Lancaster Hearts Series by Anna Holt

She found a letter. He never meant her to read it.Emma Yoder’s world is defined by the gentle rhythms of her family bakery and the expectations of her Amish community. But when she finds a forgotten book of poetry containing a heartfelt letter, everything changes. The words stir a longing she never expected—and a curiosity about the identity of the secret author.As courtship with the bishop's son begins, Emma's heart wrestles with duty and an invisible pull toward the unknown... moreShe found a letter. He never meant her to read it.Emma Yoder’s world is defined by the gentle rhythms of her family bakery and the expectations of her Amish community. But when she finds a forgotten book of poetry containing a heartfelt letter, everything changes. The words stir a longing she never expected—and a curiosity about the identity of the secret author.As courtship with the bishop's son begins, Emma's heart wrestles with duty and an invisible pull toward the unknown. When a quiet, book-loving young man reappears in her life, Emma begins to wonder if the letter was written not just for someone... but for her.In a world where every decision is weighed by faith, will Emma follow her head—or her heart?Perfect for fans of sweet Amish romance, mystery letters, and stories about love growing in the most unexpected places. less

She left ten years ago. He never stopped needing her.When Mary Beiler returns to Lancaster County after a decade in the English world, all she wants is a fresh start. Scarred by a painful past and desperate to reclaim her faith, she finds refuge in a housekeeping job on a struggling farm.Aaron Fisher, a widowed father trying to keep his world from crumbling, needs help—but not complications. Mary's presence brings back memories he thought buried and feelings he never expected to feel again... moreShe left ten years ago. He never stopped needing her.When Mary Beiler returns to Lancaster County after a decade in the English world, all she wants is a fresh start. Scarred by a painful past and desperate to reclaim her faith, she finds refuge in a housekeeping job on a struggling farm.Aaron Fisher, a widowed father trying to keep his world from crumbling, needs help—but not complications. Mary's presence brings back memories he thought buried and feelings he never expected to feel again.Can two broken hearts find healing in each other—or will the ghosts of their past keep them apart?An emotional, second-chance Amish romance about forgiveness, faith, and finding love where you least expect it. less

Two suitors. One letter. A choice that will change everything.Hannah Stoltzfus has always done what was expected. But when her parents arrange a courtship with the steady and respected Eli Lapp, she can’t ignore the unexpected return of Daniel King—her childhood friend who left the community years ago.As Hannah's heart is torn between duty and desire, a secret letter from the past resurfaces, forcing her to confront everything she thought she knew about love, forgiveness, and God's plan... moreTwo suitors. One letter. A choice that will change everything.Hannah Stoltzfus has always done what was expected. But when her parents arrange a courtship with the steady and respected Eli Lapp, she can’t ignore the unexpected return of Daniel King—her childhood friend who left the community years ago.As Hannah's heart is torn between duty and desire, a secret letter from the past resurfaces, forcing her to confront everything she thought she knew about love, forgiveness, and God's plan.In a community that values order and tradition, can Hannah listen to the quiet whisper of her own heart?An emotional Amish love triangle filled with faith, family tension, and the tender mystery of a hidden note. less

Her stitches told stories of sorrow. His quiet kindness offered hope.After a broken engagement, Esther Bender pours her pain into quilts meant for no one—until unexpected gifts start appearing on her doorstep, leading her toward healing and a new beginning.In his silence, he spoke volumes.Matthew Lapp has admired Esther from afar, his craftsmanship mirroring her artistry. When fate weaves their paths together, both must decide if past hurts can be pieced into something whole again... moreHer stitches told stories of sorrow. His quiet kindness offered hope.After a broken engagement, Esther Bender pours her pain into quilts meant for no one—until unexpected gifts start appearing on her doorstep, leading her toward healing and a new beginning.In his silence, he spoke volumes.Matthew Lapp has admired Esther from afar, his craftsmanship mirroring her artistry. When fate weaves their paths together, both must decide if past hurts can be pieced into something whole again.In a world where tradition weaves every life, can two hearts mend together and create a love stitched stronger than sorrow?A tender story perfect for fans of sweet romance, slow-burn healing, and Amish love stories filled with hope and quiet devotion. less

A desperate farm. A dangerous proposal. A love neither of them expected.With foreclosure looming and her family's legacy at risk, Lydia Schrock faces an impossible accept a cold, calculated marriage proposal from a powerful widower—or find another way to save the only home she’s ever known.Enter Jonas Esh. Quiet, loyal, and unexpectedly bold, Jonas offers a daring a fake engagement to protect Lydia from a loveless match and buy time to save the farm... moreA desperate farm. A dangerous proposal. A love neither of them expected.With foreclosure looming and her family's legacy at risk, Lydia Schrock faces an impossible accept a cold, calculated marriage proposal from a powerful widower—or find another way to save the only home she’s ever known.Enter Jonas Esh. Quiet, loyal, and unexpectedly bold, Jonas offers a daring a fake engagement to protect Lydia from a loveless match and buy time to save the farm.As the snow begins to fall on Lancaster County, Lydia and Jonas must navigate a web of community expectations, buried feelings, and the delicate line between pretend and real. But when fake feelings start to feel achingly genuine, will their hearts survive the truth?Faith, family, and a bargain that may cost them everything—or bring the miracle of love this Christmas.Fans of fake-relationship Amish romance, slow-burn chemistry, and high-stakes emotional drama will fall for The Christmas Bargain. less

Her heart was broken. Her hope was buried. Until a quiet stranger brought it back to life.After being left without warning by the man she thought she’d marry, Anna Byler pours herself into managing her family’s struggling dairy farm. With her father’s health failing and debts piling up, there’s no time for dreams—especially not of love.Enter Samuel Stutzman, the reserved feed deliveryman with a gentle spirit and a steady hand... moreHer heart was broken. Her hope was buried. Until a quiet stranger brought it back to life.After being left without warning by the man she thought she’d marry, Anna Byler pours herself into managing her family’s struggling dairy farm. With her father’s health failing and debts piling up, there’s no time for dreams—especially not of love.Enter Samuel Stutzman, the reserved feed deliveryman with a gentle spirit and a steady hand. When Anna’s equipment breaks and her family faces crisis after crisis, Samuel’s unexpected kindness offers more than just help—it sparks something she thought she’d lost forever.But can a woman who's sworn off courtship open her heart again? And can a man haunted by his past learn to believe he’s worthy of love?A tender story of healing, sacrifice, and the quiet romance that grows from true partnership.Perfect for fans of second-chance love stories, Amish farm settings, and deeply emotional Christian romance. less