The Amish Sisters Collection

In the heart of Amish country, where faith and family form the bedrock of life, sisterhood is a bond forged in tradition yet tested by choice. From quiet prayers to heartfelt longings, these collections of stories follow remarkable sisters as they navigate the intricate paths of love, loss, and self-discovery. Each journey shows the enduring power of family, proving that even in the most challenging moments, a sister's love can be the greatest miracle of all.
This set contains the complete stories of these sisters.

The Bontrager Sisters
In a world bound by tradition, three Amish sisters—Sarah, Emma, and Martha—walk very different paths toward love, faith, and self-discovery. As one rushes into marriage, another questions everything, and the third stirs conflict with her fiery spirit, the ties that bind them are tested in profound ways. Through joy and heartbreak, unity and division, their journeys reveal what it truly means to be a family. This is the unforgettable story of the Bontrager sisters—where every choice echoes through the lives of those they hold dear.

Ruby's Story
Two sisters torn apart by jealousy, lies, and the love of the same man must face the consequences of one devastating choice. Ruby thought her future was secure—until Mary’s betrayal shattered everything, sending her away in heartbreak and silence. As years pass and their lives take different paths, it is tragedy—not time—that forces them to confront the truth and what remains of their bond. In the end, only forgiveness can heal what was broken... but forgiveness never comes easily.

The Schwartz Sisters
Over three Christmas seasons, sisters Katie, Elizabeth, and Hannah Schwartz each face choices that could pull them away from their Amish roots—and from one another. Katie has always held the family together, but her longing for love pushes her to consider a future of her own. As Elizabeth reconnects with someone from the past and Hannah vanishes on Rumspringa, the sisters are forced to confront change, secrets, and what truly binds them. In the end, only love, trust, and faith can guide them back to one another in time for an Amish Christmas.

The Amish Patchwork Family
Naomi has always put her sister Beth first—especially after Beth’s sudden loss leaves her alone with two young children and another on the way. But as Naomi’s devotion deepens, her own hopes for love with Isaac begin to slip away. Torn between duty and desire, Naomi must face an impossible choice that could cost her the future she longs for. In a story of sacrifice, sisterhood, and second chances, the true meaning of family is tested—and beautifully redefined.

The Hershberger SIsters
Anna, Esther, and Katie each face life-altering choices that test their faith, love, and loyalty to one another. As they shoulder responsibility, long for freedom, and open their hearts to unexpected love, the bond between them proves stronger than the trials they face. Through grief, hope, and quiet miracles, the Hershberger sisters learn that family is both their greatest challenge and their greatest gift. Their journey is one of heartache, healing, and the enduring strength of sisterhood.

The Beiler Sisters
When tragedy strikes the Beiler family, sisters Lydia and Anna must learn to navigate the world without their beloved mother—and without the comfort of shared understanding. Lydia feels pressured to fill the void, while Anna begins to drift, lost in her own quiet heartache. As love, duty, and hidden feelings complicate their paths, the bond between them is both tested and transformed.