A Paxton Park Mystery: Similar series
The Paper Magician
by Charlie N. Holmberg
3.83 · 310 ratings
new adult · victorian · historical · magic · fantasy · mystery · length-short · witches · steampunk · glimpses-kisses · audiobook · urban fantasy · paranormal · young adult · age difference · 20th century · science fiction · high fantasy · horror · m-f
All books in this series ❯
Mystic Bayou
by Molly Harper
3.91 · 495 ratings
humor · fantasy · witches · magic · usa · shapeshifters · contemporary · m-f · paranormal · competent heroine · louisiana · small town · north-america · sweet-hero · urban fantasy · mystery · fae · audiobook · third-person-pov · dragon shifter
All books in this series ❯
Shadow Guild: The Rebel
by Linsey Hall
4.07 · 161 ratings
audiobook · urban fantasy · magic · paranormal · vampires · fantasy · humor · witches · fae · length-short · suspense · fated-mates · new adult · m-f · mystery · alpha male · first-in-series · standalone-first · first-person-pov · legends & fairy tales
All books in this series ❯
Sponsored links / Remove ads
Dragon's Gift: The Huntress
by Linsey Hall
4.11 · 215 ratings
paranormal · audiobook · urban fantasy · magic · mystery · fantasy · demons · strong heroine · alpha male · witches · shapeshifters · new adult · vampires · contemporary · young adult · fae · suspense · length-short · length-medium · m-f
All books in this series ❯
Dragon's Gift: The Seeker
by Linsey Hall
4.33 · 130 ratings
paranormal · demons · young adult · audiobook · urban fantasy · magic · witches · shapeshifters · new adult · fantasy · strong heroine · contemporary · length-short · time travel · mystery · fae · suspense · length-medium · standalone-first · legends & fairy tales
All books in this series ❯
The City Between
by W.R. Gingell
4.37 · 257 ratings
audiobook · glimpses-kisses · fantasy · mystery · vampires · fae · young adult · paranormal · urban fantasy · magic · contemporary · shapeshifters · werewolves · suspense · new adult · length-short · dark · humor · length-medium · found-family
All books in this series ❯
How to Be the Best Damn Faery Godmother in the World (or Die Trying)
by Helen Harper
4.13 · 90 ratings
mystery · fantasy · fae · paranormal · urban fantasy · magic · audiobook · contemporary · suspense · length-short · humor · urban · standalone-first · witches · first-in-series
All books in this series ❯
Chameleon Assassin
by B.R. Kingsolver
4.30 · 101 ratings
vampires · fantasy · mystery · shapeshifters · urban fantasy · magic · paranormal · suspense · strong heroine · dystopian · humor · futuristic · historical · length-medium · length-short · audiobook · dark · werewolves · abuse · contemporary
All books in this series ❯
Foils and Fury
by Lauretta Hignett
4.47 · 58 ratings
paranormal · demons · humor · urban fantasy · magic · vampires · fantasy · mystery · suspense · length-short · monsters · strong heroine · length-medium · m-f · past-abuse · men in uniform · witches · shapeshifters · glimpses-kisses · single-mother
All books in this series ❯
Village Flower Shop
by Nancy Warren
4.35 · 70 ratings
witches · urban fantasy · magic · audiobook · paranormal · suspense · fantasy · mystery · shapeshifters · length-short · werewolves · heroine sleuth · first-in-series · standalone-first · length-medium · humor
All books in this series ❯
Great Witches Baking Show
by Nancy Warren
4.24 · 167 ratings
audiobook · paranormal · fantasy · mystery · witches · length-short · contemporary · magic · urban fantasy · suspense · heroine sleuth · length-novella · standalone-first · first-in-series · christmas
All books in this series ❯
Supernatural Speakeasy
by Lily Harper Hart
4.67 · 163 ratings
length-short · fantasy · paranormal · audiobook · shapeshifters · mystery · magic · witches · urban fantasy · vampires · humor · suspense · gifted heroine · new adult · mental illness · strong heroine · standalone-first · contemporary · first-in-series
All books in this series ❯
Bedknobs and Broomsticks
by Josh Lanyon
4.02 · 65 ratings
queer · mystery · fantasy · witches · m-m · contemporary · magic · paranormal · age difference · length-short · audiobook · urban fantasy · open-door · suspense · first-person-pov · christmas · standalone-first · hurt-comfort · men in uniform · insta-love
All books in this series ❯
Witching Hour
by Christine Zane Thomas
4.15 · 161 ratings
shapeshifters · witches · fantasy · mystery · paranormal · audiobook · vampires · length-short · heroine sleuth · magic · werewolves · suspense · demons · urban fantasy · contemporary · humor · fae · length-medium · first-in-series · standalone-first
All books in this series ❯
The Paranormal PI Files
by Jenna Wolfhart
4.07 · 62 ratings
fantasy · paranormal · vampires · shapeshifters · urban fantasy · audiobook · mystery · humor · fae · magic · suspense · cliffhanger · length-short · young adult · length-medium · reverse harem · first-in-series · poly · standalone-first · strong heroine
All books in this series ❯
Matchmaker Monster Romance
by Luna Joya
3.83 · 56 ratings
magic · california · audiobook · m-f · monsters · fantasy · paranormal · contemporary · witches · fated-mates · demons · sweet heroine · abduction · possessive hero · explicit-open-door · non-human-hero · shapeshifters · age difference · forced proximity · humor
All books in this series ❯
Four Ways to Fate
by Sara C. Roethle
4.09 · 70 ratings
urban fantasy · magic · fantasy · audiobook · paranormal · gifted heroine · first-person-pov · mystery · monsters · reverse harem · m-f · poly · competent heroine · fae · insta-love · non-human-hero · fighters · mental-trauma · explicit-open-door · bodyguard-hero
All books in this series ❯
Tangled Fae
by Sarah K.L. Wilson
4.24 · 68 ratings
gifted heroine · first-person-pov · cruel hero · non-human-hero · dark · graphic-violence · sunny hero · survival · grumpy sunshine · strong heroine · slow burn · high fantasy · vengeance · disabilities and marks · magic · horror · fantasy · mystery · humor · forced proximity
All books in this series ❯
Offbeat Crimes
by Angel Martinez
3.98 · 81 ratings
contemporary · paranormal · queer · fantasy · m-m · urban fantasy · magic · men in uniform · mystery · humor · north-america · usa · vampires · length-short · pennsylvania · length-novella · suspense · open-door · standalone-first · first-in-series
All books in this series ❯
The Gargoyles of Arrington
by Jenn Burke
4.13 · 34 ratings
magic · age difference · mystery · fantasy · length-short · urban fantasy · paranormal · queer · shapeshifters · m-m · contemporary · hurt-comfort · suspense · friends to lovers · standalone-first · first-in-series · first-person-pov · open-door · dark · explicit-open-door
All books in this series ❯
Oxford Magic Kitten Mysteries
by Rosemary A. Johns
4.58 · 40 ratings
paranormal · shapeshifters · mystery · fantasy · witches · demons · magic · urban fantasy · length-short · suspense · humor · heroine sleuth · audiobook · dragon shifter · length-medium · standalone-first · first-in-series · fae · vampires
All books in this series ❯
Carnival of Mysteries
by L.A. Witt
4.15 · 88 ratings
queer · fantasy · m-m · paranormal · contemporary · magic · suspense · mystery · urban fantasy · length-short · length-medium · audiobook · age difference · humor · historical · war · demons · standalone-first · abuse · dark
All books in this series ❯
The Accidental Reaper
by Misty Evans
4.18 · 11 ratings
paranormal · fantasy · vampires · witches · magic · mystery · shapeshifters · length-short · urban fantasy · young adult · suspense · demons · fae · first-in-series · contemporary · standalone-first · length-medium
All books in this series ❯
Entwined Fates
by Juliane Maibach
4.24 · 25 ratings
high-school · bodyguard-hero · college · urban fantasy · m-f · california · audiobook · contemporary · strong heroine · young adult · sassy heroine · magic · first-person-pov · other-man-woman · dark · mystery · heroine sleuth · fantasy · third-person-pov · paranormal
All books in this series ❯