That Old Black Magic: Similar romance series

The Dark Side

by Kristy Cunning

4.13 · 1308 ratings

bad boys · monsters · immortal-heroine · urban fantasy · neurodivergent · 100-plus-years-fmc · strong heroine · angels · tortured hero · 100-plus-years-mmc · first-person-pov · fighters · warrior-heroine · cold hero · explicit-open-door · possessive hero · poly · alpha male · m-f · non-human-heroine

All books in this series ❯

Cruel Shifterverse

by Jasmine Mas

3.98 · 1641 ratings

fantasy · forced proximity · slow burn · strong heroine · grumpy sunshine · survival · dual-pov · disabilities and marks · high fantasy · mental-trauma · graphic-violence · past-child-neglect · past-abuse · tortured heroine · first-person-pov · virgin heroine · war · cold hero · anal sex · paranormal

All books in this series ❯

Cursed Legacies

by Morgan B. Lee

4.36 · 1224 ratings

reverse harem · sweet-hero · north-america · past-child-abuse · non-human-hero · late-20s-mmc · praise-kink · possessive hero · m-f · menage · fae · shapeshifters · gifted heroine · death · m-f-m · usa · fantasy · early-20s-fmc · monsters · dual-pov

All books in this series ❯

All The Pretty Monsters

by Kristy Cunning

4.23 · 1220 ratings

shapeshifters · height-difference · gifted heroine · paranormal · audiobook · contemporary · poly · alpha male · m-f · monsters · super rich hero · male-pov · reverse harem · fantasy · age difference · werewolves · magic · sweet heroine · vampires · urban fantasy

All books in this series ❯

Witchwood Boys

by C.M. Stunich

4.17 · 516 ratings

spanking · bad boys · california · male-pov · witches · reverse harem · independent heroine · exhibitionism · magic · from hate to love · sassy heroine · explicit-plentiful · suspense · paranormal · found-family · contemporary · poly · cold hero · past-child-neglect · dark

All books in this series ❯

The Arrow Hart Academy

by Hannah Haze

4.12 · 633 ratings

victim-blaming · black-mc · magic · dangerous heroine · misogyny · witches · reverse harem · fated-mates · bad boys · independent heroine · male-pov · contemporary · poly · found-family · college · non-human-heroine · suspense · paranormal · forbidden love · sassy heroine

All books in this series ❯

The Lost Sentinel

by Ivy Asher

4.14 · 434 ratings

fantasy · reverse harem · fated-mates · witches · magic · werewolves · gifted heroine · shapeshifters · poly · m-f · contemporary · audiobook · paranormal · first-person-pov · vampires · urban fantasy · strong heroine · death · length-medium · m-f-m

All books in this series ❯

Shifter City Fated Mates

by Jaymin Eve

4.10 · 348 ratings

possessive hero · praise-kink · poly · m-f · omegaverse · bodyguard-hero · cold hero · non-human-hero · fighters · graphic-violence · torture-mcs · first-person-pov · caretaking · bear shifter · tortured hero · past-child-abuse · disabilities and marks · abduction · tycoon · athletes

All books in this series ❯

Supernaturals of Castle Academy

by Tessa Hale

3.81 · 242 ratings

rhode-island · misogyny · fantasy · mystery · forced proximity · fated-mates · reverse harem · super rich hero · witches · independent heroine · magic · second chances · demons · length-medium · usa · werewolves · nerdy-hero · high-school · abuse · shapeshifters

All books in this series ❯

Saints Academy

by K.C. Kean

4.06 · 356 ratings

first-person-pov · new adult · shapeshifters · early-20s-mmc · paranormal · contemporary · poly · found-family · non-human-heroine · fated-mates · reverse harem · fantasy · early-20s-fmc · forced proximity · demons · werewolves · magic · vampires · angels · dual-pov

All books in this series ❯

Shadow Bred

by Grace McGinty

4.07 · 277 ratings

reverse harem · creative-anatomy · north-america · non-human-hero · standalone · omegaverse · non-human-heroine · contemporary · poly · m-f · menage · shapeshifters · magic · standalone-first · m-m-f · usa · montana · sweet-hero · urban fantasy · independent heroine

All books in this series ❯

The Mate Games: Pestilence

by Meg Anne

4.24 · 343 ratings

witches · fated-mates · reverse harem · suspense · paranormal · contemporary · poly · bdsm · first-person-pov · urban fantasy · dual-pov · vampires · arranged marriage · monsters · super rich hero · fantasy · aristocratic heroine · fetish · m-m-f · demons

All books in this series ❯

A Monstrous World

by Jillian West

4.15 · 336 ratings

magic · demons · witches · fated-mates · contemporary · non-human-heroine · paranormal · working class heroine · explicit-plentiful · height-difference · first-person-pov · cold hero · dual-pov · creative-anatomy · standalone-first · m-f-m · age difference · fantasy · audiobook · alpha male

All books in this series ❯

Hidden Kingdom

by L. Rose

3.80 · 189 ratings

non-human-hero · bisexual · sassy heroine · royalty · gifted heroine · shapeshifters · poly · alpha male · non-human-heroine · paranormal · menage · political-intrigue · humor · fantasy · dangerous heroine · fated-mates · reverse harem · death · magic · demons

All books in this series ❯

Reborn

by M. Sinclair

4.07 · 292 ratings

reverse harem · fated-mates · nerdy-hero · new adult · height-difference · paranormal · dragon shifter · poly · contemporary · non-human-heroine · found-family · human-trafficking · bodyguard-hero · past-child-neglect · abuse-non-mc · caretaking · past-abuse · first-person-pov · urban fantasy · dual-pov

All books in this series ❯

Myths & Monsters

by Beatrix Hollow

3.96 · 104 ratings

possessive hero · praise-kink · first-person-pov · dark · graphic-violence · non-human-hero · creative-anatomy · dual-pov · sweet-hero · fantasy · reverse harem · fated-mates · independent heroine · exhibitionism · monsters · stepsibling · curvy heroine · working class heroine · explicit-plentiful · height-difference

All books in this series ❯

Princess of Hell

by Eve Langlais

3.87 · 112 ratings

paranormal · urban fantasy · poly · audiobook · shapeshifters · explicit-open-door · demons · reverse harem · fantasy · humor · angels · menage · contemporary · length-novella · vampires · magic · witches · m-f · erotica · m-f-m

All books in this series ❯

The Witch's Monsters

by Sarah Piper

4.18 · 105 ratings

magic · demons · dangerous heroine · fantasy · fated-mates · reverse harem · witches · independent heroine · forced proximity · monsters · m-f · poly · found-family · non-human-heroine · audiobook · paranormal · competent heroine · fae · explicit-plentiful · sassy heroine

All books in this series ❯

Freakn' Shifters

by Eve Langlais

3.89 · 179 ratings

shapeshifters · paranormal · contemporary · audiobook · fantasy · menage · erotica · m-f · fated-mates · alpha male · poly · werewolves · length-short · humor · curvy heroine · m-f-m · urban fantasy · length-medium · non-human-hero · non-human-heroine

All books in this series ❯

Thieves

by Lexi Blake

4.20 · 126 ratings

urban fantasy · fantasy · paranormal · erotica · shapeshifters · vampires · contemporary · menage · audiobook · explicit-open-door · length-medium · werewolves · magic · fae · poly · reverse harem · witches · m-f-m · love triangle · demons

All books in this series ❯

Moretti Academy

by Allie Santos

3.94 · 58 ratings

non-human-hero · abuse-non-mc · fae · sassy heroine · from hate to love · shapeshifters · height-difference · contemporary · poly · betrayal · alpha male · college · non-human-heroine · suspense · dragon shifter · paranormal · fantasy · witches · reverse harem · monsters

All books in this series ❯

The Prophecy

by Bre Rose

4.14 · 30 ratings

length-medium · usa · north-carolina · vampires · angst · north-america · class difference · small town · hurt-comfort · grumpy sunshine · poor heroine · caretaking · insta-love · mental-trauma · single-mother · boss & employee · sassy heroine · fae · bisexual · queer

All books in this series ❯

Institute Thirteen

by K.C. Kean

4.18 · 40 ratings

dark · vampires · witches · reverse harem · fated-mates · new adult · explicit-plentiful · paranormal · poly · fantasy · forced proximity · shapeshifters · fae · m-f · betrayal · sunny hero · bodyguard-hero · cold hero · insta-love · past-child-neglect

All books in this series ❯