Witches of Keyhole Lake: Similar series
Ruthless Boys of the Zodiac
by Caroline Peckham
4.25 · 1554 ratings
poly · possessive hero · m-f · audiobook · sunny hero · himbo · dark · mental-trauma · graphic-violence · first-person-pov · cruel hero · past-abuse · tortured hero · vampires · vengeance · grumpy sunshine · strong heroine · lion shifter · dual-pov · urban fantasy
All books in this series ❯
Cruel Shifterverse
by Jasmine Mas
3.98 · 1641 ratings
disabilities and marks · fantasy · forced proximity · humor · early-20s-fmc · monsters · immortal-heroine · super rich hero · audiobook · alpha male · m-f · menage · competent heroine · queer · mental illness · fae · bisexual · m-m-m · shapeshifters · gifted heroine
All books in this series ❯
Zodiac Academy
by Caroline Peckham
4.09 · 4192 ratings
vampires · urban fantasy · new adult · contemporary · paranormal · fantasy · fae · shapeshifters · first-person-pov · werewolves · magic · from hate to love · dragon shifter · dark · possessive hero · super rich hero · alpha male · cruel hero · dual-pov · male-pov
All books in this series ❯
Sponsored links / Remove ads
Cursed Legacies
by Morgan B. Lee
4.36 · 1224 ratings
dragon shifter · late-20s-mmc · possessive hero · praise-kink · non-human-hero · north-america · past-child-abuse · sweet-hero · early-20s-fmc · fantasy · monsters · death · usa · m-f-m · fae · shapeshifters · gifted heroine · m-f · menage · cold hero
All books in this series ❯
Kingdom of the Wicked
by Kerri Maniscalco
3.88 · 988 ratings
witches · fantasy · mystery · demons · magic · young adult · paranormal · dark · monsters · independent heroine · forced proximity · historical · new adult · from hate to love · political-intrigue · commander · competent heroine · audiobook · m-f · first-person-pov
All books in this series ❯
Innkeeper Chronicles
by Ilona Andrews
4.33 · 1256 ratings
contemporary · urban fantasy · aliens · magic · non-human-hero · fighters · vampires · strong heroine · futuristic · mystery · humor · werewolves · death · shapeshifters · gifted heroine · science fiction · competent heroine · m-f · alpha male · audiobook
All books in this series ❯
Stay a Spell
by Juliette Cross
4.03 · 1030 ratings
dual-pov · urban fantasy · vampires · first-person-pov · louisiana · contemporary · paranormal · magic · witches · explicit-open-door · possessive hero · m-f · audiobook · gifted heroine · werewolves · usa · fantasy · strong heroine · fated-mates · friends to lovers
All books in this series ❯
Witchwood Boys
by C.M. Stunich
4.17 · 516 ratings
strong heroine · urban fantasy · dual-pov · survival · cold hero · mental-trauma · dark · graphic-violence · past-child-neglect · past-abuse · first-person-pov · explicit-plentiful · sassy heroine · from hate to love · suspense · paranormal · contemporary · poly · found-family · witches
All books in this series ❯
The Arrow Hart Academy
by Hannah Haze
4.12 · 633 ratings
witches · male-pov · hurt-comfort · athletes · angst · victim-blaming · tortured hero · past-child-abuse · class difference · non-human-hero · torture-mcs · fighters · possessive hero · poor heroine · slut-shaming · alpha male · audiobook · competent heroine · shapeshifters · death
All books in this series ❯
Gates of Myth and Power
by K.M. Shea
4.19 · 346 ratings
non-human-hero · first-person-pov · past-abuse · glimpses-kisses · possessive hero · strong heroine · slow burn · urban fantasy · dual-pov · north-america · vampires · werewolves · usa · magic · wisconsin · plain heroine · witches · super rich hero · clean · independent heroine
All books in this series ❯
Magiford Supernatural City
by K.M. Shea
4.20 · 975 ratings
vampires · north-america · dual-pov · urban fantasy · strong heroine · glimpses-kisses · first-person-pov · non-human-hero · fae · gifted heroine · shapeshifters · m-f · contemporary · audiobook · paranormal · fantasy · humor · witches · wisconsin · magic
All books in this series ❯
Supernaturals of Castle Academy
by Tessa Hale
3.81 · 242 ratings
rhode-island · misogyny · fantasy · mystery · forced proximity · fated-mates · reverse harem · super rich hero · witches · independent heroine · magic · second chances · demons · length-medium · usa · werewolves · nerdy-hero · high-school · abuse · shapeshifters
All books in this series ❯
But Did You Die?
by Sedona Ashe
4.05 · 401 ratings
mental-trauma · graphic-violence · insta-love · past-child-neglect · past-abuse · caretaking · tortured heroine · first-person-pov · cheerful heroine · cold hero · human-trafficking · bodyguard-hero · slow burn · grumpy sunshine · strong heroine · dual-pov · survival · late-20s-fmc · magic · exhibitionism
All books in this series ❯
The Wolves of Crescent Creek
by Tessa Hale
3.87 · 219 ratings
fated-mates · independent heroine · dual-pov · urban fantasy · sweet-hero · super rich hero · strong heroine · abduction · north-america · small town · colorado · past-child-abuse · disabilities and marks · tortured hero · first-person-pov · tortured heroine · cruel hero · past-abuse · caretaking · non-human-hero
All books in this series ❯
The Mate Games: Pestilence
by Meg Anne
4.24 · 343 ratings
witches · fated-mates · reverse harem · suspense · paranormal · contemporary · poly · bdsm · first-person-pov · urban fantasy · dual-pov · vampires · arranged marriage · monsters · super rich hero · fantasy · aristocratic heroine · fetish · m-m-f · demons
All books in this series ❯
A Monstrous World
by Jillian West
4.15 · 336 ratings
magic · demons · witches · fated-mates · contemporary · non-human-heroine · paranormal · working class heroine · explicit-plentiful · height-difference · first-person-pov · cold hero · dual-pov · creative-anatomy · standalone-first · m-f-m · age difference · fantasy · audiobook · alpha male
All books in this series ❯
Hall of Blood and Mercy
by K.M. Shea
4.23 · 250 ratings
urban fantasy · vampires · paranormal · young adult · magic · witches · fantasy · slow burn · strong heroine · dual-pov · north-america · fighters · non-human-hero · first-person-pov · glimpses-kisses · cold hero · audiobook · contemporary · m-f · alpha male
All books in this series ❯
The Storm Dragons' Mate
by M. Sinclair
4.03 · 198 ratings
magic · m-f-m · werewolves · fantasy · misogyny · forced proximity · mystery · fated-mates · reverse harem · independent heroine · audiobook · contemporary · poly · alpha male · slut-shaming · college · dragon shifter · suspense · paranormal · non-human-heroine
All books in this series ❯
Court of Midnight and Deception
by K.M. Shea
4.16 · 192 ratings
paranormal · fantasy · magic · urban fantasy · royalty · from hate to love · sassy heroine · fae · shapeshifters · new adult · marriage of convenience · height-difference · gifted heroine · non-human-heroine · contemporary · audiobook · m-f · young adult · political-intrigue · competent heroine
All books in this series ❯
Nevermore Bookshop Mysteries
by Steffanie Holmes
4.13 · 257 ratings
reverse harem · humor · fantasy · mystery · paranormal · poly · contemporary · urban fantasy · witches · shapeshifters · audiobook · disabilities and marks · united-kingdom · explicit-open-door · small town · magic · vampires · grumpy sunshine · office · suspense
All books in this series ❯
Cat McKenzie
by Lauren Dawes
4.20 · 93 ratings
sassy heroine · fae · shapeshifters · maine · m-f · alpha male · bodyguard-heroine · contemporary · audiobook · paranormal · competent heroine · humor · fantasy · mystery · age difference · length-short · magic · werewolves · demons · usa
All books in this series ❯
First Ordinance
by Connie Suttle
4.13 · 88 ratings
length-medium · shapeshifters · audiobook · menage · aliens · reverse harem · magic · demons · immortal-hero · poly · early-20s-mmc · vampires · 100-plus-years-mmc · immortal-heroine · in-his-30s · time travel · futuristic · abuse · strong heroine · fantasy
All books in this series ❯
Four Ways to Fate
by Sara C. Roethle
4.09 · 70 ratings
magic · fantasy · paranormal · audiobook · urban fantasy · monsters · reverse harem · mystery · competent heroine · m-f · poly · gifted heroine · fae · first-person-pov · high fantasy · vampires · werewolves · m-f-m · usa · demons
All books in this series ❯
Luna Rejected
by River Ramsey
3.72 · 36 ratings
office · suspense · paranormal · found-family · non-human-heroine · poly · m-m · height-difference · sassy heroine · explicit-plentiful · m-m-f · second chances · curvy heroine · magic · bad boys · witches · exhibitionism · reverse harem · independent heroine · misogyny
All books in this series ❯