Penny Black
by Stacey Wallace Benefiel
4.25 · 12 ratings
fantasy · friends to lovers · contemporary · love triangle · other-man-woman · superheroes · paranormal · bisexual · disabilities and marks · humor · futuristic · time travel · witches · multicultural · curvy heroine · magic · strong heroine · virgin hero · length-short · new adult
Penny Black: Similar series
Crescent City
by Sarah J. Maas
4.22 · 1523 ratings
fae · paranormal · curvy heroine · werewolves · non-human-hero · non-human-heroine · sassy heroine · competent heroine · torture-scs · abuse-non-mc · war · shapeshifters · m-f · torture-mcs · vampires · angels · third-person-pov · dystopian · witches · aristocratic heroine
All books in this series ❯
Cruel Shifterverse
by Jasmine Mas
4.06 · 953 ratings
reverse harem · from hate to love · gifted heroine · past-child-abuse · magic · male-pov · dangerous heroine · misogyny · mental illness · warrior-heroine · competent heroine · first-person-pov · explicit-open-door · dual-pov · poly · mental-trauma · monsters · forced proximity · slow burn · strong heroine
All books in this series ❯
Sookie Stackhouse
by Charlaine Harris
3.78 · 2533 ratings
fantasy · urban fantasy · vampires · paranormal · magic · mystery · shapeshifters · werewolves · contemporary · witches · fae · demons · length-medium · m-f · love triangle · non-human-hero · other-man-woman · suspense · humor · strong heroine
All books in this series ❯
Sponsored links
Darkmore Penitentiary
by Caroline Peckham
4.33 · 349 ratings
alpha male · magic · humor · bad boys · spanking · fated-mates · independent heroine · gifted heroine · fantasy · past-child-abuse · outlaw-heroine · tortured hero · urban fantasy · strong heroine · vampires · reverse harem · dark · poly · dual-pov · disabilities and marks
All books in this series ❯
Cursed Legacies
by Morgan B. Lee
4.34 · 334 ratings
cold hero · strong heroine · tortured hero · north-america · graphic-violence · virgin hero · reverse harem · vampires · monsters · praise-kink · sweet-hero · death · magic · demons · usa · abuse · fantasy · super rich hero · independent heroine · fated-mates
All books in this series ❯
The Arrow Hart Academy
by Hannah Haze
4.17 · 368 ratings
magic · slut-shaming · victim-blaming · from hate to love · tortured hero · reverse harem · witches · dark · mental-trauma · poly · athletes · dual-pov · first-person-pov · cruel hero · non-human-hero · dangerous heroine · misogyny · forbidden love · college · alpha male
All books in this series ❯
The Dark Elements
by Jennifer L. Armentrout
4.17 · 560 ratings
urban fantasy · shapeshifters · young adult · contemporary · fantasy · from hate to love · demons · love triangle · magic · forbidden love · paranormal · strong heroine · angst · new adult · bad boys · humor · high-school · alpha male · friends to lovers · other-man-woman
All books in this series ❯
Witchwood Boys
by C.M. Stunich
4.21 · 214 ratings
tortured hero · north-america · urban fantasy · strong heroine · graphic-violence · somnophilia · fetish · reverse harem · forced proximity · small town · witches · praise-kink · horror · alpha male · california · death · magic · child-death · found-family · bad boys
All books in this series ❯
But Did You Die?
by Sedona Ashe
4.14 · 259 ratings
angst · caretaking · first-person-pov · poly · mental-trauma · survival · dual-pov · insta-love · human-trafficking · exhibitionism · dangerous heroine · non-human-hero · gifted heroine · past-child-abuse · from hate to love · magic · reverse harem · abduction · sweet-hero · praise-kink
All books in this series ❯
A Monstrous World
by Jillian West
4.22 · 203 ratings
alpha male · age difference · found-family · bad boys · fated-mates · fantasy · urban fantasy · virgin hero · creative-anatomy · vampires · monsters · possessive hero · pregnancy · cold hero · shapeshifters · contemporary · height-difference · werewolves · paranormal · fae
All books in this series ❯
The Mate Games: Pestilence
by Meg Anne
4.30 · 219 ratings
arranged marriage · suspense · dual-pov · poly · bdsm · first-person-pov · aristocratic heroine · witches · fetish · reverse harem · contemporary · paranormal · urban fantasy · monsters · vampires · super rich hero · fated-mates · fantasy · non-human-hero · explicit-plentiful
All books in this series ❯
Supernatural Prison
by Jaymin Eve
4.23 · 181 ratings
urban fantasy · witches · fantasy · shapeshifters · paranormal · fae · magic · non-human-heroine · vampires · alpha male · werewolves · new adult · length-medium · reverse harem · young adult · poly · strong heroine · friends to lovers · mystery · royalty
All books in this series ❯
The Beauchamp Family
by Melissa de la Cruz
3.52 · 178 ratings
young adult · contemporary · paranormal · magic · fantasy · mystery · urban fantasy · witches · horror · vampires · dark · possessive hero · angst · suspense · competent heroine · curvy heroine · non-human-heroine · forbidden love · historical · alpha male
All books in this series ❯
Arcane Mage
by T.S. Snow
4.18 · 213 ratings
reverse harem · paranormal · office · bodyguard-hero · second chances · contemporary · urban fantasy · humor · first-person-pov · fantasy · poly · magic · possessive hero · dual-pov · superheroes · new adult · friends to lovers · explicit-open-door · forced proximity · witches
All books in this series ❯
Spooky Boys
by Fae Quin
4.14 · 139 ratings
first-person-pov · queer · possessive hero · anal sex · paranormal · m-m · height-difference · non-human-hero · contemporary · fantasy · death · magic · monsters · sweet-hero · past-abuse · breeding · dual-pov · humor · grumpy sunshine · forced proximity
All books in this series ❯
Heartstrikers
by Rachel Aaron
4.27 · 202 ratings
witches · paranormal · urban fantasy · fantasy · m-f · magic · monsters · dystopian · third-person-pov · sweet-hero · competent heroine · dragon shifter · young adult · non-human-hero · north-america · futuristic · gifted heroine · independent heroine · shapeshifters · new adult
All books in this series ❯
Kingdom of Shifters and Witches
by Lacey Carter Andersen
3.92 · 84 ratings
shapeshifters · aristocratic heroine · war · tortured heroine · slow burn · bear shifter · m-f-m · vengeance · sweet heroine · reverse harem · forced proximity · grumpy sunshine · bodyguard-hero · multicultural · witches · monsters · alpha male · death · magic · abuse
All books in this series ❯
Zellie Wells
by Stacey Wallace Benefiel
3.75 · 73 ratings
paranormal · small town · contemporary · strong heroine · young adult · humor · fantasy · magic · athletes · forbidden love · witches · m-m · other-man-woman · virgin hero · bisexual · queer · length-short · virgin heroine · love triangle · pregnancy
All books in this series ❯
Rhiannon's Law
by J.A. Saare
3.90 · 91 ratings
vampires · magic · urban fantasy · demons · fantasy · paranormal · strong heroine · contemporary · length-short · open-door · dystopian · love triangle · m-f · werewolves · shapeshifters · other-man-woman · witches · futuristic · mystery · sassy heroine
All books in this series ❯
Umbra Hunters
by B.M. Clemton
4.30 · 90 ratings
possessive hero · poly · dual-pov · small town · sunny hero · disabilities and marks · shapeshifters · tortured heroine · first-person-pov · canada · cold hero · height-difference · contemporary · royalty · paranormal · magic · demons · found-family · age difference · fantasy
All books in this series ❯
Four Ways to Fate
by Sara C. Roethle
4.17 · 39 ratings
urban fantasy · magic · mystery · fantasy · paranormal · north-america · strong heroine · tortured hero · sweet heroine · m-f-m · high fantasy · forced proximity · angels · bodyguard-hero · vampires · reverse harem · monsters · multicultural · witches · class difference
All books in this series ❯
Luna Rejected
by River Ramsey
3.99 · 29 ratings
urban fantasy · aristocratic heroine · vengeance · tycoon · m-f-m · bodyguard-hero · grumpy sunshine · forced proximity · vampires · fetish · reverse harem · double-penetration · friends to lovers · hurt-comfort · praise-kink · witches · small town · magic · multicultural · class difference
All books in this series ❯
Bound to the Vampires
by Traci Lovelot
3.99 · 28 ratings
paranormal · sassy heroine · angst · poly · reverse harem · witches · urban fantasy · strong heroine · fantasy · independent heroine · gifted heroine · death · magic · dangerous heroine · explicit-plentiful · marriage of convenience · second chances · dual-pov · forced proximity · vampires
All books in this series ❯
Penny Black
by Stacey Wallace Benefiel
4.25 · 12 ratings
fantasy · friends to lovers · contemporary · love triangle · other-man-woman · superheroes · paranormal · bisexual · disabilities and marks · humor · futuristic · time travel · witches · multicultural · curvy heroine · magic · strong heroine · virgin hero · length-short · new adult
All books in this series ❯