Makings of a Witch

by Melody Rose

4.10 · 51 ratings

suspense · paranormal · poly · urban fantasy · witches · reverse harem · shapeshifters · fantasy · length-short · standalone-first · length-long · first-in-series · magic · new adult

Makings of a Witch: Similar series

Supernaturals of Castle Academy

by Tessa Hale

3.81 · 242 ratings

rhode-island · misogyny · fantasy · mystery · forced proximity · fated-mates · reverse harem · super rich hero · witches · independent heroine · magic · second chances · demons · length-medium · usa · werewolves · nerdy-hero · high-school · abuse · shapeshifters

All books in this series ❯

The Mate Games: Pestilence

by Meg Anne

4.24 · 343 ratings

arranged marriage · fantasy · super rich hero · monsters · aristocratic heroine · fetish · witches · fated-mates · reverse harem · contemporary · poly · suspense · paranormal · bdsm · first-person-pov · urban fantasy · dual-pov · vampires · death · usa

All books in this series ❯

Immortals of Talonswood

by Alex Lidell

4.03 · 130 ratings

sassy heroine · from hate to love · fae · vampires · new adult · shapeshifters · tortured hero · college · dual-pov · poly · audiobook · contemporary · paranormal · fantasy · cold hero · age difference · fated-mates · reverse harem · witches · independent heroine

All books in this series ❯

Pizza Shop Exorcist

by Dakota Brown

4.23 · 134 ratings

contemporary · reverse harem · length-short · fantasy · demons · sassy heroine · vampires · paranormal · competent heroine · dual-pov · poly · audiobook · witches · nerdy-hero · magic · death · strong heroine · angels · gifted heroine · fae

All books in this series ❯

The Witch's Monsters

by Sarah Piper

4.18 · 105 ratings

demons · abduction · vampires · disabilities and marks · strong heroine · cold hero · sassy heroine · explicit-plentiful · fae · shapeshifters · gifted heroine · found-family · non-human-heroine · audiobook · poly · m-f · competent heroine · paranormal · fantasy · dangerous heroine

All books in this series ❯

Nevermore Bookshop Mysteries

by Steffanie Holmes

4.13 · 257 ratings

reverse harem · humor · fantasy · mystery · paranormal · poly · contemporary · urban fantasy · witches · shapeshifters · audiobook · disabilities and marks · united-kingdom · explicit-open-door · small town · magic · vampires · grumpy sunshine · office · suspense

All books in this series ❯

The Godbearer

by L.C. Davis

3.87 · 121 ratings

m-m · new adult · height-difference · queer · paranormal · menage · contemporary · poly · alpha male · witches · reverse harem · fantasy · magic · small town · dual-pov · anal sex · omegaverse · non-human-hero · first-person-pov · shapeshifters

All books in this series ❯

Drexel Academy

by Lexie Scott

3.86 · 115 ratings

reverse harem · magic · audiobook · poly · paranormal · fantasy · vampires · young adult · shapeshifters · witches · urban fantasy · length-short · high-school · m-m-f · werewolves · length-medium · menage · fae · first-in-series · standalone-first

All books in this series ❯

Paranormal House Flippers

by Lidiya Foxglove

3.86 · 56 ratings

demons · paranormal · suspense · werewolves · menage · poly · audiobook · urban fantasy · magic · reverse harem · length-short · witches · shapeshifters · monsters · fae · fantasy · vampires · mystery · humor · standalone-first

All books in this series ❯

The Demon Lords of Blackwood

by Jewel Killian

4.11 · 55 ratings

dual-pov · urban fantasy · strong heroine · cold hero · first-person-pov · bdsm · cruel hero · non-human-hero · from hate to love · sassy heroine · shapeshifters · gifted heroine · m-f · contemporary · audiobook · poly · paranormal · cold heroine · fantasy · bad boys

All books in this series ❯

Salsang Chronicles

by Serena Akeroyd

3.97 · 91 ratings

paranormal · vampires · fantasy · shapeshifters · poly · reverse harem · length-short · cliffhanger · magic · witches · urban fantasy · dual-pov · werewolves · erotica · standalone-first · first-person-pov · menage · first-in-series · length-medium · strong heroine

All books in this series ❯

Fortuna Academy

by J.B. Trepagnier

3.91 · 67 ratings

fantasy · paranormal · witches · reverse harem · poly · demons · vampires · new adult · shapeshifters · length-short · magic · suspense · menage · from hate to love · queer · bisexual · m-f-m · m-m · fated-mates · first-in-series

All books in this series ❯

Legends Unleashed

by Helen Scott

3.87 · 49 ratings

magic · paranormal · vampires · fantasy · reverse harem · witches · length-short · poly · urban fantasy · demons · fae · shapeshifters · standalone-first · dual-pov · first-person-pov · first-in-series · explicit-plentiful · humor

All books in this series ❯

Willow's Forbidden Pack

by Avery Song

4.29 · 65 ratings

shapeshifters · poly · m-f · urban fantasy · paranormal · suspense · length-epic · fantasy · reverse harem · witches · magic · vampires · fae · queer · contemporary · fated-mates · demons · werewolves · mafia · m-m

All books in this series ❯

The Chaos of Foxes

by Emma Dean

3.91 · 63 ratings

magic · witches · fantasy · paranormal · poly · shapeshifters · past-abuse · possessive hero · strong heroine · third-person-pov · urban fantasy · past-child-abuse · demons · bad boys · reverse harem · fated-mates · suspense · contemporary · audiobook · warrior-heroine

All books in this series ❯

The Four Horsemen

by L.J. Swallow

3.92 · 137 ratings

fantasy · paranormal · demons · vampires · urban fantasy · reverse harem · poly · length-short · shapeshifters · magic · witches · legends & fairy tales · new adult · fae · cliffhanger · death · suspense · strong heroine · alpha male · length-novella

All books in this series ❯

Chronicles of Deadworld

by Debbie Cassidy

4.20 · 53 ratings

length-short · magic · reverse harem · shapeshifters · vampires · dystopian · fantasy · demons · paranormal · werewolves · poly · urban fantasy · witches · dark · strong heroine · first-in-series · standalone-first · horror

All books in this series ❯

Luna Rejected

by River Ramsey

3.72 · 36 ratings

office · suspense · paranormal · found-family · non-human-heroine · poly · m-m · height-difference · sassy heroine · explicit-plentiful · m-m-f · second chances · curvy heroine · magic · bad boys · witches · exhibitionism · reverse harem · independent heroine · misogyny

All books in this series ❯

Order of Helsing

by Debbie Cassidy

4.51 · 58 ratings

fantasy · demons · magic · shapeshifters · fae · from hate to love · paranormal · competent heroine · contemporary · m-f · alpha male · dark · graphic-violence · non-human-hero · cruel hero · first-person-pov · vampires · strong heroine · urban fantasy · witches

All books in this series ❯