First Time Gay Top Series by Max Santino

3.83 · 6 ratings
  • Topping my best friend: Straight to Gay First Time MM (First Time Gay Top #1)
    #1

    Topping my best friend: Straight to Gay First Time MM (First Time Gay Top #1)

    Max Santino

    Rated: 3.50 of 5 stars
    · 2 ratings · published 2025

    I’m straight, so why I crave so much to top my gay best friend? When my old high school buddy Elliot reaches me through a casual DM, I expect nothing more than a trip down memory lane. But Elliot isn’t how I remember—he’s bolder, funnier, and unapologetically himself. And openly, loudly, proudly gay. As our reunion turns into late-night messages, coffee shop meetups, and inside jokes that come way too easily, I realise that what I feel for Elliot might not just be I want him all to myself... more

    Sponsored links / Remove ads
  • My Nerdy Bossy Bottom: Straight to Gay First Time MM (First Time Gay Top #2)
    #2

    My Nerdy Bossy Bottom: Straight to Gay First Time MM (First Time Gay Top #2)

    Max Santino

    Rated: 4.00 of 5 stars
    · 2 ratings · published 2025

    I’m straight. How come such a soft, nerdy, grumpy dude holds so much power over me? I’m not the brightest guy — ask my Econ grades. But I know a few things for football’s my life, I’m barely hanging on to my scholarship, and my tutor, Noah, is driving me insane. Not because he’s a pain (okay, maybe a little), but because every time he leans over my notes, frowning in concentration, I’m not thinking about the next quiz. I’m thinking about his lips. His hands... more

  • Gay for my Roommate: Straight to Gay First Time MM (First Time Gay Top #3)
    #3

    Gay for my Roommate: Straight to Gay First Time MM (First Time Gay Top #3)

    Max Santino

    Rated: 4.00 of 5 stars
    · 1 ratings · published 2025

    My roommate's butterfly hip tattoo is going to destroy my heterosexuality. I thought I had college all figured play football, ace my classes, keep my room clean, stay straight. Easy. Enter Cameron. He’s my new roommate thanks to a dorm mix-up, and he’s a walking glitter bomb in a mesh crop top. Loud. Flirty. Infuriatingly pretty. And somehow always in my on my bed, sitting next to me in class, throwing off my entire heterosexuality with one smirk. We argue about laundry... more

  • Creamy Crush: Straight to gay MM first time (First Time Gay Top #4)
    #4

    Creamy Crush: Straight to gay MM first time (First Time Gay Top #4)

    Max Santino

    Rated: 4.00 of 5 stars
    · 1 ratings · published 2025

    This summer, I had one work my shifts at the Sea Whirl Ice Cream Shack, avoid sunburn, and remain straight. Easy enough. Until Eli strolls back into town with sun-bleached curls, relentless charm, and zero personal space. Eli, who makes everything look easy; winning over customers, singing off-key while restocking cones, making me question if I'm really straight. And then he kissed me. During a milkshake... more

  • Two naughty elves: Straight to gay MM First Time (First Time Gay Top #5)
    #5

    Two naughty elves: Straight to gay MM First Time (First Time Gay Top #5)

    Max Santino

    Rated: 0.00 of 5 stars
    · 0 ratings · published 2025

    The last thing I expected this Christmas was getting snowed in overnight at the mall with Gabriel, my overly cheerful, glitter-covered, annoyingly perfect coworker in the Elf Department. The plan for this Christmas was survive my seasonal mall job, ignore my confusing. “I-came-out-as-bi-last-year-and-still-don’t-know-what-I’m-doing”. feelings, and avoid Gabriel, my loud, glitter-soaked, infuriatingly pretty coworker elf. The universe lol, no. A surprise snowstorm traps us overnight in the mall... more

Find similar series to First Time Gay Top  ❯