Supernatural Dating Agency

by Andie M. Long

4.17 · 38 ratings

paranormal · vampires · fantasy · humor · witches · shapeshifters · audiobook · length-novella · length-short · standalone-first · m-f · first-in-series · legends & fairy tales · betrayal · magic · demons · standalone

Supernatural Dating Agency: Similar series

Dragon Goddess

by Sedona Ashe

4.08 · 107 ratings

fated-mates · reverse harem · length-short · age difference · fantasy · werewolves · magic · gifted heroine · shapeshifters · paranormal · dragon shifter · audiobook · m-f · poly · explicit-open-door · insta-love · first-person-pov · vampires · abduction · dual-pov

All books in this series ❯

The Beginner’s Guide to Necromancy: The Epilogues

by Hailey Edwards

4.17 · 157 ratings

fantasy · mystery · humor · vampires · fae · shapeshifters · witches · urban fantasy · magic · m-f · contemporary · audiobook · paranormal · new adult · length-short · found-family · bad boys · length-novella · young adult · suspense

All books in this series ❯

Federal Bureau of Magic

by Annabel Chase

4.43 · 334 ratings

vampires · fantasy · mystery · length-short · witches · magic · urban fantasy · paranormal · demons · shapeshifters · audiobook · humor · heroine sleuth · contemporary · werewolves · fae · monsters · standalone-first · first-in-series · open-door

All books in this series ❯

Witching Hour

by Christine Zane Thomas

4.15 · 161 ratings

paranormal · shapeshifters · witches · fantasy · mystery · audiobook · vampires · magic · length-short · heroine sleuth · werewolves · suspense · demons · urban fantasy · contemporary · fae · humor · length-medium · first-in-series · standalone-first

All books in this series ❯

Pet Psychic

by Erin Johnson

4.42 · 71 ratings

urban fantasy · magic · paranormal · heroine sleuth · mystery · fantasy · witches · shapeshifters · vampires · length-short · audiobook · humor · suspense · length-medium · fae

All books in this series ❯

Hannah Hickok

by Lily Harper Hart

4.56 · 56 ratings

paranormal · magic · audiobook · witches · length-short · humor · fantasy · vampires · shapeshifters · strong heroine · suspense · urban fantasy · first-in-series · standalone-first · new adult · mystery · boss & employee

All books in this series ❯

Mackenzie Grey: Trials

by Karina Espinosa

4.36 · 62 ratings

witches · length-short · shapeshifters · new adult · fae · vampires · fantasy · paranormal · explicit-open-door · werewolves · audiobook · urban fantasy · magic · humor · suspense · queer · mystery · standalone-first · first-in-series

All books in this series ❯

New Orleans Nocturnes

by Carrie Pulkinen

4.37 · 84 ratings

humor · fantasy · audiobook · paranormal · vampires · witches · length-short · shapeshifters · length-medium · demons · non-human-hero · angels · mystery · standalone-first · urban fantasy · first-in-series · open-door · child-death · non-human-heroine

All books in this series ❯

Real Men of Othercross

by Celia Kyle

4.04 · 59 ratings

fantasy · humor · shapeshifters · length-novella · paranormal · vampires · witches · military · urban fantasy · audiobook · europe · scandinavia · standalone-first · first-in-series · m-f

All books in this series ❯

Mages of Mistvale

by Stella Rainbow

3.94 · 48 ratings

magic · fated-mates · fantasy · paranormal · found-family · m-m · queer · sweet-hero · dual-pov · small town · male-pov · witches · humor · contemporary · non-human-hero · first-person-pov · caretaking · anal sex · urban fantasy · audiobook

All books in this series ❯

Age of Night

by May Sage

4.01 · 45 ratings

audiobook · fantasy · shapeshifters · paranormal · urban fantasy · length-novella · witches · new adult · fated-mates · length-short · humor · vampires · angels · possessive hero · psychics · werewolves · insta-love · demons · first-in-series · magic

All books in this series ❯

The Jamesburg Shifters

by Lynn Red

3.61 · 76 ratings

shapeshifters · fantasy · humor · paranormal · vampires · contemporary · bear shifter · witches · length-short · length-novella · angels · demons · m-f · military · bad boys · bikers · curvy heroine · erotica · standalone-first · cowboys

All books in this series ❯

Forbidden Shifters

by Selena Scott

4.14 · 40 ratings

shapeshifters · vampires · angels · paranormal · audiobook · multicultural · witches · length-short · humor · fantasy · demons · military · tortured hero · m-f · werewolves · explicit-open-door · alpha male · forced proximity · cold hero · class difference

All books in this series ❯

Down & Dirty Supernatural Cleaning Services

by Demitria Lunetta

4.37 · 62 ratings

paranormal · audiobook · urban fantasy · shapeshifters · vampires · fantasy · mystery · humor · length-short · fae · heroine sleuth · werewolves · magic · witches · suspense · contemporary · new adult · length-medium · strong heroine · length-novella

All books in this series ❯

Jackson Valley Shifters

by Candace Ayers

4.22 · 23 ratings

fantasy · paranormal · demons · angels · length-novella · military · audiobook · witches · shapeshifters · sports · vampires · humor · standalone · standalone-first · first-in-series

All books in this series ❯

Grim Dating

by Eve Langlais

3.95 · 27 ratings

paranormal · demons · audiobook · shapeshifters · witches · length-short · humor · fantasy · angels · vampires · urban fantasy · open-door · first-in-series · contemporary · standalone-first

All books in this series ❯

The Fate of the Fallen

by R. Phoenix

3.52 · 31 ratings

paranormal · m-m · queer · dark · witches · fantasy · vampires · urban fantasy · audiobook · shapeshifters · dystopian · werewolves · bdsm · length-novella · rape · abuse · magic · slavery · standalone-first · length-short

All books in this series ❯