An Amish Candy Shop Mystery
by Amanda Flower
4.13 · 52 ratings
length-medium · amish · contemporary · science fiction · audiobook · mystery · heroine sleuth · paranormal · christian · christmas
An Amish Candy Shop Mystery: Similar series
Sookie Stackhouse
by Charlaine Harris
3.79 · 3239 ratings
vampires · urban fantasy · fantasy · paranormal · audiobook · mystery · werewolves · magic · shapeshifters · contemporary · witches · fae · length-medium · demons · m-f · non-human-hero · love triangle · other-man-woman · suspense · humor
All books in this series ❯
The Lazy Girl's Guide to Magic
by Helen Harper
4.01 · 286 ratings
fantasy · mystery · witches · humor · magic · first-person-pov · audiobook · contemporary · urban fantasy · paranormal · cold hero · childfree-couple · behind-doors · england · sassy heroine · m-f · alpha male · strong heroine · grumpy sunshine · heroine sleuth
All books in this series ❯
October Daye
by Seanan McGuire
4.21 · 1141 ratings
urban fantasy · fantasy · paranormal · fae · magic · non-human-hero · found-family · warrior-heroine · mystery · non-human-heroine · royalty · behind-doors · california · heroine sleuth · audiobook · shapeshifters · first-person-pov · north-america · usa · contemporary
All books in this series ❯
Sponsored links / Remove ads
Firebrand
by Helen Harper
4.21 · 292 ratings
length-medium · magic · mystery · fantasy · paranormal · audiobook · contemporary · urban fantasy · shapeshifters · vampires · werewolves · suspense · strong heroine · heroine sleuth · m-f · fae · age difference · young adult · mental-trauma · first-person-pov
All books in this series ❯
Supernatural London
by Helen Harper
4.19 · 291 ratings
shapeshifters · vampires · suspense · paranormal · audiobook · urban fantasy · mystery · fantasy · werewolves · magic · contemporary · m-f · length-medium · strong heroine · heroine sleuth · fae · young adult · age difference · first-person-pov · non-human-heroine
All books in this series ❯
The Conspiracy of Us
by Maggie Hall
3.92 · 111 ratings
young adult · length-medium · historical · love triangle · other-man-woman · contemporary · audiobook · rich heroine · fantasy · mystery · dystopian · science fiction · paranormal · suspense · found-family · high-school · magic · first-in-series · standalone-first · cliffhanger
All books in this series ❯
The Other Realm
by Heather G. Harris
4.28 · 327 ratings
fantasy · heroine sleuth · magic · shapeshifters · paranormal · urban fantasy · audiobook · witches · mystery · vampires · werewolves · time travel · contemporary · monsters · demons · length-medium · fae · strong heroine · glimpses-kisses · new adult
All books in this series ❯
Kate Burkholder
by Linda Castillo
4.06 · 217 ratings
length-medium · suspense · amish · clean · audiobook · christian · mystery · contemporary · heroine sleuth · fatphobia · first-in-series · standalone-first · vengeance
All books in this series ❯
Victory Nelson's Blood Investigations
by Tanya Huff
3.74 · 196 ratings
paranormal · fantasy · heroine sleuth · length-medium · horror · audiobook · contemporary · urban fantasy · magic · vampires · mystery · canada · north-america · science fiction · monsters · suspense · dark · demons · behind-doors · standalone-first
All books in this series ❯
Jayne Frost
by Kristen Painter
4.22 · 168 ratings
fae · vampires · paranormal · audiobook · urban fantasy · mystery · fantasy · christmas · humor · heroine sleuth · magic · witches · length-medium · love triangle · shapeshifters · royalty · contemporary · werewolves · reverse harem · other-man-woman
All books in this series ❯
Ghost-in-Law
by Jana Deleon
4.22 · 136 ratings
audiobook · fantasy · heroine sleuth · mystery · paranormal · suspense · contemporary · humor · length-medium · length-novella · north-america · length-short · usa · first-in-series · standalone-first
All books in this series ❯
Crow Investigations
by Sarah Painter
4.05 · 161 ratings
paranormal · mystery · fantasy · audiobook · contemporary · magic · urban fantasy · heroine sleuth · suspense · length-medium · behind-doors · young adult · standalone-first · first-in-series · length-short · new adult · cliffhanger
All books in this series ❯
Christmas Tree Farm Mystery
by Jacqueline Frost
3.98 · 132 ratings
audiobook · christmas · mystery · heroine sleuth · contemporary · length-medium · suspense · standalone-first · first-in-series
All books in this series ❯
Frogmorton Farm
by Jodi Taylor
4.39 · 102 ratings
contemporary · audiobook · fantasy · humor · paranormal · magic · urban fantasy · science fiction · length-medium · length-novella · m-f · mystery · christmas · time travel · abuse · slow burn · open-door · first-in-series · glimpses-kisses · alcoholism
All books in this series ❯
Magical Cats Mystery
by Sofie Kelly
4.18 · 174 ratings
audiobook · paranormal · length-medium · magic · fantasy · mystery · heroine sleuth · contemporary · death
All books in this series ❯
The Haunted Library Mysteries
by Allison Brook
3.80 · 69 ratings
mystery · paranormal · heroine sleuth · contemporary · audiobook · fantasy · length-medium · christmas
All books in this series ❯
A Stitch in Time
by Kelley Armstrong
3.92 · 176 ratings
historical · fantasy · paranormal · time travel · audiobook · length-medium · mystery · victorian · behind-doors · christmas · urban fantasy · science fiction · first-person-pov · open-door · m-f · contemporary · strong heroine · length-novella · suspense · death
All books in this series ❯
Witch Way Librarian Mysteries
by Angela M. Sanders
3.92 · 88 ratings
magic · contemporary · paranormal · length-medium · mystery · fantasy · heroine sleuth · witches · urban fantasy · audiobook · glimpses-kisses · first-in-series · standalone-first · oregon · young adult · usa · friends to lovers · north-america
All books in this series ❯
Relic Seekers
by Anita Clenney
3.87 · 58 ratings
psychics · fantasy · mystery · audiobook · urban fantasy · length-medium · paranormal · heroine sleuth · super rich hero · contemporary · suspense · vikings · europe · scandinavia · arthurian · other-man-woman · love triangle · standalone-first · first-in-series · ancient times
All books in this series ❯
Crochet Mystery
by Betty Hechtman
3.83 · 106 ratings
mystery · heroine sleuth · audiobook · length-medium · contemporary · science fiction · love triangle · other-man-woman · humor · first-in-series · standalone-first · death
All books in this series ❯
Amish Quilt Shop Mystery
by Isabella Alan
4.07 · 49 ratings
audiobook · heroine sleuth · amish · length-medium · contemporary · science fiction · mystery · christian · christmas · clean · suspense
All books in this series ❯
Ghostly Southern Mystery
by Tonya Kappes
4.14 · 94 ratings
audiobook · contemporary · paranormal · mystery · fantasy · magic · length-medium · heroine sleuth · horror · death · humor · small town · urban fantasy · first-in-series · standalone-first · suspense · length-short
All books in this series ❯
Life Coach Mystery
by Victoria Laurie
4.16 · 60 ratings
audiobook · length-medium · paranormal · mystery · heroine sleuth · contemporary · humor · other-man-woman · suspense · cheating · science fiction · fantasy · mafia · standalone-first · first-in-series · abuse · rape
All books in this series ❯
Amish Village Mystery
by Vannetta Chapman
4.03 · 38 ratings
suspense · amish · mystery · christian · contemporary · audiobook · length-medium · clean · heroine sleuth · first-in-series · standalone-first
All books in this series ❯