Magical Holiday Matchmaker: Similar romance series

Darkmore Penitentiary

by Caroline Peckham

4.26 · 450 ratings

humor · fantasy · dangerous heroine · fated-mates · reverse harem · independent heroine · bad boys · spanking · magic · werewolves · queer · fae · sassy heroine · bisexual · m-m-m · gifted heroine · shapeshifters · contemporary · poly · alpha male

All books in this series ❯

Heart Hassle

by Raven Kennedy

4.27 · 486 ratings

insta-love · demons · magic · humor · fantasy · paranormal · contemporary · fae · non-human-hero · first-person-pov · caretaking · praise-kink · cheerful heroine · cold hero · grumpy sunshine · strong heroine · sweet-hero · neurodivergent · sweet heroine · high fantasy

All books in this series ❯

The Lost Sentinel

by Ivy Asher

4.18 · 352 ratings

magic · witches · reverse harem · fated-mates · fantasy · paranormal · urban fantasy · audiobook · poly · shapeshifters · vampires · length-medium · werewolves · non-human-hero · explicit-open-door · virgin heroine · strong heroine · menage · contemporary · sassy heroine

All books in this series ❯

A Demon's Guide to the Afterlife

by Kel Carpenter

4.13 · 155 ratings

age difference · fantasy · humor · reverse harem · fated-mates · witches · alcoholism · magic · demons · usa · werewolves · mental illness · fae · sassy heroine · gifted heroine · shapeshifters · alpha male · poly · m-f · audiobook

All books in this series ❯

Shadowblood Souls

by Eva Chase

3.79 · 258 ratings

vengeance · friends to lovers · dual-pov · urban fantasy · survival · strong heroine · cold hero · first-person-pov · dark · graphic-violence · mental-trauma · abuse · gifted heroine · shapeshifters · new adult · height-difference · poly · non-human-heroine · found-family · suspense

All books in this series ❯

Steel Demons MC

by Crystal Ash

4.23 · 489 ratings

male-pov · futuristic · reverse harem · usa · working class heroine · competent heroine · audiobook · poly · alpha male · m-f · latinx-mc · arizona · first-person-pov · dystopian · bikers · survival · dual-pov · urban fantasy · fantasy · paranormal

All books in this series ❯

Royals of Villain Academy

by Eva Chase

3.96 · 320 ratings

paranormal · urban fantasy · dual-pov · college · poly · audiobook · contemporary · new adult · magic · cruel hero · reverse harem · witches · fantasy · shapeshifters · first-person-pov · suspense · from hate to love · length-medium · explicit-open-door · strong heroine

All books in this series ❯

The Phoenix Prophecy

by Cara Clare

3.90 · 259 ratings

paranormal · poly · shapeshifters · m-m · queer · magic · fated-mates · age difference · dark · new adult · reverse harem · witches · fantasy · urban fantasy · demons · vampires · audiobook · explicit-plentiful · from hate to love · dual-pov

All books in this series ❯

Heir Academy

by K.C. Kean

4.25 · 163 ratings

paranormal · shapeshifters · alpha male · m-f · new adult · fae · werewolves · magic · fantasy · forced proximity · strong heroine · urban fantasy · vampires · competent heroine · political-intrigue · contemporary · college · gifted heroine · from hate to love · sassy heroine

All books in this series ❯

Fallen University

by Callie Rose

3.93 · 77 ratings

shapeshifters · disabilities and marks · sassy heroine · vampires · explicit-plentiful · paranormal · dragon shifter · urban fantasy · college · poly · audiobook · reverse harem · independent heroine · sunny hero · fantasy · cold hero · age difference · demons · childfree-couple · length-medium

All books in this series ❯

The Wolves of Forest Grove

by Elena Lawson

4.14 · 94 ratings

paranormal · shapeshifters · fantasy · m-f-m · young adult · audiobook · poly · urban fantasy · fated-mates · length-medium · menage · high-school · werewolves · contemporary · magic · reverse harem · suspense · dark · length-long · non-human-heroine

All books in this series ❯

Nevermore Bookshop Mysteries

by Steffanie Holmes

4.13 · 221 ratings

urban fantasy · fantasy · humor · reverse harem · mystery · witches · poly · contemporary · paranormal · disabilities and marks · audiobook · shapeshifters · united-kingdom · vampires · small town · grumpy sunshine · magic · suspense · office · first-person-pov

All books in this series ❯

Broken Ashes

by Nikita Parmenter

4.34 · 94 ratings

fantasy · humor · m-f · non-human-heroine · found-family · alpha male · paranormal · urban fantasy · neurodivergent · possessive hero · fae · past-child-neglect · orcs · warrior-heroine · sassy heroine · gifted heroine · shapeshifters · height-difference · poly · bodyguard-heroine

All books in this series ❯

The Witch's Monsters

by Sarah Piper

4.24 · 74 ratings

vampires · abduction · disabilities and marks · strong heroine · cold hero · fae · explicit-plentiful · sassy heroine · gifted heroine · shapeshifters · audiobook · poly · m-f · found-family · non-human-heroine · paranormal · competent heroine · fantasy · forced proximity · dangerous heroine

All books in this series ❯

Their Shifter Princess

by May Dawson

4.04 · 54 ratings

competent heroine · fantasy · witches · fated-mates · reverse harem · magic · high-school · non-human-hero · shapeshifters · new adult · urban fantasy · non-human-heroine · contemporary · poly · alpha male · young adult · paranormal · first-person-pov · insta-love · explicit-open-door

All books in this series ❯

Bonds of Blood

by Cate Corvin

4.10 · 52 ratings

warrior-heroine · demons · first-person-pov · usa · new-york-state · cruel hero · stepsibling · independent heroine · witches · reverse harem · fantasy · forced proximity · age difference · paranormal · competent heroine · dual-pov · college · poly · contemporary · north-america

All books in this series ❯

Nightworld Academy

by L.J. Swallow

4.06 · 179 ratings

paranormal · poly · reverse harem · fantasy · vampires · young adult · urban fantasy · witches · shapeshifters · length-medium · magic · contemporary · age difference · dystopian · werewolves · new adult · from hate to love · friends to lovers · dual-pov · college

All books in this series ❯

Vengeance Aforethought

by Kyra Alessy

4.14 · 40 ratings

abuse · explicit-plentiful · poly · paranormal · fantasy · reverse harem · fated-mates · demons · vampires · fae · from hate to love · shapeshifters · contemporary · dual-pov · monsters · praise-kink · cruel hero · past-abuse · first-person-pov · magic

All books in this series ❯

The Looking-Glass Curse

by Eva Chase

4.17 · 34 ratings

sunny hero · found-family · urban fantasy · contemporary · audiobook · dual-pov · m-f · paranormal · sweet heroine · shapeshifters · first-person-pov · length-medium · explicit-open-door · fantasy · age difference · single-father · male-pov · reverse harem · independent heroine · poly

All books in this series ❯

Institute of Unpredictable Magic

by Sadie Moss

4.11 · 38 ratings

witches · reverse harem · fantasy · mystery · shapeshifters · paranormal · poly · urban fantasy · dangerous heroine · length-medium · magic · first-person-pov · gifted heroine · strong heroine · contemporary · oregon · sunny hero · demons · nerdy-hero · m-f-m

All books in this series ❯

Order of Helsing

by Debbie Cassidy

4.51 · 45 ratings

fantasy · paranormal · vampires · shapeshifters · magic · urban fantasy · from hate to love · fae · demons · dark · reverse harem · witches · contemporary · poly · death · werewolves · length-medium · forced proximity · length-short · fated-mates

All books in this series ❯

Fated to the Alphas

by Alice Wilde

3.89 · 35 ratings

shapeshifters · fantasy · paranormal · reverse harem · vampires · omegaverse · werewolves · young adult · poly · length-short · monsters · length-medium · contemporary · magic · fated-mates · dual-pov · new adult · substance abuse · mystery · grumpy sunshine

All books in this series ❯

The Wraith Lords

by Amy Sumida

3.88 · 30 ratings

length-medium · magic · male-pov · fantasy · dragon shifter · menage · paranormal · audiobook · poly · m-m · queer · explicit-plentiful · m-m-m · first-person-pov · war · breeding · anal sex · medieval · shapeshifters · fae

All books in this series ❯