A Paxton Park Mystery: Similar series
The Paper Magician
by Charlie N. Holmberg
3.85 · 297 ratings
magic · historical · victorian · mystery · fantasy · glimpses-kisses · steampunk · witches · length-short · urban fantasy · audiobook · young adult · paranormal · new adult · age difference · 20th century · science fiction · high fantasy · horror · m-f
All books in this series ❯
Bewitched and Bewildered
by Alanea Alder
4.36 · 821 ratings
shapeshifters · paranormal · fantasy · magic · vampires · urban fantasy · fated-mates · witches · m-f · dual-pov · non-human-hero · fae · contemporary · bear shifter · military · alpha male · bodyguard-hero · humor · strong heroine · insta-love
All books in this series ❯
Shadow Guild: The Rebel
by Linsey Hall
4.10 · 155 ratings
paranormal · humor · fantasy · vampires · witches · urban fantasy · magic · audiobook · fae · length-short · fated-mates · suspense · mystery · new adult · m-f · bad boys · shapeshifters · legends & fairy tales · first-person-pov · alpha male
All books in this series ❯
Sponsored links
Vampire Knitting Club
by Nancy Warren
4.08 · 440 ratings
witches · fantasy · mystery · vampires · paranormal · urban fantasy · magic · audiobook · contemporary · suspense · humor · length-short · heroine sleuth · length-medium · glimpses-kisses · length-novella · christmas · m-f · historical · horror
All books in this series ❯
How to Be the Best Damn Faery Godmother in the World (or Die Trying)
by Helen Harper
4.13 · 90 ratings
magic · paranormal · contemporary · fae · audiobook · mystery · fantasy · urban fantasy · suspense · humor · length-short · urban · witches
All books in this series ❯
The Fantastic Fluke
by Sam Burns
4.15 · 98 ratings
queer · tortured hero · m-m · north-america · cowboys · contemporary · california · alpha male · audiobook · urban fantasy · found-family · paranormal · age difference · mystery · fantasy · male-pov · magic · first-person-pov · usa · nerdy-hero
All books in this series ❯
Silver Hollow
by Leighann Dobbs
4.00 · 52 ratings
mystery · paranormal · suspense · witches · shapeshifters · audiobook · fantasy · length-short · magic · urban fantasy · humor · christian · vampires
All books in this series ❯
Torrent Witches
by Tess Lake
3.98 · 179 ratings
mystery · fantasy · witches · audiobook · paranormal · length-short · suspense · urban fantasy · magic · humor · heroine sleuth · contemporary · length-medium · glimpses-kisses
All books in this series ❯
Bedknobs and Broomsticks
by Josh Lanyon
4.04 · 64 ratings
paranormal · mystery · fantasy · queer · m-m · witches · magic · contemporary · age difference · length-short · urban fantasy · audiobook · open-door · first-person-pov · suspense · christmas · men in uniform · hurt-comfort · insta-love
All books in this series ❯
Supernatural Speakeasy
by Lily Harper Hart
4.66 · 138 ratings
fantasy · length-short · audiobook · paranormal · mystery · shapeshifters · magic · witches · urban fantasy · vampires · humor · suspense · gifted heroine · mental illness · new adult · contemporary · strong heroine
All books in this series ❯
Winter Wayne
by D.N. Hoxa
4.13 · 82 ratings
magic · witches · shapeshifters · fae · fantasy · paranormal · werewolves · audiobook · young adult · urban fantasy · length-short · mystery · strong heroine · vampires · suspense · length-medium · new adult · slow burn · contemporary
All books in this series ❯
Four Ways to Fate
by Sara C. Roethle
4.09 · 65 ratings
urban fantasy · fantasy · magic · paranormal · audiobook · first-person-pov · monsters · reverse harem · mystery · gifted heroine · fae · competent heroine · m-f · poly · contemporary · possessive hero · cheerful heroine · bodyguard-hero · non-human-hero · insta-love
All books in this series ❯
The Escaped
by Kristin Cast
3.57 · 48 ratings
urban fantasy · new adult · fantasy · paranormal · suspense · demons · young adult · audiobook · magic · length-short · mystery · contemporary · glimpses-kisses · sassy heroine · length-novella · legends & fairy tales
All books in this series ❯
Hidden Magic
by Jayne Hawke
3.88 · 33 ratings
length-short · witches · shapeshifters · fae · fantasy · mystery · paranormal · suspense · audiobook · urban fantasy · magic · hurt-comfort · new adult · forced proximity · from hate to love · strong heroine
All books in this series ❯
The Gargoyles of Arrington
by Jenn Burke
4.09 · 29 ratings
queer · shapeshifters · m-m · urban fantasy · paranormal · age difference · mystery · fantasy · length-short · magic · friends to lovers · contemporary · hurt-comfort · suspense · m-m-m · angst · abuse · fae · boss & employee · from hate to love
All books in this series ❯
Familiar Mates
by T.J. Nichols
3.71 · 119 ratings
paranormal · m-m · queer · fantasy · contemporary · shapeshifters · magic · witches · fated-mates · urban fantasy · suspense · dual-pov · non-human-hero · length-short · male-pov · mystery · third-person-pov · anal sex · insta-love · caretaking
All books in this series ❯
Frostbite
by Stacey Kennedy
3.89 · 41 ratings
paranormal · fantasy · urban fantasy · mystery · contemporary · length-short · magic · suspense · witches · sassy heroine · demons · length-novella · length-medium
All books in this series ❯
Shrouded Nation
by Brenda Trim
4.59 · 36 ratings
audiobook · paranormal · vampires · fantasy · witches · length-short · mature couple · shapeshifters · urban fantasy · science fiction · heroine sleuth · mystery · legends & fairy tales · magic · suspense · demons · humor · vikings
All books in this series ❯
Mystic River Shifters
by Delta James
4.37 · 36 ratings
audiobook · paranormal · fantasy · length-short · magic · shapeshifters · science fiction · mystery · fated-mates · historical · explicit-open-door · suspense · from hate to love · vengeance · small town · men in uniform · hurt-comfort · non-human-heroine · contemporary · erotica
All books in this series ❯
Flint and Tinder
by Gregory Ashe
4.07 · 28 ratings
contemporary · urban fantasy · paranormal · queer · age difference · mystery · fantasy · m-m · length-short · magic · horror · suspense · dark · length-novella · hurt-comfort
All books in this series ❯
Carnival of Mysteries
by L.A. Witt
4.18 · 79 ratings
queer · paranormal · m-m · fantasy · contemporary · magic · suspense · mystery · urban fantasy · length-short · length-medium · audiobook · historical · age difference · hurt-comfort · third-person-pov · dark · war · abuse · humor
All books in this series ❯
The Blood Witch Saga
by Theophilus Monroe
4.62 · 21 ratings
vampires · urban fantasy · audiobook · young adult · suspense · length-short · magic · fantasy · paranormal · demons · science fiction · witches · mystery · humor · fae · contemporary · multicultural · abduction · shapeshifters · length-novella
All books in this series ❯
Entwined Fates
by Juliane Maibach
4.24 · 25 ratings
strong heroine · young adult · urban fantasy · college · m-f · california · audiobook · contemporary · sassy heroine · high-school · bodyguard-hero · third-person-pov · paranormal · dark · magic · first-person-pov · other-man-woman · mystery · heroine sleuth · fantasy
All books in this series ❯
Westwick Witches
by Colleen Cross
3.64 · 14 ratings
witches · fantasy · mystery · paranormal · length-short · humor · urban fantasy · heroine sleuth · audiobook · magic · suspense · psychics · mafia
All books in this series ❯