Creamy Crush: Straight to gay MM first time (First Time Gay Top #4)

Max Santino


Rated: 4.00 of 5 stars
4.00 ·
[?] · 1 rating · 49 pages · Published: 04 Jul 2025
This summer, I had one work my shifts at the Sea Whirl Ice Cream Shack, avoid sunburn, and remain straight.

Easy enough. Until Eli strolls back into town with sun-bleached curls, relentless charm, and zero personal space. Eli, who makes everything look easy; winning over customers, singing off-key while restocking cones, making me question if I'm really straight.

And then he kissed me.

During a milkshake.

Now I can’t stop thinking about him, or the way my heart flipped like a waffle cone when it happened. But I’m fine. Totally fine. I just have to survive a few more weeks of close quarters, shared milkshakes, and him looking at me like I’m something worth melting for.
Sponsored links / Remove ads

Tagged as:

    romance tags


    Reviews