Kept in a cell with no explanation from my kidnappers. All I can do is wait. The guys will rescue me eventually, right? If they know where I am. Or, maybe…. Maybe it’s time to rescue myself. Trust is the fourth book in The Zara Chronicles Series...Categorized as:
insta-love reverse harem contemporary young adult high-school love triangle mystery men in uniform -
![Starlee's Turn by Angel Lawson]()
Starlee's Turn by Angel Lawson
After speaking up for Dexter and then yanked from the only place she's ever felt at home, Starlee is lost. Lost without George to make her laugh. Lost without Jake's strong arms. Lost without Charlie's calming presence. Lost without Dexter's intensity and determination. No one is okay with this situation. No one is willing to give up. Not Starlee and certainly not the Wayward Sons.Categorized as:
m-f reverse harem contemporary young adult high-school menage new adult friends to lovers -
![Kings of Mercia Academy 1-4 by Sofia Daniel]()
Kings of Mercia Academy 1-4 by Sofia Daniel
Rated: 4.17 of 5 stars · 6 ratingsBritish boarding schools aren't for the weak. According to the Kings of Mercia Academy. .. they aren't for Americans, either. Blake, Edward, and Henry rule my new school. They're aristocratic. Old money. Brutal as hell. They'll do whatever it takes to break my spirit and make me leave. If I survive Mercia, I'll get a free ride to college. My future will be set. My past will be forgotten... -
![The Anti-Bullies by KT Strange]()
The Anti-Bullies by KT Strange
Rated: 4.17 of 5 stars · 6 ratingsThis heated academy romance features Haisley, Asher, Benji, Jace, and Ethan, and is the first in a new series by internationally bestselling author, KT Strange. Happy endings guaranteed, and no love triangles here. Enjoy all the guys! I just wanted to be normal. But when your dad is a famous film director, everyone follows your every move... -
![Heirs of Havoc by L.J. Woods]()
Heirs of Havoc by L.J. Woods
Rated: 4.17 of 5 stars · 6 ratingsFour beautiful, brutal enemies. One wealthy university. Capturing me is their goal. Bullying is their tactic. Tough luck, Bratva bastards. This mafia princess never bows. A small town. A Christian university. Church on Sundays. The good girl is the simplest of covers. Correction: was the simplest of covers. It all comes crashing down when the Bratva re-enters my life... -
![Safe Haven Academy: The Complete Series by E.M. Moore]()
Safe Haven Academy: The Complete Series by E.M. Moore
Rated: 4.17 of 5 stars · 6 ratingsINCLUDES NEVER-BEFORE-SEEN BONUS CONTENT. Macie Davenport’s life is over. The girl who has everything is reduced to an empty black hole of nothing they call Safe Haven Academy. It’s where bad souls go for reform, but end up getting worse until they’re shipped out to another “sheltered place” with an equally uninspired name... -
![Saint View Rebels by Elle Thorpe]()
Saint View Rebels by Elle Thorpe
Three men destroyed her. Three new men will stand beside her when she gets her revenge. Rebel's story is coming in the Saint View Rebels series. This is a reverse harem, dark romance series. If you loved Saint View Prison, and Saint View Psychos, get ready for more. This release date is temporary and will be brought forward.Categorized as:
m-f anal sex independent heroine tortured heroine contemporary suspense m-m bisexual -
![Busted Dreams by Blake Blessing]()
Busted Dreams by Blake Blessing
Rated: 4.20 of 5 stars · 5 ratingsSmall town. Broken homes. Big dreams. Finally. Finally, life seems like it’s on the track I want it to be on. I had good friends that really care about me as a person, not me the pastor’s daughter. Good memories of senior year, maybe even good enough to overcloud Mother Dearest. There are even some new experiences that I blush just thinking about. But the guys? They want to get out too... -
-
![Well That Happened: A Why Choose Hockey Romance by Reese Calloway]()
Well That Happened: A Why Choose Hockey Romance by Reese Calloway
My name is Rilee Jameson, and all I want is to survive nursing school, keep my head down, and make it to graduation. Instead? My apartment floods. And I end up crashing with three hockey players. Now, I’m living in a testosterone-soaked disaster zone filled with a suspicious number of shirtless abs and very questionable house rules...Categorized as:
sports m-f-m anal sex hockey independent heroine possessive hero sunny hero athletes -
![Brittle Heart by Blake Black]()
Brittle Heart by Blake Black
My life has never been perfect. In fact, it’s anything but. When my parents passed away in a car accident, I had to take care of my little sister. I supported us both as I tried to finish college and work two jobs. It’s hard to focus on my life when I have to keep myself together for someone else... -
![The Fake Date Agreement by Ember L. Nicole]()
The Fake Date Agreement by Ember L. Nicole
Fake dating three hockey players to get back at my cheating ex? Win. A relationship that is not real, will never be real, and can't possibly last? Surprisingly perfect. Everyone cheers when a guy kisses his date for the kiss cam. Except me. See that guy was my boyfriend. Emphasis on was... -
![Rich Boys Poor Girl by Mia Belle]()
Rich Boys Poor Girl by Mia Belle
Rated: 4.00 of 5 stars · 10 ratingsHis name is Declan Worthington. Heir to a multi-billion dollar empire. Arrogant, self-absorbed, jerk. And I saved his life. In gratitude for my heroic act, his father offers me a full ride to Queenswood Academy, the top high school in the country. Where only the exclusive rich kids attend. I don’t belong there. I know it, everyone knows it...Categorized as:
m-f contemporary young adult reverse harem cruel hero poor heroine poly length-medium -
![Scent of Home by Tea Ravine]()
Scent of Home by Tea Ravine
When it Raines it pours and I’m on the bus to nowhere with a dream that shouldn’t exist. On the bus to nowhere I meet Locke Raines who is as mysterious as he is appealing. He looks familiar yet hoards secrets and pain and the only promise he’ll commit to, is that this is a one time thing...Categorized as:
omegaverse fated-mates anal sex m-f possessive hero sunny hero independent heroine insta-love -
![Clash by K. Walker]()
Clash by K. Walker
Rated: 3.98 of 5 stars · 13 ratingsThings were never supposed to end this way. I didn't have plans to fall for the hottest guy in school and I certainly didn't think he would dump my ass in front of everyone either with no explanation. Nada! Weeks go by as I tend to my broken heart. Fine, I say. I'm so over him...
Fantastic book recommendations by romance book lovers for romance book lovers.
Find out more about romance.io.
Find out more about romance.io.
Get recommendations by genres & tropes
Use the romance book finder to mix and match over 100 content keywords to find the books that match your preferences
Or - use our amazing romance book finder to get recommendations based on your favorite content tropes and themes. Mix and match at will.
