That Old Black Magic: Similar romance series

Cruel Shifterverse

by Jasmine Mas

3.97 · 1191 ratings

magic · m-m-f · dangerous heroine · misogyny · reverse harem · fated-mates · independent heroine · male-pov · bad boys · poly · paranormal · abuse · from hate to love · sassy heroine · height-difference · m-m · past-abuse · first-person-pov · tortured heroine · mental-trauma

All books in this series ❯

All The Pretty Monsters

by Kristy Cunning

4.24 · 991 ratings

urban fantasy · dual-pov · slow burn · sweet heroine · vampires · non-human-hero · audiobook · poly · alpha male · paranormal · gifted heroine · shapeshifters · height-difference · magic · werewolves · age difference · fantasy · reverse harem · monsters · first-person-pov

All books in this series ❯

Heart Hassle

by Raven Kennedy

4.27 · 486 ratings

insta-love · fae · paranormal · contemporary · fantasy · humor · demons · magic · sweet heroine · high fantasy · grumpy sunshine · strong heroine · sweet-hero · neurodivergent · cheerful heroine · praise-kink · cold hero · non-human-hero · first-person-pov · caretaking

All books in this series ❯

Emerald Lakes

by Britt Andrews

4.25 · 465 ratings

paranormal · audiobook · poly · shapeshifters · m-m-f · demons · magic · witches · reverse harem · fated-mates · fantasy · non-human-hero · alpha male · explicit-plentiful · bisexual · curvy heroine · possessive hero · menage · non-human-heroine · sassy heroine

All books in this series ❯

The Arrow Hart Academy

by Hannah Haze

4.17 · 460 ratings

fated-mates · reverse harem · witches · independent heroine · bad boys · dangerous heroine · misogyny · black-mc · magic · new adult · forbidden love · sassy heroine · paranormal · poly · contemporary · college · found-family · non-human-heroine · cold hero · bodyguard-hero

All books in this series ❯

Witchwood Boys

by C.M. Stunich

4.18 · 324 ratings

north-america · past-child-abuse · tortured hero · fetish · small town · angst · somnophilia · california · praise-kink · possessive hero · non-human-hero · primal-play · competent heroine · menage · m-f · alpha male · animal-death · humor · fantasy · forced proximity

All books in this series ❯

Saints Academy

by K.C. Kean

4.12 · 304 ratings

werewolves · demons · magic · fated-mates · reverse harem · fantasy · forced proximity · paranormal · found-family · non-human-heroine · poly · contemporary · new adult · shapeshifters · non-human-hero · first-person-pov · possessive hero · angels · dual-pov · vampires

All books in this series ❯

Shadow Bred

by Grace McGinty

4.10 · 236 ratings

shapeshifters · menage · contemporary · poly · m-f · non-human-heroine · reverse harem · montana · usa · m-m-f · magic · north-america · creative-anatomy · omegaverse · non-human-hero · bisexual · explicit-plentiful · paranormal · competent heroine · alpha male

All books in this series ❯

Hidden Kingdom

by L. Rose

3.89 · 156 ratings

non-human-hero · graphic-violence · aristocratic heroine · possessive hero · anal sex · racism · strong heroine · urban fantasy · sweet-hero · creative-anatomy · vampires · m-m-f · demons · magic · death · fated-mates · reverse harem · dangerous heroine · humor · fantasy

All books in this series ❯

The Mate Games: Pestilence

by Meg Anne

4.30 · 251 ratings

aristocratic heroine · fetish · fantasy · super rich hero · monsters · arranged marriage · bdsm · first-person-pov · vampires · urban fantasy · dual-pov · witches · fated-mates · reverse harem · contemporary · poly · suspense · paranormal · possessive hero · fighters

All books in this series ❯

A Monstrous World

by Jillian West

4.23 · 248 ratings

magic · demons · witches · poly · non-human-heroine · paranormal · explicit-plentiful · first-person-pov · dual-pov · m-f-m · fantasy · shapeshifters · non-human-hero · pregnancy · breeding · small town · reverse harem · fated-mates · independent heroine · bad boys

All books in this series ❯

Reborn

by M. Sinclair

4.14 · 215 ratings

audiobook · alpha male · m-f · menage · shapeshifters · death · m-f-m · age difference · fantasy · super rich hero · sweet-hero · sweet heroine · abduction · past-child-abuse · non-human-hero · possessive hero · contemporary · poly · non-human-heroine · found-family

All books in this series ❯

Princess of Hell

by Eve Langlais

3.86 · 105 ratings

demons · paranormal · explicit-open-door · urban fantasy · poly · shapeshifters · audiobook · reverse harem · humor · fantasy · angels · magic · contemporary · length-novella · menage · witches · vampires · m-f · erotica · m-f-m

All books in this series ❯

Freakn' Shifters

by Eve Langlais

3.91 · 175 ratings

paranormal · contemporary · audiobook · shapeshifters · fantasy · menage · erotica · m-f · fated-mates · alpha male · poly · werewolves · m-f-m · curvy heroine · length-short · humor · urban fantasy · length-medium · non-human-hero · anal sex

All books in this series ❯

The Splintered Bond

by Merri Bright

4.10 · 115 ratings

paranormal · shapeshifters · magic · witches · fated-mates · m-f · poly · alpha male · reverse harem · fantasy · hurt-comfort · urban fantasy · tortured heroine · non-human-heroine · audiobook · contemporary · height-difference · rape-non-mc · m-f-m · usa

All books in this series ❯

Raven Investigations

by Stacey Brutger

3.90 · 122 ratings

shapeshifters · reverse harem · witches · fantasy · vampires · paranormal · length-medium · magic · urban fantasy · poly · werewolves · alpha male · erotica · menage · bear shifter · mystery · suspense · contemporary · dragon shifter · new adult

All books in this series ❯

Broken Ashes

by Nikita Parmenter

4.34 · 94 ratings

fantasy · humor · non-human-heroine · found-family · m-f · alpha male · paranormal · urban fantasy · neurodivergent · possessive hero · poly · contemporary · bodyguard-heroine · menage · competent heroine · sassy heroine · fae · orcs · shapeshifters · height-difference

All books in this series ❯

Kindred of Arkadia

by Alanea Alder

4.27 · 74 ratings

shapeshifters · found-family · paranormal · werewolves · vampires · fantasy · humor · alpha male · queer · m-m · contemporary · erotica · poly · magic · urban fantasy · m-f · menage · fated-mates · lion shifter · length-novella

All books in this series ❯

The Witch's Monsters

by Sarah Piper

4.24 · 74 ratings

fantasy · forced proximity · dangerous heroine · monsters · witches · fated-mates · reverse harem · independent heroine · magic · demons · sassy heroine · fae · explicit-plentiful · shapeshifters · gifted heroine · found-family · non-human-heroine · audiobook · poly · m-f

All books in this series ❯

The Chosen

by Charlene Hartnady

4.14 · 121 ratings

shapeshifters · m-f · contemporary · paranormal · fantasy · demons · vampires · urban fantasy · insta-love · multicultural · third-person-pov · angels · body-betrayal · slut-shaming · psychics · misogyny · independent heroine · witches · hurt-comfort · non-human-hero

All books in this series ❯

Thieves

by Lexi Blake

4.17 · 120 ratings

fantasy · urban fantasy · paranormal · erotica · contemporary · shapeshifters · vampires · length-medium · werewolves · magic · menage · audiobook · m-f-m · reverse harem · witches · poly · fae · demons · love triangle · other-man-woman

All books in this series ❯

The Prophecy

by Bre Rose

4.08 · 28 ratings

hurt-comfort · grumpy sunshine · vampires · angst · class difference · small town · north-america · caretaking · mental-trauma · explicit-open-door · insta-love · poor heroine · secret child · contemporary · m-f · poly · betrayal · found-family · suspense · paranormal

All books in this series ❯