Supernaturalette: Similar romance series

Cruel Shifterverse

by Jasmine Mas

3.98 · 1641 ratings

abuse · torture-mcs · non-human-hero · warrior-heroine · fighters · explicit-open-door · military · possessive hero · sweet-hero · past-child-abuse · tortured hero · immortal-heroine · monsters · super rich hero · early-20s-fmc · humor · fantasy · forced proximity · menage · competent heroine

All books in this series ❯

Supernaturals of Castle Academy

by Tessa Hale

3.81 · 242 ratings

rhode-island · misogyny · fantasy · mystery · forced proximity · fated-mates · reverse harem · super rich hero · witches · independent heroine · magic · second chances · demons · length-medium · usa · werewolves · nerdy-hero · high-school · abuse · shapeshifters

All books in this series ❯

The Mate Games: Pestilence

by Meg Anne

4.24 · 344 ratings

paranormal · aristocratic heroine · fetish · fantasy · monsters · super rich hero · arranged marriage · bdsm · first-person-pov · vampires · dual-pov · urban fantasy · witches · reverse harem · fated-mates · contemporary · poly · suspense · possessive hero · non-human-hero

All books in this series ❯

Nora Jacobs

by Jackie May

4.16 · 256 ratings

vampires · urban fantasy · sweet-hero · strong heroine · first-person-pov · past-sexual-abuse · fae · abuse · sassy heroine · shapeshifters · new adult · alpha male · poly · contemporary · paranormal · dragon shifter · fantasy · mystery · reverse harem · heroine sleuth

All books in this series ❯

Fate Hollow Academy

by Lyra Winters

3.98 · 219 ratings

sweet-hero · dual-pov · sweet heroine · vampires · virgin hero · friends to lovers · tortured hero · teacher-hero · first-person-pov · virgin heroine · cheerful heroine · possessive hero · praise-kink · war · contemporary · audiobook · alpha male · poly · college · dragon shifter

All books in this series ❯

Strange Angels

by Lili St. Crow

4.05 · 271 ratings

vampires · shapeshifters · audiobook · contemporary · urban fantasy · paranormal · strong heroine · young adult · mystery · fantasy · other-man-woman · magic · love triangle · demons · werewolves · length-medium · poly · college · witches · reverse harem

All books in this series ❯

The Storm Dragons' Mate

by M. Sinclair

4.03 · 198 ratings

poly · slut-shaming · audiobook · possessive hero · insta-love · non-human-hero · explicit-open-door · first-person-pov · caretaking · friends to lovers · angst · slow burn · dual-pov · hurt-comfort · independent heroine · fated-mates · fantasy · forced proximity · mystery · misogyny

All books in this series ❯

Prodigium Academy

by Katie May

4.00 · 229 ratings

gifted heroine · queer · bisexual · m-m-m · paranormal · non-human-heroine · found-family · audiobook · poly · monsters · fantasy · humor · dangerous heroine · famous heroine · m-m-f · vampires · dual-pov · non-human-hero · first-person-pov · m-m

All books in this series ❯

Black Wings

by Christina Henry

3.92 · 203 ratings

contemporary · shapeshifters · fantasy · fae · vampires · werewolves · demons · paranormal · urban fantasy · magic · length-medium · audiobook · poly · reverse harem · witches · mystery · strong heroine · north-america · usa · illinois

All books in this series ❯

Reapers of the Grimm Brotherhood

by Kel Carpenter

4.02 · 139 ratings

shapeshifters · vampires · paranormal · urban fantasy · contemporary · witches · fantasy · humor · werewolves · demons · magic · new adult · standalone-first · audiobook · poly · reverse harem · mystery · first-in-series · cliffhanger · length-novella

All books in this series ❯

Rosario+Vampire

by Akihisa Ikeda

4.23 · 295 ratings

vampires · high-school · fantasy · humor · shapeshifters · glimpses-kisses · magic · urban fantasy · paranormal · demons · werewolves · young adult · mystery · length-short · witches · non-human-heroine · harems · poly · monsters · standalone-first

All books in this series ❯

Elemental Magic Unleashed

by Serenity Ackles

4.18 · 64 ratings

dark · vampires · urban fantasy · witches · reverse harem · magic · demons · immortal-hero · m-m · new adult · poly · paranormal · fantasy · immortal-heroine · werewolves · queer · teenage-fmc · shapeshifters · audiobook · m-f

All books in this series ❯

Syndicate Mafia

by Kira Stanley

4.17 · 101 ratings

mafia · poly · magic · vampires · fae · suspense · paranormal · competent heroine · fated-mates · reverse harem · fantasy · dangerous heroine · werewolves · demons · dual-pov · possessive hero · first-person-pov · shapeshifters · gifted heroine · menage

All books in this series ❯

The Thirteenth Sign

by Debbie Cassidy

4.21 · 89 ratings

paranormal · fantasy · vampires · shapeshifters · witches · reverse harem · urban fantasy · magic · audiobook · poly · length-medium · suspense · humor · werewolves · menage · demons · fae · cliffhanger · from hate to love · f-f

All books in this series ❯

Princes of Mayhem

by Jocelynn Drake

3.96 · 66 ratings

length-novella · m-m · fantasy · humor · queer · shapeshifters · witches · vampires · werewolves · grumpy sunshine · paranormal · demons · magic · urban fantasy · contemporary · mystery · found-family · glimpses-kisses · first-in-series · standalone-first

All books in this series ❯

The Dead and Not So Dead

by M. Sinclair

4.34 · 65 ratings

friends to lovers · vampires · werewolves · demons · fated-mates · reverse harem · humor · fantasy · paranormal · poly · shapeshifters · non-human-hero · open-door · first-person-pov · louisiana · latinx-mc · possessive hero · cheerful heroine · strong heroine · dual-pov

All books in this series ❯

Rosario+Vampire: Season II

by Akihisa Ikeda

4.31 · 142 ratings

demons · paranormal · fantasy · werewolves · young adult · urban fantasy · magic · shapeshifters · vampires · mystery · witches · length-short · monsters · humor · poly · glimpses-kisses · harems · high-school · length-medium · standalone-first

All books in this series ❯

The Nightwatch

by Debbie Cassidy

4.14 · 61 ratings

magic · dark · demons · mystery · fantasy · witches · reverse harem · poly · urban fantasy · paranormal · fae · vampires · shapeshifters · horror · length-medium · m-f · other-man-woman · love triangle · werewolves · standalone-first

All books in this series ❯

Four Ways to Fate

by Sara C. Roethle

4.09 · 70 ratings

magic · fantasy · paranormal · audiobook · urban fantasy · monsters · reverse harem · mystery · competent heroine · m-f · poly · gifted heroine · fae · first-person-pov · high fantasy · vampires · werewolves · m-f-m · usa · demons

All books in this series ❯

Werewolves, Vampires and Demons, Oh My

by Eve Langlais

3.86 · 41 ratings

werewolves · demons · magic · witches · mystery · fantasy · humor · paranormal · suspense · m-f · shapeshifters · new adult · contemporary · audiobook · insta-love · strong heroine · urban fantasy · vampires · m-f-m · competent heroine

All books in this series ❯

Order of Helsing

by Debbie Cassidy

4.51 · 58 ratings

first-person-pov · cruel hero · non-human-hero · dark · graphic-violence · urban fantasy · strong heroine · vampires · magic · demons · fantasy · contemporary · alpha male · m-f · paranormal · from hate to love · competent heroine · fae · shapeshifters · warrior-heroine

All books in this series ❯

The Prophecy

by Bre Rose

4.14 · 30 ratings

poor heroine · mental-trauma · insta-love · caretaking · small town · class difference · north-america · vampires · angst · grumpy sunshine · hurt-comfort · male-pov · witches · reverse harem · fated-mates · independent heroine · forced proximity · fantasy · mystery · length-medium

All books in this series ❯

Bloody Desires

by Yumoyori Wilson

4.19 · 38 ratings

fantasy · dark · vampires · paranormal · mystery · witches · reverse harem · magic · demons · werewolves · abuse · shapeshifters · poly · length-short · super rich hero · bad boys · fated-mates · cliffhanger · new adult · urban fantasy

All books in this series ❯