The Amish Fairytale

by Ashley Emma

4.58 · 12 ratings

amish · christian · audiobook · western · mystery · historical western · historical · first-in-series · standalone-first · contemporary

The Amish Fairytale: Similar series

The Gold Seer Trilogy

by Rae Carson

3.88 · 110 ratings

western · fantasy · historical western · audiobook · historical · urban fantasy · paranormal · young adult · magic · mystery · length-long · found-family · length-medium · science fiction · abuse · suspense · death · futuristic · north-america · multicultural

All books in this series ❯

Yukon Quest

by Tracie Peterson

4.06 · 71 ratings

audiobook · length-medium · historical · christian · western · historical western · suspense · first-in-series · mystery · standalone-first

All books in this series ❯

Daughters of Caleb Bender

by Dale Cramer

4.25 · 62 ratings

amish · clean · length-medium · audiobook · christian · historical · historical western · western · first-in-series · suspense · latinx-mc · standalone-first

All books in this series ❯

Heart of the Prairie

by Kim Vogel Sawyer

3.97 · 147 ratings

audiobook · historical · length-medium · christian · amish · western · historical western · clean · mystery · contemporary · first-in-series · standalone-first

All books in this series ❯

The Amish of Apple Grove

by Lori Copeland

3.78 · 44 ratings

christian · amish · clean · kansas · arkansas · usa · length-medium · western · north-america · audiobook · cowboys · historical western · historical · contemporary · first-in-series · standalone-first · length-novella

All books in this series ❯

Colorado Cowgirls

by Jody Hedlund

4.46 · 37 ratings

western · christian · cowboys · historical western · audiobook · historical · suspense · length-short · super rich hero · glimpses-kisses · length-medium · tycoon · cold hero · forbidden love · boss & employee · standalone-first · first-in-series · behind-doors · grumpy sunshine

All books in this series ❯

Secrets of Sweetwater Crossing

by Amanda Cabot

4.28 · 29 ratings

historical · length-medium · christian · audiobook · western · historical western · mystery · first-in-series · standalone-first · amish · dual-pov · second chances · suspense

All books in this series ❯

The Pinkerton Matchmaker

by Rebecca Connolly

4.40 · 20 ratings

western · historical western · audiobook · historical · marriage of convenience · length-short · suspense · christian · mystery · humor · from hate to love · length-medium

All books in this series ❯

Treasures of the Earth

by Kimberley Woodhouse

4.33 · 25 ratings

historical · length-medium · mystery · christian · audiobook · western · first-in-series · standalone-first · historical western · suspense · slow burn · second chances

All books in this series ❯

Quaking Heart

by Janith Hooper

4.27 · 17 ratings

western · historical · historical western · christian · audiobook · length-medium · montana · length-long · first-in-series · north-america · standalone-first · usa · suspense

All books in this series ❯

Covert Police Detectives Unit

by Ashley Emma

4.44 · 41 ratings

audiobook · amish · christian · western · historical western · historical · mystery · young adult · suspense · first-in-series · standalone-first

All books in this series ❯

The Pinkerton Matchmaker

by Laura Beers

4.61 · 18 ratings

audiobook · suspense · western · mystery · historical · christian · heroine sleuth · victorian · historical western · length-short · length-novella

All books in this series ❯

The Pinkerton Matchmaker

by Patricia PacJac Carroll

4.32 · 22 ratings

christian · western · audiobook · historical · historical western · length-novella · mystery · suspense · anthologies · length-short · victorian

All books in this series ❯

The Pinkerton Matchmaker

by Marie Higgins

4.51 · 35 ratings

historical western · historical · western · audiobook · length-novella · christian · mystery · victorian · suspense · humor · christmas · length-short

All books in this series ❯

The Pinkerton Matchmaker

by Lynn Donovan

4.40 · 15 ratings

length-novella · mystery · western · historical western · historical · christian · audiobook · humor · suspense

All books in this series ❯

Romance at the Gilded Age Resorts

by Denise Weimer

4.42 · 31 ratings

christian · historical · length-short · audiobook · historical western · western · mystery · suspense · christmas · standalone-first · military · regency · first-in-series · clean

All books in this series ❯

The Pinkerton Matchmaker

by Christine Sterling

4.57 · 21 ratings

historical western · historical · western · length-novella · christian · audiobook · mystery · suspense · victorian

All books in this series ❯

The Proxy Brides

by Marisa Masterson

4.67 · 9 ratings

historical · western · audiobook · historical western · christian · suspense · length-short · victorian · length-novella

All books in this series ❯

Westward Wanted

by Crystal Anne Tilden

3.88 · 8 ratings

western · christian · audiobook · historical · historical western · length-short · first-in-series · contemporary · cowboys · length-novella · standalone-first

All books in this series ❯

Westward Home and Hearts Mail-Order Brides

by Marisa Masterson

4.63 · 8 ratings

western · historical · historical western · christian · length-novella · audiobook · length-short · victorian

All books in this series ❯