The Amish Fairytale: Similar series
Providence
by Alissa Johnson
3.75 · 83 ratings
virgin heroine · regency · length-medium · historical · independent heroine · third-person-pov · humor · mystery · class difference · open-door · possessive hero · competent heroine · m-f · audiobook · forced proximity · slow burn · strong heroine · neurodivergent · tortured hero · friends to lovers
All books in this series ❯
Daughters of Caleb Bender
by Dale Cramer
4.25 · 62 ratings
historical · amish · clean · length-medium · christian · audiobook · historical western · western · suspense · latinx-mc
All books in this series ❯
Land of the Lone Star
by Tracie Peterson
4.02 · 52 ratings
length-medium · historical western · audiobook · christian · western · historical · american civil war · cowboys
All books in this series ❯
Sponsored links
Heart of the Prairie
by Kim Vogel Sawyer
3.97 · 147 ratings
christian · audiobook · historical · length-medium · historical western · western · amish · clean · contemporary · mystery
All books in this series ❯
The Amish of Apple Grove
by Lori Copeland
3.78 · 44 ratings
amish · clean · christian · kansas · arkansas · north-america · western · usa · length-medium · historical western · audiobook · cowboys · historical · contemporary · length-novella
All books in this series ❯
Prescott Pioneers
by Karen Baney
4.13 · 32 ratings
historical · audiobook · length-medium · western · christian · historical western · usa · arizona · north-america
All books in this series ❯
Secrets of Sweetwater Crossing
by Amanda Cabot
4.28 · 29 ratings
christian · audiobook · historical · length-medium · historical western · western · mystery · dual-pov · suspense · amish · second chances
All books in this series ❯
The Pinkerton Matchmaker
by Rebecca Connolly
4.40 · 20 ratings
audiobook · historical · western · historical western · marriage of convenience · length-short · suspense · mystery · christian · from hate to love · length-medium · humor
All books in this series ❯
Cowboy Mountain Christmas, Small Town Sweet Romance
by Jessie Gussman
4.62 · 26 ratings
western · christian · audiobook · historical · historical western · length-novella · humor · contemporary · betrayal · length-short
All books in this series ❯
Treasures of the Earth
by Kimberley Woodhouse
4.33 · 25 ratings
historical · length-medium · audiobook · christian · mystery · western · suspense · historical western · second chances · slow burn
All books in this series ❯
Covert Police Detectives Unit
by Ashley Emma
4.44 · 41 ratings
christian · amish · audiobook · western · historical · historical western · mystery · young adult · suspense
All books in this series ❯
The Pinkerton Matchmaker
by Laura Beers
4.61 · 18 ratings
suspense · audiobook · historical · western · mystery · christian · heroine sleuth · victorian · historical western · length-short · length-novella
All books in this series ❯
The Pinkerton Matchmaker
by Patricia PacJac Carroll
4.32 · 22 ratings
christian · western · audiobook · historical western · length-novella · historical · mystery · suspense · victorian · length-short · anthologies
All books in this series ❯
The Pinkerton Matchmaker
by Marie Higgins
4.51 · 35 ratings
historical western · historical · audiobook · western · length-novella · christian · mystery · victorian · suspense · humor · christmas · length-short
All books in this series ❯
The Pinkerton Matchmaker
by Lynn Donovan
4.40 · 15 ratings
length-novella · mystery · western · historical · historical western · audiobook · suspense · humor · christian
All books in this series ❯
Romance at the Gilded Age Resorts
by Denise Weimer
4.42 · 31 ratings
length-short · historical · christian · audiobook · western · historical western · mystery · suspense · christmas · military · regency · clean
All books in this series ❯
The Pinkerton Matchmaker
by Christine Sterling
4.57 · 21 ratings
historical · western · historical western · length-novella · christian · mystery · audiobook · suspense · victorian
All books in this series ❯
Cowboy Confidential
by Lori Wilde
4.40 · 10 ratings
audiobook · western · christian · humor · historical western · historical · length-short · length-medium · contemporary · cowboys · suspense
All books in this series ❯
An Appleton, WV Romantic Mystery
by Carole Brown
4.00 · 4 ratings
suspense · christian · audiobook · historical western · length-medium · historical · heroine sleuth · western · length-short · christmas
All books in this series ❯
A Breath Without Life Novel
by Janith Hooper
5.00 · 4 ratings
western · historical · historical western · christian · audiobook · length-medium · boss & employee · age difference · m-f · 20th century
All books in this series ❯
Of Gold & Blood
by Jenny Wheeler
4.00 · 8 ratings
historical · historical western · western · christian · mystery · length-medium · suspense · audiobook · length-novella · death · victorian · latinx-mc · glimpses-kisses · single-mother
All books in this series ❯