The Substitute (New York Gods #4)
Andi Jaxon, J.R. Gray
Rated: 4.07 of 5 stars
4.07
· Steam/Spice level: 5 of 5
Explicit and plentiful [?]
· 24 ratings · 468 pages · Published: 08 Oct 2025
I saved his life the same night I burned mine to the ground and now the guy who’s haunted my dreams for months is my new roommate. This should be great except I met him on the worst night of his life and all he sees is that I’m a hockey player.
Only made worse when my cocky, confident, infuriating step-brother, Savage, decides to flirt with Tobi to get under my skin.
Jealousy eats at me when I see life coming back into Tobi’s eyes when he smiles at his phone.
Savage knows it too, pushing me into competing for Tobi until my head is so twisted I don’t know what or who I want anymore.
Now I have to see his pretty face at my door and on the ice.
I can’t have my dream and both of them. The media will eat me alive.
Right?
Sponsored links / Remove ads
Tagged as:
- sports 7
- hockey 7
- poly (3+ people) 6
- gay romance 6
- step siblings 5
- love triangle 5
- double anal 5
- college 5
- possessive hero 5
- queer romance 5
- contemporary 4
- caretaking 4
- nerdy hero 4
- athlete hero 4
- hurt/comfort 4
- sweet/gentle hero 4
- virgin hero 4
- enemies to lovers 3
- masc-dom 3
- bondage 3
- anal sex 3
- shy hero 3
- angst 3
- funny 3
- secret relationship 3
- menage 3
- mmm+ 3
- tortured hero 3
- forced proximity 2
- second chances 2
- double penetration 2
- exhibitionism 2
- bisexuality 2
- grumpy & sunshine 2
- height difference 2
- friends to lovers 2
- good grovel 2
- praise kink 2
- grumpy/cold hero 2
- sunny/happy hero 2
- found family 1
- Add topics
- content warnings
- suicide / ideation 6
- mental illness 6
- queerphobia 5
- past child abuse 5
- mental trauma 5
- religious trauma 3
- past abuse 3
- past child neglect 3
- body betrayal 2
- third party abuse 2
- misogyny 1
- geography
- new york state 4
- usa 3
- north america 2
- Format
- first person pov 4
- dual pov 4
- male pov 2
romance tags
The 'New York Gods' series
4.01 · 208 ratings
m-m · sports · queer · north-america · secret-relationship · angst · athletes · sweet-hero · dual-pov · possessive hero · anal sex · mental-trauma · new-york-state · first-person-pov · new adult · explicit-plentiful · mental illness · college · contemporary · male-pov
New York Gods reading order and complete book list ❯
