Hollister's Choice (Montana Miracles #2)
Grace Walton

Hollister was hiding secrets. He hated the way he was drawn to his friend’s innocent sister. She was years too young for him. But something about her appeal was irresistible. He couldn’t explain his obsession with her. And that bothered him. Hollister didn’t like mysteries. His life was a carefully constructed and protected façade. He wanted nothing to threaten the stability he’d worked so hard to build. Beautiful, repressed Maggie Ferguson could so easily cost him everything.
So many obstacles stood between them. His honor and her chastity were only the beginning. Of course, there was the fact that she was adamant about her faith. A faith he didn’t believe was real, much less share. How could a man of cold, hard reason ever believe in epic myths? How could a man who’d built his life on violence and bloodshed, even if they were done for worthy causes, ever trust in an invisible, loving God?
Maggie had made her choice. She’d hidden the truth so deep in her anguished soul she thought not even God knew the terrible secret she was hiding. In the process, she’d emotionally crippled herself forever. Now it was time for… Hollister’s Choice.