Extraordinarily Yours

by J. Kenner

3.57 · 67 ratings

fantasy · humor · paranormal · magic · length-medium · urban fantasy · superheroes · contemporary · shapeshifters · length-novella · suspense

Extraordinarily Yours: Similar series

Rivers of London

by Ben Aaronovitch

4.09 · 512 ratings

contemporary · urban fantasy · paranormal · magic · fantasy · mystery · audiobook · suspense · humor · witches · fae · horror · length-medium · young adult · vampires · historical · monsters · dark · queer · gifted heroine

All books in this series ❯

Arcane Mage

by T.S. Snow

4.14 · 249 ratings

magic · first-person-pov · second chances · bodyguard-hero · humor · fantasy · possessive hero · reverse harem · urban fantasy · dual-pov · poly · audiobook · contemporary · paranormal · office · superheroes · explicit-open-door · new adult · friends to lovers · length-medium

All books in this series ❯

Highland Magic

by Helen Harper

4.23 · 161 ratings

new adult · fantasy · fae · strong heroine · demons · paranormal · magic · urban fantasy · audiobook · contemporary · royalty · dystopian · young adult · suspense · length-medium · mystery · humor · alpha male · united-kingdom · war

All books in this series ❯

Seven

by Dannika Dark

4.17 · 384 ratings

urban fantasy · vampires · paranormal · shapeshifters · fantasy · audiobook · werewolves · alpha male · contemporary · m-f · new adult · demons · multicultural · length-medium · witches · psychics · magic · fated-mates · angels · open-door

All books in this series ❯

Hell's Library

by A.J. Hackwith

3.92 · 112 ratings

magic · urban fantasy · contemporary · audiobook · paranormal · demons · length-medium · fantasy · mystery · humor · queer · found-family · death · horror · high fantasy · m-m · m-f · young adult · suspense · f-f

All books in this series ❯

Haven Ever After

by Hazel Mack

3.94 · 293 ratings

paranormal · magic · fated-mates · dual-pov · first-person-pov · audiobook · monsters · humor · fantasy · non-human-hero · found-family · creative-anatomy · m-f · alpha male · massachusetts · independent heroine · urban fantasy · length-medium · small town · contemporary

All books in this series ❯

Gang of Ghouls

by Eva Chase

4.05 · 142 ratings

paranormal · fantasy · poly · audiobook · contemporary · urban fantasy · dual-pov · friends to lovers · nerdy-hero · magic · first-person-pov · sunny hero · reverse harem · praise-kink · possessive hero · humor · new adult · length-medium · suspense · explicit-plentiful

All books in this series ❯

A Wishcraft Mystery

by Heather Blake

4.19 · 250 ratings

witches · length-medium · paranormal · mystery · fantasy · urban fantasy · magic · audiobook · contemporary · heroine sleuth · humor · horror · suspense

All books in this series ❯

Gilded Blood

by Rachel Rener

4.25 · 132 ratings

fantasy · new adult · urban fantasy · audiobook · paranormal · humor · magic · open-door · length-medium · friends to lovers · fae · m-f · contemporary · forced proximity · first-person-pov · non-human-hero · sassy heroine · boss & employee · vampires · sweet-hero

All books in this series ❯

Scales 'n' Spells

by A.J. Sherwood

4.13 · 123 ratings

explicit-open-door · queer · shapeshifters · m-m · urban fantasy · dual-pov · multicultural · paranormal · fantasy · age difference · fated-mates · male-pov · magic · germany · third-person-pov · dragon shifter · anal sex · non-human-hero · length-medium · found-family

All books in this series ❯

Jane True

by Nicole Peeler

3.93 · 228 ratings

fantasy · urban fantasy · paranormal · fae · vampires · contemporary · shapeshifters · mystery · length-medium · magic · audiobook · witches · humor · north-america · usa · length-novella · maine · young adult · love triangle · massachusetts

All books in this series ❯

Two Broomsticks Gas & Grill Witch

by Amanda M. Lee

4.58 · 241 ratings

witches · mystery · fantasy · paranormal · magic · audiobook · urban fantasy · length-medium · shapeshifters · humor · contemporary · vampires · length-short · suspense · werewolves · m-f · gifted heroine · monsters · fae · christmas

All books in this series ❯

Le Beau Brothers

by V.A. Dold

4.07 · 129 ratings

shapeshifters · paranormal · fantasy · werewolves · vampires · contemporary · length-medium · curvy heroine · abuse · urban fantasy · humor · magic · angst · m-f · cowboys · length-short · witches · military · western · demons

All books in this series ❯

Witchlore

by Hazel Beck

3.85 · 72 ratings

small town · north-america · m-f · contemporary · audiobook · paranormal · fantasy · humor · witches · first-person-pov · magic · missouri · length-medium · usa · urban fantasy · political-intrigue · dual-pov · young adult · cold hero · male-pov

All books in this series ❯

Witchless in Seattle

by Dakota Cassidy

4.16 · 204 ratings

paranormal · magic · contemporary · witches · mystery · fantasy · humor · audiobook · heroine sleuth · length-medium · urban fantasy · suspense · length-novella · monsters · length-short · demons · christmas

All books in this series ❯

Fae Out of Water

by E.J. Russell

3.77 · 46 ratings

m-m · from hate to love · fae · queer · political-intrigue · paranormal · audiobook · contemporary · oregon · witches · male-pov · humor · fantasy · mystery · usa · magic · length-medium · north-america · disabilities and marks · tortured hero

All books in this series ❯

Magical Romantic Comedies

by R.J. Blain

4.36 · 201 ratings

fantasy · urban fantasy · audiobook · humor · paranormal · length-medium · magic · shapeshifters · m-f · contemporary · werewolves · vampires · mystery · demons · usa · north-america · length-long · strong heroine · length-novella · alpha male

All books in this series ❯

Mythmatched World

by E.J. Russell

4.02 · 211 ratings

magic · fantasy · contemporary · paranormal · queer · m-m · humor · audiobook · urban fantasy · north-america · usa · male-pov · oregon · shapeshifters · third-person-pov · mystery · witches · fae · non-human-hero · multicultural

All books in this series ❯

Mark of Nexus

by Carrie Butler

3.79 · 51 ratings

paranormal · fantasy · humor · audiobook · urban fantasy · new adult · length-medium · young adult · contemporary · magic · college · length-long · strong heroine · alpha male · m-f · friends to lovers

All books in this series ❯

Heroine Complex

by Sarah Kuhn

3.84 · 86 ratings

fantasy · superheroes · urban fantasy · audiobook · contemporary · paranormal · humor · mystery · young adult · demons · found-family · new adult · science fiction · length-medium · length-long · magic · m-f · beta-hero · christmas · time travel

All books in this series ❯

Monster MAS*H

by Angie Fox

3.94 · 59 ratings

vampires · fantasy · military · urban fantasy · paranormal · fae · length-medium · demons · shapeshifters · contemporary · magic · humor · audiobook · legends & fairy tales · suspense · length-short · m-f · competent heroine · werewolves

All books in this series ❯