Books like 'Lena’s Plain Inheritance'
Readers who enjoyed Lena’s Plain Inheritance by Betty Bontrager also liked the following books featuring the same tropes, story themes, relationship dynamics and character types.
-
The Search, A Novel by Suzanne Woods Fisher
When worlds collide, can the truth set two young women free? As a child caught up in a crisis, Lainey O'Toole made a split-second decision with far-reaching effects. Fifteen years later, when her car breaks down in Stoney Ridge--the very town in which that decision was made--she is forced to face the past and discover how her decision has impacted so many... -
![A Life of Joy by Amy Clipston]()
A Life of Joy by Amy Clipston
Take a trip to Bird-in-Hand, Pennsylvania, where you ll meet the women of the Kauffman Amish Bakery in Lancaster County. As each woman s story unfolds, you will share in her heartaches, trials, joys, dreams and secrets. You ll discover how the simplicity of the Amish lifestyle can clash with the English way of life and the decisions and consequences that follow... -
![]()
![]()
Sponsored links / Remove ads -
![Leah's Choice by Marta Perry]()
Leah's Choice by Marta Perry
Rated: 4.33 of 5 stars · 23 ratingsThe first of three Amish-set novels in which a woman? s faith must guide her through challenging times. All of Pleasant Valley seems to think the newcomer from Lancaster County is the perfect match for Teacher Leah. After all, so few new families come to their separate Amish community, and fewer still unmarried men... -
![The Longing by Beverly Lewis]()
The Longing by Beverly Lewis
Rated: 4.23 of 5 stars · 32 ratingsAlthough she still prays for Caleb, Nellie Mae Fisher has broken up with her beau. Now, her heart's greatest longing is for more knowledge of the Lord. Caleb yearns for freedom, as his plans to leave Honeybrook have been thwarted. He must stay on as caretaker for his father, who was crippled in a wintertime accident... -
-
![Amish Circle of Blessings: Amish Romance by Samantha Price]()
Amish Circle of Blessings: Amish Romance by Samantha Price
Rated: 4.75 of 5 stars · 8 ratingsFrom Samantha Price, USA Today Bestselling Author, comes the eagerly awaited final book in the cherished The Amish Bonnet Sisters series. In 'Amish Circle of Blessings,' the quiet lives of the Baker/Bruner extended family are shaken to their core by the revelation of a secret that will change their future. Catch up with all your favorite characters in this finale... -
![The Mercy by Beverly Lewis]()
The Mercy by Beverly Lewis
Rated: 4.25 of 5 stars · 28 ratingsThe Powerful Conclusion to Beverly Lewis' Latest #1 Bestselling Series! Rose Kauffman pines for prodigal Nick Franco, the Bishop's foster son who left the Amish under a cloud of suspicion after his foster brother's death. His rebellion led to the "silencing" of their beloved Bishop... -
![Her Hopeful Heart: Amish Romance by Samantha Price]()
Her Hopeful Heart: Amish Romance by Samantha Price
Rated: 4.67 of 5 stars · 9 ratingsDebbie is stepping into a new life beyond what she had ever imagined, and her family is right there with her. They're pitching in, ensuring her new home is as warm and welcoming as possible. It's a team effort, and Favor and Cherish refuse to go home until it feels just right... -
![Return to Love's Promise: Amish Romance by Samantha Price]()
Return to Love's Promise: Amish Romance by Samantha Price
Rated: 4.67 of 5 stars · 9 ratingsThe Baker family's generations-old apple orchard faces a season unlike any before. Three unexpected visitors bring a deluge of secrets and emotions, disrupting everything. As these revelations unfold, love finds a way to blossom in the most unexpected of places. Don't miss this second-last book in The Amish Bonnet Sisters series... -
![Along Wooded Paths by Tricia Goyer]()
Along Wooded Paths by Tricia Goyer
Rated: 4.36 of 5 stars · 18 ratingsAll she wanted was a simple Amish life . . . But now Marianna Sommer finds herself depending on Englisch neighbors. Although proud of living apart from the world, she and her newly relocated Amish family have discovered that life in the remote mountains of Montana requires working together... -
![The Parting/The Forbidden/The Longing by Beverly Lewis]()
The Parting/The Forbidden/The Longing by Beverly Lewis
Rated: 4.48 of 5 stars · 12 ratingsFrom Book 1: NY Times best-selling author's new series chronicling the separation of families during the New Order/Old Order split in the Amish community in Lancaster County, PA. -
![The Judgment by Beverly Lewis]()
The Judgment by Beverly Lewis
Rated: 4.23 of 5 stars · 27 ratingsRose Kauffman is engaged to Silas Good, a well-liked Amish fellow, so why does she still pine for Nick Franco, the former foster son of the bishop? Especially now that Nick has left the Amish community under a cloud of suspicion after the death of the bishop's biological son? Will Rose marry Silas, even while struggling with romantic feelings for Nick? Meanwhile, Rose's older sister, Hen, has... -
![An Amish Cinderella by Shelley Shepard Gray]()
An Amish Cinderella by Shelley Shepard Gray
Rated: 4.38 of 5 stars · 15 ratingsSet in the close-knit Amish community of Apple Creek, Ohio, this sweet Cinderella -inspired novel from the New York Times and USA Today bestselling and award-winning author is complete with a matchmaking pet rat, and will delight fans of heartwarming, wholesome fiction and readers of Charlotte Hubbard, Beverly Lewis, and Beth Wiseman... -
![Her Amish Wish: Amish Romance by Samantha Price]()
Her Amish Wish: Amish Romance by Samantha Price
Rated: 4.63 of 5 stars · 8 ratingsThe Baker/Bruner family looks forward to a new beginning with newborn babies and blossoming relationships. Florence has added another baby to her family and couldn't be happier. Wilma, Ada, and their friends diligently prepare for Debbie's special day when an unwelcome visitor arrives. Meanwhile, Matthew tries to figure out what he has done wrong in his interactions with women... -
![The Amish Widow's Plight by Naomi Troyer]()
The Amish Widow's Plight by Naomi Troyer
Rated: 4.63 of 5 stars · 8 ratingsA tale of love, loss, blessings, and faith! Grace Speicher is desperate! Recently widowed, penniless, and carrying the precious gift of new life, she seeks refuge with the only family she has left–her estranged Amish in-laws in Lancaster County. Her unexpected arrival during a thunderstorm is met with uncertainty... -
-
![Spring's Renewal by Shelley Shepard Gray]()
Spring's Renewal by Shelley Shepard Gray
Rated: 4.28 of 5 stars · 18 ratingsTim Graber arrives in Sugarcreek to help his aunt and uncle with spring planting. At first, Tim doesn't fit in with his many cousins and their crowded lifestyle. But when he meets Clara Slabaugh, the local school teacher, he understands why the Lord brought him to Sugarcreek. Clara is shy and quiet... -
![The Shunning/The Confession/The Reckoning by Beverly Lewis]()
The Shunning/The Confession/The Reckoning by Beverly Lewis
Rated: 4.35 of 5 stars · 14 ratingsHERITAGE OF LANCASTER COUNTY Journey into the fascinating world of the Amish with the three-part story of a young woman who must face her past in order to discover her future. The Shunning Katie Lapp, a young Amish woman, lives a quiet life in Hickory Hollow, Pennsylvania, but after one visit to the attic, her world begins to crumble... -
![Grace by Shelley Shepard Gray]()
Grace by Shelley Shepard Gray
Rated: 4.24 of 5 stars · 21 ratingsIt's never too late to go home. It's Christmastime at the Brenneman Bed and Breakfast, and everyone is excited about closing down for the holidays. But when two unexpected visitors appear seeking shelter, the family's commitment to hospitality is tested. First Levi arrives, sullen and angry. .. but insisting on staying for five days. Next Melody shows up... -
![The Forgiving Jar by Wanda E. Brunstetter]()
The Forgiving Jar by Wanda E. Brunstetter
What would happen if you found out someone has been impersonating you? Sara Murray had never met her mother’s parents and was surprised to learn after her death that they were Amish living in Pennsylvania. When she is finally able to make the trip to meet them, she is shocked to learn someone else has been living with them and pretending to be Sara... -
![How the Light Gets in by Jolina Petersheim]()
How the Light Gets in by Jolina Petersheim
Rated: 4.42 of 5 stars · 11 ratings"Compellingly woven by Jolina Petersheim's capable pen, How the Light Gets In follows a trail of grief toward healing, leading to an impossible choice--what is best when every path will hurt someone? " --Lisa Wingate, New York Times bestselling author of Before We Were Yours... -
![On a Coastal Breeze by Suzanne Woods Fisher]()
On a Coastal Breeze by Suzanne Woods Fisher
For Madison Grayson, life is good. Newly licensed as a marriage and family therapist, she can't wait to start her practice. Despite the unfortunate shortage of eligible bachelors on the island--they're all too young, too old, or too weird--Maddie feels like she's finally found her sweet spot. Not even one panic attack in the last year. Not one. And then Ricky O'Shea drops in. Literally... -
![An Honest Love by Kathleen Fuller]()
An Honest Love by Kathleen Fuller
Rated: 4.37 of 5 stars · 12 ratingsAnna must find the courage to tell Lukas the truth. Will he find the courage to forgive her? Anna was once betrayed by someone she loved deeply. In an attempt to never be hurt again, she and her mother relocated to Middlefield, Ohio. It was the ideal place for Anna's broken heart to mend... -
![The Promise Box by Tricia Goyer]()
The Promise Box by Tricia Goyer
Rated: 4.40 of 5 stars · 11 ratingsEvery year, young Amish men descend on the cozy little town of West Kootenai, Montana, arriving in the spring to live there for six months and receive “resident” status for the hunting season in the fall... -
![Lilly's Wedding Quilt by Kelly Long]()
Lilly's Wedding Quilt by Kelly Long
Rated: 4.31 of 5 stars · 14 ratingsHandsome, headstrong Jacob offers Lilly his hand in marriage, but his heart belongs to someone else. While Lilly Lapp has loved Jacob for years, she wouldn't compete with Sarah King, the woman Jacob was determined to marry. But when Sarah marries another, Jacob spontaneously agrees to wed Lilly... -
![Christmas in Apple Ridge: Three-in-One Collection: The Sound of Sleigh Bells, The Christmas Singing, NEW! The Dawn of Christmas by Cindy Woodsmall]()
Christmas in Apple Ridge: Three-in-One Collection: The Sound of Sleigh Bells, The Christmas Singing, NEW! The Dawn of Christmas by Cindy Woodsmall
Experience the holidays with the Plain folk of Apple Ridge, Pennsylvania, in these touching novellas centered around love, romance, heartache, and restoration from best-selling author Cindy Woodsmall. The Sound of Sleigh Bells... -
-
![His Accidental Amish Family by Rachel J. Good]()
His Accidental Amish Family by Rachel J. Good
Rated: 4.67 of 5 stars · 6 ratingsIn the picturesque Amish community of Lancaster, Pennsylvania, life's detours may prove the path to true happiness . . . After a buggy accident when she was a teenager, Anna Flaud was told she would never walk again. Unwilling to be an object of pity, she put aside her dreams of marriage and found purpose as an assistant at a Community Care Center... -
![A Season on the Wind by Suzanne Woods Fisher]()
A Season on the Wind by Suzanne Woods Fisher
Rated: 4.67 of 5 stars · 6 ratingsBen Zook had only two loves in his life: books and birds. In a stroke of good fortune, he'd stumbled onto a way to cobble together those two loves into a career, writing books about rare birds. He was as free as a bird--until a chase for a rare White-winged Tern takes him to the one place on earth he planned to never return: his Amish home in Stoney Ridge... -
![A Season on the Wind by Suzanne Woods Fisher]()
A Season on the Wind by Suzanne Woods Fisher
Rated: 4.67 of 5 stars · 6 ratingsBen Zook had only two loves in his life: books and birds. In a stroke of good fortune, he'd stumbled onto a way to cobble together those two loves into a career, writing books about rare birds. He was as free as a bird--until a chase for a rare White-winged Tern takes him to the one place on earth he planned to never return: his Amish home in Stoney Ridge... -
![A Season on the Wind by Suzanne Woods Fisher]()
A Season on the Wind by Suzanne Woods Fisher
Rated: 4.67 of 5 stars · 6 ratings"After a long absence, Ben Zook returns to his childhood home of Stoney Ridge in search of a rare bird. He plans to find the bird and leave rather than pick up where he left off. But he soon discovers that even if you try to forget the past, the past remembers you"--. -
![Every Good Gift by Kelly Irvin]()
Every Good Gift by Kelly Irvin
Rated: 4.67 of 5 stars · 6 ratings"An Amish girl faces an impossible choice as the consequences from her Rumspringa become all too real"--. -
![Two Christmas Brothers: Amish Romance by Hannah Miller]()
Two Christmas Brothers: Amish Romance by Hannah Miller
Rated: 4.67 of 5 stars · 6 ratingsJosiah Schrock has his hands full. His two young nephews have temporarily been living with him since losing their parents in a tragic accident. Unable to care for them while at work, he hires Olivia King to watch them and manage the household. What he doesn’t count on, is how easily Olivia slips into the role. Josiah’s girlfriend, Marjorie, is none too pleased... -
![Rebecca's Redemption by Hannah Schrock]()
Rebecca's Redemption by Hannah Schrock
Rated: 4.67 of 5 stars · 6 ratingsShe had everything, yet nothing at all, until a secret changed everything. Rebecca traded her happiness to rescue her parents from inevitable impoverishment. Her decision meant losing the one man in the world she loved more than life itself - David Fisher. Amos Zook was her much older husband. It was not a happy marriage. When Amos suddenly dies, Rebecca soon discovers he was keeping many secrets... -
![A Wedding for Julia by Vannetta Chapman]()
A Wedding for Julia by Vannetta Chapman
Rated: 4.50 of 5 stars · 8 ratingsA Wedding for Julia, the third book in a romantic series from popular author Vannetta Chapman, takes a last look at the Amish community of Pebble Creek and the kind, caring people there. As they face challenges from the English world, they come together to reach out to their non-Amish neighbors while still preserving their cherished Plain ways. Julia Beechy is so stunned, she can hardly breathe... -
![Miriam's Quilt by Jennifer Beckstrand]()
Miriam's Quilt by Jennifer Beckstrand
Rated: 4.50 of 5 stars · 8 ratingsMiriam Bontrager has loved Ephraim Neuenschwander for as long as she can remember. As young teenagers they make a secret pact to wed when they come of age. But when Miriam’s headstrong brother is arrested and her sister is discovered with child, Ephraim decides that Miriam, with her disgraced family ties, is not worthy of him... -
![Valley of Hope by Sarah Price]()
Valley of Hope by Sarah Price
Rated: 4.50 of 5 stars · 8 ratingsSamuel Lapp isn't ready to think about joining the Amish church yet. However, he's feeling the pressure from his family, community, and church. The harder they push, the more he rebels. Not even his pretty neighbor, Mary Ruth Smucker, can get Samuel to settle down into the Amish ways... -
-
![Huckleberry Harvest by Jennifer Beckstrand]()
Huckleberry Harvest by Jennifer Beckstrand
Rated: 4.50 of 5 stars · 8 ratingsAnna and Felty Helmuth’s zest for matchmaking is unstoppable—and with grown-up grandchild number three on her way to their home in lovely Huckleberry Hill, Wisconsin, what better reason to put their talents to work once more? .. . When Mandy Helmuth hears that her best friend Kristina’s heart has been broken, she decides to visit her grandparents and cheer her up... -
![The Quieting by Suzanne Woods Fisher]()
The Quieting by Suzanne Woods Fisher
Bestselling Author Delivers the Intrigue and Romance Fans Crave. The Stoltzfus family faces serious problems, both in the church and at home. Everyone in the community expects minister David Stoltzfus to fix things--fast. But David doesn't work fast. He prefers to wait for God to work in individual hearts... -
![The Devoted by Suzanne Woods Fisher]()
The Devoted by Suzanne Woods Fisher
The Amish life is all she's ever known--but will it satisfy her soul? Restless and adventurous, Ruthie Stoltzfus is right on the cusp of leaving her Amish home. Secretly, she's earned her GED, saved her money--but she can't quite set her journey into motion. Just as everything falls into place, along comes Patrick Kelly. Patrick is a young man on a journey of his own... -
![Gathering the Threads by Cindy Woodsmall]()
Gathering the Threads by Cindy Woodsmall
After three months of draus in da Welt , Ariana has returned to Summer Grove, the Old Order Amish community where she was raised for twenty years, and life with her Brenneman family. Skylar Nash, the Englisch-raised young woman is working in Ariana s cafe while getting to know her birth family and their Plain way of life... -
![Indiana Cousins Trilogy by Wanda E. Brunstetter]()
Indiana Cousins Trilogy by Wanda E. Brunstetter
Enjoy the pleasure of owning the complete Indiana Cousins trilogy all under one cover. Follow four young Amish women who are forever changed after a traffic accident takes their friends and leave them scarred. Loraine’s fiancé is severely injured and breaks their engagement. Katie’s boyfriend is killed, and she sinks into depression. Jolene loses her hearing... -
![At Lighthouse Point by Suzanne Woods Fisher]()
At Lighthouse Point by Suzanne Woods Fisher
Blaine Grayson returns to Three Sisters Island with a grand plan--to take Camp Kicking Moose to the next level. Her dream starts to unravel when she discovers Moose Manor's kitchen has been badly remodeled by her sister, Cam, who doesn't know how to cook. Added to that blow is the cold shoulder given by her best friend, Artie Lotosky, now a doctor to the unbridged Maine islands... -
![Hopefully Ever After by Beth Wiseman]()
Hopefully Ever After by Beth Wiseman
Rated: 4.50 of 5 stars · 8 ratingsIn the third and final novel of Beth Wiseman’s Amish Bookstore series, two young people must find the courage to defy expectations and become who they’re meant to be. Sixteen-year-old Eden Hale doesn’t want to be defined by her current circumstances. Her mother is in prison, she doesn’t know her father, and she’s had her own run-ins with the law, but Eden refuses to become what people expect... -
![The Amish Widow's Rescue by Rachel J. Good]()
The Amish Widow's Rescue by Rachel J. Good
Rated: 4.50 of 5 stars · 8 ratingsThe perfect family awaits. .. if only he'll risk his heart. Pregnant and recently widowed, Grace Fisher is determined to provide for her family on her own. Thankfully, her jam business is popular in her Amish community. But it's difficult keeping up with her work, her farm chores, and her two mischievous children. Especially now that they've taken to idolizing their neighbor Elijah... -
![Whispers of Change: Inspirational Amish Romance by Samantha Price]()
Whispers of Change: Inspirational Amish Romance by Samantha Price
Rated: 4.50 of 5 stars · 8 ratingsAll the Baker girls are home to help with Debbie's wedding. But the reunion isn't just about the wedding preparations. Old memories resurface, unresolved feelings stir, and the tight-knit bond of the Baker sisters is tested as never before... -
![Stronger Than Whispers by Sarah Miller]()
Stronger Than Whispers by Sarah Miller
Rated: 4.50 of 5 stars · 8 ratingsIn the heart of Faith's Creek, the lives of the Sommer sisters are about to be transformed by unexpected love and a family secret. Annie, the eldest Sommer sister, had given up on love. That was the sacrifice needed to help her sisters when they lost their mother. It was gladly given, but the arrival of Christian, a kind-hearted newcomer to the Amish community, brings change... -
-
![Missing Love by Hannah Schrock]()
Missing Love by Hannah Schrock
Rated: 4.50 of 5 stars · 8 ratingsAll Esther’s dreams came true… until they were ripped from her without warning. Esther fell in love at the age of five. When she finally married the boy of her dreams she knew her future would hold nothing but happiness. Jacob was the love of her life and had they only been blessed with a boppli; their lives couldn’t have been happier. The one dream that wouldn’t come true... -
![A Lancaster County Christmas by Suzanne Woods Fisher]()
A Lancaster County Christmas by Suzanne Woods Fisher
Jaime and C. J. Fitzpatrick began their married life as most couples do--in love and looking forward to a bright future together. But four years later they've drifted apart and are almost ready to call it quits. Mattie Riehl was hoping to give her husband Sol the Christmas gift they have both longed for--news that a baby was on the way. But as usual, she is disappointed... -
![The Secret Keeper by Beverly Lewis]()
The Secret Keeper by Beverly Lewis
Rated: 4.17 of 5 stars · 24 ratingsReaders Eagerly Await the Latest from Beverly Lewis, the #1 Name in Amish Fiction. With her love for all things old-fashioned, Jennifer Burns has often been told she's an "old soul," but no one is prepared for the young woman's decision to set aside her modern life in favor of the Old Order Amish world... -
![Courting Ruth by Emma Miller]()
Courting Ruth by Emma Miller
Rated: 4.30 of 5 stars · 13 ratingsAmish widow Hannah Yoder prays her daughters will each find a husband someday. Still, sensible Ruth believes it's God's will that she stay home and help care for her younger sisters. But when a handsome young man comes to Kent County, Ruth starts to rethink her plans. Not yet part of the church, Eli Lapp is allowed to run wild... -
![The Telling by Beverly Lewis]()
The Telling by Beverly Lewis
Rated: 4.14 of 5 stars · 28 ratingsGrace Byler leaves Bird-in-Hand in a fancy car to search for her mother in Ohio. But what if Lettie Byler doesn't wish to be found? Meanwhile, Lettie continues her private quest to find the missing piece of her life. As clues take her from state to state, she is increasingly torn between the family she has left behind and the yearning for her long-lost child... -
![What the Heart Sees: A Collection of Amish Romances by Kathleen Fuller]()
What the Heart Sees: A Collection of Amish Romances by Kathleen Fuller
Rated: 4.38 of 5 stars · 10 ratingsTogether for the first time, three Amish romances from Kathleen Fuller. "A Miracle for Miriam" from An Amish Christmas. Miriam fell for Seth, but he broke her heart. Years later, after he's nearly killed in an accident, Miriam sees him at a Christmas party and notices something is different about him-not just how he looks, but how he acts...
Fantastic book recommendations by romance book lovers for romance book lovers.
Find out more about romance.io.
Find out more about romance.io.
Get recommendations by genres & tropes
Use the romance book finder to mix and match over 100 content keywords to find the books that match your preferences
Or - use our amazing romance book finder to get recommendations based on your favorite content tropes and themes. Mix and match at will.
