Wicked When He Cries (Sinners of Blackthorne U #4)
Avery Collins
Rated: 4.60 of 5 stars
4.60
· Steam/Spice level: 4 of 5
Explicit open door [?]
· 5 ratings · 395 pages · Published: 25 Feb 2026
Four years ago, I left without a word and swore I’d never look back. Now Noah Adams is living under the same roof as I am, and every second around him feels like punishment for the choice I never wanted to make. Everyone thinks I’m the easy one—the hookup king of the Sin Bin. But the truth is, I’ve only ever wanted him.
He was the first boy I ever loved, and the only one I could never have.
Noah
I came to Blackthorne U without knowing my first heartbreak would be a hallway away, acting as if nothing had happened while I drowned in everything we never said. I shouldn’t want him; I definitely shouldn’t still love him. But some wounds don’t fade just because you pretend they don’t hurt.
One house. Two broken hearts.
What do you do when the past never really lets go?
Sponsored links / Remove ads
Tagged as:
- queer romance 3
- sports 3
- gay romance 3
- step siblings 2
- forced proximity 2
- hurt/comfort 2
- anal sex 2
- praise kink 2
- college 2
- basketball 2
- shy hero 2
- possessive hero 2
- sweet/gentle hero 2
- sunny/happy hero 2
- virgin hero 2
- athlete hero 2
- new adult 1
- contemporary 1
- angst 1
- childfree 1
- bisexuality 1
- caretaking 1
- friends to lovers 1
- good grovel 1
- second chances 1
- slow burn 1
- masc-dom 1
- role switching 1
- somnophilia 1
- found family 1
- betrayal 1
- tortured hero 1
- Add topics
- content warnings
- queerphobia 2
- eating disorders 2
- body betrayal 1
- mental illness 1
- mental trauma 1
- misogyny 1
- self harm 1
- past child neglect 1
- Format
- male pov 2
- dual pov 2
- first person pov 2
- interconnected standalone 1
- standalone 1
romance tags
The 'Sinners of Blackthorne U' series
4.36 · 82 ratings
college · m-m · sports · new adult · queer · possessive hero · athletes · dual-pov · male-pov · from hate to love · explicit-plentiful · dark · anal sex · self harm · past-child-abuse · length-long · forced proximity · contemporary · masc-dom · lgbtqia hate
Sinners of Blackthorne U reading order and complete book list ❯
