Supernatural Dating Agency

by Andie M. Long

4.17 · 38 ratings

vampires · fantasy · humor · paranormal · witches · shapeshifters · length-novella · audiobook · length-short · m-f · betrayal · magic · legends & fairy tales · demons

Supernatural Dating Agency: Similar series

The Beginner’s Guide to Necromancy: The Epilogues

by Hailey Edwards

4.18 · 151 ratings

shapeshifters · contemporary · m-f · audiobook · magic · urban fantasy · paranormal · vampires · fae · fantasy · humor · mystery · witches · new adult · found-family · length-short · length-novella · young adult · bad boys · horror

All books in this series ❯

Reapers of the Grimm Brotherhood

by Kel Carpenter

4.03 · 138 ratings

witches · fantasy · humor · werewolves · demons · magic · shapeshifters · vampires · paranormal · urban fantasy · contemporary · new adult · audiobook · poly · reverse harem · mystery · length-novella · m-f · glimpses-kisses · length-short

All books in this series ❯

Blood and Magic

by Lauretta Hignett

4.53 · 101 ratings

suspense · fantasy · humor · vampires · fae · shapeshifters · witches · urban fantasy · magic · audiobook · paranormal · demons · length-short · length-medium · werewolves · dystopian

All books in this series ❯

Cat McKenzie

by Lauren Dawes

4.21 · 88 ratings

shapeshifters · sassy heroine · fae · paranormal · maine · competent heroine · contemporary · bodyguard-heroine · alpha male · m-f · audiobook · length-short · fantasy · humor · mystery · age difference · werewolves · usa · demons · magic

All books in this series ❯

A Witch on the Rocks

by Lily Harper Hart

4.63 · 157 ratings

fantasy · mystery · length-short · witches · shapeshifters · audiobook · magic · paranormal · urban fantasy · humor · suspense · vampires · werewolves · fae · gifted heroine · contemporary

All books in this series ❯

Magic and Mayhem

by Robyn Peterman

4.16 · 67 ratings

audiobook · demons · paranormal · humor · fantasy · witches · shapeshifters · magic · urban fantasy · length-short · contemporary · werewolves · non-human-hero · vampires · mystery · sassy heroine · m-f · open-door · insta-love · from hate to love

All books in this series ❯

Howls Romance

by Celia Kyle

3.72 · 49 ratings

shapeshifters · fantasy · paranormal · audiobook · witches · humor · vampires · werewolves · contemporary · length-novella · m-f · poor heroine · fated-mates · pregnancy · non-human-hero · magic · alpha male

All books in this series ❯

Cocktails in Hell

by S.E. Babin

4.51 · 76 ratings

magic · length-short · fae · vampires · humor · fantasy · paranormal · demons · urban fantasy · witches · audiobook · shapeshifters · fated-mates · werewolves · alpha male · new adult

All books in this series ❯

Darkling Mage

by Nazri Noor

4.31 · 111 ratings

fantasy · audiobook · urban fantasy · magic · suspense · paranormal · queer · vampires · m-m · horror · humor · witches · ancient times · demons · historical · young adult · length-short · shapeshifters · length-medium · fae

All books in this series ❯

Dragons of the Bayou

by Candace Ayers

4.35 · 50 ratings

military · audiobook · shapeshifters · sports · demons · paranormal · angels · vampires · fantasy · humor · witches · length-novella · m-f · length-short

All books in this series ❯

Cybermates

by Candace Ayers

4.39 · 58 ratings

angels · vampires · humor · fantasy · witches · shapeshifters · sports · military · audiobook · urban fantasy · demons · paranormal · length-novella · werewolves · contemporary

All books in this series ❯

Mages of Mistvale

by Stella Rainbow

3.94 · 47 ratings

fated-mates · fantasy · magic · m-m · queer · paranormal · witches · humor · found-family · contemporary · non-human-hero · caretaking · small town · dual-pov · urban fantasy · sweet-hero · male-pov · height-difference · shapeshifters · audiobook

All books in this series ❯

Bloodmoon

by Briana Alisandra

3.74 · 46 ratings

urban fantasy · reverse harem · shapeshifters · vampires · fantasy · paranormal · young adult · audiobook · poly · age difference · witches · length-short · high-school · length-novella · fated-mates · new adult · m-f-m · werewolves · contemporary · magic

All books in this series ❯

Age of Night

by May Sage

4.01 · 45 ratings

fantasy · shapeshifters · audiobook · paranormal · urban fantasy · new adult · witches · length-novella · humor · vampires · fated-mates · length-short · angels · demons · sassy heroine · psychics · possessive hero · small town · non-human-heroine · lion shifter

All books in this series ❯

P.O.L.A.R.

by Candace Ayers

4.38 · 53 ratings

military · audiobook · demons · paranormal · angels · vampires · fantasy · humor · witches · shapeshifters · sports · length-novella · m-f · urban fantasy

All books in this series ❯

Big Bad Bite

by Jessie Lane

3.78 · 44 ratings

fantasy · paranormal · shapeshifters · witches · vampires · humor · demons · alpha male · length-medium · werewolves · audiobook · length-novella · magic · urban fantasy · virgin heroine · fated-mates · possessive hero · suspense · curvy heroine · strong heroine

All books in this series ❯

Real Men Love Witches

by Celia Kyle

4.12 · 25 ratings

vampires · fantasy · length-short · witches · shapeshifters · military · audiobook · paranormal · werewolves · humor · magic · mystery · contemporary · non-human-hero

All books in this series ❯

The Firehouse Feline

by Lacey Carter Andersen

4.03 · 29 ratings

witches · shapeshifters · humor · fantasy · paranormal · reverse harem · vampires · demons · multicultural · poly · length-short · length-novella · new adult · magic

All books in this series ❯

Witch Detectives

by Eve Paludan

3.82 · 49 ratings

fantasy · paranormal · audiobook · urban fantasy · witches · length-short · vampires · humor · shapeshifters · length-medium · mystery · suspense · magic · heroine sleuth

All books in this series ❯