Extraordinarily Yours

by J. Kenner

3.57 · 67 ratings

humor · fantasy · paranormal · length-medium · magic · superheroes · urban fantasy · contemporary · shapeshifters · suspense · length-novella

Extraordinarily Yours: Similar series

Ex Hex

by Erin Sterling

3.62 · 353 ratings

contemporary · urban fantasy · paranormal · witches · magic · humor · mystery · fantasy · new adult · cold hero · competent heroine · forced proximity · grumpy sunshine · small town · m-f · dual-pov · length-medium · open-door · gifted heroine · from hate to love

All books in this series ❯

Hex Hall

by Rachel Hawkins

3.92 · 473 ratings

contemporary · shapeshifters · fantasy · mystery · length-medium · magic · demons · witches · paranormal · vampires · fae · werewolves · urban fantasy · love triangle · young adult · other-man-woman · georgia · gifted heroine · bad boys · humor

All books in this series ❯

Fire and Ice Trilogy

by K.F. Breene

3.98 · 218 ratings

alpha male · demons · m-f · magic · gifted heroine · shapeshifters · fantasy · from hate to love · mystery · humor · contemporary · werewolves · urban fantasy · strong heroine · non-human-hero · witches · monsters · vampires · paranormal · fae

All books in this series ❯

Titan

by Jennifer L. Armentrout

4.27 · 264 ratings

bad boys · humor · fighters · length-medium · new adult · fantasy · tall-heroine · gifted heroine · explicit-open-door · magic · possessive hero · alpha male · m-f · demons · paranormal · non-human-hero · urban fantasy · non-human-heroine · curvy heroine · contemporary

All books in this series ❯

The Mediator

by Meg Cabot

4.06 · 562 ratings

fantasy · paranormal · young adult · urban fantasy · contemporary · humor · mystery · magic · science fiction · high-school · futuristic · length-medium · glimpses-kisses · time travel · new adult · gifted heroine · death · m-f · suspense · horror

All books in this series ❯

A Love Story

by Christopher Moore

3.82 · 185 ratings

fantasy · contemporary · urban fantasy · young adult · paranormal · vampires · horror · death · historical · length-medium · humor · mystery · behind-doors · monsters · magic · ancient times · non-human-heroine · north-america · suspense · sassy heroine

All books in this series ❯

The Beginner's Guide to Necromancy

by Hailey Edwards

4.27 · 227 ratings

urban fantasy · magic · m-f · contemporary · paranormal · vampires · fantasy · witches · mystery · humor · length-medium · shapeshifters · fae · new adult · strong heroine · betrayal · other-man-woman · friends to lovers · love triangle · alpha male

All books in this series ❯

Arcane Mage

by T.S. Snow

4.18 · 213 ratings

second chances · fantasy · contemporary · urban fantasy · paranormal · reverse harem · office · bodyguard-hero · poly · magic · possessive hero · dual-pov · humor · first-person-pov · superheroes · new adult · friends to lovers · explicit-open-door · from hate to love · somnophilia

All books in this series ❯

My Fair Godmother

by Janette Rallison

3.97 · 123 ratings

legends & fairy tales · magic · paranormal · fantasy · contemporary · young adult · historical · length-medium · fae · time travel · urban fantasy · christian · humor · medieval · length-long · royalty · clean · mystery · science fiction

All books in this series ❯

Black Hat Bureau

by Hailey Edwards

4.30 · 303 ratings

demons · urban fantasy · magic · witches · fantasy · paranormal · shapeshifters · fae · mystery · vampires · contemporary · length-medium · length-short · humor · open-door · monsters · suspense · new adult · royalty · found-family

All books in this series ❯

Glimmer Lake

by Elizabeth Hunter

4.34 · 88 ratings

fantasy · magic · urban fantasy · mystery · paranormal · contemporary · length-medium · christian · suspense · humor · behind-doors · length-short · single-mother

All books in this series ❯

Umbra Hunters

by B.M. Clemton

4.30 · 90 ratings

forced proximity · reverse harem · small town · sweet-hero · slow burn · north-america · strong heroine · tortured hero · fantasy · from hate to love · independent heroine · found-family · age difference · magic · demons · paranormal · royalty · height-difference · contemporary · first-person-pov

All books in this series ❯

Good to the Last Death

by Robyn Peterman

4.43 · 259 ratings

paranormal · fantasy · demons · urban fantasy · contemporary · humor · magic · mystery · length-medium · length-short · witches · dark · suspense · angels · science fiction · vampires · mature couple · glimpses-kisses · from hate to love · amish

All books in this series ❯

Witchlore

by Hazel Beck

3.71 · 58 ratings

contemporary · magic · length-medium · paranormal · humor · witches · fantasy · urban fantasy · open-door · small town · m-f · second chances · missouri · legends & fairy tales · death · usa · young adult · found-family · pregnancy · mystery

All books in this series ❯

Not Dead Yet

by Jenn Burke

3.90 · 49 ratings

magic · male-pov · m-m · vampires · paranormal · suspense · demi-sexual-hero · contemporary · north-america · non-human-hero · urban fantasy · height-difference · queer · cold hero · fantasy · first-person-pov · canada · mystery · humor · latinx-mc

All books in this series ❯

Welcome To Midlife Magic

by Lauretta Hignett

4.40 · 60 ratings

length-medium · urban fantasy · mature couple · humor · fantasy · contemporary · paranormal · fae · magic · glimpses-kisses · dark · behind-doors

All books in this series ❯

Broken Ashes

by Nikita Parmenter

4.45 · 63 ratings

fantasy · humor · possessive hero · m-f · paranormal · non-human-heroine · found-family · neurodivergent · alpha male · urban fantasy · first-person-pov · shapeshifters · tortured heroine · caretaking · cold hero · past-child-neglect · cheerful heroine · fighters · dual-pov · insta-love

All books in this series ❯

Fae Out of Water

by E.J. Russell

3.84 · 37 ratings

m-m · paranormal · fae · contemporary · urban fantasy · queer · fantasy · length-medium · humor · witches · magic · death · multicultural · male-pov · third-person-pov · vampires · hurt-comfort · rape-non-mc · sweet-hero · grumpy sunshine

All books in this series ❯

Heroine Complex

by Sarah Kuhn

3.84 · 86 ratings

fantasy · urban fantasy · superheroes · contemporary · paranormal · demons · young adult · humor · mystery · magic · found-family · length-long · science fiction · length-medium · new adult · length-novella · m-f · christmas · beta-hero · vampires

All books in this series ❯