Makings of a Witch

by Melody Rose

4.10 · 51 ratings

paranormal · reverse harem · fantasy · witches · shapeshifters · suspense · poly · urban fantasy · length-short · new adult · magic · length-long

Makings of a Witch: Similar series

Royals of Villain Academy

by Eva Chase

3.96 · 359 ratings

cruel hero · magic · witches · reverse harem · fantasy · paranormal · audiobook · contemporary · poly · urban fantasy · college · dual-pov · new adult · first-person-pov · shapeshifters · suspense · explicit-open-door · length-medium · from hate to love · slow burn

All books in this series ❯

Daughter of Cain

by Marie Mistry

4.07 · 114 ratings

second chances · werewolves · dangerous heroine · fantasy · reverse harem · futuristic · alpha male · poly · non-human-heroine · found-family · paranormal · suspense · bisexual · queer · shapeshifters · m-m · first-person-pov · tortured heroine · fighters · mental-trauma

All books in this series ❯

Blood Oath

by R.L. Caulder

3.92 · 180 ratings

from hate to love · paranormal · fantasy · vampires · teacher-hero · shapeshifters · height-difference · sassy heroine · competent heroine · non-human-heroine · poly · m-f · audiobook · alpha male · fated-mates · reverse harem · super rich hero · independent heroine · male-pov · age difference

All books in this series ❯

Kingdom of Shifters and Witches

by Lacey Carter Andersen

3.91 · 102 ratings

fighters · abuse · non-human-hero · past-child-neglect · cruel hero · bear shifter · aristocratic heroine · terminal-illness · past-abuse · abuse-non-mc · first-person-pov · tortured heroine · virgin heroine · cheerful heroine · possessive hero · war · cold hero · bodyguard-hero · slow burn · grumpy sunshine

All books in this series ❯

Syndicate Mafia

by Kira Stanley

4.19 · 91 ratings

first-person-pov · possessive hero · dual-pov · vampires · demons · nerdy-hero · werewolves · magic · fated-mates · reverse harem · fantasy · dangerous heroine · suspense · paranormal · competent heroine · audiobook · contemporary · poly · mafia · shapeshifters

All books in this series ❯

Academy of Assassins

by Stacey Brutger

3.93 · 180 ratings

urban fantasy · werewolves · magic · reverse harem · fantasy · paranormal · poly · audiobook · shapeshifters · teacher-hero · college · first-person-pov · demons · fae · vampires · witches · suspense · alpha male · new adult · non-human-hero

All books in this series ❯

Pizza Shop Exorcist

by Dakota Brown

4.18 · 127 ratings

reverse harem · length-short · fantasy · demons · vampires · sassy heroine · paranormal · competent heroine · poly · audiobook · contemporary · dual-pov · witches · nerdy-hero · magic · death · angels · strong heroine · gifted heroine · fae

All books in this series ❯

Mountain Magic

by Dakota Brown

4.06 · 73 ratings

reverse harem · witches · shapeshifters · vampires · fantasy · paranormal · demons · explicit-open-door · poly · college · length-short · cheerful heroine · bisexual · audiobook · urban fantasy · magic · dual-pov · male-pov · small town · time travel

All books in this series ❯

The Godbearer

by L.C. Davis

3.87 · 119 ratings

alpha male · poly · contemporary · menage · paranormal · queer · m-m · new adult · height-difference · magic · fantasy · reverse harem · witches · dual-pov · small town · first-person-pov · non-human-hero · omegaverse · anal sex · from hate to love

All books in this series ❯

Paranormal House Flippers

by Lidiya Foxglove

3.88 · 55 ratings

urban fantasy · magic · audiobook · poly · werewolves · suspense · demons · paranormal · fantasy · menage · fae · monsters · shapeshifters · length-short · witches · reverse harem · vampires · mystery · humor

All books in this series ❯

The Demon Lords of Blackwood

by Jewel Killian

4.19 · 51 ratings

strong heroine · urban fantasy · dual-pov · cold hero · non-human-hero · bdsm · first-person-pov · cruel hero · shapeshifters · gifted heroine · sassy heroine · from hate to love · cold heroine · paranormal · audiobook · contemporary · m-f · poly · bad boys · witches

All books in this series ❯

Willow's Forbidden Pack

by Avery Song

4.29 · 65 ratings

length-epic · fantasy · reverse harem · witches · magic · shapeshifters · poly · m-f · urban fantasy · paranormal · suspense · fated-mates · demons · werewolves · vampires · fae · queer · contemporary · super rich hero · horror

All books in this series ❯

The Chaos of Foxes

by Emma Dean

3.91 · 63 ratings

shapeshifters · poly · paranormal · fantasy · witches · magic · contemporary · audiobook · suspense · reverse harem · fated-mates · bad boys · demons · past-child-abuse · urban fantasy · third-person-pov · strong heroine · possessive hero · past-abuse · insta-love

All books in this series ❯

Force of Nature

by Amber Lynn Natusch

4.09 · 62 ratings

audiobook · paranormal · fantasy · vampires · shapeshifters · reverse harem · urban fantasy · witches · poly · length-medium · magic · length-short · werewolves · non-human-hero · fae · new adult

All books in this series ❯

Luna Rejected

by River Ramsey

3.75 · 35 ratings

office · suspense · competent heroine · bodyguard-hero · cold hero · possessive hero · praise-kink · first-person-pov · tortured heroine · caretaking · aristocratic heroine · non-human-hero · past-abuse · past-child-neglect · insta-love · friends to lovers · vampires · vengeance · angst · double-penetration

All books in this series ❯

Thornwood Academy

by L.J. Swallow

3.95 · 35 ratings

fantasy · paranormal · poly · urban fantasy · reverse harem · shapeshifters · vampires · young adult · witches · length-short · demons · dark · length-medium · magic · virgin heroine · humor

All books in this series ❯

Grey Witch

by Cece Rose

4.10 · 45 ratings

urban fantasy · fantasy · paranormal · demons · witches · poly · length-short · vampires · reverse harem · shapeshifters · fae · magic

All books in this series ❯

Order of Helsing

by Debbie Cassidy

4.52 · 54 ratings

vampires · fantasy · paranormal · shapeshifters · magic · urban fantasy · from hate to love · fae · dark · demons · witches · reverse harem · contemporary · poly · death · werewolves · length-medium · length-short · fated-mates · forced proximity

All books in this series ❯

Haven Realm

by Mila Young

3.44 · 53 ratings

paranormal · poly · reverse harem · fantasy · audiobook · new adult · shapeshifters · length-medium · magic · urban fantasy · non-human-hero · explicit-open-door · first-person-pov · legends & fairy tales · length-short · witches · strong heroine · competent heroine · non-human-heroine · survival

All books in this series ❯