Aaron Holliman and his wife, Evelyn, move their three adult daughters - Madeline, Susanna, and Cordelia - to Deep Springs, Texas after the pastor accepts a call to serve as the pastor of the town's church. Their only son, Thomas, remains behind in Colorado to continue a job he does not want to leave. The young man is soon embroiled in a predicament that endangers his reputation. At the same time, his parents are quickly immersed into a tumultuous situation due to the willful choices of one of their daughters. The crisis leads to the revealing of long-protected secrets, while others remain carefully hidden. Ultimately, the prodigal child experiences various sufferings that bring her to a clear understanding of who she can truly trust. The entire family learns the importance of forgiveness, unconditional love, and an unshakable faith in their sovereign God.