The Toad Witch Mysteries: Similar series
Zodiac Academy
by Caroline Peckham
4.09 · 4200 ratings
contemporary · paranormal · new adult · urban fantasy · vampires · fantasy · fae · shapeshifters · first-person-pov · werewolves · magic · dragon shifter · from hate to love · dark · super rich hero · alpha male · possessive hero · male-pov · fated-mates · college
All books in this series ❯
The Others
by Anne Bishop
4.23 · 894 ratings
magic · werewolves · mystery · fantasy · audiobook · suspense · paranormal · shapeshifters · urban fantasy · racism · vampires · dystopian · humor · male-pov · futuristic · contemporary · m-f · alpha male · abuse · dark
All books in this series ❯
Circle Trilogy
by Nora Roberts
4.09 · 189 ratings
mystery · fantasy · medieval · vampires · shapeshifters · witches · urban fantasy · magic · historical · contemporary · m-f · audiobook · suspense · open-door · paranormal · length-novella · cold heroine · non-human-hero · time travel · war
All books in this series ❯
Sponsored links / Remove ads
Night Huntress Universe
by Jeaniene Frost
3.88 · 243 ratings
urban fantasy · vampires · fantasy · m-f · contemporary · paranormal · magic · non-human-hero · length-novella · north-america · demons · usa · mystery · audiobook · suspense · past-abuse · explicit-open-door · dual-pov · sweet-hero · third-person-pov
All books in this series ❯
Forty Proof
by Shannon Mayer
4.47 · 344 ratings
paranormal · urban fantasy · audiobook · m-f · fantasy · contemporary · fae · demons · magic · witches · gifted heroine · vampires · length-medium · mystery · strong heroine · shapeshifters · werewolves · open-door · humor · suspense
All books in this series ❯
Bound
by Cynthia Eden
3.81 · 174 ratings
non-human-heroine · urban fantasy · alpha male · contemporary · m-f · paranormal · suspense · vampires · shapeshifters · werewolves · fantasy · length-novella · non-human-hero · demons · possessive hero · fated-mates · witches · tortured heroine · betrayal · magic
All books in this series ❯
Shadow Guild: The Rebel
by Linsey Hall
4.07 · 161 ratings
humor · fantasy · vampires · witches · urban fantasy · magic · audiobook · paranormal · fae · length-short · fated-mates · suspense · mystery · new adult · m-f · shapeshifters · bad boys · first-in-series · first-person-pov · alpha male
All books in this series ❯
Jill Kismet
by Lilith Saintcrow
3.99 · 180 ratings
contemporary · shapeshifters · horror · audiobook · urban fantasy · magic · length-medium · demons · paranormal · werewolves · vampires · fantasy · suspense · mystery · dark · strong heroine · standalone-first · betrayal · first-in-series · dangerous heroine
All books in this series ❯
The Witch's Monsters
by Sarah Piper
4.18 · 105 ratings
explicit-plentiful · fae · sassy heroine · gifted heroine · shapeshifters · audiobook · poly · m-f · non-human-heroine · found-family · paranormal · competent heroine · fantasy · forced proximity · dangerous heroine · witches · reverse harem · fated-mates · independent heroine · monsters
All books in this series ❯
Nevermore Bookshop Mysteries
by Steffanie Holmes
4.13 · 257 ratings
urban fantasy · fantasy · mystery · humor · reverse harem · poly · contemporary · paranormal · disabilities and marks · witches · audiobook · shapeshifters · united-kingdom · explicit-open-door · small town · grumpy sunshine · vampires · magic · office · suspense
All books in this series ❯
Shadows & Flame
by C.N. Crawford
4.10 · 84 ratings
fantasy · demons · paranormal · m-f · magic · young adult · urban fantasy · length-medium · legends & fairy tales · new adult · audiobook · witches · cliffhanger · shapeshifters · from hate to love · vampires · fae · suspense · mystery · length-epic
All books in this series ❯
City of Wishes
by Rachel Morgan
4.08 · 88 ratings
fantasy · paranormal · fae · legends & fairy tales · urban fantasy · magic · length-novella · young adult · audiobook · vampires · mystery · glimpses-kisses · new adult · first-in-series · standalone-first
All books in this series ❯
Witches of New York
by Kim Richardson
4.36 · 117 ratings
witches · shapeshifters · vampires · fantasy · paranormal · audiobook · length-medium · suspense · magic · urban fantasy · humor · mystery · demons · length-short · monsters · standalone-first · first-in-series · m-f · contemporary
All books in this series ❯
Undead in Brown County
by S.J. Wright
3.77 · 69 ratings
paranormal · fantasy · vampires · contemporary · length-short · urban fantasy · magic · suspense · latinx-mc · shapeshifters · witches · first-in-series · horror · standalone-first · young adult · length-novella
All books in this series ❯
Red Rock Pass
by Moira Rogers
3.75 · 74 ratings
fantasy · urban fantasy · paranormal · magic · werewolves · contemporary · shapeshifters · length-novella · m-f · witches · suspense · vampires · erotica · north-america · death · first-in-series · tortured heroine · past-abuse · caretaking · standalone-first
All books in this series ❯
Offbeat Crimes
by Angel Martinez
3.98 · 81 ratings
contemporary · paranormal · queer · fantasy · m-m · urban fantasy · magic · men in uniform · mystery · humor · north-america · usa · vampires · length-short · pennsylvania · length-novella · suspense · open-door · standalone-first · first-in-series
All books in this series ❯
Vampire Bound
by R.A. Steffan
4.08 · 45 ratings
demons · paranormal · fantasy · vampires · fae · witches · magic · urban fantasy · audiobook · m-f · length-medium · explicit-open-door · alpha male · war · class difference · suspense · single-mother · boss & employee · working class heroine · vengeance
All books in this series ❯
Institute Thirteen
by K.C. Kean
4.18 · 40 ratings
fantasy · forced proximity · shapeshifters · fae · witches · fated-mates · reverse harem · paranormal · poly · new adult · explicit-plentiful · dark · vampires · m-f-m · werewolves · horror · death · super rich hero · monsters · humor
All books in this series ❯
Savage
by Tamara Rose Blodgett
3.94 · 58 ratings
science fiction · psychics · fantasy · futuristic · audiobook · multicultural · paranormal · young adult · vampires · dystopian · witches · shapeshifters · urban fantasy · magic · steampunk · suspense · length-medium · mystery · royalty · cliffhanger
All books in this series ❯
A Culling of Blood and Magic
by K.M. Rives
3.81 · 36 ratings
audiobook · explicit-open-door · vampires · third-person-pov · dual-pov · fated-mates · fantasy · magic · paranormal · m-f · possessive hero · urban fantasy · witches · werewolves · length-long · royalty · betrayal · virgin heroine · pregnancy · non-human-hero
All books in this series ❯
Dominion
by Lissa Kasey
3.93 · 62 ratings
paranormal · fantasy · vampires · magic · contemporary · witches · shapeshifters · m-m · queer · suspense · length-novella · urban fantasy · length-medium · abuse · friends to lovers · usa · dark · poly · standalone-first · first-in-series
All books in this series ❯
Only Human
by Candace Blevins
4.02 · 53 ratings
explicit-plentiful · vampires · shapeshifters · urban fantasy · paranormal · fantasy · bdsm · werewolves · demons · alpha male · m-f · suspense · poly · length-long · magic · length-medium · dual-pov · erotica · anal sex · dark
All books in this series ❯
Paranormal True Mate Dating Agency
by Amelia Wilson
4.14 · 14 ratings
paranormal · demons · suspense · witches · shapeshifters · vampires · fantasy · angels · urban fantasy · length-novella · standalone-first · audiobook · first-in-series · length-short
All books in this series ❯
Vampire: Alpha Claim
by Tamara Rose Blodgett
4.00 · 22 ratings
witches · shapeshifters · vampires · psychics · fantasy · demons · paranormal · angels · military · multicultural · length-novella · urban fantasy · magic · futuristic · science fiction · audiobook · suspense · first-in-series · standalone-first · m-f
All books in this series ❯