Pizza Shop Exorcist: Similar romance series

Crescent City

by Sarah J. Maas

4.22 · 1523 ratings

magic · slavery · fae · paranormal · torture-scs · competent heroine · sassy heroine · curvy heroine · werewolves · non-human-hero · non-human-heroine · shapeshifters · war · abuse-non-mc · m-f · torture-mcs · witches · vampires · third-person-pov · angels

All books in this series ❯

Ruthless Boys of the Zodiac

by Caroline Peckham

4.29 · 854 ratings

cruel hero · shapeshifters · dark · poly · sunny hero · himbo · paranormal · fae · college · mafia · werewolves · dragon shifter · mystery · bad boys · fated-mates · fantasy · new adult · from hate to love · alpha male · lion shifter

All books in this series ❯

Cruel Shifterverse

by Jasmine Mas

4.06 · 953 ratings

reverse harem · from hate to love · gifted heroine · past-child-abuse · magic · dangerous heroine · misogyny · mental illness · male-pov · warrior-heroine · competent heroine · explicit-open-door · first-person-pov · mental-trauma · poly · dual-pov · forced proximity · monsters · strong heroine · slow burn

All books in this series ❯

Monstrous Matches

by Lillian Lark

4.00 · 918 ratings

magic · non-human-hero · first-person-pov · dual-pov · monsters · creative-anatomy · urban fantasy · fantasy · fated-mates · paranormal · contemporary · m-f · praise-kink · explicit-plentiful · anal sex · breeding · witches · gifted heroine · insta-love · double-penetration

All books in this series ❯

Coven of Bones

by Harper L. Woods

3.71 · 268 ratings

fantasy · vampires · paranormal · fated-mates · independent heroine · gifted heroine · super rich hero · new adult · past-child-abuse · from hate to love · abuse · arranged marriage · victim-blaming · mystery · bad boys · spanking · length-medium · age difference · usa · found-family

All books in this series ❯

Darkmore Penitentiary

by Caroline Peckham

4.33 · 349 ratings

fae · paranormal · dangerous heroine · contemporary · werewolves · competent heroine · sassy heroine · disabilities and marks · angst · shapeshifters · first-person-pov · tortured heroine · poly · dark · dual-pov · vampires · reverse harem · outlaw-heroine · tortured hero · urban fantasy

All books in this series ❯

Cursed Legacies

by Morgan B. Lee

4.34 · 334 ratings

tortured hero · shapeshifters · tortured heroine · teacher-hero · cold hero · abuse-non-mc · past-child-neglect · possessive hero · mental-trauma · poly · sunny hero · past-abuse · college · dangerous heroine · fae · paranormal · sassy heroine · warrior-heroine · mental illness · dragon shifter

All books in this series ❯

Heart Hassle

by Raven Kennedy

4.28 · 417 ratings

paranormal · fae · contemporary · insta-love · humor · fantasy · demons · magic · neurodivergent · curvy heroine · non-human-hero · height-difference · non-human-heroine · sassy heroine · cheerful heroine · caretaking · cold hero · first-person-pov · shapeshifters · poly

All books in this series ❯

The Arrow Hart Academy

by Hannah Haze

4.17 · 368 ratings

bad boys · new adult · fantasy · independent heroine · fated-mates · super rich hero · alpha male · black-mc · found-family · age difference · bodyguard-hero · forced proximity · urban fantasy · slow burn · graphic-violence · disabilities and marks · fighters · shapeshifters · tortured heroine · cold hero

All books in this series ❯

Witchwood Boys

by C.M. Stunich

4.21 · 214 ratings

somnophilia · urban fantasy · strong heroine · graphic-violence · tortured hero · north-america · praise-kink · witches · small town · forced proximity · reverse harem · fetish · found-family · child-death · magic · death · california · horror · alpha male · fantasy

All books in this series ❯

The Forgotten Angel

by Merri Bright

4.35 · 206 ratings

poly · demons · angels · reverse harem · paranormal · fantasy · fated-mates · humor · urban fantasy · dual-pov · insta-love · mental-trauma · first-person-pov · bdsm · caretaking · angst · competent heroine · commander · suspense · non-human-hero

All books in this series ❯

A Monstrous World

by Jillian West

4.22 · 203 ratings

fated-mates · fantasy · bad boys · age difference · found-family · alpha male · monsters · vampires · virgin hero · creative-anatomy · urban fantasy · cold hero · shapeshifters · pregnancy · possessive hero · paranormal · fae · contemporary · werewolves · height-difference

All books in this series ❯

A Demon's Guide to the Afterlife

by Kel Carpenter

4.13 · 145 ratings

tortured hero · shapeshifters · tortured heroine · first-person-pov · dual-pov · possessive hero · poly · m-f · paranormal · fae · sassy heroine · mental illness · texas · werewolves · non-human-heroine · contemporary · fantasy · fated-mates · gifted heroine · humor

All books in this series ❯

The Mate Games: Pestilence

by Meg Anne

4.30 · 219 ratings

super rich hero · fated-mates · fantasy · arranged marriage · monsters · vampires · urban fantasy · paranormal · contemporary · witches · fetish · reverse harem · aristocratic heroine · bdsm · first-person-pov · dual-pov · poly · suspense · bisexual · alpha male

All books in this series ❯

Magic on Main Street

by K.M. Shea

4.50 · 126 ratings

paranormal · fae · usa · age difference · death · magic · alpha male · fantasy · from hate to love · super rich hero · wisconsin · gifted heroine · humor · independent heroine · shy heroine · slow burn · north-america · urban fantasy · strong heroine · tortured hero

All books in this series ❯

The Mate Games: Death

by K. Loraine

4.27 · 146 ratings

dragon shifter · suspense · contemporary · curvy heroine · non-human-hero · non-human-heroine · paranormal · fae · dual-pov · poly · possessive hero · scotland · first-person-pov · shapeshifters · tortured heroine · vikings · pirates · witches · monsters · vampires

All books in this series ❯

Deals with Demons

by Stacia Stark

4.11 · 209 ratings

urban fantasy · witches · demons · magic · fantasy · humor · paranormal · fae · age difference · alpha male · sassy heroine · strong heroine · dystopian · found-family · independent heroine · super rich hero · from hate to love · competent heroine · contemporary · non-human-hero

All books in this series ❯

Syndicate Mafia

by Kira Stanley

4.18 · 77 ratings

demons · nerdy-hero · dangerous heroine · paranormal · fae · suspense · competent heroine · werewolves · contemporary · mafia · first-person-pov · shapeshifters · dual-pov · possessive hero · poly · reverse harem · vampires · fantasy · fated-mates · magic

All books in this series ❯

Umbra Hunters

by B.M. Clemton

4.30 · 90 ratings

possessive hero · poly · dual-pov · small town · sunny hero · disabilities and marks · shapeshifters · tortured heroine · first-person-pov · canada · cold hero · height-difference · contemporary · royalty · paranormal · magic · demons · found-family · age difference · fantasy

All books in this series ❯