Books like 'Forever Theirs'
Readers who enjoyed Forever Theirs by Kennedy L. Mitchell also liked the following books featuring the same tropes, story themes, relationship dynamics and character types.
contemporary poly (3+ people) menage mystery suspense new adult military grumpy sunshine caretaking masc-dom
-
Pucking Ever After: Volume 1 by Emily Rath
From the Amazon Bestselling Jacksonville Rays Hockey Series comes a Happily Ever After novella full of spice, laughter, and so much love. Curious to know what happened to Rachel and the guys after that fateful hockey game in LA? PUCKING EVER VOL 1 provides readers with a six-chapter peek into the future of Team Price. Bonus content in this volume spans four years after the end of PUCKING AROUND...Categorized as:
sunny hero breeding cheerful heroine anal sex praise-kink menage double-penetration m-f-m -
![Parts of Us by Cara Dee]()
Parts of Us by Cara Dee
The Game Series, #14 | Doll Parts Sequel | MMMM | M/s | DD/lb | Hurt/Comfort. Grab your favorite stuffie and join Cam, Lucian, KC, and Noa as they jump over life’s hurdles together with their kinky friends as support. Brat shenanigans are to be expected, starting with an Easter Egg Hunt—that has a twist—and continue until they’re off on their Caribbean cruise...Categorized as:
menage found-family spanking double-penetration grumpy sunshine caretaking masc-dom anal sex -
![]()
![]()
Sponsored links / Remove ads -
![Rocker by Marie James]()
Rocker by Marie James
Life can change in the blink of an eye. As a member of the Cerberus MC, an elite organization that specializes In the rescue and recovery of trafficked women, I’ve seen it happen more than once. I’ve witnessed how easily a family can be torn apart from a single bad choice. We’ve been too late before, and have to live with the guilt of how a few hours would’ve changed everything... -
![Strings by Bea Paige]()
Strings by Bea Paige
Rated: 4.55 of 5 stars · 14 ratingsWith Ivan I found acceptance. With Anton, home in the dark. With Erik, I fear my undoing…. Erik Hadley is a gifted violinist with a dark past and an even more troubled soul. His only place of safety, a glass room built to protect others from his violent outbursts. But it’s nothing more than a prison, and I have every intention of setting him free. It won’t be easy...Categorized as:
military suspense found-family contemporary reverse harem poly length-medium audiobook -
-
![Pucker Factor by Giulia Lagomarsino]()
Pucker Factor by Giulia Lagomarsino
Rated: 4.62 of 5 stars · 10 ratingsWhat the hell just happened? Today has been a bad combination of a Seinfeld episode and Lethal Weapon. Bombs, crazy people, and a woman who can’t stop making friends with the people trying to kill her. I’m not sure what to make of this beautiful disaster. Other than the fact that I’m insanely attracted to her. And one other small problem. I’ve already slept with her... -
![Quintessence: The Boxset 1-3 by Serena Akeroyd]()
Quintessence: The Boxset 1-3 by Serena Akeroyd
Rated: 4.67 of 5 stars · 9 ratingsWhen Sascha heads for a job interview, she has no idea that her life is about to change. There's more at stake than just a job here. With five sexy geniuses as her new bosses, she has two choices. Keep things platonic or make things interesting. .. Find out what her decision is in Quintessence: The Boxset. Books 1-3 are available in this omnibus edition for the first time... -
![Permanently Pucked by Emma Foxx]()
Permanently Pucked by Emma Foxx
Chicago Racketeers book four. I don’t do casual hookups. Never have. Not even with the three supposed-to-be one-night stands I had six months ago. They all turned into the loves of my life. But now I know exactly what to do with the three hot guys I met at that serendipitous hockey game. Love them. Forever. At least that’s the plan...Categorized as:
grumpy sunshine found-family new adult anal sex double-penetration spanking m-f-m cheerful heroine -
![The Accidental Siren by Lexi Blake, Sophie Oak]()
The Accidental Siren by Lexi Blake, Sophie Oak
Joshua Barnes-Fleetwood is the prince of Willow Fork, Texas, but not all is right with his world. He’s the heir to a multimillion-dollar company, has a family he adores, and his best friend at his side. He can’t figure out what is missing until Nicole takes a job at Christa’s Café. The pretty waitress is a mystery he needs to solve... -
![Lies Untold by Lexie Winston]()
Lies Untold by Lexie Winston
Rated: 4.49 of 5 stars · 11 ratingsTori and Gio are doing everything they can to solidify their positions as a badass mafia family. But a traitor still lurks within the ranks and they need to find out who it is before the threat to their lives becomes a reality. Tori gets a chance to enact revenge against Stacey, but she's playing the long game... -
![Theirs to Hunt : Girls Like Us - Book One by Salem Hurley]()
Theirs to Hunt : Girls Like Us - Book One by Salem Hurley
Theirs to Hunt. Girls Like Us, Book One. By Salem Hurley. Grayson and Brooks wanted her before the hunt even started. One night with Reagan Marks didn’t derail their plan—. It sealed it. She was never prey. She was the one they’d been waiting for. Smart. Loyal. Too strong for her own good. Now she’s caught between two obsessed men who will rewrite every rule to claim her. But Reagan doesn’t run... -
![Wayward by Ellie Pond]()
Wayward by Ellie Pond
We thought escaping the island meant we were finally safe. We were wrong. Rescued by the son of the man who wants us dead, we're trapped in a deadly game of cat and mouse across three continents. Our rescuer claims he's protecting us from his father's wrath, but his idea of protection feels a lot like a gilded cage... -
![Only After by Emily Klepp]()
Only After by Emily Klepp
Rated: 4.71 of 5 stars · 7 ratingsThis is the 2nd book in The Saviors Duet. Please ensure you have read "Until Then" before beginning this. They want to break me, watch me surrender. Don’t they know I’m stronger now? I won’t let them take my freedom. When my knight in shining armor becomes my reason for breathing, no one will ever make me bow to them again. No one except my knight... -
![Three Ways to Mend a Broken Heart by Trilina Pucci]()
Three Ways to Mend a Broken Heart by Trilina Pucci
Imagine dating a guy for six months, and then one night, you make him dinner, recreating your first date so you can say “I love you” for the first time. Romantic, right? No. Because when you dress up as dessert, he tells you he’d rather be a party of one. So now, you’re crying in your whipped cream boobs, drinking a bottle of tequila, and debating on cutting bangs... -
![Silver Fox Firefighters Next Door by Summer Haze]()
Silver Fox Firefighters Next Door by Summer Haze
Stuck with a glued dildo, I never expected my firefighters neighbors to be the rescue team—and my new obsession. Moving back to Harmony Valley was supposed to be about helping Grandpa and editing romance novels. Instead, it's about Nash, Tate, and Aiden—three alpha firefighters who are too tempting to ignore...Categorized as:
new adult anal sex spanking double-penetration menage m-f-m disabilities and marks found-family -
-
![Uncharted by Ellie Pond]()
Uncharted by Ellie Pond
After months stranded on our island paradise, we've built something beautiful—a home, a family, a love I never thought possible. The real world keeps creeping closer and it's not bringing rescue with it. Pirates haunt the horizon threatening everything we've built. And there are secrets about the yacht’s sabotage that point to someone wanting us dead...Categorized as:
m-f-m double-penetration anal sex suspense menage found-family cheerful heroine competent heroine -
![Brie's Denver Desires by Red Phoenix]()
Brie's Denver Desires by Red Phoenix
Rated: 4.43 of 5 stars · 11 ratingsSubmissive in Love #2 (The Brie series continues! ). Brie Bennett is not prepared for the surprises and delights that await her in Denver. An unexpected encounter uncovers Master Anderson's past, while a sweet reunion with Baron complements the provocative scene she must film with Ms. Clark. She also discovers that Lea has a mysterious new friend - a person Brie was fated to meet... -
![Sweet Little Spies by Lexi Blake]()
Sweet Little Spies by Lexi Blake
Since he was a kid, Aidan O’Donnell has known two things about the world. Tristan is his best friend, and Carys is the love of his life. Sharing her with Tristan was oddly easy. They both loved her deeply, and they never cared what anyone else thought. They were a team and everything was wonderful. Until the day it ended. Carys Taggart has spent the last year and a half of her life living a lie... -
![Neighbors with Benefits by Cassie Cole, Andi Eloise]()
Neighbors with Benefits by Cassie Cole, Andi Eloise
Rated: 4.22 of 5 stars · 19 ratingsIt's a bad idea to hook up with the three guys next door. No matter how tall, handsome, and charismatic they might be. But when I move in next to Aiden, Sebastian, and Dante? Nobody's willpower is that strong. The three Romeos travel for work, which means one of them is always out of town. Sharing me is the perfect solution. Although Dante's a lot more possessive than the other two…... -
![Beast Brothers 3 by Stephanie Brother]()
Beast Brothers 3 by Stephanie Brother
After I spot the sexiest man I’ve ever seen -- tall, ripped, tattooed, and impossibly gorgeous -- I spend weeks fantasizing about all the dirty, dirty things he could do to me. When we finally meet, I’m ready for the hottest one-night fling ever -- until he introduces me to his twin brother! Unlike my besties, I’ve always thought two men were too much trouble... -
![Unmoored by Ellie Pond]()
Unmoored by Ellie Pond
These men have become my world, my family, my everything. We survived the shipwreck. We survived the pirates. But the island isn't done testing us yet. The island itself holds deadly secrets that could change everything we thought we knew about this place—and each other. Some mysteries are meant to stay buried. Some islands hold more than treasure...Categorized as:
suspense mystery double-penetration anal sex found-family cheerful heroine sweet-hero sunny hero -
![Auction Me by Ivy Smoak]()
Auction Me by Ivy Smoak
Rated: 4.19 of 5 stars · 21 ratingsMy bestie has been kidnapped by a mafia boss. And now he’s going to auction her virginity. The most powerful, handsome men from all over the world have flown in to bid on her tonight. But I’m going to save her. It won’t be easy. I have to disable the security cameras, break into the mafia boss’s private suite on the top floor of the hotel, and then somehow get back out... -
![Walker by LeAnn Ashers]()
Walker by LeAnn Ashers
Rated: 4.36 of 5 stars · 10 ratingsSUMMER. All it took was one night for my past and my present to collide headfirst. Consumed by work, I was letting life pass me by. I had reached a point where I found myself merely existing, so I decided to go out and have some fun with my friend, Lynn. That night brought me face to face with the two men that would become my everything—Walker and Darren... -
![Dirty Puckers by Mila Wilde]()
Dirty Puckers by Mila Wilde
The night my husband, soon to be ex, dares me to f*ck his best friends in exchange for the divorce I want, I think it’s going to be the end. The end of us. The end of me. But it isn’t. It’s the beginning of something I can’t undo. Because Colt Andersson isn’t just my husband. He’s the captain of the Milwaukee Fury, the man every fan worships, the one who wears control like a second skin...Categorized as:
double-penetration anal sex masc-dom praise-kink found-family fetish caretaking menage -
![Four Real by Stephanie Brother]()
Four Real by Stephanie Brother
Twenty-four and never been kissed. Twenty-four and never been … anything else. After the most embarrassing moment of my life (a public and very unexpected "O" while riding on Logan Evans' shoulders! ), the Evans brothers offer to take me on practice dates so I can get some experience with the opposite sex. I should have known it was a terrible idea...Categorized as:
new adult anal sex double-penetration m-f-m cheerful heroine sunny hero sweet-hero contemporary -
-
![Don't Shoot the Messenger by Samantha A. Cole]()
Don't Shoot the Messenger by Samantha A. Cole
Rated: 4.38 of 5 stars · 8 ratingsBlair lost the love of her life when her fiancé, and father to their unborn child, went missing and was presumed dead. Returning to Hazard Falls, she must plan for her baby’s future without Grant by her side... -
![Shaw by M. Tasia]()
Shaw by M. Tasia
Rated: 4.38 of 5 stars · 8 ratingsSNEAK ATTACK. A child shouldn't know the games adults play, but since Shaw's parents hadn't shielded him from their "proclivities" his take on love and intimacy was forever skewed. Fast-forward to his life after being a Navy SEAL, and although he now has the time, Shaw still hasn't found a reason to engage in more than temporary arrangements... -
![Twisted Legacy by Dakota Lee]()
Twisted Legacy by Dakota Lee
Rated: 4.50 of 5 stars · 6 ratingsI woke up in an unfamiliar room, broken and bruised, with no memory of how I got hurt. I’m grateful LJ and Wolfe were there to nurse me back to health. Everything’s different when I get back to school. The Dean covered up the truth about Mayhem Night. Called it a sorority prank gone wrong. That won’t stop me from getting answers. Based on our history, The Trium is at the top of my suspect list... -
![Stolen Beauty by Isabel Jolie]()
Stolen Beauty by Isabel Jolie
Rated: 4.50 of 5 stars · 6 ratingsHer sister's missing. There's a killer on her trail. And falling for the man sworn to protect her is not an option. Sage Watson, a heart transplant survivor, is no stranger to fighting for her life. But now an armed intruder is hunting her, and her sister--a scientist researching overseas--has vanished without a trace... -
![Claimed by Her Daddies by Laylah Roberts]()
Claimed by Her Daddies by Laylah Roberts
Will it be rags to riches? Or fairytale to nightmare? They were the Princes of Escana. Seductive. Powerful. Dominant. Her boss. Her friend. Her lover. Her protector. Everyone wanted a piece of them. She just wanted to have their love. To be their baby girl. Their everything. But there is someone who is determined to make sure that never happens . . . and that person just might get their way...Categorized as:
suspense grumpy sunshine caretaking anal sex spanking fetish working class heroine sunny hero -
![Cloud 9 by Stephanie Brother, Cosmic Designs]()
Cloud 9 by Stephanie Brother, Cosmic Designs
My vacation Down Under is a bust until a bar-load of Aussie men offer to take me to Cloud 9! When my best friend shacks up with eight gorgeous tattoo artists, I decide it’s time to shake up my life. A ticket to Australia seems like a perfect way to find some desperately needed fun and leave behind the black cloud hanging over me... -
![The Proximity Effect by Maya Nicole]()
The Proximity Effect by Maya Nicole
Getting stuck in a snowdrift and watching my red thong take flight into a pine tree was not how I imagined starting my honeymoon. Then again, I also hadn't imagined starting it alone... -
![Branding Belle by Crystal North, Kira Roman]()
Branding Belle by Crystal North, Kira Roman
Ink. Lies. Secrets. Betrayal. When I fly halfway across the country to finally get my dream tattoo, I don’t expect my asshole brother to have sent my artist on holiday. We’ve always had a rocky relationship but things are about to get downright turbulent between us. Especially when he continually butts into my business and tries to control my life...Categorized as:
new adult working class hero spanking double-penetration anal sex menage fetish m-f-m -
![Eye Candy by Tawna Fenske]()
Eye Candy by Tawna Fenske
I see them staring. Blame the scar that’s carved from my chest to face, or my reputation as a beast. Keeping to myself keeps others from knowing how I got this way. Then she moves in next door. My sexy neighbor revels in me watching her most intimate moments. The kicker? She wants to watch me. What’s the harm in staging sinful shows across our shared fence line? No words. No contact...Categorized as:
grumpy sunshine menage disabilities and marks spanking m-f-m double-penetration anal sex masc-dom -
![Overexposed by Heather Long, Tate James]()
Overexposed by Heather Long, Tate James
With Dad’s medical bills piling up, the solution to our problems might lie in the world of glitz and glamor, which means following in his footsteps. I grew up in the whirlwind of celebrity scandals, where every moment is a potential headline. I know the thrill of the “Unicorn List”—the ultimate scoop that could change everything... -
-
![Their Shy Submissive by Anya Summers]()
Their Shy Submissive by Anya Summers
Rated: 4.22 of 5 stars · 9 ratingsYvette Pfeifer is bemoaning her fate as the submissive no one wants. She left her family and friends in Florida to work as a receptionist on the exclusive resort Pleasure Island. There, her deepest hope is that she will find a Dom who will claim her and make her his. Her only problem is her crippling social anxiety; an affliction which makes it hard for her to attend any club or events... -
![Unraveling Love by K.L. Donn]()
Unraveling Love by K.L. Donn
Rated: 4.25 of 5 stars · 8 ratingsFrom USA Today Bestselling Author KL Donn comes a protectors to lovers romantic suspense that will have you laughing out loud and swooning in your seat. For Boston Falco and Dare Waters fighting in war was easy. Protecting an independent woman with a penchant for saying everything on her mind was like walking through a mine field. But Arden Graham was worth it. For them she was worth everything... -
![Broken by Them by Kelli Callahan]()
Broken by Them by Kelli Callahan
Rated: 4.25 of 5 stars · 8 ratingsWhat does it mean to be truly broken? They used to call me Doll Face. The pretty girl with perfect porcelain skin. But that was a lifetime ago. Before I learned how cruel this world really is. Now I belong to them. All of my secrets have been exposed. They smile when I cry. They laugh when I scream. They won’t stop until I’m broken... -
![Her Military Mountain Men: A Reverse Harem Romance by Veronica Wade]()
Her Military Mountain Men: A Reverse Harem Romance by Veronica Wade
Rated: 4.33 of 5 stars · 6 ratingsLoving three men at once? Sure, it's a fantasy. .. but I never dreamed it could come true. When I witness something nobody should have seen, all I want to do is get out of dodge and start a new life. Luckily the mob feels the same way, and buys my silence with a suitcase full of cash and an order to leave. Immediately. But leaving town is not the craziest thing that happens to me... -
![Off Field Drama (Class in Session) by Ember Davis]()
Off Field Drama (Class in Session) by Ember Davis
Rated: 4.40 of 5 stars · 5 ratingsSALEM. Senior year is upon us and as much as this is the last hurrah, it’s also time to buckle down because before I know we won’t have the quad to call home and then life truly begins. I’m not sure where I’m going, but I also want to enjoy the time I have left... -
![Nanny for the Athletes by Cassie Cole]()
Nanny for the Athletes by Cassie Cole
Three chiseled professional athletes. One single woman. And a little girl who will bring them all together. When these guys showed up to board their dogs, I thought they were just a trio of extremely handsome men. I definitely didn’t know they were the three most famous athletes in St. Louis... -
![My Three Hometown Hard Hats by Lacey Day]()
My Three Hometown Hard Hats by Lacey Day
A hookup with a handsome stranger at 30,000 feet… Yes, please. Coming home to three off-limits contractors who want to claim me? That escalated fast. After one life-shattering day, I ditched New York and ended up in a tiny airplane bathroom being given the best O of my life. I didn’t catch his name. Or expect to see him again. But fate has jokes... -
![Knot My Daddy by Lavinia Arbor]()
Knot My Daddy by Lavinia Arbor
Charlotte Hines hadn't moved to South York to find a mate. It was rare for an omega to be accepted into the prestigious Master's program at South York University. Even rarer for them to be awarded an internship at a publishing house. And sure, the three alphas in the c-suite might make her want to bend over the nearest desk, but that's fine...Categorized as:
anal sex m-f-m spanking double-penetration praise-kink caretaking competent heroine sweet-hero -
![Royally Tempted by Madison Faye]()
Royally Tempted by Madison Faye
Rated: 4.10 of 5 stars · 10 ratingsFilthy. Royal. Gorgeous. Triplets . Temptation’s never tasted so sweet. They’re the hottest, dirtiest fantasy that I never saw coming. Three gorgeous, powerful princes – triplets at that – who share everything. And now they’ve got their eyes on me... -
![Brush Strokes by Rebecca Rathe]()
Brush Strokes by Rebecca Rathe
Beth Heaton wants nothing more than to be an artist, but a lifetime of internalizing the judgment of her family and peers has left her full of self-consciousness and doubt. She quietly fades into the background, until she captures the attention of the ruggedly handsome and world renown photographer Callaghan Flynn...Categorized as:
menage anal sex double-penetration praise-kink m-f-m new adult found-family cheerful heroine -
-
![A Not So Silent Night by J.L. Quick]()
A Not So Silent Night by J.L. Quick
Rated: 4.13 of 5 stars · 8 ratingsTwelve Days of Day 12. “Take the scenic drive through Canada,” they said. “It’ll be fun,” they said. Ok, so no one said it. I’m the one with the bright idea to sightsee on my way home from college. When one of the biggest storms of the year hits, I end up stuck, waiting it out in a lakeside cabin with the two gorgeous men who rescued me from a snowbank... -
![Caged By Them by Kelli Callahan]()
Caged By Them by Kelli Callahan
Rated: 4.14 of 5 stars · 7 ratingsThe bars that surround me are the just the beginning. .. I had the brightest of futures. And the one in front of me was vivid. I carved out my own place in the world. But I wasn't always proud of what I did. I should have known that my mistakes would catch up to me eventually. One moment changed everything. I woke up in a cage. A prison of my own making. But I didn't know why. .Categorized as:
military suspense m-f-m contemporary poly length-short first-in-series standalone-first -
![Double Scrooged by Shae Sullivan]()
Double Scrooged by Shae Sullivan
Rated: 4.17 of 5 stars · 6 ratingsThey say everyone has a Scrooge in their life, and I unfortunately have two. Nate and Barron, my arrogant ex-stepbrothers, hate me. Like really hate me. Ever since my dad, their ex-stepdad, cheated on their mom for the fifth time, they’ve wanted nothing to do with me—or him. Not that I can blame them. Daddy has never been the standard father figure... -
![A Degree of Submission by Verika Sloane]()
A Degree of Submission by Verika Sloane
Rated: 4.17 of 5 stars · 6 ratingsGood girls get punished when they do bad things. I gave my innocence to Gage and Alex with my eyes and arms wide open. I thought we would end there. We didn't. Someone smeared my erotica online. I thought it would end there. It hasn't. My explicit fantasies have been exploited as the biggest joke on campus. Someone somehow knows about the three of us, pushing our secret to the line of discovery... -
![In His Hands by Hannah Murray]()
In His Hands by Hannah Murray
Consent is everything…and with consent, everything is possible. Olivia has one wish—to find a partner who will do consensual non-consent scenes with her. She thought she’d found the perfect man, but he turned out to be more dud than Dom. When their relationship implodes, she moves out, and moves in with her friend Cade. He’s happy to have her, but living with him won’t be easy...Categorized as:
spanking double-penetration masc-dom anal sex caretaking m-f-m competent heroine sweet-hero -
![Three Shots by Brigham Vaughn]()
Three Shots by Brigham Vaughn
A musician, a computer designer, and a tavern owner walk into a bar: it’ll take three shots to get this right …. When Reeve Jenkins picks up his guitar to sing at a local dive bar, the last thing he expects is to bring a guy home that night. Grant McGuire is a man drowning his sorrows in beer after a painful breakup...
Fantastic book recommendations by romance book lovers for romance book lovers.
Find out more about romance.io.
Find out more about romance.io.
Get recommendations by genres & tropes
Use the romance book finder to mix and match over 100 content keywords to find the books that match your preferences
Or - use our amazing romance book finder to get recommendations based on your favorite content tropes and themes. Mix and match at will.
