A Broomstick Bay Paranormal Cozy Mystery: Similar series
Hidden Legacy
by Ilona Andrews
4.41 · 2409 ratings
paranormal · fantasy · magic · urban fantasy · contemporary · witches · humor · alpha male · mystery · strong heroine · texas · audiobook · m-f · suspense · heroine sleuth · usa · class difference · north-america · length-novella · gifted heroine
All books in this series ❯
Night Huntress Universe
by Jeaniene Frost
3.92 · 229 ratings
urban fantasy · vampires · fantasy · contemporary · m-f · paranormal · magic · non-human-hero · length-novella · north-america · usa · demons · mystery · audiobook · suspense · past-abuse · sweet-hero · dual-pov · third-person-pov · abduction
All books in this series ❯
The Vampire Diaries: The Return
by L.J. Smith
3.66 · 183 ratings
vampires · paranormal · audiobook · fantasy · young adult · urban fantasy · werewolves · dark · demons · love triangle · magic · contemporary · other-man-woman · m-f · shapeshifters · witches · horror · length-long · length-novella · mystery
All books in this series ❯
Sponsored links
The Lynburn Legacy
by Sarah Rees Brennan
3.79 · 208 ratings
young adult · paranormal · urban fantasy · magic · witches · mystery · fantasy · contemporary · m-f · glimpses-kisses · length-novella · sassy heroine · virgin hero · length-medium · love triangle · east-asian-mc · other-man-woman · virgin heroine · strong heroine · suspense
All books in this series ❯
Mercedes Thompson Graphic Novels
by Patricia Briggs
4.19 · 132 ratings
magic · urban fantasy · length-novella · werewolves · paranormal · mystery · fantasy · fae · vampires · shapeshifters · witches · contemporary · young adult · strong heroine · audiobook · m-f · alpha male · non-human-heroine · behind-doors · indigenous-mc
All books in this series ❯
The Assassin's Curse
by Cassandra Rose Clarke
3.54 · 127 ratings
young adult · fantasy · paranormal · pirates · contemporary · magic · slow burn · dangerous heroine · length-medium · strong heroine · audiobook · length-novella · witches · mystery · demons · royalty · sassy heroine · male-pov · futuristic · steampunk
All books in this series ❯
World of Kate Daniels
by Ilona Andrews
4.13 · 134 ratings
paranormal · urban fantasy · shapeshifters · magic · fantasy · strong heroine · length-novella · vampires · werewolves · witches · alpha male · dystopian · male-pov · mystery · glimpses-kisses · futuristic · humor · young adult · competent heroine · suspense
All books in this series ❯
Althea Rose Mystery
by Tricia O'Malley
4.43 · 113 ratings
paranormal · witches · mystery · fantasy · heroine sleuth · audiobook · length-novella · length-short · magic · humor · suspense · length-medium · christmas
All books in this series ❯
Otherworld Stories
by Kelley Armstrong
4.13 · 657 ratings
fantasy · paranormal · urban fantasy · werewolves · shapeshifters · length-novella · contemporary · magic · vampires · witches · mystery · demons · audiobook · length-short · length-long · non-human-heroine · length-epic · length-medium · sassy heroine · young adult
All books in this series ❯
Sugar Shack Witch Mysteries
by Danielle Garrett
4.01 · 195 ratings
mystery · fantasy · witches · urban fantasy · audiobook · paranormal · shapeshifters · magic · vampires · contemporary · length-novella · length-medium · humor · monsters · glimpses-kisses · length-short · christmas · fae · found-family · suspense
All books in this series ❯
Shadows of Salem
by Jasmine Walt
4.12 · 71 ratings
paranormal · competent heroine · urban fantasy · audiobook · contemporary · m-f · bodyguard-heroine · north-america · new adult · small town · sassy heroine · from hate to love · royalty · sweet heroine · vampires · fae · abuse · non-human-hero · usa · magic
All books in this series ❯
Princes of Mayhem
by Jocelynn Drake
4.02 · 63 ratings
queer · humor · fantasy · m-m · length-novella · grumpy sunshine · vampires · witches · shapeshifters · contemporary · magic · urban fantasy · paranormal · demons · werewolves · mystery · found-family · glimpses-kisses
All books in this series ❯
Kat, Incorrigible
by Stephanie Burgis
4.07 · 72 ratings
fantasy · paranormal · regency · witches · magic · historical · contemporary · young adult · mystery · humor · length-epic · length-novella · new adult · length-medium
All books in this series ❯
Baba Yaga
by Deborah Blake
3.81 · 95 ratings
urban fantasy · witches · fantasy · paranormal · contemporary · magic · fae · mystery · length-medium · audiobook · length-novella · shapeshifters · men in uniform · clean · north-america · humor · usa · strong heroine · illinois
All books in this series ❯
Jade Calhoun
by Deanna Chase
4.06 · 191 ratings
fantasy · paranormal · witches · angels · urban fantasy · mystery · audiobook · psychics · demons · length-novella · contemporary · magic · length-short · length-medium · suspense · heroine sleuth · shapeshifters · possessive hero · humor · vampires
All books in this series ❯
Avalon Café
by Hermione Moon
4.41 · 41 ratings
mystery · fantasy · paranormal · time travel · witches · magic · suspense · length-novella · audiobook · length-short · urban fantasy · sweet heroine · glimpses-kisses · cheerful heroine · gifted heroine · arthurian · first-person-pov · sweet-hero · insta-love · competent heroine
All books in this series ❯
Amethyst's Wand Shop Mysteries
by Laura Greenwood
4.11 · 24 ratings
mystery · paranormal · magic · witches · urban fantasy · fantasy · length-novella · contemporary · audiobook · length-short · suspense · m-f
All books in this series ❯
Fate Weaver
by ReGina Welling
4.42 · 12 ratings
fantasy · paranormal · mystery · humor · length-novella · audiobook · suspense · witches · length-short · magic · contemporary · new adult
All books in this series ❯
Keating Hollow Happily Ever Afters
by Deanna Chase
4.58 · 12 ratings
length-novella · fantasy · witches · paranormal · audiobook · mystery · urban fantasy · contemporary · magic
All books in this series ❯
The Skeleton Crew
by Dahlia Donovan
4.18 · 11 ratings
queer · paranormal · suspense · magic · length-novella · witches · fantasy · mystery · vampires · fae · age difference · british-isles · slow burn · neurodivergent · urban fantasy · demons · scotland · latinx-mc · glimpses-kisses · m-f-x
All books in this series ❯
Witch of Wickrock Bay
by Wendy Meadows
4.25 · 20 ratings
magic · mystery · fantasy · paranormal · witches · length-novella · contemporary · urban fantasy · young adult
All books in this series ❯
Wicked Good Mystery
by Lucy May
4.46 · 13 ratings
audiobook · mystery · paranormal · fantasy · witches · humor · suspense · length-novella · length-short · heroine sleuth
All books in this series ❯
Black Rose Mystery
by Amanda McKinney
4.00 · 6 ratings
witches · suspense · paranormal · fantasy · mystery · heroine sleuth · length-novella · length-short
All books in this series ❯
The Hexer and the Telekinetic
by N.R. Hairston
3.33 · 3 ratings
m-m · queer · fantasy · length-novella · urban fantasy · death · witches · mystery · paranormal · magic · futuristic · war · f-f · military
All books in this series ❯