That Old Black Magic: Similar romance series

Cruel Shifterverse

by Jasmine Mas

4.06 · 953 ratings

sassy heroine · height-difference · menage · paranormal · fae · possessive hero · torture-mcs · past-abuse · shapeshifters · queer · tortured heroine · cold hero · slow burn · graphic-violence · strong heroine · monsters · forced proximity · alpha male · fantasy · fated-mates

All books in this series ❯

Monstrous Matches

by Lillian Lark

4.00 · 918 ratings

non-human-hero · dual-pov · first-person-pov · magic · contemporary · paranormal · creative-anatomy · urban fantasy · monsters · fantasy · fated-mates · explicit-plentiful · anal sex · breeding · praise-kink · m-f · insta-love · witches · gifted heroine · shapeshifters

All books in this series ❯

Darkmore Penitentiary

by Caroline Peckham

4.34 · 353 ratings

humor · bad boys · spanking · fated-mates · independent heroine · gifted heroine · fantasy · magic · past-child-abuse · alpha male · vampires · reverse harem · urban fantasy · strong heroine · outlaw-heroine · tortured hero · disabilities and marks · angst · shapeshifters · first-person-pov

All books in this series ❯

The Mate Games: War

by K. Loraine

4.19 · 409 ratings

urban fantasy · witches · vampires · reverse harem · alpha male · magic · super rich hero · fated-mates · fantasy · suspense · contemporary · werewolves · paranormal · dual-pov · poly · possessive hero · teacher-hero · first-person-pov · shapeshifters · creative-anatomy

All books in this series ❯

The Arrow Hart Academy

by Hannah Haze

4.17 · 368 ratings

slut-shaming · paranormal · sassy heroine · contemporary · werewolves · non-human-heroine · teacher-hero · cold hero · shapeshifters · tortured heroine · fighters · disabilities and marks · poor heroine · possessive hero · torture-mcs · forced proximity · bodyguard-hero · slow burn · graphic-violence · urban fantasy

All books in this series ❯

Saints Academy

by K.C. Kean

4.18 · 271 ratings

first-person-pov · shapeshifters · possessive hero · poly · dual-pov · paranormal · non-human-hero · non-human-heroine · contemporary · werewolves · fantasy · new adult · fated-mates · magic · demons · found-family · forced proximity · angels · vampires · reverse harem

All books in this series ❯

Shadow Bred

by Grace McGinty

4.14 · 214 ratings

magic · m-m-f · reverse harem · poly · shapeshifters · menage · omegaverse · alpha male · fantasy · bisexual · length-medium · creative-anatomy · urban fantasy · witches · vampires · pregnancy · m-f · contemporary · non-human-hero · paranormal

All books in this series ❯

A Monstrous World

by Jillian West

4.22 · 203 ratings

demons · magic · m-f-m · north-america · small town · witches · reverse harem · dual-pov · breeding · poly · first-person-pov · working class heroine · non-human-hero · explicit-plentiful · age difference · found-family · alpha male · fated-mates · fantasy · bad boys

All books in this series ❯

The Mate Games: Pestilence

by Meg Anne

4.30 · 219 ratings

fantasy · super rich hero · fated-mates · arranged marriage · monsters · vampires · urban fantasy · paranormal · contemporary · witches · fetish · reverse harem · aristocratic heroine · bdsm · first-person-pov · dual-pov · poly · suspense · bisexual · death

All books in this series ❯

Reborn

by M. Sinclair

4.17 · 189 ratings

sweet heroine · m-f-m · reverse harem · abduction · sweet-hero · nerdy-hero · past-child-abuse · non-human-hero · misogyny · human-trafficking · poly · virgin heroine · dual-pov · insta-love · abuse-non-mc · caretaking · death · alpha male · found-family · age difference

All books in this series ❯

A Faery Story

by Sophie Oak

3.94 · 89 ratings

fated-mates · urban fantasy · contemporary · menage · vampires · fae · paranormal · witches · magic · erotica · alpha male · poly · fantasy · bdsm · werewolves · non-human-hero · royalty · reverse harem · virgin heroine · m-f

All books in this series ❯

de La Vega Cats

by Lauren Dane

4.05 · 84 ratings

paranormal · witches · shapeshifters · fantasy · erotica · alpha male · contemporary · werewolves · magic · urban fantasy · m-f · length-medium · menage · suspense · reverse harem · bisexual · latinx-mc · m-m-f · bad boys · mystery

All books in this series ❯

Princess of Hell

by Eve Langlais

3.87 · 104 ratings

humor · explicit-open-door · paranormal · reverse harem · fantasy · shapeshifters · urban fantasy · demons · poly · angels · vampires · witches · magic · contemporary · length-novella · menage · m-f-m · m-f · erotica · suspense

All books in this series ❯

Syndicate Mafia

by Kira Stanley

4.18 · 77 ratings

dual-pov · poly · possessive hero · first-person-pov · shapeshifters · suspense · competent heroine · contemporary · mafia · werewolves · paranormal · fae · dangerous heroine · demons · nerdy-hero · magic · fated-mates · fantasy · vampires · reverse harem

All books in this series ❯

Freakn' Shifters

by Eve Langlais

3.91 · 175 ratings

fantasy · shapeshifters · contemporary · paranormal · erotica · m-f · fated-mates · menage · poly · alpha male · werewolves · length-short · humor · m-f-m · curvy heroine · length-medium · urban fantasy · non-human-hero · anal sex · magic

All books in this series ❯

Umbra Hunters

by B.M. Clemton

4.30 · 90 ratings

disabilities and marks · canada · cold hero · shapeshifters · tortured heroine · poly · possessive hero · sunny hero · first-person-pov · dual-pov · paranormal · contemporary · height-difference · royalty · independent heroine · fantasy · from hate to love · demons · magic · age difference

All books in this series ❯

Nevermore Bookshop Mysteries

by Steffanie Holmes

4.16 · 199 ratings

poly · contemporary · paranormal · fantasy · humor · mystery · urban fantasy · witches · reverse harem · shapeshifters · disabilities and marks · vampires · united-kingdom · small town · grumpy sunshine · suspense · office · magic · first-person-pov · time travel

All books in this series ❯

The Splintered Bond

by Merri Bright

4.18 · 92 ratings

magic · fantasy · witches · shapeshifters · paranormal · age difference · fated-mates · urban fantasy · forced proximity · reverse harem · poly · contemporary · alabama · alpha male · death · usa · past-child-abuse · tortured hero · m-f-m · hurt-comfort

All books in this series ❯

Thieves

by Lexi Blake

4.22 · 115 ratings

urban fantasy · fantasy · paranormal · erotica · vampires · contemporary · shapeshifters · werewolves · menage · length-medium · magic · poly · witches · fae · reverse harem · m-f-m · demons · love triangle · m-f · other-man-woman

All books in this series ❯

Broken Ashes

by Nikita Parmenter

4.45 · 63 ratings

humor · fantasy · m-f · possessive hero · paranormal · non-human-heroine · alpha male · found-family · neurodivergent · urban fantasy · fighters · cheerful heroine · past-child-neglect · caretaking · cold hero · first-person-pov · tortured heroine · shapeshifters · past-abuse · mental-trauma

All books in this series ❯

Werewolves, Vampires and Demons, Oh My

by Eve Langlais

3.92 · 37 ratings

shapeshifters · insta-love · m-f · paranormal · suspense · werewolves · contemporary · fantasy · new adult · mystery · humor · magic · demons · witches · vampires · urban fantasy · strong heroine · cold hero · working class hero · possessive hero

All books in this series ❯

Wyldthorn Academy

by L.K. Shear

3.89 · 39 ratings

fated-mates · fantasy · shapeshifters · new adult · demons · poly · magic · paranormal · reverse harem · fae · queer · bdsm · dark · m-f · explicit-plentiful · m-m · contemporary · bondage · urban fantasy · m-f-m

All books in this series ❯

The Prophecy

by Bre Rose

4.08 · 28 ratings

magic · betrayal · found-family · usa · mystery · length-medium · bisexual · fantasy · fated-mates · independent heroine · north-america · m-f-m · north-carolina · grumpy sunshine · forced proximity · vampires · reverse harem · hurt-comfort · witches · class difference

All books in this series ❯