Witches of Keyhole Lake: Similar series
Ruthless Boys of the Zodiac
by Caroline Peckham
4.26 · 1359 ratings
magic · tortured hero · vampires · vengeance · grumpy sunshine · strong heroine · lion shifter · dual-pov · urban fantasy · sunny hero · possessive hero · dark · graphic-violence · mental-trauma · himbo · cruel hero · past-abuse · first-person-pov · mafia · shapeshifters
All books in this series ❯
Cruel Shifterverse
by Jasmine Mas
3.97 · 1457 ratings
poly · possessive hero · contemporary · paranormal · abuse · sassy heroine · from hate to love · new adult · height-difference · m-m · magic · m-m-f · dangerous heroine · misogyny · fated-mates · reverse harem · independent heroine · male-pov · bad boys · suicide
All books in this series ❯
Vampire Academy
by Richelle Mead
4.15 · 2151 ratings
paranormal · young adult · fantasy · vampires · contemporary · magic · urban fantasy · age difference · strong heroine · behind-doors · m-f · alpha male · betrayal · slut-shaming · audiobook · competent heroine · suspense · forbidden love · abuse · sassy heroine
All books in this series ❯
Sponsored links
Kingdom of the Wicked
by Kerri Maniscalco
3.87 · 818 ratings
dark · first-person-pov · strong heroine · tortured hero · vengeance · vampires · demons · magic · independent heroine · witches · mystery · fantasy · forced proximity · young adult · paranormal · competent heroine · commander · m-f · non-human-hero · cold hero
All books in this series ❯
All The Pretty Monsters
by Kristy Cunning
4.22 · 1110 ratings
paranormal · contemporary · audiobook · alpha male · poly · m-f · shapeshifters · height-difference · gifted heroine · werewolves · magic · monsters · male-pov · super rich hero · reverse harem · fantasy · age difference · slow burn · dual-pov · urban fantasy
All books in this series ❯
Innkeeper Chronicles
by Ilona Andrews
4.33 · 1181 ratings
contemporary · magic · aliens · urban fantasy · competent heroine · audiobook · alpha male · m-f · shapeshifters · gifted heroine · science fiction · werewolves · mystery · humor · strong heroine · vampires · non-human-hero · fighters · usa · death
All books in this series ❯
Witchwood Boys
by C.M. Stunich
4.15 · 447 ratings
primal-play · non-human-hero · possessive hero · somnophilia · california · small town · fetish · tortured hero · past-child-abuse · north-america · angst · horror · death · animal-death · age difference · fantasy · forced proximity · humor · competent heroine · menage
All books in this series ❯
The Arrow Hart Academy
by Hannah Haze
4.13 · 548 ratings
victim-blaming · tortured hero · athletes · possessive hero · poor heroine · non-human-hero · torture-mcs · fighters · shapeshifters · slut-shaming · alpha male · audiobook · fantasy · age difference · super rich hero · werewolves · disabilities and marks · dual-pov · bodyguard-hero · cold hero
All books in this series ❯
Gates of Myth and Power
by K.M. Shea
4.19 · 303 ratings
shapeshifters · height-difference · past-abuse · wisconsin · first-person-pov · magic · usa · werewolves · non-human-hero · age difference · fantasy · mystery · humor · clean · witches · super rich hero · possessive hero · independent heroine · glimpses-kisses · plain heroine
All books in this series ❯
Supernaturals of Castle Academy
by Tessa Hale
3.80 · 224 ratings
werewolves · vampires · angst · friends to lovers · abduction · class difference · past-child-abuse · north-america · hurt-comfort · sweet-hero · strong heroine · cold hero · virgin heroine · poor heroine · sunny hero · possessive hero · caretaking · tortured heroine · first-person-pov · mental-trauma
All books in this series ❯
Magiford Supernatural City
by K.M. Shea
4.20 · 874 ratings
vampires · north-america · dual-pov · urban fantasy · strong heroine · glimpses-kisses · first-person-pov · non-human-hero · fae · shapeshifters · gifted heroine · m-f · contemporary · audiobook · paranormal · fantasy · humor · witches · magic · wisconsin
All books in this series ❯
But Did You Die?
by Sedona Ashe
4.06 · 359 ratings
possessive hero · praise-kink · poly · primal-play · non-human-hero · torture-mcs · fighters · north-america · tortured hero · past-child-abuse · abduction · sweet heroine · angst · tycoon · sweet-hero · hurt-comfort · super rich hero · fantasy · humor · forced proximity
All books in this series ❯
Hall of Blood and Mercy
by K.M. Shea
4.22 · 215 ratings
vampires · werewolves · usa · death · magic · wisconsin · witches · male-pov · super rich hero · fantasy · humor · age difference · young adult · paranormal · audiobook · contemporary · m-f · alpha male · betrayal · new adult
All books in this series ❯
Pack of Dawn and Destiny
by K.M. Shea
4.24 · 182 ratings
werewolves · non-human-hero · warrior-heroine · usa · magic · first-person-pov · fighters · length-medium · wisconsin · glimpses-kisses · fated-mates · independent heroine · clean · male-pov · dangerous heroine · witches · humor · fantasy · mystery · strong heroine
All books in this series ❯
The Mate Games: Pestilence
by Meg Anne
4.27 · 301 ratings
super rich hero · monsters · fantasy · arranged marriage · aristocratic heroine · fetish · reverse harem · fated-mates · witches · paranormal · suspense · poly · contemporary · first-person-pov · bdsm · vampires · dual-pov · urban fantasy · alaska · childfree-couple
All books in this series ❯
Court of Midnight and Deception
by K.M. Shea
4.13 · 174 ratings
competent heroine · cold hero · glimpses-kisses · cheerful heroine · first-person-pov · aristocratic heroine · non-human-hero · fighters · vampires · north-america · urban fantasy · dual-pov · grumpy sunshine · strong heroine · slow burn · humor · fantasy · monsters · clean · male-pov
All books in this series ❯
A Monstrous World
by Jillian West
4.18 · 290 ratings
fated-mates · witches · magic · demons · working class heroine · explicit-plentiful · height-difference · contemporary · non-human-heroine · paranormal · cold hero · first-person-pov · creative-anatomy · dual-pov · age difference · fantasy · m-f-m · fae · shapeshifters · alpha male
All books in this series ❯
Magic on Main Street
by K.M. Shea
4.48 · 171 ratings
cheerful heroine · glimpses-kisses · fighters · non-human-hero · warrior-heroine · first-person-pov · tortured hero · north-america · vampires · slow burn · strong heroine · dual-pov · urban fantasy · neurodivergent · independent heroine · male-pov · super rich hero · witches · age difference · dangerous heroine
All books in this series ❯
The Wolves of Crescent Creek
by Tessa Hale
3.98 · 153 ratings
found-family · sunny hero · possessive hero · cold hero · bodyguard-hero · graphic-violence · fighters · mental-trauma · non-human-hero · torture-mcs · cruel hero · past-abuse · caretaking · first-person-pov · tortured heroine · small town · colorado · disabilities and marks · north-america · past-child-abuse
All books in this series ❯
The Storm Dragons' Mate
by M. Sinclair
4.06 · 175 ratings
fantasy · forced proximity · mystery · slow burn · grumpy sunshine · dual-pov · hurt-comfort · angst · friends to lovers · explicit-open-door · non-human-hero · insta-love · caretaking · aristocratic heroine · first-person-pov · possessive hero · paranormal · dragon shifter · suspense · political-intrigue
All books in this series ❯
Nevermore Bookshop Mysteries
by Steffanie Holmes
4.12 · 243 ratings
urban fantasy · fantasy · humor · mystery · reverse harem · poly · contemporary · paranormal · disabilities and marks · witches · shapeshifters · audiobook · united-kingdom · explicit-open-door · small town · vampires · grumpy sunshine · magic · office · suspense
All books in this series ❯
Cat McKenzie
by Lauren Dawes
4.20 · 93 ratings
competent heroine · bodyguard-hero · first-person-pov · non-human-hero · vampires · north-america · men in uniform · urban fantasy · strong heroine · humor · fantasy · mystery · age difference · length-short · magic · werewolves · usa · demons · sassy heroine · fae
All books in this series ❯
Four Ways to Fate
by Sara C. Roethle
4.09 · 65 ratings
urban fantasy · fantasy · magic · paranormal · audiobook · first-person-pov · monsters · reverse harem · mystery · gifted heroine · fae · competent heroine · m-f · poly · contemporary · possessive hero · cheerful heroine · bodyguard-hero · non-human-hero · insta-love
All books in this series ❯
Luna Rejected
by River Ramsey
3.75 · 35 ratings
m-f · poly · betrayal · alpha male · found-family · non-human-heroine · possessive hero · paranormal · suspense · office · political-intrigue · competent heroine · bisexual · fae · queer · boss & employee · sassy heroine · royalty · explicit-plentiful · shapeshifters
All books in this series ❯