An Unlikely Tale

by Katie Trapp

4.29 · 7 ratings

shapeshifters · witches · f-f · mystery · fantasy · queer · paranormal · magic · length-short · from hate to love · suspense · urban fantasy · first-in-series · standalone-first · erotica · length-novella

An Unlikely Tale: Similar series

Cruel Shifterverse

by Jasmine Mas

3.98 · 1650 ratings

mental illness · bisexual · mental-trauma · graphic-violence · past-child-neglect · tortured heroine · first-person-pov · past-abuse · war · virgin heroine · anal sex · cold hero · grumpy sunshine · strong heroine · slow burn · survival · dual-pov · disabilities and marks · high fantasy · m-m-f

All books in this series ❯

Kingdom of the Wicked

by Kerri Maniscalco

3.88 · 993 ratings

dark · witches · mystery · fantasy · demons · magic · paranormal · young adult · first-person-pov · tortured hero · vengeance · vampires · strong heroine · independent heroine · monsters · forced proximity · historical · new adult · from hate to love · commander

All books in this series ❯

The Edge

by Ilona Andrews

4.08 · 508 ratings

urban fantasy · contemporary · paranormal · shapeshifters · magic · fantasy · class difference · open-door · audiobook · alpha male · m-f · suspense · competent heroine · slow burn · strong heroine · past-child-abuse · tortured heroine · fighters · poor heroine · death

All books in this series ❯

The Wicked Years

by Gregory Maguire

3.51 · 297 ratings

new adult · urban fantasy · audiobook · fantasy · dark · standalone-first · queer · high fantasy · dystopian · young adult · strong heroine · suspense · paranormal · contemporary · steampunk · witches · 20th century · mystery · humor · high-school

All books in this series ❯

Mismatched Mates

by Eliot Grayson

3.92 · 670 ratings

shapeshifters · queer · fantasy · m-m · paranormal · contemporary · urban fantasy · anal sex · werewolves · magic · usa · north-america · explicit-open-door · witches · male-pov · creative-anatomy · first-person-pov · alpha male · forced proximity · humor

All books in this series ❯

Warts & Claws Inc.

by Clio Evans

3.76 · 255 ratings

monsters · witches · fated-mates · fantasy · demons · magic · explicit-plentiful · bisexual · office · paranormal · audiobook · poly · praise-kink · insta-love · bdsm · forced proximity · queer · menage · omegaverse · urban fantasy

All books in this series ❯

The Rising

by Kristen Ashley

4.08 · 231 ratings

explicit-open-door · suspense · paranormal · audiobook · alpha male · arranged marriage · demons · magic · witches · fated-mates · fantasy · strong heroine · sweet-hero · sweet heroine · angst · tortured heroine · aristocratic heroine · possessive hero · cheerful heroine · war

All books in this series ❯

Hidden Species

by Louisa Masters

4.05 · 210 ratings

office · paranormal · audiobook · contemporary · found-family · m-m · queer · usa · demons · magic · witches · male-pov · humor · fantasy · grumpy sunshine · sweet-hero · urban fantasy · dual-pov · north-america · vampires

All books in this series ❯

RELIC

by Maz Maddox

4.14 · 201 ratings

contemporary · audiobook · paranormal · queer · shapeshifters · m-m · fantasy · humor · forced proximity · dual-pov · urban fantasy · first-person-pov · non-human-hero · immortal-hero · standalone-first · age difference · male-pov · sweet-hero · ic-standalone · grumpy sunshine

All books in this series ❯

Night Watch

by Cynthia Eden

4.02 · 155 ratings

contemporary · m-f · urban fantasy · suspense · paranormal · vampires · shapeshifters · magic · explicit-open-door · demons · werewolves · fantasy · alpha male · mystery · witches · audiobook · standalone-first · length-medium · non-human-hero · possessive hero

All books in this series ❯

The Dragon Lairds

by Amy Pennza

3.78 · 172 ratings

menage · shapeshifters · bisexual · queer · fantasy · highlander · paranormal · dragon shifter · poly · height-difference · explicit-plentiful · m-m-f · fated-mates · dual-pov · double-penetration · first-person-pov · anal sex · alpha male · audiobook · erotica

All books in this series ❯

The Godbearer

by L.C. Davis

3.87 · 121 ratings

witches · dual-pov · small town · first-person-pov · non-human-hero · omegaverse · anal sex · alpha male · poly · contemporary · paranormal · menage · queer · new adult · m-m · height-difference · magic · fantasy · reverse harem · friends to lovers

All books in this series ❯

Perfect Pixie

by M.J. May

4.20 · 108 ratings

magic · length-medium · usa · virginia · werewolves · fantasy · fated-mates · contemporary · found-family · fae · queer · m-m · shapeshifters · first-person-pov · urban fantasy · dual-pov · vampires · north-america · standalone-first · age difference

All books in this series ❯

Hexworld

by Jordan L. Hawk

4.12 · 148 ratings

magic · historical · fantasy · mystery · paranormal · urban fantasy · shapeshifters · m-m · queer · witches · erotica · audiobook · suspense · fated-mates · length-novella · length-medium · explicit-open-door · death · length-short · steampunk

All books in this series ❯

Blood and Moonlight

by Cynthia Eden

3.89 · 60 ratings

werewolves · paranormal · suspense · urban fantasy · alpha male · military · shapeshifters · audiobook · witches · fantasy · vampires · magic · erotica · length-short · mystery · insta-love · usa · first-in-series · contemporary · m-f

All books in this series ❯

Dreary Shadows

by R.E. Bond

4.01 · 77 ratings

dark · vampires · new adult · shapeshifters · poly · paranormal · suspense · mystery · fantasy · age difference · reverse harem · witches · length-short · werewolves · from hate to love · fae · angst · alpha male · erotica · menage

All books in this series ❯

Fae Out of Water

by E.J. Russell

3.72 · 57 ratings

political-intrigue · standalone · non-human-hero · angst · tortured hero · hurt-comfort · dual-pov · urban fantasy · third-person-pov · fantasy · humor · mystery · male-pov · witches · standalone-first · magic · length-medium · usa · queer · fae

All books in this series ❯

Wild Magic

by Claire Cullen

3.89 · 74 ratings

contemporary · shapeshifters · magic · urban fantasy · paranormal · werewolves · queer · fantasy · mystery · witches · m-m · length-short · omegaverse · fated-mates · hurt-comfort · abuse · from hate to love · new adult · standalone-first · first-in-series

All books in this series ❯

The Blackwood Five

by Jesi Donovan

3.26 · 49 ratings

bisexual · queer · m-m-m · m-m · paranormal · fantasy · witches · m-m-f · demons · from hate to love · audiobook · pregnancy · length-short · magic · shapeshifters · new adult · urban fantasy · poly · first-in-series · standalone-first

All books in this series ❯

Order of Helsing

by Debbie Cassidy

4.51 · 58 ratings

fantasy · demons · magic · shapeshifters · fae · from hate to love · paranormal · competent heroine · m-f · alpha male · contemporary · dark · graphic-violence · non-human-hero · cruel hero · first-person-pov · vampires · strong heroine · urban fantasy · witches

All books in this series ❯

Winterfell Academy

by Elle Mae

3.79 · 53 ratings

paranormal · fantasy · poly · urban fantasy · witches · reverse harem · length-medium · magic · queer · from hate to love · f-f · new adult · strong heroine · dark · demons · standalone-first · first-in-series · shapeshifters · explicit-plentiful · science fiction

All books in this series ❯

Nocturnal Hearts

by Elliott Rose

4.09 · 51 ratings

fated-mates · witches · fantasy · explicit-plentiful · paranormal · m-f · vampires · magic · suspense · third-person-pov · age difference · forced proximity · standalone-first · length-long · shapeshifters · bodyguard-hero · non-human-hero · standalone · aristocratic heroine · dual-pov

All books in this series ❯

The Fate of the Fallen

by R. Phoenix

3.52 · 31 ratings

fantasy · witches · dark · queer · m-m · paranormal · vampires · bdsm · werewolves · dystopian · shapeshifters · audiobook · urban fantasy · length-short · standalone-first · magic · slavery · abuse · rape · length-novella

All books in this series ❯

Dylan Rivers Chronicles

by Richard Amos

3.92 · 13 ratings

m-m · queer · paranormal · urban fantasy · fantasy · suspense · poly · magic · shapeshifters · vampires · fae · royalty · contemporary · erotica · witches · length-short · length-medium · werewolves · bdsm · first-in-series

All books in this series ❯

© Copyright 2015-2023, Elektrolabs Limited · Advertising Disclosure: Please note that many links to retailers are affiliate links, which yields a commission for us. romance.io is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to amazon.com.

Remove ads