Penny's Choice: Similar series
Never Never
by Colleen Hoover
3.65 · 304 ratings
contemporary · paranormal · suspense · audiobook · young adult · mystery · friends to lovers · fantasy · new adult · m-f · length-novella · dual-pov · high-school · male-pov · college · magic · dark · angst · forbidden love · other-man-woman
All books in this series ❯
The Vampire Diaries
by L.J. Smith
3.46 · 333 ratings
paranormal · audiobook · vampires · fantasy · young adult · urban fantasy · witches · werewolves · magic · shapeshifters · mystery · horror · other-man-woman · contemporary · m-f · love triangle · length-novella · glimpses-kisses · dark · length-long
All books in this series ❯
The Syrena Legacy
by Anna Banks
3.95 · 242 ratings
fantasy · paranormal · contemporary · magic · urban fantasy · young adult · male-pov · behind-doors · usa · length-medium · sassy heroine · north-america · dual-pov · audiobook · m-f · length-novella · possessive hero · legends & fairy tales · new-jersey · high-school
All books in this series ❯
Sponsored links
Nightshade
by Andrea Cremer
3.94 · 241 ratings
magic · werewolves · fantasy · witches · urban fantasy · young adult · paranormal · shapeshifters · demons · contemporary · love triangle · cruel hero · other-man-woman · mystery · futuristic · audiobook · length-novella · length-long · war · dystopian
All books in this series ❯
The Beginner’s Guide to Necromancy: The Epilogues
by Hailey Edwards
4.21 · 146 ratings
urban fantasy · magic · contemporary · m-f · audiobook · paranormal · mystery · fantasy · humor · fae · vampires · shapeshifters · witches · found-family · new adult · length-short · length-novella · young adult · bad boys · strong heroine
All books in this series ❯
Altered
by Jennifer Rush
3.82 · 154 ratings
dystopian · fantasy · science fiction · young adult · paranormal · mystery · contemporary · length-medium · glimpses-kisses · futuristic · m-f · audiobook · length-novella · new adult · strong heroine · suspense · bad boys · male-pov
All books in this series ❯
The Lotus War
by Jay Kristoff
3.86 · 81 ratings
magic · paranormal · fantasy · dystopian · science fiction · steampunk · futuristic · historical · audiobook · young adult · urban fantasy · demons · length-novella · legends & fairy tales · love triangle · other-man-woman · east-asian-mc · multicultural · strong heroine · length-long
All books in this series ❯
Court of Fives
by Kate Elliott
3.86 · 99 ratings
fantasy · high fantasy · young adult · dystopian · paranormal · magic · audiobook · sports · political-intrigue · length-long · length-novella · glimpses-kisses · class difference · royalty · science fiction · racism · historical
All books in this series ❯
Shadowshaper Cypher
by Daniel José Older
4.00 · 89 ratings
urban fantasy · magic · horror · contemporary · young adult · paranormal · fantasy · audiobook · high-school · mystery · queer · death · suspense · length-medium · length-novella · african-american · black-mc · multicultural · love triangle · demons
All books in this series ❯
My Boyfriend Is a Monster
by Evonne Tsang
3.71 · 52 ratings
paranormal · length-novella · audiobook · fantasy · young adult · magic · urban fantasy · horror · contemporary · dystopian · athletes · high-school · usa · baseball · m-f · multicultural · north-america · monsters · futuristic · florida
All books in this series ❯
Night World: Extras
by L.J. Smith
4.22 · 27 ratings
paranormal · young adult · length-novella · vampires · horror · fantasy · audiobook · urban fantasy · witches · shapeshifters · werewolves
All books in this series ❯
The Hidden Society
by Jude Archer
3.64 · 42 ratings
fantasy · urban fantasy · paranormal · contemporary · audiobook · length-long · young adult · length-novella · magic · vampires · fae · from hate to love · friends to lovers · witches · new adult
All books in this series ❯
Royal Fae Guardians
by Heather Renee
3.82 · 24 ratings
young adult · audiobook · paranormal · magic · fantasy · urban fantasy · fae · length-novella · contemporary · war · length-short · cruel hero
All books in this series ❯
Darkwood Trilogy
by Anthea Sharp
3.97 · 36 ratings
fantasy · audiobook · young adult · magic · paranormal · length-medium · fae · length-novella · legends & fairy tales · humor · multicultural · war
All books in this series ❯
Soul Seers
by Rene Folsom
3.73 · 39 ratings
contemporary · audiobook · paranormal · fantasy · length-novella · young adult · college · fated-mates · male-pov · urban fantasy
All books in this series ❯
The Harbinger [Dramatized Adaptation]
by Jennifer L. Armentrout
4.16 · 16 ratings
young adult · audiobook · fantasy · paranormal · demons · explicit-open-door · length-novella · magic · urban fantasy · contemporary
All books in this series ❯
Beautiful Immortals Series Three
by Tim O'Rourke
4.46 · 13 ratings
fantasy · vampires · length-novella · audiobook · shapeshifters · young adult · paranormal · witches · psychics · angels · demons
All books in this series ❯
Nightshade Academy
by Kestra Pingree
4.00 · 5 ratings
young adult · shapeshifters · new adult · paranormal · fantasy · urban fantasy · length-novella · vampires · audiobook
All books in this series ❯
Phantom Horse Bridge
by George H. McVey
4.50 · 2 ratings
fantasy · christian · contemporary · paranormal · length-novella · audiobook · young adult · length-short · historical · western · new adult
All books in this series ❯
The Victorian Adventures
by Tim O'Rourke
5.00 · 3 ratings
demons · paranormal · witches · angels · shapeshifters · young adult · vampires · audiobook · fantasy · length-novella
All books in this series ❯
Eternal Time Shadows
by Lisa Shea
3.67 · 3 ratings
historical · futuristic · paranormal · young adult · science fiction · time travel · length-novella · fantasy · audiobook
All books in this series ❯
Psy Squad
by Linda Palmer
5.00 · 1 ratings
fantasy · paranormal · audiobook · new adult · length-novella · young adult · suspense · psychics · sports · contemporary
All books in this series ❯